9 Best Eye Brightener Pencils Of 2023

Pop up your eye makeup with the most intense and pigmented essentials, for a brighter look.

Reviewed by Nini Amerlise, Supermodel & Beauty Enthusiast Nini Amerlise Nini AmerliseSupermodel & Beauty Enthusiast facebook_icontwitter_iconlinkedin_iconyoutube_iconinsta_icon
Written by , MA (English) Baishali Bhattacharya MA (English)
Edited by , MA (English & Literature), Certified Style & Image Consultant Srijita De MA (English & Literature), Certified Style & Image Consultant Experience: 2 years
Fact-checked by , MBA, Certified Skin Care Coach Krati Darak MBA, Certified Skin Care Coach Experience: 3 years
 • 

Hectic and long workdays can make your eyes look stressed and dull. Though eye creams are there to your rescue, a quick and easy solution to restore the natural shine of your eyes would be to invest in the best eye brightener pencils. An eye brightener helps to remove the dark circles and puffiness.

To make your search easy, we have listed the 9 best eye brightener pencils that you should try. So keep scrolling through to check out some of our top picks!

Top Picks
CHECK PRICE
Best 2-In-1 Gluten-Free Brightener Pencil:TreStiQue Shimmer Shadow Crayon- Kona Coffee Shimmer
Price on Amazon
Best Organic Formula:Ere Perez Eye Pencil
Price on Amazon
Best For Entrancing Eyes:Beautyjunkees Cosmetics Stick Eye Brightener- Cool Beige Duo Brow Crayon
Price on Amazon
Best Phthalate-Free Eye Pencil:Trish McEvoy Eye Brightener Pencil – Shell
Price on Amazon
Best Natural Highly Pigmented Eye Pencil:Pure Ziva White Eyeliner – 117 Matte White
Price on Amazon
Best Eye Pencils With Glossy Light Coverage:Fashionwu Soft Eyeliner Pencil
Price on Amazon
Best For Shimmery Finish:Artisan L'uxe Bio Beauty Eyeliner Pencil
Price on Amazon
Best Multipurpose:Thrive Causemetics Brilliant Eye Brightener
Price on Amazon
Best Long-Lasting:Wunder2 SUPERSTAY Liner
Price on Amazon

9 Best Eye Brightener Pencils Of 2023

1. Best 2-In-1 Gluten-Free Brightener Pencil:TreStiQue Shimmer Shadow Crayon- Kona Coffee Shimmer

star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
4.2
TreStiQue Shimmer Shadow Crayon- Kona Coffee Shimmer Image: Trestique

The TreStiQue Shimmer Shadow Crayon has a buildable, long-lasting shade called Kona Coffee Shimmer. It has a darker hue of shimmery brown that gives a natural blend. A 2-in-1 stick has an in-build blending brush to blend color seamlessly. It is a multi-purpose pencil that instantly gives you a wide-awake look. The formula has a creamy and smooth texture that glides effortlessly for a flawless, natural finish. The shade is enriched with antioxidants and vitamin E that nourishes the skin while moisturizing it for a silky feel and long-lasting wearable color. Forget dull eyes with this silky feel, D-5 Free eye brightener.

Color: Aspen Shimmer

Pros
  • No need to sharpen
  • Vegan
  • Glides effortlessly
  • Fragrance-free
  • Talc-free
  • Gluten-free
  • Paraben-free
  • Cruelty-free

Cons
  • Expensive

protip_icon Trivia
Jennifer Kapahi created trèStiQue with the goal of “simplifying and empowering the lives of real women of all ages” by developing the first ever 2-in-1 products that combine quality ingredients and refillable twist-on and off tools.

2. Best Organic Formula:Ere Perez Eye Pencil

star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
4.3
Ere Perez Eye Pencil Image: Ere Perez

The Ere Perez Eye Pencil is a super soothing natural eyeliner pencil. It is a soothing combination of oils known to nourish your skin and condition the eyelashes. Its lightweight formula helps camouflage blemishes effortlessly. The pencil is very calming on the eyes and is suitable for those who are subjected to sensitive reactions. It is cruelty-free, vegan, and easily blendable.

