9 Best Cruelty-Free Eyeliners You Should Get Your Hands On (2024)

Elevate the beauty of your eyes with a smudge-free and long-lasting eye makeup look.

Reviewed by Deepti Sadhwani, Professional Makeup Artist & Licensed Barber
Written by Srijita De, MA (English & Literature), Certified Style & Image Consultant
Edited by Rajeshwari Das, MA (Journalism & Mass Communication)
Fact-checked by Srijani Roy Chowdhury, MA (Journalism & Mass Communication), Certified Style & Image Consultant  • 

Eyeliners are an ideal way to express your eyes. And, if you are an advocate for green earth and animal safety, you can try the best cruelty-free eyeliner to help you achieve smoky eyes, cat’s eye flick, and winged lines smoothly. Although many eyeliner brands claim they are not animal tested or cruelty-free, they may still have beeswax, carmine, and stearic acid in their ingredients list. So, check for a stamp from PETA or Leaping Bunny before you make a purchase.

The eyeliners in our list are smudge-free, long-lasting, and hypoallergenic. They are available in the form of gel eyeliners, liquid eyeliners, and pencil eyeliners that are easy to use. Furthermore, the cruelty-free eyeliners are formulated with plant-derived ingredients and contain no harmful chemicals that irritate your eyes. This article is a list of the 9 best cruelty-free eyeliners that make your eyes appealing.

Top PicksCheck Price
Best Overall:Honest Beauty Liquid Eyeliner
Price on Amazon
Best Quick-Drying:Zuzu Luxe Liquid Eyeliner
Price on Amazon
Best Pigmented:Beauty For Real Waterproof Eyeliner
Price on Amazon
Best For All Skin Types:Kokie Retractable Liquid EyelinerPrice on Amazon
Best For Contact Lens Wearers:Vasanti Kajal Waterline Eyeliner
Price on Amazon
Best Smear-Proof:Milani Infinite Liquid Eyeliner
Price on Amazon
Best Long-Lasting:Honeybee Gardens Eyeliner - Belgian ChocolatePrice on Amazon
Best Waterproof:3INA Cruelty-Free Matte Pen Eyeliner
Price on Amazon
Best Smudge-proof:Almay Eyeliner Pencil
Price on Amazon

Top 9 Best Cruelty-Free Eyeliners Of 2024

1. Best Overall:Honest Beauty Liquid Eyeliner

4.1
Honest Beauty Liquid Eyeliner Vegan Smudge Flake Transfer Proof Carbon Free Silicone Free Cruelty Free Ophthalmologist Tested 0.058 fl. oz, Black, 0.06 Fl Oz Image: Honest Beauty

Suppose you struggle to perfect the winged eyeliner look or any eyeliner style for that matter. Ideal for beginners and professionals alike, the Honest Beauty Liquid Eyeliner comes with a long and flexible tip that can make application easy to practice and master. You can create thick or thin, bold or mellow precision lines with the fantastic tip of this vegan liquid eyeliner. It is packed with all the properties that anyone would look for in a perfect eyeliner — no flaking, no smudging, long-lasting, hypoallergenic, and ophthalmologist-tested. None of the nasty ingredients like parabens, silicones, petrochemicals, or carbon black make it to this product with intense pigmentation, which rightfully earns this celebrity-endorsed brand its name — Honest Beauty Eyeliner.

Color: Black | Product Dimensions: 0.6 x 0.5 x 4.6 inches | Weight: 0.32 Ounces.

Pros

  • Long-lasting
  • Dermatologist-tested
  • Opthamologist-tested
  • Does not smudge or flake
  • Satin finish
  • 8-hour wear
  • Easy to wash off
  • Quick-drying
  • Ultra-pigmented
  • Suitable for sensitive skin
  • Sustainable

Cons

  • It may be difficult to apply if you have greasy or excessively oily skin.
  • However an eyeshadow primer from mac, nars or elf can help with staying power.

My Personal Experience

"This eyeliner comes with a flexible brush that applies the product easily to my lids. It is highly pigmented and gives me a bold look. I love that it is easy to remove too. The formula is long-lasting and it lends a satiny finish."


protip_icon Pro Tip
If you cannot draw the perfect wing using liquid eyeliner, try applying sticky tape to the corners of your eyes and then draw the wings. This way, if you make a mistake, it will not affect the makeup and can be quickly removed with tape.

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

With over 3,017 Amazon acclaimed reviews, this product is sure to find a place in everyone’s shopping bag.

