10 Best Drugstore Pencil Eyeliners For Bold, Intense Eyes – 2022

Written by Priyam Gupta
All products recommended on StyleCraze are independently selected by our editorial team. If you make a purchase through any of these links, we may receive a commission. Learn more about our product selection process here.

If you are a pro at eye makeup or just venturing into its many possibilities, you must keep the best drugstore pencil eyeliner handy with you. Whether you like to keep your whole makeup to the bare minimum or you like to glam it up all the way, a drugstore pencil liner is like the tiny all-purpose magic wand in your pocket. Not only can it give you different eye looks— winged liner, cat-eye, or full swipe kohl effect, but, it can also jazz up your look with different color shade options like emerald green, electric blue, or the metallic pinks and reds. Additionally, on days when you don’t have mascara handy, you can simply tight line your upper lash line with a pencil eyeliner to give you that full lash effect.

A drugstore pencil eyeliner is not only high-quality like any of the luxurious brands, but easily available and affordable as well. Given its affordability and color options, it helps you experiment with all the possible color combinations and effects pretty well. To help you choose from the many options available, we have enlisted the 10 best drugstore pencil eyeliners for you to get started.

TOP 10 PRODUCTS
CHECK PRICE
Best Creamy Texture: NYX Professional Makeup Jumbo Eye Pencil - Black Bean
Price on Amazon
Price on Walmart
Best Waterproof: Revlon Colorstay Eyeliner - Black Brown
Price on Amazon
Price on Walmart
Best Long-Lasting: Covergirl Perfect Blend Eye Pencil - Basic Black
Price on Amazon
Price on Walmart
Best Gel Formula: Maybelline MasterPrecise Skinny Gel Pencil - Sharp Brown
Price on Amazon
Price on Walmart
Best For Sensitive Skin: Physicians Formula Eye Definer - Ultra Black
Price on Amazon
Price on Walmart
Best Cruelty-Free: l.f Satin Eyeliner Pencil - Black
Price on Amazon
Price on Walmart
Best Ophthalmologist-Tested: Burt’s Bees Nourishing Eyeliner - Warm Brown
Price on Amazon
Price on Walmart
Best Moisturizing: Neutrogena Smokey Kohl Eyeliner - Dark Brown
Price on Amazon
Price on Walmart
Best For All Skin Types: Milani Stay Put Waterproof Eyeliner - Stay With SlatePrice on Amazon
Price on Walmart
Best Smudge-Proof: Almay Top Of The Line Eyeliner Pencil - Black Brown
Price on Amazon

Achieve Perfectly Defined Eyes With The 10 Best Drugstore Pencil Eyeliners

1. Best Creamy Texture: NYX Professional Makeup Jumbo Eye Pencil – Black Bean

 

If you’re looking for a good drugstore pencil eyeliner that is versatile enough to double up as an eyeshadow and highlighter, try this one! You’re going to love this radiant crayon-style makeup must-have, which will instantly transform your look from drab to fab. Smooth and intense, with a deliciously creamy texture, this blendable eyeliner glides on effortlessly for a finish that lasts all day long without fading, tugging, or pulling. Easily sharpenable, these voluptuous eye pencils come in a wide variety of vivid colors in finishes ranging from a subtle matte to a glittery metallic.

PROS

  • Ultra-creamy texture
  • Sharpenable crayon design
  • 2-in-1 multi-use eyeliner and eyeshadow
  • Vegan and cruelty-free

CONS

  • Some might find these eyeliner pencils a bit thick.

2. Best Waterproof: Revlon Colorstay Eyeliner – Black Brown

 

Say hello to gorgeous, mesmerizing eyes with this amazing waterproof eyeliner with a luxuriously silky formula that lasts up to 24 hours without drying or flaking. This drugstore eye pencil provides rich, intense color and comes with a convenient in-built sharpener and smudger, making it easy to create looks ranging from the perfect cat eye to an alluring smokey eye. So what are you waiting for? Try it out, and we’re sure you’ll agree that this multi-use eyeliner deserves a permanent place in your makeup bag!

PROS

  • Up to 24 hour wear
  • Ultra-silky formula for smooth application
  • Smudge-proof and waterproof
  • Built-in sharpener and smudger

CONS

  • Some might find the texture of this eye pencil a bit waxy.

