20 Best Drugstore Eyebrow Pencils Of 2024, According To A Makeup Artist
Enhance your facial features by flaunting your well-shaped and defined eyebrows.
Deepti SadhwaniProfessional Makeup Artist & Licensed Barber 
Deepti is a professional makeup artist, licensed barber, men’s groomer, and educator with 8 years of experience in TV, films, commercials, and print. She specializes in makeup, hair, and nail artistry and aims to create a unique character... more
sakshi bahalMA (English Literature) Experience: 5 yearsSakshi Bahal is a commerce writer with a master's degree in English Literature from Calcutta University. She was a part of the editorial team of her school magazine. Her love for writing inspired her ... more
srijani roy chowdhuryMA (Journalism & Mass Communication), Certified Style & Image Consultant Experience: 3 yearsSrijani is an associate commerce editor with a master's degree in journalism and mass communication from the University of Calcutta, West Bengal. She is certified in makeup techniques and is also a ce... more
Image: StyleCraze Design Team
An eyebrow pencil is a great way to fix your natural brow hair and make them look stunning quickly. The best drugstore eyebrow pencils help sculpt your pair of eyebrows effortlessly. Over-plucking and uneven shape is a problem to many girls, but fret not; the eyebrow pencils work like magic to your brows, making them gorgeous and bold. Some eyebrow pencils are smudge-proof, while some are resistant to water and sweat and long-lasting. Some eyebrow pencils are also available in different shades. Try out some of the 20 best drugstore eyebrow pencils to flaunt your well-shaped eyebrows. They are selected after going through the honest reviews from users online. Check them out below!
In This Article
20 Best Drugstore Eyebrow Pencils For Natural-Looking Brows
1. Best Over-All:Maybelline Total Temptation Brow Definer Eyebrow Pencil
The Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil by Maybelline fills in the brows precisely with its teardrop-shaped applicator. Its creamy texture works brilliantly by delivering exceptional results for light, sparse eyebrows. The fluffy spoolie is ideal for blending to create softly-defined, natural-looking eyebrows. This eyebrow pencil is available in 4 shades – blonde, soft brown, medium brown, and deep brown. Here’s an honest review of the product along with a tester’s experience of using it.
Pros
- Long-wearing
- Built-in spoolie
- Sweat-resistant
- Easy to use
- Does not flake
- Budget-friendly
- Non-greasy formula
- Available in 4 shades
Cons
- None
Quick tip2. Best 3-In-1 Formula:Hourglass Arch Brow Sculpting Pencil
The Hourglass Arch Brow Sculpting Pencil is an innovative, multi-dimensional powder, pencil, and wax-based formula. Professional makeup artists, like Brittany Whitfield, love using it on celebrities. The triangular tip lets you create the perfect base for flawless eyebrows. This makeup artist-approved pencil also features a spoolie to help you groom your brows into perfection. Hourglass offers 9 different shades to choose from to suit your desired intensity. Here’s a video featuring a detailed review of the product and a tester’s experience of using it.
Pros
- 3-in-1 format
- No synthetic fragrances
- Built-in blending brush
- Cruelty-free
- Gluten-free
- Sulfate-free
- Phthalate-free
- GMO-free
- Triclosan-free
- Vegan
- No harsh chemicals
- No synthetic dyes
- Available in 9 shades
Cons
- None
"This eyebrow pencil offers the eyebrows a natural finish. It is fairly easy to use and offers long-lasting wear. It has an angled tip that helps in shaping and filling brows easily."
3. Best Long-Lasting:Benefit Goof Proof Brow Pencil
The Goof Proof brow pencil from Benefit is available in 12 stunning shades that shape and fill your brows easily and quickly. Professional makeup artists swear by using this brow pencil on celebrities and their clients. The makeup artist-approved pencil has a custom tapered tip that makes it easy and effortless to define your brows. The wide base helps build color with minimum strokes, and the pointed edge adds dimension and definition to the sides of your eyebrows. The brand even conducted an instrumental test on 20 panelists, and 95% of women said the product made it easy to fill and shape their brows. This video will help you understand the product better through the reviewer’s experience of using it.
Pros
- Long-lasting
- Water-proof
- Built-in blending brush
- Glides on easily
- Available in 12 shades
Cons
- Expensive
"This eyebrow pencil is great for both beginners and experts in brow makeup. Once you get the hang of using it, it provides a natural and consistent fill. It comes with an angled tip and built-in spoolie that makes it convenient to use."