2. Best Quick-Drying:Zuzu Luxe Liquid Eyeliner

4.3
ZUZU LUXE Precision Liquid Liner (Raven - Black/ Matte), Liquid Eyeliner featuring a fine calligraphy tip, quick-drying, water resistant. Natural, Paraben Free, Vegan, Gluten-free,Cruelty-free, Non GMO, 0.1 oz. Image: Zuzu Luxe

Zuzu Luxe all-natural cruelty-free liquid eyeliner is a quick-drying formula enriched with the goodness of jojoba oil for better hydration. In addition to jojoba oil, it is packed with ingredients like aloe barbadensis leaf juice that make it soothing without compromising its creamy consistency. This brush tip eyeliner is popular for being a clean product sans parabens, gluten, and GMO, making it one of the best organic alternatives. The calligraphy tip aids in a smooth and precise application and all you need is a few seconds for the eyeliner to dry so that you can move on to your lipstick and blush without wasting precious time. Click here to check out a detailed personal review of this product.

Color: Raven | Product Dimensions: 4.1 x 0.7 x 0.7 inches | Weight: 0.16 Ounces

Pros

  • Skin-loving natural ingredients
  • Budge-free brush
  • Non-flaky
  • Available in many shades

Cons

  • It is water-resistant, not waterproof.

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

There are more than 934 Amazon reviews attesting to the quality of the product and endorsing its value.

3. Best Pigmented:Beauty For Real Waterproof Eyeliner

This eyeliner is a gel-based crayon eyeliner with a creamy texture for smooth application. If you find it hard to work with an eyeliner brush, this is the best kohl eyeliner that can replace your liquid eyeliner and make your life easier. It contains vitamin E, making it a nourishing and conditioning eyeliner. If you like to experiment with smokey-eye looks, the Beauty For Real eyeliner with intense pigmentation won’t disappoint you. While it is easy to smudge the eyeliner for a smokey eye, you can also conveniently use it for well-defined strokes. Reviews on online forums assert that the product offers a subtle spread and is even suitable for sensitive eyes.

Color: Black Matte | Product Dimensions: 5.25 x 0.62 x 0.62 inches | Weight: 0.3 Ounces

Pros

  • Waterproof
  • Long-lasting
  • Richly pigmented
  • Twist-open mechanism
  • It can also be used on the waterline.

Cons

  • It may not be smear-resistant.

protip_icon Pro Tip
Apply the eyeliner on the upper lash line and then use a flat brush or a q-tip to smudge the eyeliner into the lash line. Set it with the help of black eyeshadow and you will achieve the perfect smudged eyeliner look.

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

The overwhelming 1,323 positive reviews on Amazon show how popular this product is with happy users.

4. Best For All Skin Types:Kokie Retractable Liquid Eyeliner

Make your eye makeup pop with the Kokie Retractable Liquid Eyeliner. This eyeliner comes with a pointed tip and offers an intense carbon black color. The eyeliner extends to full size upon opening and collapses upon closing, making it a travel-friendly choice. It provides smooth gliding, smudge-free, application, and prevents clumps.

Product Dimensions: 0.4 x 0.4 x 3.8 inches | Weight: 0.81 Ounces.

Pros

  • Water-proof
  • Long-lasting
  • Travel-friendly
  • Does not bleed
  • Lightweight
  • Suitable for all skin types

Cons

None

5. Best For Contact Lens Wearers:Vasanti Kajal Waterline Eyeliner

4.1
VASANTI Kajal Waterline Eyeliner Pencil - Long-lasting, Waterproof, Smudge-proof, Safe for Sensitive Eyes, Waterline Eye Liner - Opthalmologist Approved and Tested (Intense Black) Image: Vasanti Cosmetics

When you apply eyeliner, water-lining completes the look, and there are no two ways about it. But finding the right waterline eyeliner that’s safe for the eyes and does not transfer to the lower waterline, unless you decide to fill it, can be a struggle. Vasanti Kajal Waterline Eyeliner can solve this problem. It is ophthalmologically tested, incredibly pigmented, and  stays intact for hours. You can also apply it to both the water lines for a bold celebrity-inspired look, or to define your lashes. It is paraben and gluten-free, making it suitable for sensitive eyes. Also, this one is a favorite among reviewers who are in awe of its creamy texture and precise application.