3. Best Long-Lasting: Covergirl Perfect Blend Eye Pencil – Basic Black

 

Get ready to flaunt your easy, breezy, and beautiful look with this classic top-rated drugstore eyeliner pencil, which promises to deliver a transformative effect on your eye makeup. So whether you’re going for a defined, precise eyeliner look, or a softly smudged smokey eye, this blendable eye pencil is your one-stop solution for gorgeous eyes. And there’s more, this formula is long-lasting and water-resistant, making it the ideal makeup essential to see you through a busy, activity-filled day.

PROS

  • Blendable, glossy color
  • Water-resistant formula
  • Soft in-built smudger for expert blending
  • Suitable for all skin types

CONS

  • Some might find that this eye pencil tends to smudge a bit.

4. Best Gel Formula: Maybelline MasterPrecise Skinny Gel Pencil – Sharp Brown

 

Hey there, gorgeous! This pretty, skinny automatic gel eye pencil packs a punch when it comes to delivering long-lasting color that adds precise definition to your beautiful eyes. In addition, the accurate microtip makes the application of this gel-based formula a breeze and can be used to create any look you desire. Designed for the busy modern woman who likes to spend minimal time on makeup before starting her day, this beauty must-have ensures your eyes are always in tip-top shape. 

PROS

  • Twist-up automatic ultra-smooth eyeliner
  • Up to 24-hour wear
  • Waterproof gel formula
  • Microtip for precise application

CONS

  • Some might find that the texture of this eye pencil is a bit crumbly.

5. Best For Sensitive Skin: Physicians Formula Eye Definer – Ultra Black

 

Who knew clean beauty could look this good! This drugstore pencil eyeliner is crafted specifically for sensitive skin and delivers rich pigment that lasts all day long without irritating the delicate skin around the eyes. So whether you want to swipe on a bold cat eye or try a more natural, smudged look, this eyeliner glides on smoothly to add unbelievable definition to your pretty eyes. Hypoallergenic and clinically tested, this makeup essential is formulated without harmful toxins and is ideal for daily use.

PROS

  • Automatic and retractable pencil
  • Gentle, waterproof formula
  • Hypoallergenic and dermatologist-tested
  • Cruelty-free

CONS

  • Some might find the texture of this eyeliner a bit dry.

6. Best Cruelty-Free: l.f Satin Eyeliner Pencil – Black

 

If you find liquid eyeliners too messy and fussy, you’re going to love this eye pencil that glides on flawlessly to create precise lines every time. Creamy and richly pigmented, this pencil provides a gorgeous satin finish which is perfect whether you’re going for a natural bare-faced look or a full-on glam diva avatar. The convenient built-in sharpener makes touch-ups super easy when you’re on the go. Trust us when we say this is the perfect makeup accessory to throw into your handbag.

PROS

  • Creamy and richly pigmented
  • Convenient built-in sharpener
  • Free of parabens, phthalates, and hydroquinone
  • 100% vegan and cruelty-free

CONS

  • Some might find this eyeliner a bit difficult to remove.

7. Best Ophthalmologist-Tested: Burt’s Bees Nourishing Eyeliner – Warm Brown

 

If you’re looking for a good drugstore eyeliner pencil that stays on all day, you can’t go wrong with this crowd favorite from Burt’s Bees. Infused with jojoba, mango, and meadowfoam seed oils, this eye pencil provides a striking definition that lasts all day long without fading or smudging. Formulated without any of the commonly found nasties in makeup products, this makeup bag essential is safe for sensitive skin and contact lens wearers. Just pair this natural eyeliner with a dash of mascara and some peachy lip gloss for an all-day look that is effortless and oh-so-gorgeous.

PROS

  • Made with 99.9% natural ingredients
  • Resists fading and smearing
  • Safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers
  • Ophthalmologist-tested
  • Free of parabens, phthalates, SLS, and petrolatum

CONS

  • Some might find this eyeliner a bit difficult to sharpen.

8. Best Moisturizing: Neutrogena Smokey Kohl Eyeliner – Dark Brown

 

Say hello to mysterious, alluring eyes with this over-the-counter eyeliner pencil infused with nourishing vitamin E to provide a smooth, bold look that lasts all day long. Easy to apply, this kohl eyeliner can be smudged for the first 30 seconds to create the perfect glamorous smokey eye, and after drying, it becomes smudge and flake resistant. Long-lasting and gentle on the eyes, this drugstore pencil eyeliner glides on effortlessly and will transport you seamlessly from a neutral, daytime office look to a fancy cocktail party in the last hours of the night.

PROS

  • Highly pigmented and long-wearing
  • Gentle, water-resistant formula
  • Infused with moisturizing vitamin E
  • Easy to apply and remove

CONS

  • Some might find the texture of this eyeliner pencil a bit waxy.

