8 Best Mascara For Redheads of 2024 Reviews

Achieve flawless eye makeup with intense mascaras that work wonders on your look!

Reviewed by Nyssa Green, Makeup Artist
Written by Srijita De, MA (English & Literature), Certified Style & Image Consultant
Edited by Srijani Roy Chowdhury, MA (Journalism & Mass Communication), Certified Style & Image Consultant
Fact-checked by Madhumati Chowdhury, MA (English Literature)  • 
All products recommended on StyleCraze are independently selected by our editorial team. If you make a purchase through any of these links, we may receive a commission. Learn more about our product selection process here.

Redheads are gifted with a unique complexion and lash color that makes them stand beautifully apart. If you are one of those beautiful people, try getting your hands on the best mascara for redheads to make your eyes pop and look their best. The commonly available black and brown mascaras might look out of place on your lashes and would not suit your natural complexion as well. That’s why using a mascara made especially for your complexion and pale lashes would give them a more naturally defined look. Available in many options and variations, these statement-making mascaras are sure to elevate your lashes to another level. To help you get started, we have enlisted the top 8 mascara options for you so that you can pick the most suitable one for yourself.

Top PicksCheck Price
Best For Natural Thickness:L'Oreal Paris Makeup Voluminous Original Mascara – Deep Burgundy
Price on Amazon
Best Cruelty-Free: Covergirl Lash Blast Volume Mascara – Brown
Price on Amazon
Best For Length:Farmasi Double Lash Extend Mascara - BrownPrice on Amazon
Best For Healthy Lashes:Mineral Fusion Lash Lengthening Mascara - RockPrice on Amazon
Best For Tired Eyes:Eyeko Lash Alert MascaraPrice on Amazon
Best Collagen-Infused Formula: By Terry Terrybly Growth Booster Mascara
Price on Amazon
Best For Wide-Eye Coverage:Christian Dior Diorshow Iconic Overcurl Mascara
Price on Amazon
Price on Walmart
Best Water-Resistant:Just for Redheads Mascara Naturelle — Ginger AuburnPrice on Amazon

8 Best Mascara Reviews of 2024 For Redheads!

1. Best For Natural Thickness: L’Oreal Paris Makeup Voluminous Original Mascara – Deep Burgundy

4.4

For redheads who fancy long lashes but want to keep it natural, this deep burgundy mascara by Loreal Paris is a must-try. Augmenting the natural lash color, it adds volume up to 5 times! Its unique formula, on the other hand, contains panthenol and ceramide-R that conditions and protects the strands. And as for the volume-maximizing bristle brush — it glides smoothly and tints every lash evenly to deliver a gorgeous, longer, fuller, and thick appearance! This is the perfect mascara for natural redheads and is a must-have to get the celebrity makeup artist kinda look. This colored mascara is perfect for special occasions and has no less than 75,976 reviews on Amazon for being user-friendly and for giving a lengthening coverage. So, if black or brown mascara for redheads or the traditional mascara is not working out, this lash volumizer in deep burgundy might be the one.

Color: Washable Deep Burgundy | Product Dimensions: 0.67 x 2.75 x 7.06 inches | Weight: 0.26 Ounces

Pros

  • Softens and lengthens the eyelashes
  • Adds a natural thickness
  • Defines the eyes
  • Clump-free formula
  • Protects and nourishes the lashes
  • Ideal to get a natural look
  • Gentle and suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers

Cons

  • It may flake.
  • It may not be easy to remove.

Our Tester's Experience

"This mascara enhances my natural eyelashes. It has a good applicator that coats my fine lashes well. It adds volume without clumping or flaking. It does not smudge, even on my oily lids. It is easy to remove and does not create messes."


protip_icon Pro Tip
Apply the L’Oreal Paris Voluminous Lash Primer before applying the mascara to get voluminous lashes with every use.

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

The overwhelming 77,645 positive reviews on Amazon show how popular this product is with happy users.

2. Best Cruelty-Free: Covergirl Lash Blast Volume Mascara – Brown

4.4

Heading out to a beach or picnic? Go big and bold with this lash maximizer! An inexpensive yet effective hypoallergenic mascara, it promises to mega-boost those tired and dull lashes instantly. Delivering fullness up to 10 times with its volumizing brush, this drugstore mascara for redheads is a great pick if you want to add a stunning lush to your eyes. Accentuating your auburn tresses, this brown mascara for redheads by Covergirl is not only a classic blend of drama and volume. This formula is gentle enough for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. The applicator brush works great on your bottom lashes too. This redhead mascara is a great budget-friendly option. Suitable for blonde or brown lashes, this volume-building and lash-maximizing mascara has over 4,500 rave reviews on Amazon for being smudge-free, smear-free, and sweat-resistant. Also, ethically-conscious consumers opt for this product as it is not tested on animals. Here’s an honest review of a tester’s experience of using this affordable mascara.