Color: Black

Pros
  • Organic formula
  • Blendable coverage
  • Easy to sharpen
  • Anti-slip grip
  • Vegan
  • Cruelty-free
  • Ideal for sensitive eyes

Cons

None

3. Best For Entrancing Eyes:Beautyjunkees Cosmetics Stick Eye Brightener- Cool Beige Duo Brow Crayon

The dual-ended pencil from Beautyjunkees gives a natural lift to your brows and eye makeup. It has a matte eye brightener that accentuates the brows while shaping and concealing for a cleaner edge. This versatile and portable tool enhances eye makeup and blends seamlessly for a statement-making look and flawless finish. Its other end has a shimmer eye shade that adds a pop to your eye makeup. The Cool Beige Duo Brow Crayon shade is light brown with a pink undertone, and the matt end of this eye pencil brightener gives great definition and enhanced fullness. In addition, the highlighter gives you a subtle shine while highlighting your eyes. The shade is enriched with beeswax and castor seed oil that hydrates the skin while nourishing it without drying. The formula is creamy, easily blendable, and gives a smooth, light, and shimmery natural shine. Moreover, it can be used for highlighting your brows, eyes, and cheekbones.

Color: COOL BEIGE DUO BROW CRAYON | Product Dimensions: 5.5 x 0.5 x 0.5 inches | Weight: 0.4 Ounces

Pros
  • Natural ingredients
  • Non-drying
  • Dual purpose
  • Cruelty-free
  • Gluten-free
  • Paraben-free

Cons
  • Does not last long
worth-buy-icon

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

There are more than 408 Amazon reviews attesting to the quality of the product and endorsing its value.

4. Best Phthalate-Free Eye Pencil:Trish McEvoy Eye Brightener Pencil – Shell

star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
4.4
Trish McEvoy Eye Brightener Pencil – Shell Image: Trish Mcevoy

Want a small, easy-to-carry product that can perfectly complement your eyes? The eye brightener pencil from Trish McEvoy is a multipurpose pencil that conceals skin imperfection, highlights the features, and brightens the waterline of your eyes. Moreover, the pencil is enriched with natural ingredients like minerals and castor oils that hydrate the skin. It is versatile and portable, making it perfect for on-the-go touch-ups.

Its Shell shade glides easily, leaving behind the trail of bright pale pink, which highlights your brow bone, accentuates the lash line, defines the shape of your brows, and brightens up the inner corners of your eye. The creamy texture is easy to blend and gives you complete, flawless, defined eye makeup. The application is super easy, and it contours your facial features effectively without streaks. As per reviews, a little streak of the product goes a long way and it does not irritate the eyes.

Number of Items: 1

Pros
  • Easy to carry
  • Smears easily
  • Mild coverage
  • Smooth and precise application
  • Contours dark patches
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Safe for sensitive eyes
  • Phthalate-free
  • Sulfate-free

Cons

None

5. Best Natural Highly Pigmented Eye Pencil:Pure Ziva White Eyeliner – 117 Matte White

Looking for a highly pigmented pencil to instantly illuminate your eyes? The white eyeliner by Pure Ziva is an excellent addition to your vanity. The 117 Matte White gives an opaque pigmented finish for a tight lining technique. It is enriched with natural ingredients like mineral and castor oils that hydrate and nourish your eyes without drying. This highly pigmented product has a matte finish with a creamy texture. It is perfect for making sharp lines on the waterline of your eyes. This product is developed with smudge-proof and non-irritating formula, making it an absolute favorite for people who keep on rubbing their eyes.

Product Dimensions: 2 x 2 x 2 inches | Weight: 0.32 Ounces.

