11 Best Brown Mascaras That Make Your Eyes Pop Instantly – 2024

Add some brown and accentuate your lashes with long-lasting and richly pigmented mascaras.

Reviewed by Cha Cha Woska, Certified Makeup Artist Cha Cha Woska Cha Cha WoskaCertified Makeup Artist insta_icon
Written by , MA (English & Literature), Certified Style & Image Consultant Srijita De MA (English & Literature), Certified Style & Image Consultant Experience: 2 years
Edited by , MA (Journalism & Mass Communication) Rajeshwari Das MA (Journalism & Mass Communication) Experience: 3 years
Fact-checked by , MA (Journalism & Mass Communication), Certified Style & Image Consultant Srijani Roy Chowdhury MA (Journalism & Mass Communication), Certified Style & Image Consultant Experience: 3 years
 • 

Brown mascara is desired by most people nowadays, given that it offers a much more neutral and natural look to the eyes. Knowing this, we have compiled a list of the 11 best brown mascaras that you must consider buying right now.

The traditional black mascara is indeed the go-to option, but the tint of fresh and subtle brown mascara on the lashes can help you steal the show like never before. Especially if your eyelashes are lighter, brown mascara can be your best friend because it will appear less pigmented and allow your eyes to pop instantly. The best part is, it gives that minimalistic vibe and provides the maximum amount of impact to give a twist to your look. It is a fun escape from the regular black mascara. So, scroll down and give this piece a read and pick the one that your heart desires.

Top PicksCheck Price
Best Flake-Resistant:L’Oreal Paris Voluminous Mascara- Washable Black Brown
Price on Amazon
Price on Walmart
Best Buildable:Maybelline Lash Sensational Washable Mascara- Brownish Black
Price on Amazon
Best Smudge-Proof:Covergirl Lash Blast Volume Mascara- Black Brown
Price on Amazon
Price on Walmart
Best Hypoallergenic:Simply Naked Beauty Lash Science 3D Fiber Lash Mascara- Dark Brown
Price on Amazon
Price on Walmart
Best Travel-Friendly:Endlessly Beautiful Brown Mascara
Price on Amazon
Price on Walmart
Best Organic Formula:Ecco Bella FlowerColor Advanced Vegan brown Mascara- Brown
Price on Amazon
Price on Walmart
Best Skin-Friendly:Pacifica Beauty Stellar Gaze Length & Strength Mascara- Stardust Brown
Price on Amazon
Price on Walmart
Best For Sensitive Eyes:Burt’s Bees 100% Natural Origin Nourishing Mascara- Black Brown
Price on Amazon
Price on Walmart
Best Antioxidant-Rich:Neutrogena Healthy Lengths Mascara
Price on Amazon
Price on Walmart
Best Volumizing:ETUDE HOUSE Color Eyebrow Mascara- Light Brown
Price on Amazon
Price on Walmart

 11 Best Brown Mascaras

1. Best Flake-Resistant:L’Oreal Paris Voluminous Mascara- Washable Black Brown

star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
4.4

For making your lashes look perfectly curled and perky, this is a volume-building mascara that will build lashes for up to 5 times their natural thickness. This lash-enhancing mascara features a volume maximizing svelte bristle brush that thickens the lashes smoothly and makes them appear full naturally. Plus, the mascara also consists of ceramide-R and panthenol that safeguards the lashes and conditions the lashes, so you don’t have to worry about losing your precious lashes.

Color: Washable Black Brown | Product Dimensions: 0.75 x 2.75 x 7.07 inches | Weight: 0.32 Ounces

Pros
  • Suitable for contact lens users and those with sensitive eyes·
  • Clump and flake-resistant
  • Separates and builds every single lash
  • Easy to remove
  • A dark chocolate brown shade

Cons
  • May not be 100% sweat-proof

protip_icon Quick Tip
When applying two coats of the mascara, give enough time between each to prevent flaking.

worth-buy-icon

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

This product has received 76,315 reviews from customers on Amazon, indicating its popularity and reliability.

2. Best Buildable:Maybelline Lash Sensational Washable Mascara- Brownish Black

star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
4.4
Maybelline Lash Sensational Washable Mascara Image: Maybelline New York

Maybelline never fails to deliver some of the outstanding beauty products, and this washable brownish-black mascara is no exception. The mascara features a tilted fanning brush to cover the lashes from roots to tips and separate each lash for a plumper, fuller, and timeless beauty look. The fanning brush has 10 layers of bristles to offer a full-fan effect to your lashes and make the lashes look longer without clumping or flaking them.