Color: Intense Black | Product Dimensions: 0.75 x 5.2 x 0.59 inches | Weight: 0.32 Ounces

Pros

  • Long-lasting
  • Easy to apply
  • Dermatologist-tested
  • Transfer-proof
  • It is safe to use for contact lens wearers.

Cons

  • Slightly expensive
  • It is non-retractable (you can’t slide it back in if you over twist it).

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

It has received 3,161 reviews on Amazon and is a popular choice among shoppers.

6. Best Smear-Proof:Milani Infinite Liquid Eyeliner

4.2
Milani Infinite Liquid Eyeliner - Everlast (0.17 Fl. Oz.) Vegan, Cruelty-Free Liquid Eyeliner to Define & Intensify Eyes for Up to 24 Hours Image: Milani

Milani Infinite Liquid Eyeliner is famous for its high-quality, waterproof formula, among other exceptional qualities. If you’re out to watch an emotional movie at the theater, you’d still walk out of it looking fabulous, even after a good cry. Many users also call it “cry-proof”, making it the ideal choice if you live in a humid place, are a swimmer, a sportsperson, or take a crowded bus to your workplace on a sultry day. This non-toxic, liquid eyeliner is quite pigmented, and it is a PETA-certified cruelty-free eyeliner. To understand the nuances of the product in detail, you can check out this review.

Color: Everlast | Product Dimensions: 1.93 x 0.7 x 5.5 inches | Weight: 0.18 Ounces

Pros

  • Fade-proof
  • Smear-proof
  • 24-hour wear
  • The brush does not fray.

Cons

  • Some may find the application brush too stiff.

7. Best Long-Lasting:Honeybee Gardens Eyeliner – Belgian Chocolate

4.2
Honeybee Gardens Effortless Eye Liner, Belgian Chocolate | Gluten Free, Vegan, Paraben Free Image: Honeybee Gardens

If you’re a fan of pencil eyeliners, Honeybee Gardens Eyeliner is the best natural eyeliner on a budget. A truly black eyeliner may sometimes be the center of attention and overshadows the rest of the makeup. If you’re hunting for a fix for this, choosing a neutral color like Belgian Chocolate can solve your problem. This shade is ideal for an elegant and subtle finish without going over the top. It is free of synthetic fragrances, phthalates, SLS, and parabens, bringing a clean and toxin-free pencil eyeliner to your makeup bag. Check out this YouTuber’s review that details the tester’s experience with using the product.

Color: Belgian Chocolate | Product Dimensions: 5.5 x 0.4 x 0.4 inches | Weight: 0.64 Ounces

Pros

  • Glides on easily
  • Long-lasting
  • Available in other shades
  • Works well on dry skin without pulling the lids.

Cons

  • As it is softer than regular eyeliner formula, one needs to be careful while sharpening it.

8. Best Waterproof:3INA Cruelty-Free Matte Pen Eyeliner

4.3

If you’re strictly on the lookout for natural, waterproof eyeliners with a matte finish, the 3INA matte pen eyeliner is tailor-made for you. Many influencers vouch for 3INA products, and it’s serving serious competition to many cruelty-free drugstore eyeliners. It stays intact for hours as the day progresses from morning to evening. The pen is sleek and easy to hold, helping you maneuver them better. It doesn’t bleed, crease, or smudge, and the fact that it is free of harmful toxins and is a certified vegan eyeliner makes it worth a try.

Number of Items: 1

Pros

  • Waterproof
  • Smudge-proof
  • 24-hour wear
  • Flexible precision tip
  • Matte finish

Cons

  • The pen may run out of ink sooner than expected.

Product Link:

9. Best Smudge-proof:Almay Eyeliner Pencil

4.4

The Almay Eyeliner Pencil is designed to glide on smoothly and stay in place for up to 16 hours. The waterproof and smudge-proof formula makes it a great option for all-day wear. The pencil glides on your skin smoothly without tugging on it for exceptional results and a perfect look. It even comes with a built-in sharpener so that you can keep applying it precisely. It is infused with vitamin E which makes it suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers also.

Color: 210 Black Amethyst | Product Dimensions: 0.75 x 1.94 x 5.75 inches | Weight: 0.32 Ounces.

Pros

  • Hypoallergenic
  • Cruelty-free
  • Oil-free
  • Fragrance-free
  • Ophthalmologist tested
  • Long-wearing
  • Water-resistant

Cons

None

Cruelty-free eyeliners are gentle on your eyes and the environment. However, picking the best cruelty-free eyeliner can be difficult with the various options available. With this buying guide, we will help you decide what type of eyeliner is best for you. Here are some things to consider before you buy.