Why We Think It's Worth Buying
It has gained over 214 positive reviews on Amazon, making it an all-time best-seller.
Maybelline Total Temptation Brow Definer Eyebrow Pencil Best Over-All | Hourglass Arch Brow Sculpting Pencil Best 3-In-1 Formula | Benefit Goof Proof Brow Pencil Best Long-Lasting | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Color | SOFT BROWN | Soft Brunette | 3.5 Medium |
| Dimensions | 1.88 x 0.39 x 5.61 inches | - | 19.69 x 19.69 x 11.02 inches |
| Weight | 0.49 Ounces | - | 0.01 Ounces |
| Rating | |||
| Reviews | 9,330 | 52 | 214 |
| Price | $8.89 | $37 | $26 |
4. Best Smudge-Proof:Browluxe Precision Brow Pencil
The Browluxe Precision Brow Pencil has a range of 8 custom shades to match your natural brows perfectly. This smudge-proof brow pen features an extra-thin tip with a long edge for a powdered fill. It also has a built-in spoolie brow brush on the other end to help you groom your brows perfectly. The powder makeup tip enables natural hair-like strokes while the spoolie helps soften harsh lines for seamless blending.
Pros
- Available in 8 shades
- Long-lasting
- Water-proof
- No smudging or fading
- Smudge-proof
- Sweat-resistant
- Not tested on animals
- Built-in spoolie
- Provides buildable coverage
Cons
- The tip may break off easily.
"This eyebrow pencil has a unique triangular tip that comes in handy for shading and precise application. It is perfect for creating those natural-looking, buildable strokes. It has a dual-ended design and has a spoolie that blends the product effortlessly."
Quick tip5. Best Built-In Spoolie:Chella Eyebrow Pencil
The Chella Eyebrow Pencil comes in 9 attractive shades. It provides a natural finish and has a smooth and long-wearing consistency. As per reviews online, it glides on effortlessly and gives precise strokes without the need for a sharpener. The product combines the good qualities of a pencil and a built-in spoolie that lets you lightly blend your makeup for a more natural look.
Pros
- Available in 9 shades
- Tames unruly brows
- Built-in spoolie
- Paraben-free
- Gluten-free
- Cruelty-free
Cons
- Might not last long.
"This eyebrow pencil is soft to use and has good lasting power. It makes sure that my brows look natural and neat throughout the day. It is good for daily use."
Why We Think It's Worth Buying
There are more than 374 Amazon reviews attesting to the quality of the product and endorsing its value.
6. Best For Contact Lens Wearers:L’Oreal Paris Brow Stylist Definer
The L’Oreal Brow Stylist Designer Eye Pencil uses subtle color to create soft, natural definition. On one end, you get a soft crayon tip, and on the other, a spoolie brush that is perfect for feathering. Use the fine tip to draw hair like strokes. This eyebrow pencil is available in 7 shades ranging from light blonde to light brunette and soft black. It has been tested by an ophthalmologist to be suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.
Pros
- Water-proof
- Ophthalmologist-tested
- Long-lasting
- Built-in spoolie
- Easy to use
- Available in 7 shades
- Suitable for contact lens wearers and sensitive eyes
Cons
- Not enough product
"The eyebrow pencil is easy to apply. It has a fine point tip that creates a natural, precise look. I love how it stays on until washed off."
7. Best Value For Money:Rimmel London Professional Eyebrow Pencil
The Professional Eyebrow Pencil from Rimmel London fills in gaps, conceals over-plucked areas, and enhances or refines the shape of your brows. You get fuller eyebrows without looking fake. The design is basic and newbie-friendly, with an inbuilt brow brush on the pencil cap. This eyebrow pencil comes in three shades – dark brown, hazel, and black-brown.
Pros
- Smudge-resistant
- Long-lasting
- Value for money
- Available in 3 shades
Cons
- Not enough pigmentation
8. Best For Maximum Precision:Milani Stay Put Brow Sculpting Mechanical Pencil
The Milani Stay Put Brow Sculpting Mechanical Pencil offers gorgeous and flawless eyebrows with every use. It features a micro-angled tip that delivers a smooth glide finish for maximum precision and a smooth brow grooming experience. The double-edged spoolie brush helps with blending and grooming all kinds of eyebrow shapes. Several reviewers noted that it is smudge-proof and water-resistant for up to 12 hours.