Pros
  • Gentle liquid black-brown formula
  • Offers volume definition and length
  • Waterproof and sweat-resistant
  • Buildable formula
  • Provides a fully curled effect
  • Ophthalmologist-tested

Cons
  • Some find the mascara hard and weighty on lashes

3. Best Smudge-Proof:Covergirl Lash Blast Volume Mascara- Black Brown

star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
4.3
Covergirl Lash Blast Volume Mascara Image: Procter & Gamble - Cosmetics

While the other conventional intense volumizing mascaras may weigh down your lashes, this volume-blasting mascara feels featherweight and smooth on the lashes. Many reviews have indicated that the mascara enhances every single lash and creates deep volume instantly. Also if you have short and fewer lashes, this lengthening and volumizing mascara will make your lashes pop. The best thing about the mascara is that it offers a lengthening effect without flaking or clumping the lashes even after hours of use. It is a perfect product that offers exceptional results on any lash type. If you need further convincing, check this YouTuber’s review that details a tester’s experience with the product.

Color: 810 - Black Brown | Product Dimensions: 1.05 x 5.63 x 2.88 inches | Weight: 1.3 Ounces

Pros
  • A dramatic black-brown shade
  • Cruelty-free product
  • Smear and smudge-proof mascara
  • Scent-free and safe product
  • Easy to remove

Cons
  • May not offer required curling effect
worth-buy-icon

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

With 2,572 positive reviews on Amazon, this product has become a bestseller.

L’Oreal Paris Voluminous Mascara- Washable Black Brown
Best Flake-Resistant
Maybelline Lash Sensational Washable Mascara- Brownish Black
Best Buildable
Covergirl Lash Blast Volume Mascara- Black Brown
Best Smudge-Proof
Color Washable Black Brown- 810 - Black Brown
Dimensions 0.75 x 2.75 x 7.07 inches- 1.05 x 5.63 x 2.88 inches
Weight 0.32 Ounces- 1.3 Ounces
Rating
Reviews76,315103,6282,572
Price$8.98$8.98$8.98

4. Best Hypoallergenic:Simply Naked Beauty Lash Science 3D Fiber Lash Mascara- Dark Brown

star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
3.7
3D Lash Fiber Mascara DARK BROWN - Water Resistant Image: Simply Naked Beauty

If you don’t want to wear fake lashes and want to embrace the length and look of your natural lashes, this is an ideal lengthening and volumizing mascara to try. The mascara features a gel and 3D fiber formula that provides fuller and intense-looking lashes instantly. Plus, the mascara uses magnifying gel and microfibers to make the lashes look more extended and bright within just 5 minutes.

Color: Dark Brown | Product Dimensions: 6 x 2 x 1 inches | Weight: 4.96 Ounces

Pros
  • Water and smudge-proof
  • Made using organic and natural ingredients
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Easy application
  • Easy to wipe off
  • Cruelty-free and paraben-free
  • Buildable coverage

Cons
  • The gel formula may take time to build and dry-off.

protip_icon Quick Tip
Apply some baby powder on your eyelashes to make them smudge-proof and enhance the volume.

5. Best Travel-Friendly:Endlessly Beautiful Brown Mascara

star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
3.9
Brown Mascara by Endlessly Beautiful Image: Endlessly Beautiful

If you emphasize on using organic and natural beauty products, this Endlessly Beautiful Brown Mascara can be a great pick. The product is made using non-toxic, chemical-free and harmless natural ingredients to prevent your eyes from irritation. This is one of the best brown mascaras that are ideal for people with sensitive eyes as well as for contact lens wearers. This vegan mascara is gentle, features a moisturizing formula and is also gluten and paraben-free.

Color: Brown

Pros
  • Smudge and flake-free
  • Thickens and lengthens the lashes
  • Water and sweat-proof
  • Infused with vitamin E, chamomile and conditioning ingredients
  • Compact and travel-friendly
  • Strengthens the lashes

Cons
  • Mascara may dry off quickly
worth-buy-icon

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

The overwhelming 2,283 positive reviews on Amazon show how popular this product is with happy users.

6. Best Organic Formula:Ecco Bella FlowerColor Advanced Vegan brown Mascara- Brown

If you don’t want to end up with those panda eyes at the end of the day, this vegan mascara is a perfect option that is water-resistant and will prevent your mascara from smudging for hours.  The lash lift mascara features a water-resistant and smudge-proof formula, and yet it is not waterproof, which means that you won’t have to spend hours to remove it. While using soap or a gentle makeup remover, you can wipe off the mascara within minutes and without hurting your lashes.

