15 Best Eyebrow Pencils For Beautiful & Perfectly Defined Eyebrows

We often mistake ignoring our eyebrows and concentrating our eyes on eye makeup. Eyebrows are the frame of your eyes, and drawing them perfectly makes half the work down for your gorgeous eyes. Using the best eyebrow pencils can make sure your eyebrows are natural-looking and perfect no matter where you go. Especially if your eyebrows are naturally thin, using a brow pencil will help you get enhanced features. It will add thickness and shape to your brows and complete your look. They fill in the sparse area between brow hairs and give a naturally voluminous look. To help you pick the best one, here are 15 top-rated pencils crafted to give you perfect eyebrows for everyday use.

15 Best Eyebrow Pencils

1. Best Overall:Maybelline Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil

4.4

Image: Maybelline New York

Now 11% Off

BUY ON AMAZON | $8.89

Buy on Walmart

The diamond-shaped head of the Maybelline Total Temptations Eyebrow Pencil allows for both shading and defining brow lines. The spoolie brush, along with a teardrop tip pencil, helps blend properly and offers a softly defined, natural-looking brow. The pencil is available in four different shades designed explicitly for pure indulgence.

Pros

• Performs dual roles
• Teardrop tip suitable for outlining and filling brows
• Available in 4 different shades
• Long-lasting effects
• Maintains natural look
• Easy to use
• Suitable for beginners

Cons

• Not smudge-proof
• No pointed tip

Quick Tip

After using an eyebrow pencil, follow it up with Maybelline Express Brow Fast Sculpt Mascara. This clear gel formulation is also designed to tame your brows and give them a precise shape.

2. Best Budge-Proof Formula:IT Cosmetics Brow Power Eyebrow Pencil

4.4

Image: It Cosmetics

BUY ON AMAZON | $26

Get perfectly polished eyebrows with the IT Cosmetics Brow Power Eyebrow Pencil. The pencil is designed with a distinct oval tip that resembles the look of a real strand of hair. Every stroke of the pencil makes the eyebrows defined, and depending on the pressure, the pencil adjusts to the eyebrow color. The budge-proof formula of the pencil has garnered positive customer reviews as it sticks to the eyebrows, giving them a natural finish. It also comes with a built-in spoolie that helps you brush the eyebrows to perfection. This eyebrow pencil contains biotin that offers beautiful brows while protecting your delicate skin.

Pros

• Adjustable oval tip
• Budge-proof formula
• Biotin-infused formula
• Suitable for sensitive skin

Cons

None

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

It has gained over 1,054 positive reviews on Amazon, making it an all-time best-seller.

3. Best Smudge-Proof:Revlon ColorStay Eyebrow Pencil

4.5

Image: Revlon

Now 32% Off

BUY ON AMAZON | $8.2

Buy on Walmart

The Revlon Color Stay Precision Eyebrow Pencil helps you mimic fine, hair-like strokes that appear incredibly real. It also lasts all day long without budging. The angled pencil tip with extra precision along with a spoolie brush defines and blends eyebrows and helps maintain a natural look. With its cult following, this pencil is also an Allure Best of Beauty award winner. If your brows are over-tweezed and way too sparse, this smudge-proof formula is guaranteed to blow your mind. It is easy to use and offers a soft, blendable color to fill the gaps. It is a long-wearing formula that stays for up to 24 hours. You can also choose your color from its range of 5 shades.

Pros

• Long-wearing
• Easy to use
• Defines brows perfectly
• Smudge-proof
• Waterproof
• Value for money
• Paraben-free
• Sweat-resistant
• Available in 5 shades

Cons

None

Quick Tip

To brighten up your brow area, use Revlon Colorstay Concealer. Pick one shade lighter than your skin tone and apply it around the eyes.

