11 Best Non-Toxic Mascaras Of 2021 To Glam Up Sensitive Eyes!

Written by Chaitra Krishnan
All products recommended on StyleCraze are independently selected by our editorial team. If you make a purchase through any of these links, we may receive a commission. Learn more about our product selection process here.

Are you giving up on mascara because of sensitive eyes? Well, you don’t have to if you use a non-toxic mascara instead. Mascara is a cosmetic staple to glam up the eyes instantly. Even on days when eye makeup feels too much, one sweep of mascara is all you need to go from drowsy to stunning eyes effortlessly. But when it comes to sensitive eyes, not all mascaras will be holy grails. And a bad one can worsen the sensitivity even more! So, instead of giving up on mascara, swap yours with the best non-toxic mascara on our list. Packed with lash-loving ingredients, most of these options are vegan, cruelty-free, and suitable for contact lens wearers too. Now, do you still want to stick to your old mascara?

All eyes (especially sensitive ones) on these all-natural and ultra-conditioning mascaras for an instant glam yet pampering experience. Check out our list of the 11 best non-toxic mascaras of 2021 for you.

TOP 10 PRODUCTS
CHECK PRICE
Stellar Gaze Length & Strength Mineral Mascara - Supernova
Check Price
Endlessly Beautiful Natural Organic Mascara - Black
Check Price
100% Pure Fruit Pigmented Ultra Lengthening Mascara – Black Tea
Check Price
ILIA Limitless Lash Mascara – After Midnight
Check Price
MOSTORY Black Lash Mascara
Check Price
Simply Naked Beauty Lash Science 4D Fiber Mascara Curler Kit – Midnight Black
Check Price
EVXO Strength ‘n Length Mineral Mascara - Black
Check Price
Chic Republic All Natural Organic Mascara - Black
Check Price
Gabriel Mascara – Black Brown
Check Price
Harvest Natural Beauty Lengthening Organic Mascara
Check Price

Top 11 Best Non-Toxic Mascaras To Try Out In 2021!

1. Stellar Gaze Length & Strength Mineral Mascara – Supernova

Voluminous lashes, anyone! Flaunt longer and thicker lashes with this mineral mascara and its 100% vegan plush brush. A nourishing formula, it contains vitamin B, jojoba oil, and coconut oil to hydrate every lash intensely. With one swipe giving you the desired length for the day, you can add layers to the same for an enviable voluminous look for the night. Non-toxic and free from harsh chemicals such as silicone, petrolatum, carmine, and phthalates, the formula also contains vitamin E, chamomile extract, brown kelp extract, algae extract, rice protein, and cucumber extract for moisturizing benefits.

Pros:

  • Intense color
  • Clump-free
  • Smear-proof
  • Lengthening formula
  • Optimum coverage
  • Cruelty-free

Cons:

  • May smudge in humid weather

Buy Now From Amazon

2. Endlessly Beautiful Natural Organic Mascara – Black

Do you have sensitive eyes; but can’t do without mascara? Try this organic bliss for soft and healthy lashes. Besides transforming your eyes from lifeless to lush, this vegan and volumizing mascara nourishes every lash with the infused organic ingredients. The formula contains coffee powder, rice powder, chamomile extract, sunflower seed oil, and vitamin E to nourish and stimulate lash growth. Besides this, it also protects and moisturizes with extracts of grapefruit, oregano, thyme, cinnamon, rosemary, and goldenseal root. Non-goopy, water-resistant, and sweat-proof, this chemical-free mascara is a fantastic choice for contact wearers too.

Pros:

  • Clump-free
  • Smudge-free
  • Flake-proof
  • Long-lasting
  • Easy to remove
  • Cruelty-free

Cons:

  • May not be the best if you need bold volumized lashes

Buy Now From Amazon

3. 100% Pure Fruit Pigmented Ultra Lengthening Mascara – Black Tea

Who needs fake lashes when you can flutter confidently with this ultra-lengthening mascara! Sweep on for colossal lashes, as the slim wand will separate, coat, condition, and lengthen each lash beautifully. And its formula is every bit nourishing and free from coal tar, toxic petrochemicals, and Teflon. It moisturizes with oat protein, wheat protein, provitamin B5, seaweed powder, rice germ powder, coffee beans powder, and lavender honey. The formula also contains extracts of green tea, black tea, oregano, thyme, rosemary, lavender, goldenseal, Theobroma cacao powder, and seed butter to fight free radical damage. Just what you need for dramatic long lashes, this non-clumpy mascara also stimulates lash growth.

