11 Best Eye Makeup Removers For Sensitive Eyes To Avoid Irritation

Safe, gentle, and effective eye makeup removers that don’t leave any trace behind.

By Chaitra Krishnan
All products recommended on StyleCraze are independently selected by our editorial team. If you make a purchase through any of these links, we may receive a commission. Learn more about our product selection process here.

If you adore eye makeup but dread taking it off, you must get your hands on the best eye makeup remover for sensitive eyes. While most eye makeup removers are made with gentle ingredients, there are few particularly tested products for sensitive eyes. These are marked safe, certified by ophthalmologists and dermatologists, and free of any fragrance or possible irritants. Those with sensitive skin might as well look for eye makeup removers for sensitive eyes, because excessive scrubbing may prove abrasive to the delicate skin around your eyes and lashes. You may also opt for washable or easily removable eye makeup instead of the long-wear and thick waterproof ones. To help you choose, we have shortlisted some of the best eye makeup removers that are effective yet gentle enough for your sensitive eyes.

Our Top PicksCheck Price
Neutrogena Oil-free Eye Makeup RemoverPrice on Amazon
Almay Makeup-free ZonePrice on Amazon
Beauty By Earth Makeup RemoverPrice on Amazon
La Roche-posay Respectissime Waterproof Eye Makeup RemoverPrice on Amazon
Rimmel London Just Let It Go Eye Makeup RemoverPrice on Amazon
L'oréal Paris Clean Artiste Eye Makeup RemoverPrice on Amazon
Sephora Collection Waterproof Eye Makeup RemoverPrice on Amazon
Simple Kind To Skin Eye Makeup RemoverPrice on Amazon
Klorane Eye Make-up RemoverPrice on Amazon
Marcelle Gentle Eye Makeup Remover For Sensitive EyesPrice on Amazon

11 Best Eye Makeup Removers For Sensitive Eyes To Use In 2022

1. Neutrogena Oil-free Eye Makeup Remover

No products found.

As the name suggests, this makeup remover is oil-free and is a great product for people who hate to deal with oily leftovers on the skin. Infused with aloe and cucumber extracts, the product is very relaxing and nourishing. It offers deep cleaning benefits and doesn’t irritate the skin, especially around the eyes. The scent is very light and is probably the best for those who get easily annoyed by strong fragrances. One thing about this makeup remover that will make you really happy is its non-greasy feel, which is quite rare to find. People who have sensitive eyes or wear contact lenses can opt for this liquid eye makeup remover.

Pros

  • Gentle formula
  • Light for skin
  • Ophthalmologist-tested
  • Gives a refreshing feel

Cons

  • Needs to be wiped off with water

2. Almay Makeup-free Zone

These eye makeup remover pads are loaded with effective makeup remover to give you clean eyes without any pulling and tugging. With a perfect botanical fusion of green tea, aloe and cucumber, these unique eye makeup remover pads are super gentle on the skin. Not only are these useful in cleansing makeup but are also great for calming down the skin with their soothing herbal blend. Perfect for sensitive skin, these soft circular pads pull off eye makeup like an eraser without making the skin greasy.

Pros

  • Oil-free
  • Cruelty-free
  • Non-comedogenic
  • Dermatologist tested
  • Hypoallergenic formula

Cons

  • Does not have any fragrance

3. Beauty By Earth Makeup Remover

This simple makeup remover is very effective towards cleaning eye makeup. Other than eye makeup, you get to remove sweat, oil, dirt and any kind of build up off the face. With no harsh ingredients, this makeup remover is gentle to the skin and keeps a good oil balance in the skin. Beauty by earth makeup remover is paraben-free, vegan, and cruelty-free. It contains sweet orange essential oil that is hydrating in nature and keeps the skin free from any sort of heaviness.

Pros

  • Easy to use
  • Free from mineral oils
  • High quality ingredients
  • Makes skin fresh

Cons

  • Slightly dries out the skin

4. La Roche-posay Respectissime Waterproof Eye Makeup Remover



This waterproof makeup remover contains a bi-phase formula of water-based cleanser and oils that work astonishingly well for sensitive skin. It is one of the best eye makeup removers for sensitive eyes and is good at removing makeup instantly and effectively. It contains poloxamer which is a mild cleanser used in contact lenses. The product can be used in combination with a cleanser or by itself. Without indulging in rubbing or irritating the eyes, you can gently wipe off all your waterproof makeup with this remover. La Roche-Posay waterproof eye makeup remover is perfect for normal and sensitive skin. You just need to shake the product, apply it to a cotton pad and gently wipe across your face and eyes.