	Best Overall	Best Budge-Proof Formula	Best Smudge-Proof
	Maybelline Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil	IT Cosmetics Brow Power Eyebrow Pencil	Revlon ColorStay Eyebrow Pencil
Color	SOFT BROWN	-	210 Soft Brown
Dimensions	1.88 x 0.39 x 5.61 inches	0.67 x 0.91 x 5.63 inches	-
Weight	0.49 Ounces	0.34 Ounces.	-
Rating*	4.4	4.4	4.5
Reviews	9,330	1,054	1,309
Price	$8.89	$26	$8.2
	Buy Now	Buy Now	Buy Now

4. Best For Daily Wear:LAURA GELLER NEW YORK Bravo Brows Soft Pencil + Brush

4.1

Image: Laura Geller

BUY ON AMAZON | $21.5

The LAURA GELLER NEW YORK Bravo Brows Soft Pencil + Brush glides smoothly on your brows and gives you an everyday look with absolutely no effort. The two-in-one design of the brush helps you shape your brows into a perfect arch. The spoolie softens and shapes your brows, while the soft pencil highlights and tints them. People with dirty blonde to light brown hair can use this pencil to shape, define, and fill their brows. Reviewers on online forums attest that the ideal balance of pigment and wax gives a natural look with one swift application. The unique formula of the pencil is infused with natural oils that condition and nourish your brow hair. Whether unruly brows, graying brows, thin brows, or thick brows, the pencil gives you tamed and defined brows that transform your whole face.

Pros

• Nourishing formula
• User-friendly application
• High pigmentation
• Glides smoothly
• Waterproof

Cons

• May dry out after some time

5. Best Budget-Friendly:NYX Professional Makeup Micro Brow Pencil

4.4

Image: Nyx Professional

Now 20% Off

BUY ON AMAZON | $8.81

Buy on Walmart

The NYX Professional Makeup Micro Brow Pencil is a long-wear formula that gives you fuller brows just as nicely as the more expensive pencils out there. The precise, super-skinny tip coats the finest of hair and helps achieve fuller-looking brows. With eight different shades in the range and an ultra-thin micro tip, this pencil will coat even the finest hairs and offer a natural-looking finish.

Pros

• Easy to use
• Budget-friendly
• Long-wearing
• Smudge-proof
• Cruelty-free
• Provides a natural-looking finish
• Easy to use

Cons

None

6. Best Pigmentation:Honest Beauty Eyebrow Pencil

4.3

Image: Honest Beauty

BUY ON AMAZON | $11.99

The celebrity-endorsed Honest Beauty Eyebrow Pencil gives you natural-looking brows with just a few smooth strokes. The pencil is infused with jojoba seed oil which nourishes the brows. The formula conditions and reshapes the brow hair and is suitable for all skin types. The creamy formula of the pencil blends seamlessly to offer a natural finish to the brows and add depth and definition to them. Ethically-conscious reviewers also recommend this product as it is free from animal testing.

Pros

• Nourishing formula
• Glides smoothly
• Cruelty-free
• Paraben-free
• Petrochemical-free
• Polyethylene-free
• Silicone-free
• Dermatologist-tested
• Ophthalmologist-tested

Cons

• Pencil may be too soft

7. Best Sweat-Resistant:Anastasia Beverly Hills Eyebrow Pencil

4.6

Image: Anastasia Beverly Hills

BUY ON AMAZON | $25

Buy on Walmart

The Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz Eyebrow Pencil helps you mimic fine, hair-like strokes that appear incredibly real. It also lasts all day long without budging. With its cult following, this pencil is also an Allure Best of Beauty award winner. This pencil tames brows that are over-tweezed and way too sparse. The smudge-proof formula is guaranteed to blow your mind. It is also not tested on animals, making it an ideal cruelty-free option. You can also choose your color from its range of 10 shades.

Pros

• Long-wearing
• Easy to use
• Value for money
• Paraben-free
• Available in 10 different shades
• Waterproof
• Sweat-resistant
• Smudge-proof

Cons

None

Quick tip

You can make faux freckles on your face by using an eyebrow pencil and gently dotting it over the cheeks and chin area.