Pros
  • Rich pigmentation
  • Lasts long
  • Dermatologically-tested
  • Ophthalmologist-tested
  • Safe for contact lens wearers
  • Allergy-tested
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Ideal for sensitive eyes
  • Cruelty-free

Cons

None

6. Best Eye Pencils With Glossy Light Coverage:Fashionwu Soft Eyeliner Pencil

star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
4.3

The Soft Eyeliner Pencil by Fashionwu creates larger, dramatic, statement-making eyes. The pencil has a glossy vanilla-toned finish, which glides seamlessly and creates a traditional cat-eye look or highlights your eyes’ inner corners. This waterproof formula is highly pigmented, and a little goes a long way. The lightweight pencil creates multiple impeccable looks by defining the shape of your brows. You can also glide it along the waterline and make your eyes look more prominent. In contrast, put it along the top lash line for a sensual look and smudge it over the eyelid, making your eye look fuller and more dramatic than ever. It also features a sharpenable tip and comes in packs of 12.

Color: 12pcs

Pros
  • Waterproof
  • Glossy finish
  • Lightweight
  • Glides effortlessly
  • Highly pigmented

Cons
  • Doesn’t last long

7. Best For Shimmery Finish:Artisan L’uxe Bio Beauty Eyeliner Pencil

star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
4
Artisan L’uxe Bio-Beauty Velvet Jumbo Eyeliner Pencil – Shameless Image: Artisan L'uxe

The Artisan L’Uxe Bio Beauty Eyeliner Pencil comes with a nourishing composition including hyaluronic acid and age-defying ceramides. It is smudge-proof and waterproof in nature. It smoothly glides on, and its powerful ingredients help firm the skin, hydrate, and nourish the eye area. The built-in smudge tip allows brushless blending that defines and shapes the eyes. Multiple reviewers noted that the product glides smoothly over the lids and stays on for long hours.

Color: Shimmering Bronze | Product Dimensions: 3.15 x 0.79 x 0.79 inches | Weight: 0.63 Ounces

Pros
  • Nourishing formula
  • Waterproof
  • Smudge-proof
  • Long-lasting

Cons

None

8. Best Multipurpose:Thrive Causemetics Brilliant Eye Brightener

star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
4.3
Thrive Causemetics Brilliant Eye Brightener Image: Thrive Causemetics

Thrive Causemetics Brilliant Eye Brightener is a unique product that is effortlessly blendable and comes with a waterproof formula. It is weightless and has a creamy texture that melts onto the skin to highlight and add a splash of smudge-proof color that lasts all day long. It mixes well with other makeup products, which makes it a great makeup essential.

Color: Stella (Champagne Shimmer)

Pros
  • Shimmery finish
  • Easily blendable
  • Smudge-proof
  • Long lasting
  • Travel-friendly
  • Creamy formula
  • Dermatologist-tested
  • Ophthalmologist-tested

Cons

None

9. Best Long-Lasting:Wunder2 SUPERSTAY Liner

star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
4.1
Wunder2 SUPERSTAY Liner Image: Wunder2

The Wunder SUPERSTAY Liner is long-lasting and easy to apply. The content of this pencil is completely waterproof, and it is available in highly pigmented shades. The formula glides easily, blends well, and does not smudge. Blend it with your fingers for a great coverage that will last long. This transfer-resistant product is completely cruelty-free and extremely magical in adding grace to your everyday look.

Color: Metallic Champagne | Product Dimensions: 1.4 x 1.4 x 14.1 inches | Weight: 0.04 Ounces

Pros
  • Highly-pigmented formula
  • Smudge-proof
  • Long-lasting
  • Creamy texture
  • Transfer-resistant
  • Glides smoothly
  • Blendable
  • Cruelty-free

Cons

None

A good quality eye brightener pencil works wonders in accentuating your eyes. These come in extremely handy to nail different eye looks. But, how do you choose one that suits your skin type and makeup needs? Given below are a few factors to keep in mind before buying the best eye brightener pencils.