What To Consider When Buying Cruelty-Free Eyeliner – Buying Guide

  • Type of Eyeliner

Decide what type of eyeliner you need. Various options are available. Liquid eyeliners are long-lasting and have various finishes; however, they may be difficult to apply. Therefore, if you’re a beginner, sketch and pencil eyeliners are best suited.

  • Waterproof

Choose an eyeliner that stays on all day long. Look for an eyeliner that won’t smudge or fade easily in the heat and humidity. Therefore, if you like your eyeliner to last, consider choosing a waterproof one. Moreover, waterproof eyeliner is ideal for you if you have watery eyes.

  • Smooth glide

The best cruelty-free eyeliners will have a smooth glide that does not tug on your skin or be patchy to apply. If you have sensitive skin, it’s best to go for a pencil or gel eyeliner with nourishing oils. It will help your eyeliner glide smoothly on the lid for a statement-making look without tugging at the skin.

  • Safe to use

Before you buy eyeliner, it’s best to determine if it’s safe to use. Cosmetics with mineral pigments are usually safer because they do not contain harmful chemicals. Avoid eyeliners with talc, BHA (butylated hydroxyanisole), urea, sulfates, and phthalates.

The Bottom Line

With consumers actively making conscious choices and switching to guilt-free products, many brands have started to make beauty products without testing them on animals. There are many cruelty-free eyeliners that are hypoallergenic, smudge-free, and long-lasting. The Honest Beauty Liquid Eyeliner lasts for about 8 long hours and delivers a satin finish, while the Zuzu Luxe Liquid Eyeliner soothes the eyelids and dries quickly to provide a matte finish. But if you want a waterproof formula that glides smoothly without tugging, the Almay Eyeliner Pencil is perfect for you. Deepti Sadhwani, a Professional Makeup Artist says “Anyone can wear eyeliner. All it takes is patience, practice, q-tips, and micellar water for quick clean-ups. Roll with the mistakes and don’t get discouraged.” You can purchase these eyeliners as they are also easy to use, and you can create seamless and precise lines with their sharp tips. Always opt for expertly crafted formulas that are not messy or flakey and tend to dry quickly. For people with sensitive skin and eyes, choose natural eyeliners with skin-friendly formulas. Additionally, check what reviewers have to say about the product and make a buying decision accordingly.

Why Trust StyleCraze?

The author of this article, Srijita De, is a fashion and makeup aficionado who advocated cruelty-free products and keeps studying new products in this range. Her strong knowledge of makeup trends and products help her curate this well-researched list of the best cruelty-free eyeliners for her readers. These products from cruelty-free makeup brands pamper your skin as they are plant-derived and contain no harmful chemicals.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do you know if an eyeliner is cruelty-free?

PETA is the most reliable website that can help determine if the eyeliner that you plan on purchasing is cruelty-free. All you have to do is go to their website and type the name of the brand on the search bar. If the brand shows up, the cruelty-free eyeliner is what it claims to be. You can also check the bunny logo and see if it matches PETA’s official bunny logo or the leaping bunny logos on the website.

Are cruelty-free eyeliners safe to use?

As per the FDA, most brands that are completely cruelty-free use extensive scientific literature and research papers with conclusive evidence, and credible studies to narrow down safe ingredients. Human trials upon informed consent are conducted to ensure that the different types of eyeliners, including other products, are safe.

Are L’Oréal and Maybelline cruelty-free?

Many websites claim that L’Oréal and Maybelline products are cruelty-free; however, they’re not. One of the easier ways to tell if a brand from any part of the world is cruelty-free is to see if they sell in Mainland China. Any product that is made or sold in Mainland China has to pass through the mandatory animal-testing procedure. L’Oréal products are sold in Mainland China, so its products are not cruelty-free. And L’Oréal is the parent company of Maybelline, which means most Maybelline products are animal-tested as well.

What’s the difference between vegan eyeliners and cruelty-free eyeliners?

Both these terms are used interchangeably, which creates a lot of confusion. Vegan cosmetics contain no animal by-products but can still be animal-tested. Cruelty-free products are not tested on animals — neither the product in itself nor the individual ingredients used for preparing the product. However, they can still contain animal by-products like beeswax, honey, yogurt, etc. So, when buying a product, you have to be clear about what you want it to be; vegan, cruelty-free, or both, and look for precise specifications as per that.

Recommended Articles

The following two tabs change content below.

Latest Articles