Color: 815 - Brown | Product Dimensions: 4 x 3 x 3 inches | Weight: 0.8 Ounces

Pros

  • Maximizes the thickness of the eyelashes
  • Adds thickness and makes them look longer
  • Flake-free
  • Defines and separates lashes
  • Volume-boosting formula
  • Does not smudge or smear
  • Cruelty-free

Cons

  • Takes longer to dry
  • Eyelashes may clump

Our Tester's Experience

"I really like this waterproof mascara's staying power. It stays through tears, showers, and even gym sessions. It is easy to apply and separates my lashes while offering decent volume. It does not clump or create any mess. I don't have to rub it harshly while removing it, which is another relief for me."


protip_icon Pro Tip
Curl your lashes with an eyelash curler, then use this mascara to achieve a lifted look. Pair with Lash Blast Amplify Primer some extra glam and volume.

3. Best For Length: Farmasi Double Lash Extend Mascara﹘Brown

4.3
Farmasi Double Lash Extend Mascara﹘Brown Image: Farmasi

The Farmasi Double Lash Extend Mascara offers three benefits in one formula. It adds length, high volume, and definition to the lashes in an instant and is perfect for a beach picnic or day trip! This long-lasting, waterproof mascara lasts all day through rain and sun and gives you a classic look mixed with just the right amount of drama. The silky formula with a double-wiper technology imparts a false lash effect in just two steps. Multiple reviewers attest that the buildable formula of the mascara is easy to apply and does not clump the lashes while applying multiple coats.

Color: Brown | Product Dimensions: 0.83 x 0.83 x 5.55 inches | Weight: 1.06 Ounces.

Pros

  • Two-part silicone brush
  • Lash-boosting
  • Buildable
  • Flake-free
  • Fade-proof
  • Waterproof
  • Gluten-free
  • Paraben-free
  • Vegan
  • Cruelty-free

Cons

  • Dry formula

Our Tester's Experience

"This mascara has enhanced the length and volume of my lashes. It is comfortable for my sensitive eyes and stays put throughout the day. I try not to touch or rub my eyes when I have eye makeup on, but this mascara does not smear even when I accidentally do so. The wand length is perfect for me and helps me in coating my lashes well."


protip_icon Quick Tip
Do not over-pump your mascara wand into the tube. This will pump air into the tube and make your mascara dry.

L'Oreal Paris Makeup Voluminous Original Mascara – Deep Burgundy
Best For Natural Thickness
Covergirl Lash Blast Volume Mascara – Brown
Best Cruelty-Free
Farmasi Double Lash Extend Mascara﹘Brown
Best For Length
Color Washable Deep Burgundy 815 - Brown Brown
Dimensions 0.67 x 2.75 x 7.06 inches 4 x 3 x 3 inches 0.83 x 0.83 x 5.55 inches
Weight 0.26 Ounces 0.8 Ounces 1.06 Ounces.
Rating
Reviews77,6454,494-
Price$5.64$8.98$16.9

4. Best For Healthy Lashes: Mineral Fusion Lash Lengthening Mascara – Rock

3.9
Mineral Fusion Lash Lengthening Mascara - Rock Image: Mineral Fusion

Now get the best of makeup and care with the Mineral Fusion Lash Lengthening Mascara. This hypoallergenic mascara is made with all natural ingredients, film-forming polymer and is enriched with luxurious botanical extracts that nourish and condition the lashes and promote lash health and vivacity. It suits both blonde and brown lashes. The precise applicator coats each lash equally for a clump-free, natural look. The rich mineral pigments of this type of mascara will ensure a bright look. Its smudge-free formula and easy removal has garnered numerous positive customer reviews online. If you’re wondering if it is worth the splurge, take a plunge!

Color: Rock | Product Dimensions: 0.9 x 0.9 x 4.95 inches | Weight: 0.48 Ounces.

Pros

  • Flake-free
  • Fade-proof
  • Waterproof
  • Fragrance-free
  • Paraben-free
  • Gluten-free
  • Phthalate-free
  • Cruelty-free

Cons

  • Dries up easily

Our Tester's Experience

"The mascara lengthens my lashes pretty well. It is easy and use and has a quick drying time. It may require multiple coats on finer lashes but it works fine for me. It does not smudge, even during humid weather conditions. Overall, I love how smoothly it glides my lashes."


5. Best For Tired Eyes: Eyeko Lash Alert Mascara

4.2
Eyeko Lash Alert Mascara Image: Eyeko

Avoid tired eyes with just two coats of this Eyeko Lash Alert Mascara in brown shade that adds an oomph factor to your lashes. The caffeine-infused formula lifts sleepy, droopy lashes for a lifted, alert look, while biotin and arginine nourish and condition the lashes. The curved brush applicator enables you to coat the entire lash evenly and separate them for a natural flutter. This long-lasting maraca complements your red hair and offers you a lively look instantly.