Color: Brown | Product Dimensions: 5 x 5 x 5 inches | Weight: 0.32 Ounces

Pros
  • All-natural formula
  • Utilized clay and flower cutins
  • Delicate and lightweight coat
  • Designed for sensitive eyes
  • Gluten and fragrance-free
  • Clump-resistant

Cons
  • Some may not like the design and application of the brush
worth-buy-icon

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

More than 1,479 customers have given the product positive reviews on Amazon.

7. Best Skin-Friendly:Pacifica Beauty Stellar Gaze Length & Strength Mascara- Stardust Brown

If you are looking for a mascara that can offer a dramatic and party-ready poppy look, then this is the mascara you should opt for. This stardust brown mascara offers long, plump and gorgeous looking lashes in a single stroke. This mascara has a long-lasting, nourishing and gentle formula, and it is infused with coconut water, minerals, and vitamin B for making your lashes stronger and healthier. The mascara helps in strengthening the lashes while adding volume, and thus, it is a good option if you are worried about your lashes falling off. Check out the review of this product on YouTube to know why it is one of the best out there.

Color: Black | Product Dimensions: 1 x 1 x 5.2 inches | Weight: 0.71 Ounces

Pros
  • Plush vegan brush
  • Paraben, phthalate, and toxin-free
  • Skin-friendly product
  • Water-resistant formula
  • Easy to remove

Cons
  • May make the lashes look glued together
worth-buy-icon

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

More than 3,669 Amazon users have vouched for this amazing product.

8. Best For Sensitive Eyes:Burt’s Bees 100% Natural Origin Nourishing Mascara- Black Brown

The easy-to-use applicator that comes with this mascara tube is a key to get long and voluminous lashes. This ophthalmologist-tested mascara will make you feel as if you are wearing false lashes or extensions. The brush of the mascara adds more volume in the upper and lower lashes and will provide an instantly bright look. The mascara is formulated with jojoba oil to moisturize and strengthen the lashes to prevent them from falling off.

Color: Black Brown | Product Dimensions: 2.25 x 0.71 x 8.31 inches | Weight: 0.01 Ounces

Pros
  • Loaded with the goodness of glycerine
  • Ophthalmologist-tested for sensitive eyes
  • Phthalate, paraben, and synthetic fragrance-free
  • Combs and brushes the lashes
  • Safe for contact lens wearers

Cons
  • May not be 100% waterproof

My Personal Experience

"This one's a great mascara for those who prefer a natural product. The medium brown color looks stunning upon application and is good for daily wear. It even layers well with a primer for a fuller lash look. It does not flake and is easy to remove."


9. Best Antioxidant-Rich:Neutrogena Healthy Lengths Mascara

If you are looking for a mascara that offers depth and dimension, this nourishing and hydrating mascara is filled with vitamin E and rice protein to enhance the natural beauty of your lashes. This refreshing mascara by Neutrogena promotes healthy lash growth and strengthens the lashes from roots. The lengthening mascara will help your lashes to grow to the fullest and look beautifully brushed and combed. Plus, its rich brown pigment will make eyes of any color look popped and bright. It is a must have for the perfect eye makeup look! In this YouTube video, you will find a detailed review of this product based on a tester’s experience with it.

Color: 03 / Brown | Product Dimensions: 0.6 x 2.25 x 5.81 inches | Weight: 0.83 Ounces

Pros
  • Smudge-free
  • Flake and clump-resistant
  • Antioxidant-rich color
  • Dermatologist and ophthalmologist-tested
  • Perfect for everyday wear
  • Easily removed with soap and water

Cons
  • Some find the product a little dry.

10. Best Volumizing:ETUDE HOUSE Color Eyebrow Mascara- Light Brown

star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
4.1

This is a mascara from the celebrity-endorsed brand Etude House that offers a neat and clean layer of pigment to your lashes. The sturdy and volumizing brush won’t leave your single lash uncovered and will offer plump and fuller lashes. Reviewers love the bright brown pigment of the mascara. It dries off quickly to fix the color on the lashes and make your eyes pop. Plus, the mascara is filled with the goodness of allantoin, carnauba wax, and beeswax to nourish the lashes and moisturize the skin for healthy lash growth.

Color: #2 Light Brown

Pros
  • Ideal for lashes and brows
  • Soft hold gel to lengthen the brows
  • Waterproof and smudge-proof
  • Stays all day long
  • Offers a natural yet pigmented look

Cons
  • The gel formula may stick the lashes together.

11. Best Highly Pigmented:Revlon Volumizing Mascara- Blackened Brown

This mascara uses its deep pigment for coating every single lash effectively. The mascara features a waterproof formula and offers a deep blackened brown color for an everyday bold makeup look. It’s ultra-creamy, and rich quick building formula will make your lashes look voluminous and long within a few minutes of application and will offer an instant color impact. Apart from this, the expertly crafted brush is designed with wavy and high-end filaments to cover every lash to hold the needed amount of product and look svelte.