Pros
- Long-lasting
- Water-resistant
- Improves brow shaping
- Smudge-proof
- Cruelty-free (PETA-certified)
- Available in 5 shades
- Built-in spoolie
Cons
- Might not last long.
"This eyebrow pencil is easy to use and offers a natural look to the brows. It has a unique multi-tip design that makes application quick on those busy morning. It blends smoothly and has a good staying power."
9. Best Buildable Coverage:Honest Beauty Eyebrow Pencil
The Honest Beauty Eyebrow Pencil has a soft tip that glides on smoothly for effortless application. Its built in spoolie lets you blend sharp lines for soft, natural brows. This highly pigmented pencil delivers fantastic results with its blendable coverage. It is dermatologist-tested and enriched with jojoba seed oil that helps condition and reshapes your brows.
Pros
- Provides buildable coverage
- Enhances brow shape
- Built-in spoolie
- Dermatologist-tested
- Paraben-free
- Silicone-free
- Cruelty-free
- Petrochemical-free
- Polyethlyene-free
Cons
- Requires sharpening
"This eyebrow pencil has such a practical design. It sharpens easily and applies smoothly. It has a dual-end brush that makes blending easy. It is durable and washes off easily."
10. Best For Natural Finish:IT Cosmetics Brow Power Eyebrow Pencil
The IT Cosmetics Brow Power Eyebrow Pencil is a dual-ended pencil featuring a spoolie applicator on one end and a retractable pencil on the other. The formula is infused with biotin, a vitamin that boosts hair and skin health. The pencil is budge-proof, long-wearing, and gives a natural-looking finish. The eyebrow pencil comes in 4 universal shades to match every hair color and cover grays.
Pros
- Infused with biotin
- Defines arches
- Waterproof
- Smudge-proof
- Long-lasting
- Comes with a spoolie
- Available in 4 shades
Cons
- Tip may break off easily
Why We Think It's Worth Buying
This product is so liked by shoppers that it has gained over 1,054 great reviews on Amazon.
11. Best Waterproof:Maybelline Brow Satin Eyebrow Pencil
The Maybelline Brow Satin Eyebrow Pencil features a sponge-tip applicator that gives you a uniform and dense brow look at a pocket-friendly price. It is available in 4 shades– blonde, soft brown, medium brown, and deep brown. This 2-in-1 product has a defining pencil to shape your brows and comes primed with a brow powder to fill in the gaps. Reviewers raved about how easy to use this pencil is! It imparts natural-looking brows with a matte finish.
Pros
- Built-in eyebrow powder
- Offers a matte finish
- Long-lasting
- Soft texture
- Available in 4 shades
- Affordable
Cons
- Might break off easily.
"This eyebrow pencil comes in handy tool for days when I want natural-looking brows. It applies easily and defines my brows. It feels gentle upon usage and comes with a powder applicator that makes the product blend easily."
12. Best Sweat-Proof:Keshimei Eyebrow Pencil
The Keshimei Eyebrow Pencil is perfect for daily use. It is smudge, sweat, and water-proof, so your makeup stays in place for a long time. The pencil tip features a 3D triangle design that allows extreme precision for fine eyebrows. The dual-tipped brush end helps manage unruly growth and provides easy blending. It comes in 3 classic shades – light brown, dark brown, and black.
Pros
- Waterproof
- Smudge-proof
- Sweat-proof
- Easy to blend
- Easy to remove
- Value for money
- Available in 3 shades
- Non-sharpening
Cons
- Not long-lasting.
"This brow pencil applies very smoothly. It is quite pigmented and fills in the brows easily. The coverage is buildable and it does not smudge easily once it is set."
13. Best All Day Along:Almay Eyebrow Pencil
The AlmayEyebrow Pencil defines, fills, and tames your brows. This versatile pencil comes in 3 shades–dark blonde, brunette, and universal taupe. It glides on smoothly and stays in place through the wildest of days. This ophthalmologist-tested eyebrow pencil is safe for sensitive eyes.
Pros
- Long-lasting
- Smudge-resistant
- Easy to use
- Hypoallergenic
- Available in 3 shades
- Safe for sensitive eyes
- Ophthalmologist-tested
- Not tested on animals
Cons
- Waxy consistency
- Might break off easily.
"This eyebrow pencil applies smoothly and gives a natural look. It is hypoallergenic and perfect for those with sensitive skin. It has a slanted tip that defines and shapes the brows easily."