Color: Brown | Product Dimensions: 0.9 x 1.6 x 6.6 inches | Weight: 0.71 Ounces

Pros

  • Gentle formula
  • Non-clumping
  • Offers curling effect
  • Easy to remove
  • Value for money

Cons

  • None

Our Tester's Experience

"I love this mascara's curved applicator. I can apply it in such a way that it does not clump or flake. The mascara also does not smudge, even in humid weather. It separates and defines my lashes without any irritation."


6. Best Collagen-Infused Formula: By Terry Terrybly Growth Booster Mascara

4.3
By Terry Terrybly Growth Booster Mascara Image: By Terry Terrybly

Formulated with advanced lumicoat care technology, here’s a waterproof mascara for redheads that’ll strengthen and nourish your lashes unconditionally and make them grow longer! Yep, no more skipping the mascara due to lash loss or weak follicle. It’s time to move beyond brown mascara and opt for Terry’s Terrybly Growth Booster Mascara. It is infused with the goodness of collagen, hyaluronic acid, and plant protein that act as a conditioning and restructuring booster for the eyelashes. Pampering on the inside, intense on the outside. This Paris-based premium brand will make your eyes look striking and stunning instantly.

Color: Black Parti-Pris Full Size.

Pros

  • Soft and nourishing formula for the lashes
  • Precise application
  • All-day wear
  • Prevents lash loss
  • Lengthens and boosts fullness
  • Highly-pigmented and adds definition
  • Smudge-free, clump-free, and flake-free
  • Waterproof
  • Ophthalmologically-tested

Cons

  • Expensive

Our Tester's Experience

"This mascara defines my lashes without clumps or the dreaded spider look. I love how easily I can wash it off as well. It has great staying power and does not smear, even when I am sweating."


7. Best For Wide-Eye Coverage: Christian Dior Diorshow Iconic Overcurl Mascara

Don’t mind splurging on mascara? Here’s a luxury from the celebrity-endorsed house of Christian Dior that can turn your eyes into party showstoppers! High-end, classy yet light enough to pull off the casual look, Diorshow Iconic Overcurl Mascara amplifies your lashes and promises to deliver eye-catching high volume and wide-eye coverage. With a curved brush that ensures your eyes look flirty and fluttery after every use, you’ll never want to go back to those regular or drugstore mascaras again. Flattering your lashes from lid to tip, this is no ordinary mascara, it’s pure indulgence. The choices for eye makeup for redheads and blue-eyed persons are not limited and this mascara is a testament to that. Reviews on online forums attest that this smudge-proof mascara keeps their lashes curled all day!

Color: Brown | Product Dimensions: 4 x 1 x 1 inches | Weight: 0.35 Ounces

Pros

  • A high-end and premium-quality brand
  • Adds natural thickness to the lashes
  • Longwear
  • Ideal to intensify and amplify curls
  • Easy removal

Cons

  • May clump
  • Expensive

Our Tester's Experience

"This mascara leaves my lashes curled and volumized. I love its waterproof formula that does not budge, even when I sweat. I usually remove it using an oil-based remover. It does not flake and is good for contact lens wearers like my sister."


8. Best Water-Resistant: Just for Redheads Mascara Naturelle – Ginger Auburn

3.8
Just for Redheads Mascara Naturelle - Ginger Auburn Image: Just For Redheads

The deep, warm Ginger Auburn shade of Just for Redheads Mascara Naturelle complements all shades of red hair. The smudge-proof formula lengthens and volumizes the lashes for a natural-looking fuller look. This lash-enhancing, long-lasting mascara is enriched with moisturizing ingredients such as hyaluronic acid and peptides such as collagen, as well as panthenol that nourishes the lashes and beeswax that prolongs their stay power. This one’s the perfect mascara that suits an array of skin tones and not just fair skin tones. It is also not tested on animals, making it an ideal cruelty-free option. Prevent any clashes with your hair and nail all your eye makeup looks with this mascara shade right here!

Color: Ginger Cocoa

Pros

  • Flake-free
  • Lash-nourishing
  • Fade-proof
  • Easy to remove
  • Paraben-free
  • Vegan
  • Cruelty-free

Cons

  • Dry formula
  • Applicator brush is not effective.

Our Tester's Experience

"This true brown mascara is great for my lighter lashes. It has great pigmentation and does not need multiple applications. I find it long-lasting and it does not smudge or budge when I apply it with a lash primer. It enhances the natural beauty of my eyes!"


*The prices provided in this article are based on the latest available information. However, they may vary due to changes in pricing by the seller and/or promotional offers.

