15 Best Cream Eyeshadows That Won’t Crease (2024), As Per A Cosmetologist
Blend these shimmery, sophisticated cream hues over your eyelids to make a statement.
Danielle Wilkinson BrucklacherLicensed Cosmetologist 
Danielle obtained her cosmetology license from MTI College and continued with her education in Makeup Artistry at Bellus Academy. She then began session styling for weddings and special events, including celebrity occasions. With 14 years o... more
baishali bhattacharyaMA (English) Baishali is a beauty and lifestyle writer and holds a master's degree in English from Assam University. She specializes in makeup and fashion and is also a certified Style and Image Consultant. Prior ... more
srijani roy chowdhuryMA (Journalism & Mass Communication), Certified Style & Image Consultant Experience: 3 yearsSrijani is an associate commerce editor with a master's degree in journalism and mass communication from the University of Calcutta, West Bengal. She is certified in makeup techniques and is also a ce... more
krati darakMBA, Certified Skin Care Coach Experience: 3 yearsKrati is an associate commerce editor, a certified skin care coach, and a beauty enthusiast. She has a master’s degree in advertising and publishing relations from DAVV University and three years of ... more
Image: StyleCraze Design Team
Nail the perfectly creaseless eye makeup looks with the best cream eyeshadow! With just one swoop eyeshadow sticks or creams give a vivid effect quickly. They say that the eyes speak a million words. Well, a cream eyeshadow gives your eyes a stunning look to convey those words even more accurately. Add some sheer, color, or glitter effects to your cream eyeshadow to get the best eye looks and become the talk of the town! Go ahead and pick form the 15 best cream eyeshadows that we have listed in this article.
In This Article
15 Best Cream Eyeshadows That Won’t Budge Or Crease –2023
1. Best Anti-Aging:By Terry Ombre Blackstar Cream Eyeshadow Pen
By Terry Ombre Blackstar Cream Eyeshadow Pen is a 3-in-1 eyeshadow, eyeliner, and illuminator. It features Tahitian black pearl extracts enriched with anti-aging proteins and fortifying calcium. The eyeshadow pen is easily blendable and buildable and has a creamy texture. It glides effortlessly onto the eyelids and provides a highly pigmented color. The eyeshadow pen has a stunning iridescent finish that lasts long and its special pen shape ensures mess-free application. This eye shadow has light-reflecting properties, which lift the eyelids to make the eyes look wider and brighter. If you are still unsure about purchasing, you can check out a review of this product on YouTube.
- Anti-aging
- Buildable
- Blendable
- Travel-friendly
- Long-lasting
- Expensive
2. Best Long-Wear:Bobbi Brown Long Wear Cream Shadow Stick
The Bobbi Brown Cream Eye Shadow Stick has a long-lasting formula. The color does not crease, stays put all day, and blends softly onto the skin. The product feels comfortable and light on the eyes. It is easy to carry and travel-friendly.
- Blends easily
- No creasing
- Long-lasting
- Easy to use
- Suitable for all-day wear
- May not suit sensitive skin
3. Best Cruelty-Free:Lauren Brooke Cosmetiques Natural Cream Eyeshadow
Lauren Brooke Cosmétiques Natural Cream Eyeshadow in the shade Dulce De Leche has a matte finish. Its organic formula with a silky smooth texture effortlessly blends onto the eyelid for a satin finish and stays all day long. The cream eyeshadow is formulated with 99.7% certified organic botanical ingredients containing essential minerals, vitamins, antioxidants, and pigments. These natural pigments create excellent, opulent colors. The product contains shea butter, rosehip, vitamin E, and jojoba oil to soften, moisturize, nourish, protect, and revitalize the skin while providing anti-aging benefits.