8. Best Affordable:Maybelline New York Brow Precise Micro Eyebrow Pencil

4.3

Image: Maybelline

BUY ON AMAZON | $15

Buy on Walmart

The Maybelline New York Brow Precise Eyebrow Pencil fills in and blends into your brows beautifully for fuller and natural-looking eyebrows. This super skinny pencil with an ultra-micro tip measures 1.5 mm. Numerous reviewers rave about this pencil for defining the brows and leaving a natural finish. The short, soft spoolie brush combs sparse hair and shapes it properly. It is available in 7 different shades.

Pros

• Affordable
• Long-wearing
• Precision pencil
• Water-resistant
• Available in 7 different shades

Cons

None

9.  Best For Precision:Wet n Wild Ultimate Brow Retractable Pencil

4.4

Image: Wet N Wild

Now 34% Off

BUY ON AMAZON | $3.18

Achieve Insta-worthy eye makeup with the Wet n Wild Ultimate Brow Retractable Pencil. The pencil contains a triangular tip which helps create thin strokes. You can safely retract the eyebrow tip after use and store it in your makeup bag without causing any damage to the tip. You can also brush and blend the brow lines with the built-in spoolie to get an even look. The unique angular design of the pencil helps you move it across your eyebrows without any mess.

Pros

• Highly-pigmented
• Mess-free application
• Ergonomic design
• Cruelty-free
• Suitable for precise eye makeup

Cons

None

10. Best Smooth Application:Etude House Drawing Eyebrow Pencil

4.2

Image: Etude House

BUY ON AMAZON | $6.9

Buy on Walmart

This is a brow pencil from a celebrity-endorsed brand that gives you a natural look even after several uses. The Etude House Drawing Eyebrow Pencil is designed with a triangle tip to create a sharp, defined stroke, making it perfect for precise brow shaping. The gel contains vitamin E that moisturizes your brow lines and glides smoothly to give you the desired eyebrow shape. The attached spoolie brush with a high-temperature-resistant capability blends the color properly with your brows and retains their natural look. Several reviewers love this eyebrow pencil as it has the right amount of pigment and base to achieve a glamorous look.

Pros

• Vitamin E in gel offers moisturization
• Glides easily
• Smooth application
• Provides precise, hair-like strokes
• Long-lasting effect
• Available in 7 different shades

Cons

• May cause irritation to the brow lines
• Expensive

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

With over 1,615 reviews, this product has become a fan favorite among users.

11. Best Dual-Ended Tip:e.l.f. Instant Lift Brow Pencil

4.4

Image: E.l.f

BUY ON AMAZON | $3

The e.l.f. Instant Lift Brow Pencil shapes, evens out, and perfectly defines your brows. The dual-ended eyebrow pencil also contains a spoolie which helps comb your eyebrows in the desired shape before drawing them. The fine tip of the pencil offers extreme accuracy, and its smudge-proof formula keeps your eyebrows well-defined throughout the day. The formula comprises grapeseed oil. This ingredient promotes healthy hair growth and conditions your hair, while vitamin E softens and nourishes the hair and skin.

Pros

• Smudge-proof formula
• Dual-ended pencil tip
• Nourishing formula
• Paraben-free
• Phthalate-free
• Sulfate-free
• Vegan
• Cruelty-free

Cons

• Tip might keep slipping inside

12. Best Hypoallergenic:Almay Eyebrow Pencil

4.4

Image: Almay

Now 26% Off

BUY ON AMAZON | $7.57

Buy on Walmart

The Almay Eyebrow Pencil is a triple tasking tool. It has a pointed tip for defining your brows, a flat-edged tip for filling the gaps, and a spoolie brush for blending the shades and grooming the eyebrows further. It provides all-day wear. It is a hypoallergenic formula suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. Additionally, this eyebrow pencil is a favorite of ethically-conscious consumers, as it is not tested on animals.