Still not sure which mascara would best-suit your lash color or complexion? Or wondering why you need a special mascara? Read on.

Why Do Redheads Need a Special Mascara?

Redheads have paler eyelashes that may end up looking too prominent with black mascaras. Their complexion and lash colors may not blend well with dark browns and blackish browns either. Therefore, redheads need special mascaras, which will not only accentuate their natural lash color but also compliment their enhanced features and more importantly, their red-blessed tresses.

How To Choose Mascara For Redheads

Here are some tips that may make your shopping experience easy:

Pigment – Since your eyelashes are on the paler side, choosing a dark or highly-pigmented color is a big no-no. Pick a pigment that enhances your natural color rather than choosing a dark color.

Volume & Length – Choose a volume-boosting and lash-lengthening mascara that’ll make your eyes look stunning even if the pigment is not extra intense. Also, the formula should be smudge-free, smear-free, and non-flaky.

Brush – The mascara wand is important. Whether you want to tint only or curl the lashes, there are different brushes available for different looks. These include natural bristle brushes and synthetic bristle brushes made of nylon. A good brush also helps in separating the lashes so that the product is distributed evenly. Hence, pick the one that suits your needs.

Waterproof – Be it any mascara, always choose a waterproof and sweatproof product so it lasts longer and stays put through accidental rubbing or tears.

Infographic: How To Choose The Ideal Mascara For Ginger-Haired Women

Having red hair is a blessing, as you stand out in the crowd, but the beauty industry does not precisely cater to your needs. If you are finding it difficult to find a suitable mascara, no worries, we have you covered. Check out the infographic below to determine how to choose the ideal mascara for your lashes.

How To Choose The Ideal Mascara For Ginger-Haired Women (infographic)

Illustration: StyleCraze Design Team

Save the high-quality PDF version on your device now.

Download Infographic in PDF version Download Infographic
Download Infographic in PDF version

The Bottom Line

For redheads, it is important to choose mascaras that can go with their natural hair color. Some of the mascaras mentioned above offer exceptional results by adding volume to the lashes and gliding smoothly to deliver a stunning look! The L’Oreal Paris Makeup Voluminous Original Mascara – Deep Burgundy is a great pick for those who want volume. For those prone to allergic reactions, the Covergirl Lash Blast Volume Mascara – Brown works perfectly, while the Christian Dior Diorshow Iconic Overcurl Mascara amplifies the lashes to give you length. Redhead or not, it is highly recommended to choose expertly-crafted mascaras that are easier to remove and do not take long to dry. However, you should definitely avoid mascaras that tend to clump or form a goop in the corner of your eyes. Remember to perform a patch test before applying the mascara to avoid irritating the area around your eyes.

Why Trust Stylecraze

Srijita De, the author, is a beauty and makeup enthusiast, who loves experimenting with new looks and trends. Especially when it comes to eye makeup, she knows how to let your eyes do all the talking with different variations each time. So when it comes to choosing the best mascara for redheads, she has gone through several reviews and customer testimonials online, before curating this list of the 8 best mascaras for all you redhead beauties. Metallic, matte, pastel or shimmery, Chaitra has chosen the best in shade and formulations to make sure you rock that Sunday brunch or Friday night party.

Frequently Asked Questions

What Color Mascara Should Redheads Wear?

Redheads should opt for warm tones like browns, almonds, coppers, or cocoa colors to give their eyelashes a flawless definition.

What Is The Best Makeup For Redheads?

Bright coppers, soft chocolate browns, pinks, and peaches are some of the best makeup colors for redheads.

What Colours Should Redheads Avoid?

You should avoid deep-pigmented blacks or dark browns that will eventually turn black on the lashes.

Do Redheads Look Better In Gold Or Silver?

Gold is a better option than silver. Be it classic, yellow, or rose gold, these colors will bring out the auburn richness like no other. Silver, however, will work with light to medium-light red hair.

Should redheads wear black or brown mascara?

Redheads may have paler eyelashes and look too dominant with black mascaras. The skin tone and lash colors of redheads may not go well with dark brown or blackish brown mascaras.

Does brown mascara look more natural on a redhead?

Yes. Although brown mascaras are underrated, they not only enhance the natural lash color but also complement red hair. They add a surreal touch to your entire look.

Can redheads wear blue mascara?

Yes. Blue is a complementary color to red. The bold blue mascara brings out the vibrance of your red hair and makes your eyes pop irrespective of your skin color.

Recommended Articles

Best Ultimate Makeup Products For Redheads
Best Mascaras For Contact Lens Wearers’ Eye Comfort
Best Mascaras For Oily Skin – A Review Guide
Best Cruelty-Free Drugstore Mascaras


Was this article helpful?
thumbsupthumbsdown
The following two tabs change content below.

Latest Articles