- Organic
- Matte finish
- Blends easily
- Cruelty-free
- Poor color payoff
Pro TipBy Terry Ombre Blackstar Cream Eyeshadow Pen Best Anti-Aging | Bobbi Brown Long Wear Cream Shadow Stick Best Long-Wear | Lauren Brooke Cosmetiques Natural Cream Eyeshadow Best Cruelty-Free | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Color | Ombre Mecure | - | Dulce De Leche (Matte). |
| Dimensions | 1.4 x 5.3 x 0.8 inches | 1.5 x 1.5 x 5 inches | - |
| Weight | 0.06 Ounces | 0.2 Ounces | - |
| Rating | |||
| Reviews | 195 | 402 | 679 |
| Price | $38 | $38.91 | $13.0 |
4. Best Waterproof: Focallure 2 Pcs Shimmer Cream Eyeshadow Stick
The Focallure 2 Pcs Shimmer Cream Eyeshadow Stick is made to give off a shimmering, illuminating effect ideal for drawing attention to the eyes. The crease-proof formula guarantees that the eyeshadow won’t crease or fade all day. The waterproof formula is perfect for people who live in hot, humid regions because it is also resistant to sweat, water, and humidity. You can create various looks with the help of this eyeshadow pencil.
- Crease-proof formula
- Waterproof formula
- Precise application
- Various shades to choose from
- Suitable for all-day wear
- Limited shade range
Pro Tip5. Best For All Skin Types:bareMinerals 5-in-1 BB Advanced Performance Cream Eyeshadow
The bareMinerals 5-in-1 Advanced Performance Cream Eyeshadow is a high-performance and long-wearing eye color with skin care benefits. This product comes with broad-spectrum SPF 15 protection and is suitable for all skin types. It contains skin-friendly ingredients and lasts up to 12 hours. You can use it as an eye primer as well. The product smoothens the appearance of fine lines and brightens the eyes.
- No creasing
- Sun protection
- Suits all skin types
- Multipurpose
- Too light
6. Best Skin-Friendly:Jillian Dempsey Lid Tint
The Jillian Dempsey Lid Tint is a vegan eyeshadow that gives a natural and sheer color to the eyes. The organic formula is devoid of harmful chemicals and is safe for the skin. It contains skin-friendly ingredients and natural antioxidants like coconut oil and shea butter. These ingredients keep the skin moisturized, hydrated, and protected from environmental aggressors. The cream-based sheer eyeshadow offers an iridescent glow and ultimate shimmer for an instant brightening. You can check out this YouTuber’s review of the product if you require more convincing.
- Paraben-free
- Sulfate-free
- Phthalates-free
- Petrochemicals-free
- GMO-free
- Synthetic fragrance-free
- Dye-free
- Cruelty-free
- Vegan
- Organic
- Does not last long
7. Best Lightweight: e.l.f. Bite-Size Eyeshadows
The e.l.f. Cosmetic Bite-Size Eyeshadow palette has four carefully chosen, highly pigmented eyeshadow hues with rich textures ranging from matte to sparkly. They are made to be portable and simple to blend to create a variety of eye makeup looks. The palette is vegan and cruelty-free and can accommodate various skin tones and preferences.
- Affordable
- Travel-friendly
- Easy to blend
- Pigmented
- Variety of shades
- Long-lasting
- Causes fall out
"This eyeshadow is perfect for those trying to achieve a simple makeup look. It has wide color options that help to build from sheer to a more pronounced look. It pairs amazingly with primer and stays on till you remove it with makeup remover."
Why We Think It's Worth Buying
A whopping 5,918 reviews on Amazon make it obvious that users genuinely love this product.
8. Best Buildable: Glo Skin Beauty Cream Eyeshadow Stick
Glo Skin Beauty Cream Eyeshadow Stick has rich pigments with buildable color. It offers maximum versatility as you can use it as an eye makeup base, shadow, and liner. The multipurpose eye stick is free of chemicals and stays on for 12 hours. The stick features a built-in sharpener and is convenient to use and travel-friendly.
- Multipurpose
- 12-hour stay
- Buildable
- Cruelty-free
- Paraben-free
- Talc-free
- Poor color payoff
9. Most Versatile Palette: Wet n Wild Color Icon Cream Eyeshadow
The Wet n Wild Color Icon Cream Eyeshadow is a long-lasting, waterproof metallic eyeshadow pencil. This product is made to offer an intense color payoff that doesn’t smear or fade over the day. The eyeshadow pencil is simple to use and can help you create a range of looks, from natural to dramatic. It is ideal for all-day wear, thanks to its waterproof composition. The precision application offered by the pencil form makes it simple to achieve a wide range of styles. It is a wonderful addition to any beauty collection because of its superior formula and excellent shade range.
