10 Best Drugstore Eyebrow Gels To Tame Those Unruly Brows

Written by Shalini Roy
All products recommended on StyleCraze are independently selected by our editorial team. If you make a purchase through any of these links, we may receive a commission. Learn more about our product selection process here.

Looking for a solution to thin brows? There is no need to shell out money on fake eyebrow extensions or search for expensive high-end products to give you those coveted Instagram brows. Your local drugstore can also offer affordable brow-grooming gels.

Eyebrow gel enhances your arches by adding volume or drama to them. With its smudge-free and non-flaky formula, you can sculpt your brows or shape and set them to perfection. Below is a carefully researched list of the best drugstore brow gels available right now. Check it out!

TOP 10 PRODUCTS
CHECK PRICE
Best Cruelty-Free Eyebrow Gel: NYX Professional Makeup Control Freak Eyebrow Gel
Check Price
Best Waterproof Eyebrow Gel: L'Oreal Paris Unbelieva Longwear Brow Gel
Check Price
Best Volumizing Eyebrow Gel: Maybelline New York TattooStudio Brow Gel
Check Price
Best Defining Gel Eyebrow Gel: COVERGIRL Easy Breezy Brow
Check Price
Best Pigmented Eyebrow Gel: Revlon Brow Fantasy By ColorStay
Check Price
Best Fast-Drying Eyebrow Gel: Ardell Brow Sculpting Gel
Check Price
Best Hold Eyebrow Gel: Rimmel London Brow This Way Brow Styling Gel
Check Price
Best Lightweight Eyebrow Gel: Wet N Wild BrowSessive Brow Shaping Gel
Check Price
Best Pore Cleanser: EltaMD Skincare Foaming Facial Cleanser
Check Price
Best Beginner-Friendly Eyebrow Gel: Milani Easy Brow Tinted Fiber Gel
Check Price

10 Best Drugstore Eyebrow Gels That You Can Try

1. Best Cruelty-Free Eyebrow Gel: NYX Professional Makeup Control Freak Eyebrow Gel

The Control Freak Eyebrow Gel from NYX is an ideal product to fill and fix your eyebrows and seal the deal. The tested formula works great with powders and pencils. This unique non-sticky defining formula is comfortable to wear all day. You can also repurpose it as a clear mascara that defines, separates, and enhances the natural curl of your lashes. NYX makeup is certified and acknowledged by PETA as a cruelty-free brand.

Pros

  •  Non-sticky
  •  Multipurpose product
  •  Vegan
  •  Cruelty-free
  •  Comfortable
  •  Long-lasting
  •  Easy to remove

Cons

  •  May become flaky after a few hours

Buy Now From Amazon

2. Best Waterproof Eyebrow Gel: L’Oreal Paris Unbelieva Longwear Brow Gel

This waterproof eyebrow gel from L’Oreal Paris has a no-sweat and no-transfer formula. This long-lasting gel thickens and sculpts your brows to look naturally intense and dream-like. It is formulated with long-wear polymers that create a waterproof film to seal in pigments on brow hair. The spherical silica gives natural-looking color and is sweat-resistant.

Pros

  •  Waterproof
  •  Long-lasting
  •  Smudge-proof
  • Sweat-resistant
  •  Transfer-resistant

Cons

  •  Not beginner-friendly

Buy Now From Amazon

3. Best Volumizing Eyebrow Gel: Maybelline New York TattooStudio Brow Gel

Maybelline New York’s Tattoo Studio Eyebrow Gel creates intense fuller-looking eyebrows that last very long due to its smudge-proof and waterproof formula. All you have to do is define your brows with the spoolie brush and then use the sculpting tip for fuller-looking brows. The micro eyebrow pencil fills in your eyebrow very precisely with its waterproof quality. It gives your arch definition, and you can create any look with it.

Pros

  •  Smudge-proof
  •  Waterproof
  •  Long-lasting
  •  Easy to use
  •  Transfer-free
  •  Easy to remove

Cons

  • Not suitable for blondes

Buy Now From Amazon

4. Best Defining Gel Eyebrow Gel: COVERGIRL Easy Breezy Brow

This volumizing brow gel from Covergirl has a long-lasting, water-resistant formula. It is fade-proof and non-transferable and keeps your brows in place all day long. From taming the arches to filling your brows, this gel can do wonders to your look. The formula is infused with argan oil and biotin that nourish your brows while styling them to perfection. It comes with a small applicator for ultimate precision, making you look fabulous.

Pros

  •  Waterproof
  •  Volumizes the brows
  •  Easy to apply
  •  Cruelty-free
  •  Long-lasting

Cons

  •  Runny consistency

Buy Now From Amazon

5. Best Pigmented Eyebrow Gel: Revlon Brow Fantasy By ColorStay

With Revlon Brow Fantasy By Color Stay, you can enhance your eyebrows in just two easy steps. The pencil fills in the eyebrows, while the tinted gel sets and shapes them for a natural finish. The ophthalmologist-tested formula is safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens-wearers. This pigmented formula is available in four natural-looking shades.