Color: Blackened Brown (903) | Product Dimensions: 0.88 x 2.38 x 5.75 inches | Weight: 0.81 Ounces

Pros
  • All-day wear
  • Smudge-free formula
  • Offers fanned-out volume
  • Triple intensity pigments
  • Loaded with the goodness of olive oil and carnauba wax.

Cons
  • May not provide optimum curling

Mascara is one of the most popular make-up purchases. They come in a wide variety of colors, styles, and abilities. Brown mascaras give a natural definition to your eyelashes and add rich color to your eyes. When it comes to choosing a brown mascara, there are a few things you should consider. Check them out below.

What To Consider In A Brown Mascara — A Buying Guide

  • Function: consider the function you are looking for, is it volume, length, definition, curl, or thickness? It is important to get the right brown mascara to make your eyes appear more attractive and complement your overall eye makeup. Look for wand britstles with a thickness of .15 mm. This one has a lot of volume and makes your eyes stand out. Avoid thicknesses of .20 mm or .25 mm as they can be too thick.
  • Formula: opt for long-lasting and water-resistant formulas that last throughout the day. Good mascaras are resistant to oily eyelids, sunlight, tears, and sweat. You can also look for mascaras that dries quickly, which helps prevent smudging. Look for an easy to use formula that does not clump your lashes on application. Look for ophthalmologist-tested, hypoallergenic formulas if you wear lenses or have sensitive skin and eyes.
  • Ingredients: look out for mascaras that contain harmful substances like mineral oils, parabens, formaldehyde, fluorine, propylene glycol, aluminium powder, and vitamin A acetate. Look for mascaras enriched with lanolin, castor oil, carnauba wax, and candelilla wax. They should be safe to use since they go near your eyes.
  • Other Features: opt for travel-friendly packaging with easy-to-hold wands and mess-free formulas if you have a busy schedule or apply makeup on the go. Look for ingredients like panthenol and ceramides for healthy lashes.

Infographic: Benefits Of A Brown Mascara & Unique Ways Of Using It

Brown mascaras are ideal if you desire a natural, no-makeup makeup look. In contrast to black mascaras, they give a minimalistic effect to your lashes yet steal the show. That’s not all! Check out the infographic below to know the benefits of wearing a brown mascara and how to use it in unique ways.

Benefits Of A Brown Mascara & Unique Ways Of Using It(infographic)

Illustration: StyleCraze Design Team

The Bottom Line

Statement-making mascaras and an instant pop to your eye makeup. Unlike regular mascaras, the best brown mascaras look more natural and instantly lift your eyes. The L’Oreal Paris Voluminous Mascara- Washable Black Brown is a great choice for people who want to add volume to their lashes, while Maybelline Lash Sensational Washable Mascara- Brownish Black is for those who want a plump and fuller look. The Covergirl Lash Blast Volume Mascara- Black Brown is great for those who want to create a dramatic look. These above-listed products smoothly glide on the eyelids and provide you with voluminous lashes. In addition, they are highly pigmented and give an intense color payoff. These products are also suitable for people with contact lenses and sensitive eyes. These mascaras are easy to apply, waterproof, and smudge-proof. However, some mascaras may feel sticky or dry out your lashes, so it is best to stay away from those. Closely refer to the product reviews to grab the best brown mascaras to suit your makeup needs.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who should wear brown mascara?

Brown mascaras work wonders on light-colored eyelashes or completely blonde lashes. People with light complexions look great in brown-colored mascaras.

Does brown mascara look good on blue eyes?

Yes, brown mascaras enhance blue and green eyes. It prevents your eyes from appearing too dark, which may happen if you put on regular black mascara on blue eyes.

Does brown mascara make your eyes look bigger?

Yes, brown mascaras make your eyes appear bigger and warm up your complexion, no matter what your undertone is. Use lengthening formulas and couple the mascara with a bright lip shade.

Is brown mascara better for mature women?

While some quip that brown mascara color makes mature eyes look reddish, others note that the color enhances their eyes. However, a regular black mascara may look too bright on mature eyes; instead, you can try a brown mascara to get a more natural look.


Recommended Articles:

Cha Cha Woska

Cha Cha WoskaCertified Makeup Artist

Cha Cha is a certified professional makeup artist, airbrush makeup artist, and beauty educator with over 20 years in the beauty industry. She is also the owner of Cha Cha Beauty Bar and has done extensive work in the bridal and special event categories. She has a passion for beauty education and loves teaching her clients quick and easy ways...read full bio