Pros

  • Paraben-free
  • Fragrance-free
  • Suitable for sensitive skin
  • Ophthalmologist-tested

Cons

  • Might be slightly oily for some

5. Rimmel London Just Let It Go Eye Makeup Remover

When looking for a fab go-to eye makeup remover that you can use regularly, this has to be your first choice. It cleans up line and stray mascara amazingly well without causing any discomfort. With a cotton swab, it cleans up the face in a beautiful way. With no irritations at all, it is a suitable eye makeup remover for sensitive skin. The product gets high ratings for its effectiveness, pocket-friendly price and great packaging. You just need to place a cotton swab on the bottle and flip it to get the swab covered in makeup remover. Use the damp cotton swab across your eyes, and you get squeaky clean eyes.

Pros

  • No irritation
  • Has no smell
  • Gentle formula
  • Greaseless formula

Cons

  • Might not suit sensitive skin

6. L’oréal Paris Clean Artiste Eye Makeup Remover

L’oreal Paris Clean Artiste Eye Makeup Remover is suitable for removing waterproof & long wearing eye makeup. This double-action makeup remover is gentle on the skin yet removes waterproof makeup effortlessly. Loaded with concentrated makeup removing ingredients, it tackles all types of makeup, dirt, greasiness, etc. The after results of using this makeup remover is wonderful soft, smooth skin. Also, it is super easy to use. You just need to take it on a cotton ball or pad and glide it over your makeup.

Pros

  • Ophthalmologist-tested
  • Gentle formula
  • For all types of skin
  • Leaves no greasy residue

Cons

  • Not oil-proof

7. Sephora Collection Waterproof Eye Makeup Remover

Sephora waterproof eye makeup remover is a top-notch makeup remover with relaxing properties. It instantly lifts off the eye makeup from the skin and leaves the skin fresh. With an effective formula of cornflower extract and pro vitamin B5, this eye makeup remover keeps your skin and eyelashes protected. It works fast and easy,  just like a magic potion. It is most suitable for contact-lens wearers or people with super sensitive eyes. The two-phase liquid formula removes waterproof makeup without any skin irritations. The best part is that it is available in many packaging formats, classic or mini, for every day or travel use.

Pros

  • No greasy effect
  • Has soothing properties
  • Ophthalmologically tested formula
  • No sulfates and parabens

Cons

  • A lot of product is required

8. Simple Kind To Skin Eye Makeup Remover

This is a gentle makeup remover that has the nourishing properties of vitamin E in it. Enriched with antioxidants, cleansing oil, purified water and vitamin B, the formula is hydrating in nature. It soothes the skin and effectively removes eye makeup. Whether it is your waterproof liner, shadow or flaky mascara, this formula works perfectly well on all types of makeup. Without any pulling or rubbing, you can take off your makeup in seconds and get healthy looking skin.

Pros

  • No dye
  • No chemicals
  • No artificial fragrances
  • Does not have sticky residue

Cons

  • Slightly oily makeup

9. Klorane Eye Make-up Remover

If you are someone who has sensitive eyes, and oily skin just drives you crazy, then this is the suitable eye makeup remover for you. Klorane eye makeup remover is free from parabens, sulfates and silicones. With no harsh ingredients in it, the formula treats the skin gently. Induced with organically farmed cornflower, this soothing eye makeup remover effectively works on all types of makeup and keeps the skin clean. The pH value of the remover is similar to tears which keeps irritation, burning and sting sensation at bay. Ophthalmologist tested, this unique formula keeps your skin free from greasy residue. Another way of using this makeup remover is to apply it on a cotton pad and place it on your eyes like an eye compress.

Pros

  • Vegan formula
  • Fragrance-free
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Oil-free formula

Cons

  • It’s a bit runny.

10. Marcelle Gentle Eye Makeup Remover For Sensitive Eyes


Marcelle eye makeup remover has a dual-phase formula considered ultra-gentle for sensitive skin. It leaves you spellbound with its good quality and gentle feel. Induced with cucumber extract, this makeup remover is super soothing and nourishes the delicate eye area. Tested by ophthalmologists and dermatologists, this eye makeup remover is specifically ideal for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. This is a formula with absolutely no harsh additives that helps remove eye and face makeup effectively without irritating the skin.

Pros

  • Paraben-free
  • Gluten-free
  • Fragrance-free
  • Alcohol-free
  • Cruelty-free

Cons   

  • Slightly expensive

11.  Avene Gentle Eye Make-up Remover

Avène gentle eye makeup remover is an all-time favorite of people who get easily irritated by makeup products. It is specifically formulated to take off makeup with care and without making the skin irritated. The formula is ophthalmologist-tested, and is also suitable for those who wear contact lenses. Its soothing watery formula makes the application easy. In fact, unlike harsh makeup removers, it can be used directly over your eyes with a cotton pad or fingers. The pH level of this makeup remover is like that of tears. It doesn’t burn the eyes and prevents any dryness post-cleaning. With the presence of sorbitol and thermal spring water, the makeup remover is super hydrating in nature.