- Long-lasting
- Waterproof
- Easy to apply
- Versatile
- Travel-friendly
- Settles very quickly
10. Best Matte Finish:bareMinerals Gen Nude Eyeshadow Plus Primer
The bareMinerals Gen Nude Eyeshadow Plus Primer has a creamy texture. The multi-purpose formula can be used alone or as a primer for long-lasting effects. Its cream-to-powder formula is easy to apply and blend and offers a matte finish with a slight shimmery effect.
- Multi-tasking
- Easy to apply
- Matte finish
- Subtle shimmer
- Blendable
- Chalky
11. Mary Kay Cream Eye Color
The Mary Kay Cream Eye Color also works as a powerful primer and eyeshadow. It gives a soft look to the eyes with its subtle color. It is buildable and you can layer the eyeshadow to make it vibrant. This versatile product suits all skin types and has a simple glide application. Its long-wearing and buildable formula lasts up to 10 hours.
- Non-comedogenic
- Versatile
- Crease-proof
- Water-proof
- Long-lasting
None
12. Julep Beauty Eyeshadow
The Julep Beauty Eyeshadow is a crème to powder stick in the shade taupe shimmer. The waterproof formula offers an impressive color pay-off that stays crease-proof all day long. The color glides on easily and requires no brushes for application. It is buildable and sets quickly. The product comes with a sponge for smudging, blending, and diffusing color. Its formula is enriched with vitamins C and E to nourish and protect your eyelids from free radical damages.
- Buildable
- Brush-free application
- Water-proof
- Crease-proof
- Long-lasting
- May crease
Why We Think It's Worth Buying
This product has made it to our top favorite list with more than 28,071 rave reviews on Amazon.
13. Luxaza Metallic Eyeshadow Stick
The Luxaza Metallic Eyeshadow Stick has buildable color and is waterproof, and long-lasting. It gives a luminous, smokey, sultry metallic finish to the eyes. The fast-applying shadow lasts for 5-20 hours with quick touch-ups. The creamy texture of the product goes on smoothly without smudging or clumping. This product is ideal for sculpting, shading, or defining the eyes and comes with a blending brush. Its auto-rotating tube design requires no sharpening.
- Easy touch-up
- Smooth texture
- Buildable
- Water-proof
- Too shiny
14. Hourglass Scattered Light Eyeshadow
The Hourglass Scattered Light Eyeshadow reflects light to give a high-impact eye makeup look. The lightweight glitter shadow with light-reflecting pearls creates a sparkling effect. Its hybrid cream formula offers buildable dimensions ranging from a soft glimmer to an intense, prismatic finish. This eyeshadow is available in nine shades and formulated without harmful chemicals and is safe for the eyes.
- Buildable
- Paraben-free
- Fragrance-free
- Gluten-free
- Sulfates-free
- Nanoparticles-free
- Phthalates-free
- Synthetic dye-free
- GMO-free
- Talc-free
- Cruelty-free
Not enough shimmer
15. Supergoop! Shimmershade
The Supergoop! Shimmershade is a long-wearing eye makeup that does not crease or fade. It is formulated with broad-spectrum SPF 30 sun protection. The creamy formula suits all skin and instantly brightens the eyes. The eye luminizer has a light-reflecting feature and adds a sheer coat of shimmer to your eyelids. It is available in four shades and easily applicable by using your fingers. The formula is a blend of roman chamomile, rose, sunflower, and jasmine, which are rich in antioxidants. These ingredients protect and soothe the delicate eye area.
- Long-lasting
- Sun protection
- Crease-proof
- Flake-free
- Non-fading
- Too sparkly
Now that you know the 15 best cream eyeshadows to achieve your desired look, ihere is a guide to help you apply a cream eyeshadow. Keep scrolling!