Pros

• Hypoallergenic
• 3-in-1 eyebrow pencil
• Suitable for sensitive eyes
• Ophthalmologist-tested
• Eye-friendly for contact lens wearers
• Long-lasting wear
• Available in 3 shades

Cons

• Pointed tip may break easily
• Darkly pigmented

13. Best Matte Coverage:Benefit Goof Proof Brow Pencil

4.6

Image: Benefit

BUY ON AMAZON | $26

The Benefit Goof Proof Brow Pencil offers volumized arches with a few strokes. The custom teardrop tip instantly fills, defines, and shapes the brows. Reviews on online forums vouch for the unique formula of the brow pencil that glides on your brows smoothly and softly to give them a matte finish and natural look. Use the brow pencil for full brows and the spoolie for a polished look. The brow pencil boasts a goof-proof tip that does not need to be sharpened and comes with a long-lasting waterproof formula.

Pros

• Matte finish
• Waterproof
• Volumizing
• Goof-proof tip
• Easy application

Cons

• Might dry out after some time

14. Best For Sensitive Eyes:COVERGIRL Easy Breezy Brow Micro-Fine + Define Pencil

4.4

Image: Covergirl

Now 27% Off

BUY ON AMAZON | $6.94

The COVERGIRL Easy Breezy Brow Micro-Fine + Define Pencil has a micro-fine tip that allows you to define your brows smoothly and easily, without having to worry about mistakes. The pencil does not require any sharpening and the efficient spoolie blends the color after the application to offer natural-looking results. The unique hypoallergenic formula of the pencil makes it ideal for sensitive eyes.

Pros

• Glides smoothly
• Adjustable built-in spoolie
• Hypoallergenic formula
• Suitable for sensitive eyes

Cons

None

15. Best Nourishing Formula:Palladio Brow Pencil

4.1

Image: Palladio

BUY ON AMAZON | $6.89

Buy on Walmart

If you want to give your brows a perfect shape and retain their moisture with natural ingredients, the Palladio Brow Pencil is the right pick. It contains a sculpture brush on one end and a pointed tip on the other end that helps draw the brow lines. The pigment is made from botanical extracts and contains vitamin E that nourishes the look of the brows. The eyebrow pencil is gentle for sensitive eyes too. Ethically-conscious beauty lovers also opt for this product as it is not tested on animals.

Pros

• Softer pencil strokes for a natural appearance
• Botanical- and vitamin-infused brow definer
• Suitable for thin brow hair
• Easy to use
• Value for money

Cons

• Pigment could be a little too brownish
• Contains a red tint

How To Use An Eyebrow Pencil

• Brush your hair using the spoolie brush in an upward motion in the direction of the hair growth.
• Draw a short, feature-like stroke in the direction of growth.
• Blend properly by using the same spoolie brush to give it a nice, clean, natural finish.
• For a fuller or more defined look, fill the sparse area by using brow powder.
• Now your eyes are ready to set a mascara and an eyeliner gel.

The most tricky part is choosing the best shade for your brow color. The next section can help you with the same.

How To Choose The Right Shade

The rule of thumb is to pick the shade as per your eyebrow color.

• Light Hair: Grey or blonde or a darker shade.
• Auburn: A taupe or light blonde shade.
• Brunettes: The same tone or one or two shades lighter.
• Dark Brown or Black Hair: Softer gray or dark or ash brown.

Go through the next section to know what to look for in an eyebrow pencil before making a purchase.

Eyebrow Pencils – A Buying Guide

• Choose the formula that has a soft texture and is smooth enough to glide on the eyebrow effortlessly. This makes your eyebrows look voluminous.
• Choose the shade that blends easily with the hair color of your brow, leaving a natural finish.
• Pick an eyebrow pencil that contains both a pointed tip and an angled-tip along with the spoolie brush to arrange and define sparse hair.
• The eyebrow pencil should be budget-friendly and easy to use.

Defined brows are a great way to make a statement-making, dramatic look pop more. This is where an eyebrow pencil comes to the rescue. Feathering in little strokes and brushing them out with a spoolie will make your brows appear naturally fuller and fluffier. Choose your favorite eyebrow pencil from this list today.