14. Best For Natural- Looking:Maybelline Brow Precise Micro Eyebrow Pencil
The Maybelline Brow Precise Micro Eyebrow Pencil shapes and styles your brows as you desire. This ultra-precise micro pencil lets you create well-defined brows, while the eyebrow spoolie brush softens harsh lines for a natural look. The ultra-fine 1.5-millimeter retractable tip creates soft, hair-like lines that fill the brows without looking artificial.
Pros
- Available in 7 shades
- Retractable micro-tip
- Inbuilt blending brush
- Long-lasting
- Does not flake
Cons
- Might crumble easily.
"This eyebrow pencil does what it claims to do. It has a fine tip that creates natural-looking strokes with ease. It also comes with a brush that is good for blending the product seamlessly."
15. Best For Easy To Use:NYX Professional Makeup Micro Brow Pencil
The Micro Brow Pencil from NYX Cosmetics provides the precision to build full, beautiful brows and rock the different eyebrow trends. The super skinny tip draws extra fine lines to create natural-looking brow hairs.It is easy to use and is an excellent dupe of Anastasia Beverly Hills’ Brow Wiz. This brow pencil is available in 8 shades.
Pros
- Long-lasting
- Inbuilt spoolie
- Offers a natural finish
- Cruelty-free
- Available in 8 shades
Cons
- Not smudge-proof
"This eyebrow pencil has a fine lead that allows for precise application. Its shades are perfect for creating that natural look. It has a lovely, smooth texture that does not feel waxy at all."
16. Best Rub-Resistant:Wet N Wild Ultimate Brow Retractable Brow Pencil
This expertly crafted brow pencil from Wet n Wild has a triangular tip that creates fine strokes for a natural finish. It is formulated with rub-resistant pigments that make it last through the longest of days. You also get a spoolie on one side of the pencil to blend out the product for the perfect brows. This brow pencil is available in 4 shades – taupe, ash brown, medium brown, and dark brown.
Pros
- Long-lasting
- Sweat-resistant
- Retractable tip
- Inbuilt spoolie
- Available in 4 shades
Cons
- May tug on the brow hair.
"The Wet n Wild Ultimate Eyebrow Retractable Definer Pencil is perfect for daily use. It has a fine-tip and a retractable design that makes application easy. I love that I don't need to run after a sharpener every now and then. It is also easy to blend."
17. Best For Everyday Use:Revlon ColorStay Eyebrow Pencil
If you are looking for a drugstore brow pencil that lasts 24 hours, Revlon’s Colorstay Brow Pencil is a great option. Its angled tip helps you fill in the brows precisely, and its brush tames the wildest of brows for a stunning, sculpted look. This waterproof, drugstore eyebrow pencil comes in 5 shades.
Pros
- Long-lasting
- Water-proof
- Easy to use
- Inbuilt spoolie
- Available in 5 shades
Cons
- Might smear
- Might feel greasy
18. Best Hypoallergenic:iMethod Liquid Eyebrow Pen
This microblading eyebrow pencil features a micro fork tip applicator that helps you create natural-looking brows effortlessly. This smudge-proof formula offers exceptional results and lasts up to 24 hours. This waterproof eyebrow pencil is not tiresome to take off at the end of the day. It glides on smoothly, making it easy to apply.
Pros
- Available in 4 shades
- Waterproof
- Sweat-proof
- Long-lasting
- Easy to apply
- Easy to remove
- Not tested on animals
- Lifetime warranty
Cons
- Might turn blotchy after a while.
"This eyebrow pen gives my brows a natural appearance. It has good lasting power and stays put throughout the day. I love the micro-fork tip that allows for precise application."
19. Best For Beginners:e.l.f. Essential Instant Lift Brow Pencil
The Instant Lift Brow Pencil from e.l.f is one of the drugstore eyebrow pencils that is suitable for beginners for its smooth texture. It shapes, defines, and fills in the sparse gaps in the brows to help you achieve a natural, polished look. This dual-shaped pencil comes with a fine-tip liner on one side, and a spoolie on the other to tame and comb your brows. It is available in 6 shades – taupe, neutral brown, deep brown, blonde, black, and auburn.
Pros
- Long-lasting
- Cruelty-free
- Vegan
- Available in 6 shades
Cons
- Not smudge-proof
"This eyebrow pencil is a smooth formula that fills brows effortlessly. It comes with a brush that blends the product well. It is perfect for those like me who prefer using a light hand for application."