9. Best For All Skin Types: Milani Stay Put Waterproof Eyeliner – Stay With Slate

 

Get your hands on this excellent eyeliner pencil and create stunning looks you can obsess over without breaking the bank! Unbelievably creamy, this drugstore waterproof eyeliner pencil provides intense color that seamlessly makes a bold, precise finish. Easy to apply and blendable, this versatile eye pencil is transfer-resistant and keeps your eyes looking gorgeous all day long. So what are you waiting for? Give this crowd favorite a try, and you’ll thank us later!

PROS

  • Creamy, blendable formula
  • Waterproof and transfer-resistant
  • Easy to apply and remove
  • Suitable for all skin types

CONS

  • Some might find the color of this eyeliner a bit dark.

10. Best Smudge-Proof: Almay Top Of The Line Eyeliner Pencil – Black Brown

 

Here’s a fantastic drugstore eyeliner pencil that ticks all the right boxes when it comes to a makeup essential that is easy to use and provides results that look precise and professional and last over 16 hours without requiring frequent touch-ups. Infused with nourishing vitamin E, this eyeliner delivers beautiful color while protecting your delicate eye area from dryness and irritation. So get your hands on this eye pencil and get your creative juices flowing to give your eyes the pop they deserve!

PROS

  • Water-resistant and smudge-proof formula
  • Enriched with antioxidant-rich vitamin E
  • Convenient built-in sharpener
  • Hypoallergenic and ophthalmologist-tested

CONS

  • Some might find the texture of this eyeliner a bit soft.

Now that we’ve had a look at our carefully curated list of the 10 best drugstore eyeliner pencils in 2022, let us look at some things to consider when picking the perfect eyeliner for your pretty peepers!

Tips To Choose The Best Drugstore Eyeliner Pencil

  • Color

When you’re looking for the perfect eyeliner to help your beautiful eyes stand out, pay close attention to which shade does the job best. While a classic black eyeliner brings intense definition to your eyes, whether they’re blue, green, brown, or black, there are many other colors available. Brown and green eyeliners are very popular and help create dazzling looks that add subtle definition to your eyes with a unique finish. Don’t hesitate to experiment a bit with colors and get ready to sport a different look every day of the week with confidence and style.

  • Texture

Not all drugstore eyeliners are created equal when it comes to the texture and finish they offer. While some are creamy and glide on smoothly, others have a kohl pencil-type design and are better suited when you’re trying to create a smudged, smokey eye. If you like to do your makeup first thing in the morning and want to have it last all day without requiring touch-ups, pick an eyeliner that is long-lasting and water-resistant. Lastly, some eyeliners have built-in sharpeners with a twist-up design, while others come with a built-in smudger for versatile use. Pick a design and texture that suits your style the best!

  • Ingredient list

Just because drugstore eyeliner pencils are relatively inexpensive doesn’t mean you have to compromise on the quality of ingredients you put on your skin. If you’re prone to allergies and sensitive skin, pick an eyeliner made of natural, good-for-you ingredients. Are you dealing with dry and flaky skin around your delicate eye area? Pick an eyeliner that is infused with skin-loving ingredients like vitamin E and jojoba oil that protect your eyes while providing unbelievable definition. As always, steer clear of the known nasties in your makeup products – be it parabens, phthalates, SLS, or petrolatum.

Drugstore pencil eyeliners are affordable and perfect for your casual outings! If you want to flaunt your eyes without having to use eyeshadows and other cosmetics, these eye pencils can work wonders! Not just black, these eye pencils come in various vibrant colors for you to choose them as per your mood. The eye pencils in our list have a creamy texture and glide effortlessly! It is important to choose eyeliners that are long-lasting and don’t fade away. From cat eyes to smokey eyes, these drugstore eye pencils are perfect for any eye makeup! Opt for eyeliners that provide rich, intense color and come with a sharpener. However, avoid eye pencils that tend to be waxy and are not smudge-proof. Makeup enthusiasts with sensitive skin can also choose hypoallergenic and dermatologist-tested formulae.

Why Trust StyleCraze?

The author of this article, Priyam Gupta, is a makeup enthusiast who believes in the expressive power of makeup. She consulted makeup experts and went through hundreds of reviews to pick out the best drugstore pencil eyeliners that help you get bold, beautiful eyes without burning a hole in your pocket. They will help you nail the best eye looks, whether you are a pro or just beginning out.

The following two tabs change content below.

LATEST ARTICLES