Pros

  •  Highly pigmented
  •  Ophthalmologist-tested
  •  Easy to apply
  •  Long-wearing
  •  Smudge-free

Cons

  •  Pencil tip chips on sharpening

Buy Now From Amazon

6. Best Fast-Drying Eyebrow Gel: Ardell Brow Sculpting Gel

Ardell Brow Sculpting Gel works wonders to keep your brows in place for a polished look. After applying your favorite brow pencil, coat them with this clear formula for a flexible hold without stiffness. The fast-drying formula is infused with castor oil to give natural conditioning to the tiny brow hair. Also, the precision makeup brush allows controlled application and deposits just the ideal amount of product. It is a luxurious non-flaky formula that does not leave any residue.

Pros

  •  Water-resistant
  •  Long-lasting
  •  Easy to apply
  •  Naturally enhances brows
  •  Dries fast
  •  Smudge-free
  •  Lightweight formula
  •  Non-sticky
  •  Non-flaky
  •  Vegan
  •  Cruelty-free
  •  Paraben-free
  • Phthalate-free

Cons

  •  Overpowering fragrance

Buy Now From Amazon

7. Best Hold Eyebrow Gel: Rimmel London Brow This Way Brow Styling Gel

Rimmel London’s Brow This Way Brow Styling Gel styles your brows in a perfect shape. Formulated with argan oil, it helps to condition and groom your brows to deliver a natural finish. The precision brush has a tapered end to allow perfect product delivery. Use it anytime, anywhere, for any occasion to amp up your brow game. The fast-drying formula does not flake.

Pros

  •  Defines eyebrows
  •  Easy to use
  •  Gives a natural look
  •  Softens the brows
  •  Fast-drying formula

Cons

  •  Color might be too dark

Buy Now From Amazon

8. Best Lightweight Eyebrow Gel: Wet N Wild BrowSessive Brow Shaping Gel

Wet n Wild BrowSessive Brow Shaping Gel is a lightweight formula to let you achieve natural-looking arches while fluffing and grooming them for a defined look. It delivers soft and non-flaky strokes with a comfortable hold. You can apply a coat of this gel over your penciled brows to hold your unruly tiny flecks of hair in place. The perfectly sized mini brush delivers just the perfect amount of buildable product. Mix and match with multiple shades to create the perfect shade matching your brows.

Pros

  •  Long-lasting
  •  Does not flake
  • Lightweight
  •  Cruelty-free
  •  Easy to apply
  •  Buildable
  •  Non-flaky

Cons

  •  Thick consistency

Buy Now From Amazon

9. Best Budget-Friendly Eyebrow Gel: e.l.f Wow Brow Gel

The e.l.f Wow Brow gel is a wax-gel hybrid formula that adheres to your brows for a fuller look. The fiber-infused brow gel delivers hair-like fibers to give a buildable effect to your thin, sparsely filled arches. Use it as a wear-alone formula or apply it over your pencil-coated brows to create your desired look. It defines your brows while providing all-day conditioning and holding. The product is 100% cruelty-free and vegan.

Pros

  •  Volumizes the brows
  •  Buildable formula
  •  Vegan
  •  Cruelty-free
  •  Paraben-free
  •  Phthalate-free
  •  Triclosan-free
  •  Triclocarban-free
  •  Nonylphenol-free
  •  Ethoxylates-free
  •  Hydroquinone-free
  • Sulfate-free

Cons

  • Small quantity

Buy Now From Amazon

10. Best Beginner-Friendly Eyebrow Gel: Milani Easy Brow Tinted Fiber Gel

Milani Easy Brow Tinted Eyebrow Gel adheres firmly to your brow hair to create thick and fuller brows with a natural finish. The formula is buildable and holds the hair in place all day long. This wear-alone formula can be paired with brow pencil too. The fine fibers of the brush allow ease of application.

Pros

  •  Smudge-free
  •  Water-proof
  •  Cruelty-free
  •  Vegan
  •  Highly pigmented

Cons

  •  Clumps fast

Buy Now From Amazon

Finding the right eyebrow gel can be a much easier job if you know what to look for. Here are a few of the pointers that can help you out.

Things To Consider When Buying A Drugstore Eyebrow Gel

Here are a few tips to consider before you shop for the best drugstore brow gel:

  •  Formula

Waxy formulas are a good long-wearing option, and creamy formulas are easy to apply. Some brow gels are infused with fibers that help add volume for a more well-defined look.

  •  Brush

Most of these gel tubes are equipped with a spoolie brush that aids in application. Makeup gurus prefer smaller brushes for ease of application and precision.

  • Color

If you have darker eyebrows, go for a shade lighter than your hair color. This will allow you to attain a natural look.

To give a defined look to your eye makeup, you will need to shape and fill in your brows. Your nearest drugstore can save you from the hunt. Browse our list of the best drugstore brow gels available right now and get shopping!

Recommended Articles

The following two tabs change content below.
Shalini Roy has a Master's degree in English literature. She is an ambivert whose expressions have found their way in writing. She channels her passion for all things fashion and makeup to write engaging content related to Beauty and Lifestyle. She first found her penchant for writing through poetry and serving on various editorial boards of Model United Nations conferences. Shalini is a lover of spoken word poetry, books, and movies.