20. Best For Sensitive Skin:Covergirl Easy Breezy Brow Micro-Fine + Define Pencil
Covergirl Easy Breezy Micro-Fine Define Brow Pencil is ideal for beginners as it lets you shape and define your brows with ease. Its brown shade comes as a retractable pencil with a microfine tip for precise application. The formula is hypoallergenic, smudge-proof, and long-lasting, with buildable coverage. It comes in various shades to suit different skin tones for natural-looking results.
Pros
- Hypoallergenic formula
- Smudge-proof
- Long-lasting
- Buildable color
- Comes with a spoolie
- Available in 4 shades
Cons
- Less quantity
Infographic: Easy Steps To Achieve Beautiful Brows With An Eyebrow Pencil
Everyone loves well-defined brows. However, it can be tricky to draw them if you are not an expert. To make matters easier, we have compiled some pointers on the easiest ways to draw natural-looking, fuller brows without spending a fortune. Whether you are a beginner or a makeup enthusiast, these tips will help elevate your brow game. Take a look!
Illustration: StyleCraze Design Team
The Bottom Line
That was our round-up of the 20 best drugstore eyebrow pencils available online with positive reviews from users. While picking a color for your brow pencil, makeup artists recommend going for a shade lighter than your natural brows for a subtle and soft look, even if you have mature eyebrows. A waxy brow pencil will always help you achieve a realistic finish. The Maybelline Total Temptation Brow Definer Eyebrow Pencil is popular for its soft, blendable formula, and the teardrop-shaped tip allows for both precise application and shading on sparse brows. The Hourglass Arch Brow Sculpting Pencil offers a luxurious experience with its unique triangular shape, that allows for easy filling and shaping of the brows. Try the drugstore brow product, L’Oreal Paris Brow Stylist Definer, for precise application, and the built-in spoolie brush helps to blend and groom the brows effectively. Choose your favorite one from our list and flaunt on-fleek eyebrows whenever you step out! Deepti Sadhwani, Professional Makeup Artist says, “Waxy pencils can sometimes feel greasy and need something to stick to. If you feel like brow products fade too quickly – powder your brows with a fine translucent powder first (to absorb oil) and then fill in with your favorite brow product.”
Frequently Asked Questions
Should I go lighter or darker with an eyebrow pencil?
Go one shade lighter to match your existing brows. When you cover your eyebrows or draw tiny hair, it may look unnatural if the pencil is too dark or pigmented.
What color should my eyebrows be if my hair is gray?
Color your eyebrows light brown if your hair is silver or gray. It will make your eyes look distinct and add youthfulness to your look.
Can using a drugstore eyebrow pencil help in growing eyebrows?
No, eyebrow pencils cannot help you grow actual eyebrows. They offer a temporary fuller look to your brows and fill the barren patches in your eyebrow region.
How long does a drugstore eyebrow pencil stay on?
Drugstore eyebrow pencils offer a distinct look to your eyebrows throughout the day. They stay on for 12 to 24 hours depending on the weather conditions.
Does a dark brown eyebrow pencil suit natural black hair?
Yes, definitely. A dark brown eyebrow pencil suits natural black hair. The shade makes your brows look prominent and natural but not overdone.
Which drugstore eyebrow pencil can I use for thin eyebrows, brown or black?
It depends on your hair color more than the density of your brows. If your hair color is on the lighter side, go for a brown eyebrow pencil. If it is dark, you may go for either a dark brown eyebrow pencil or a black eyebrow pencil.
Is eyebrow pencil safe on infants?
No, do not use an eyebrow pencil on your infant without checking the ingredients. The pencils may contain lead and zinc which are not suitable for your infant’s sensitive skin and eyes.
Can I use a drugstore eyebrow pencil a day after my Lasik surgery?
Yes, you may use a drugstore eyebrow pencil the day after a Lasik surgery. However, do not touch your eyes or use any makeup that may flake off and enter your eyes.
Why Trust StyleCraze?
The author of this article, Sakshi Bahal, is a makeup enthusiast. She has browsed several online forums for user feedback to put together this list of the best drugstore eyebrow pencils for natural-looking brows. Her list contains products that can help you sculpt your pair of brows effortlessly for a naturally fuller look. They are long-lasting, smudge-proof, water-resistant, and glide on easily.