Why Trust StyleCraze?

Baishali Bhattacharya, the author of this article, is certified in makeup artistry and enjoys experimenting with makeup items flooding the market. To help her readers achieve flawless eyebrows, she researched and curated a list of the best eyebrow pencils. She also tried some herself to create this list. These eyebrow pencils that have been listed will make your eyebrows look naturally voluminous.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is better – an eyebrow pencil or an eyebrow powder?

Both types of products have their own advantages. Eyebrow pencils are used to get a natural look. They are also easier to use as they are handy and can be used on the go. Brow powders can be used when you want to get a darker and well-defined look. They help fill all the gaps and offer a voluminous look.

Which eyebrow pencil is best for beginners?

An eyebrow pencil with a pointed tip could be ideal for beginners. It helps draw the browlines perfectly and offers a more natural look.

What kind of an eyebrow pencil is best for sparse eyebrows?

An eyebrow pencil with an angled-tip and an attached spoolie brush could be ideal for sparse eyebrows. The angled tip helps fill the entire gap in the sparse eyebrows perfectly.

Is an eyebrow pencil bad for your brows?

No, it is not. It helps define your brow lines.

Is eyebrow pencil toxic?

No. However, eyebrow pencils may contain parabens, PEGs, and carbon blacks that are toxic and unsafe for use.

Is eyebrow pencil safe for pregnancy?

Yes, it is safe to use non-toxic eyebrow pencils during pregnancy.

Can eyebrow pencils be used as eyeliner?

Yes, an eyebrow pencil may be used as a fine eyeliner.

Can I put an eyebrow pencil on after microblading?

Yes, but wait for the skin to heal for two weeks before applying any makeup products, including an eyebrow pencil.

Does the eyebrow pencil expire?

Yes, most eyebrow pencils last a year to three and must be replaced after that. Always check the packaging for the expiration date.

Does eyebrow pencil wash off?

No, most eyebrow pencil products must be removed with coconut oil or mild makeup remover.

Does eyebrow pencil cause hair loss?

No. However, if you are allergic to any ingredients or use the pencil too often, you may experience hair loss from the brows.

Recommended Articles

• Best Eyebrow Pencils For Perfect Arches
• Best Drugstore Eyebrow Pencils For Natural Looking Brows
• Best Korean Eyebrow Pencils
• Best Eyebrow Stencils For Those Ultra-Defined, Perfect Arches
• Best Eyebrow Pomades That Will Give You The Best-Looking Brows

Was this article helpful?

The following two tabs change content below.

• Reviewer
• Author
• Editor
• Fact-checker

Mary AjakaMakeup Artist

 

Mary Ajaka is a celebrity makeup artist with 15 years of experience in TV/media, editorial, and bridal makeup. She has a keen eye for detail and understands that each face is unique, which is why she uses different makeup techniques tailored to the individual. Mary's passion for makeup artistry is evident in her work, and she strives to achieve excellence...more

Baishali BhattacharyaBeauty & Lifestyle Writer

 

Baishali is a beauty and lifestyle writer and holds a master's degree in English from Assam University. She specializes in makeup and fashion and is also a certified Style and Image Consultant. Prior to this, she was a part of a digital marketing company in Kolkata where she wrote stories on travel, beauty, and home décor. Baishali loves reading and...more

Srijita DeCommerce Writer

Srijita De is a makeup and fashion enthusiast with a passion for empowering readers through practical tips and tricks to present their best selves with confidence. Armed with a postgraduate degree in English and Literature from the University of Calcutta, she has honed her writing skills and developed an in-depth understanding of the beauty and fashion world. Prior to her...more

Srijani Roy Chowdhury Associate Commerce Editor

Srijani is an associate commerce editor with a master's degree in journalism and mass communication from the University of Calcutta, West Bengal. She is certified in makeup techniques and is also a certified style and image consultant. She began her career as a freelance content writer, has worked as a journalist in several media houses, and has over three years...more