How To Apply Cream Eyeshadow: Step-By-Step Process
- Use A Primer: Apply an eyeshadow primer on the eyelids. This is especially necessary for oily skin. A primer locks the eye shadow to last all day and creates a smooth base for seamless application.
- Apply A Base Coat: Apply a cream eyeshadow in a neutral shade as a base.
Dab the cream with your finger on the middle of the eyelid and blend it towards the inner and outer corners of the eye. Then, blend towards your brow bone. - Apply A Cream Eyeshadow: Apply the cream shadow and blend the product with a brush in circular strokes.
Optional Steps:
- Blend Cream With Powder Eyeshadow: This step helps to add dimension to the eyes or create a smokey make-up look. Blend in complementary shades using powder eyeshadow. The powder color can also be used to add highlights or reduce the crease. Cream shadows set and dry fast, while a powder eyeshadow can create wonderful highlights and crease color.
- Apply Cream Shadow Along Your Lash Line: This is an optional step to add glamor to the eyes. Use a dense brush or ring finger to apply some cream shadow along the lower lash line and blend into the inner corners of the eye.
Choosing the right cream eyeshadow brightens the eyes and keeps them safe. Given below are some tips on how to choose the best cream eyeshadow.
How To Choose The Best Cream Eyeshadow
- Long-Wear: Pick a shadow that is fade-resistant, smudge-proof, and waterproof, so it lasts hours.
- Check The Ingredients: Pick a shadow with ingredients like coconut oil, almond oil, and shea butter, keeping the eyelids nourished and hydrated.
- Anti-Aging Benefits: The eye shadow cream should be antioxidant-rich to protect the eye skin from environmental aggressors and minimize the signs of aging. Look for ingredients like vitamins A, C, and E.
- Chemical-Free Formula: Choose a shadow that is free of harmful chemical ingredients. Natural botanical ingredients are the best to keep the skin and eyes protected from side effects.
The Bottom Line
There is no doubt that the cream and stick eyeshadow formulas have taken over the whole beauty industry in the past few years. The By Terry Ombre Blackstar Cream Eyeshadow Pen has a velvety consistency that’s easy to apply while the Bobbi Brown Long Wear Cream Shadow Stick doesn’t crease and blends easily on the skin, and the e.l.f. Bite-Size Eyeshadows offer compact choices in a variety of shades. The best cream eyeshadows can help you nail the perfectly creaseless eye makeup looks in no time. Nothing beats the creamy formulas when it comes to color, texture, and vibrancy. The best part about these eyeshadows is that they do not get fussy, and there is no fallout. We recommend using a primer and a base coat before applying a cream foundation to get the perfect base for your makeup.
Why Trust StyleCraze?
The author, Baishali Bhattacharya is a certified image consultant and expert in makeup techniques. She has curated this list of best cream eyeshadows while keeping the necessary quality parameters in mind. Baishali has browsed through online reviews from customers who have tried on some of the eyeshadows to bring forth this list for her readers. She believes that these cream eyeshadows ensure mess-free application and last longer as compared to other products available in the market.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are cream eyeshadows better than powder eyeshadows?
Yes, cream eyeshadows are better than powder eyeshadows. A powder eyeshadow easily fades and smudges, stains clothes, and does not last as long as a cream eyeshadow.
Is a cream eyeshadow better for mature skin?
Yes, a cream eyeshadow is better for mature skin. Although it suits all skin types and ages, a cream shadow will have hydrating and anti-aging ingredients ideal for mature skin.
How can I make my eyeshadow creamier?
Blend the eyeshadow with a shadow stick to make it creamier.
How long does cream eyeshadow last?
Cream eyeshadows have a shelf life of 6-8 months.
How to keep cream eyeshadow from creasing?
To keep the eye shadow from creasing, apply a primer under the cream shadow. It will also prevent the shadow from becoming chunky and last long.
Is cream eyeshadow better for sensitive eyes?
Yes, cream eye shadows are better for sensitive skin as they contain moisturizing and nourishing agents and protect the skin from aggressors. Powder base causes flaking and extra irritation to sensitive eyes.
Is cream eyeshadow good for hooded eyes?
No. Cream eyeshadows may cause unflattering creasing on the eyelid for hooded eyes.