Pros

  • Oil-free
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Water-gel formula
  • Paraben-free

Cons

  • Slightly less quantity

Hope after going through this article, you get the best eye makeup remover for sensitive eyes. Before heading to purchasing one, have a look at the points mentioned below that might assist you in making a better buy.

How To Choose Eye Makeup Remover For Sensitive Eyes?

Consider the following points before investing in an eye makeup remover for sensitive eyes-

  • Skin Type

It is important to understand your skin type before you pick an eye makeup remover for your sensitive eyes. An oil-based formula can create havoc on oily skin, so it is best to invest in a makeup remover with no-oil formula to keep oily greasiness away from your eyes and skin. In case you have dry skin, then invest in a water-gel or hydrating formula that not just removes makeup easily without being rough on your skin but also soothes your dry skin areas, especially around the eyes. For people with sensitive skin, look for products that contain no harsh chemicals like parabens, silicones or fragrances to avoid any kind of skin irritations around eyes.

  • Formula

Formulas that are loaded with herbal ingredients like cucumber and aloe are super hydrating in nature. One should prefer products with such ingredients to keep irritations away from sensitive eyes. In case you hate oily makeup residue on your eyes, look for formulas that contain purified water or a blend of ingredients that are less oily. For people who hate sting or burning sensation in their eyes, eye makeup removers with pH similar to that of tears would be great. In case you are a contact lens wearer, then choose a formula that is tested by ophthalmologists and considered safe for sensitive eyes. If you are someone who has very sensitive eyes, then always opt for a hypoallergenic eye makeup remover.

How To Remove Eye Makeup For Sensitive Skin?

  • Choose a gentle eye makeup remover.
  • Make sure it is free from harsh chemicals and is hypoallergenic in nature.
  • Take a cotton pad or ball.
  • Put some eye makeup remover on this cotton pad or ball. Take enough of the product to avoid rough dragging of cotton pad on the skin.
  • Gently swipe it over the eyes. Make sure there is no pulling or tugging of lashes.

Taking care of your eyes isn’t easy! We must be extra cautious about everything when it comes to our eyes. You should choose eye makeup removers that are certified by ophthalmologists and dermatologists so that your makeup remover is devoid of harmful chemicals and toxins. But at the same time, it should remove all eye makeup thoroughly. It is advised to never excessively scrub your eyes or the area around your eyes. Choose products that are gentle on your eyes and the sensitive skin around your eyes. Eye makeup removers that contain parabens, sulfates, phthalates, and other toxic chemicals must be avoided at all costs. Steer clear of eye makeup removers that are sticky, greasy, and feel heavy on the skin. Removers that make the skin feel fresh are the best ones!

Why Trust StyleCraze?

The author of this article, Chaitra Krishnan, is a makeup enthusiast who loves trying out different products. She has curated a list of the best eye makeup removers for sensitive eyes after carefully researching and browsing through online reviews. According to her, even minor mistakes can irritate the eyes, which is why investing in a powerful yet delicate eye makeup remover is always a good choice. The products listed are marked safe, certified by ophthalmologists and dermatologists, and free of any fragrance or irritants.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Eye Makeup Remover Bad For Your Eyes?

Generally, eye makeup removers are not bad for your eyes. Still, one should consider using a gentle eye makeup remover with no harsh ingredients.

Can You Use Eye Makeup Remover On Your Face?

Yes, you can use eye makeup remover on your face, depending on your skin type. If your makeup remover is free from oils, then it can be used for oily-acne prone skin, else not.

Why Does Eye Makeup Remover Irritate My Eyes?

Eye makeup remover might be irritating your eyes because you are not using the makeup remover in the right way. Ensure there is no pulling or rubbing of eyes while you remove makeup. Also, if there are harsh toxic ingredients in your makeup remover like parabens, sulfates, it can irritate your eyes.

How often should you use eye makeup removers for sensitive eyes?

Try to remove eye makeup with organic ingredients like milk, baking soda, and honey to prevent any skin irritations. If using drugstore eye makeup removers, do not use them more than twice a week. Always do a patch test before trying out products around your eye region.

Recommended Articles

The following two tabs change content below.
Chaitra has a triple main bachelor’s degree in journalism, communicative English, and economics from St. Aloysius College, Mangalore, and a... more

LATEST ARTICLES