How To Select The Best Eye Brightener Pencils

  • Formula: Choose an eye brightener pencil with a soft tip that slides smoothly and evenly through the eye area. Look for a smudge-proof, water-resistant formula that provides good coverage.
  • Ingredients To Avoid: The skin around the eye area is soft and sensitive. Choose a brightener pencil enriched with natural ingredients. These include beeswax, chamomile, jojoba oil, castor oil, and lavender to keep the skin healthy and shiny. Many eyeliners have a rich mix of vitamins E and C along with essential minerals. They nourish your eyes while keeping the surrounding skin hydrated.
  • Ingredients To Avoid: Harsh chemical ingredients added in cosmetics as preservatives damage the skin. Choose brightener pencils devoid of sulfates, silicones, phthalates, and parabens. These chemicals cause premature aging of skin by stripping its natural moisture, and uncomfortable sensations like rashes and allergies in people with sensitive skin types .
  • Additional  Features: Choose eye brighteners with high pigmentation to create multiple looks for a sustained impact. You may also look for a variety of color ranges like mint, cream, white smoke, etc.
  • Safety Measures: Choose the brightener pencil that is reviewed and tested by dermatologists and ophthalmologists, while being safe for contact lens wearers.

The Bottom Line

The perfect eye makeup can change your entire look. On days when you are stressed out and instantly want to brighten up your eyes, the best eye brightener pencils can come in handy. These expertly crafted pencils restore the natural shine of your eyes and also help to reduce dark circles and puffiness. The reviewed options mentioned above in the curated list glide effortlessly, are free from synthetic chemicals, and offer long-lasting results. The TreStiQue Shimmer Shadow Crayon – Kona Coffee Shimmer is a creamy, matte formula and imparts a rich color with just one swipe. The Ere Perez Eye Pencil has natural ingredients and is ideal for sensitive eyes, while the Trish McEvoy Eye Brightener Pencil – Shell is a multipurpose pencil perfect to highlight the brow bone and brighten the inner corners. We recommend you start using the pencil from the inner corners of your eyes. In the first instance, use a little bit and then add as per needs.

Supermodel and beauty enthusiast Nini Amerlise says, “I completely resonate with all the listed products, especially since many of them have added natural ingredients which are better for skin health. Eye brighteners help accentuate the natural shape of the eyes and beautifully contour lips and brow. One can play around with the different brands listed to find the one that’s most suitable for the look that is trying to be achieved. Whether it is to create big beautiful bright eyes, a soft and sultry glow or even a musky and mysterious feel, all can be obtained by testing out what works for you. Don’t be afraid to experiment!”

Why Trust StyleCraze?

Baishali Bhattacharya, the author of this article, is certified in makeup artistry. She is an expert in reviewing makeup tools and products, and her interest in the field of makeup helped her choose the best eye brightener pencils for intense eyes. So, after some in-depth research and reviewing, she has carefully curated a list of the best ones available on the market. They help restore your eye’s natural shine and remove the dark circles and puffiness.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does an eye brightener pencil do?

An eye brightener pencil highlights your brow bone, accentuates your lash line, and brightens the inner corner of your eyes to make your eyes look bigger.

Is eye brightener the same as eyeshadow?

No, an eye brightener is not the same as an eyeshadow. Eye brighteners are used in certain spots to define your eyes, whereas eyeshadows are applied on the eyelids and under the eyes to add pop and color to your eye makeup.

Is eye Brightener the same as concealer?

No, eye brighteners brighten certain areas of the eyes, while concealers mostly cover fine lines and dark circles. Also, eye brighteners have thicker formulas than concealers.

How do you choose an eye brightener?

You can choose an eye brightener by checking the undertone of your skin. Make sure to experiment with subtle warm, cool, or neutral shades to understand what works best for your undertone. Also, consider your eye color. Blue eye colors can be paired with warm-toned eye brighteners, while brown eyes look good with warm and cool-toned products.


Recommended Articles

Nini Amerlise

Nini AmerliseSupermodel & Beauty Enthusiast

Nini Amerlise is a multi-award winning Canadian supermodel, beauty enthusiast, TV host for Travel Africa Network, the founder of We Are Royals Inc, and the Director of Creative Agency at NA Management Inc. She graduated from Seneca @York University with a degree in graphic design and continued her education at Toronto Fashion Academy where she was offered the role as...read full bio