Pros:

  • Cruelty-free
  • Non-flaking
  • Non-smudging
  • Long-lasting
  • Water-resistant
  • Optimal coverage
  • Suitable for all skin types

Cons:

  • Slightly drying after few hours

Buy Now From Amazon

4. ILIA Limitless Lash Mascara – After Midnight

Obsessed with eye makeup, are you? This premium non-oil-based mascara will make your lashes the star of your makeup! With a dual-sided wand to explore endless lash looks, the shorter bristles are great for curling and adding volume for a dramatic look, and the longer bristles will lengthen, lift, and separate the lashes effortlessly. An award-winning mascara with 99% natural ingredients, the blend contains beeswax, carnauba wax, keratin, and shea butter for conditioning, enhancing, and keeping your lashes lifted all day! The formula is also gentle and safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. And the best part, the mascara comes off easily with water and without scrubbing or tugging.

Pros:

  • Flake-free
  • Buildable
  • Lightweight
  • Cruelty-free
  • Ophthalmologist-tested
  • Fuller healthy lash look

Cons:

  • Slightly expensive

Buy Now From Amazon

5. MOSTORY Black Lash Mascara

Say no to raccoon eyes this season, girls! This organic waterproof mascara will make sure your lashes remain tip-top for up to 24 hours. Intense black and coating every lash with a rich texture, you can explore dramatic, intense curl, volumized and colossal lash looks with this dual-sided wand. Goodbye, falsies! Infused with non-toxic, natural, and lash-friendly ingredients, the formula is hypoallergenic and suitable for sensitive eyes. All you have to do is sweep on and get ready to flaunt healthy and lush lashes with this long-lasting and sweat-proof formula.

Pros:

  • Clump-free
  • Flake-free
  • Smudge-proof
  • Allergy-tested
  • Alcohol-free
  • Easy to remove with waterproof makeup remover

Cons:

  • Slightly messy
  • Thick consistency

Buy Now From Amazon

6. Simply Naked Beauty Lash Science 4D Fiber Mascara Curler Kit – Midnight Black

With this lash-magnifier in your beauty arsenal, you’d need no falsies and fake lashes ever! Adding 400x more volume with its magnifying gel and thickening microfibers, get ready to be stunned with the lash envy it stirs. Not for your daily look (unless you don’t mind the attention), this natural mascara will enhance your lashes with an incredible volume that’ll last all day and until the party ends. A must-try for eye makeup enthusiasts, the formula is made of hypoallergenic and non-toxic ingredients. And to make the experience worthwhile, the mascara comes off quick and easy.

Pros:

  • Clump-free
  • Waterproof
  • Smudge-proof
  • Cruelty-free
  • Paraben-free

Cons:

  • It may flake.

Buy Now From Amazon

7. EVXO Strength ‘n Length Mineral Mascara – Black

This mineral mascara by EVXO will pamper your lashes with the infused olive oil. So, if you have sensitive or super sensitive eyes, this intense black mascara would be a redeemer for daily or party wear. Free from toxic preservatives, fragrances, artificial colors, and harmful ingredients, the blend goes on smoothly to make the lashes look longer, fuller, and healthier than before. You can either use it for a natural finish with one coat or build-up for a dramatic look; this mascara guarantees stellar eyes only. And as the cherry on top— the organic formula won’t clump or flake!

Pros:

  • Vegan
  • Cruelty-free
  • Long-lasting
  • Gluten-free
  • Hypoallergenic
  • No touch-ups required

Cons:

  • May smudge in humid weather

Buy Now From Amazon

8. Chic Republic All Natural Organic Mascara – Black

Craving for some lash love, are you? Indulge in this healthy mascara ASAP. Like a natural conditioner for your lash line, it has 85% organic and ultra-nourishing ingredients such as chamomile, vitamin E, lemon peel, lavender flower, coconut oil, and rosemary leaf extract. Free from preservatives, parabens, phthalates, paraffin, synthetic fragrances, artificial dyes, and more, the non-toxic formula is hypoallergenic and suitable for sensitive eyes. Easy to apply and remove, this long-lasting mascara will make your lashes look longer, fuller, and enhanced effortlessly.

Pros:

  • Cruelty-free
  • Gluten-free
  • Long-lasting
  • Safe for contact lens wearers

Cons:

  • Slightly clumpy
  • It may smudge as it’s not waterproof.

Buy Now From Amazon

9. Gabriel Mascara – Black Brown

Not a fan of intense black mascaras? This black-brown option will complement your daily natural makeup look flawlessly. Sweep on once for a natural finish or build-up for fuller and longer lashes; this vegan mascara contains provitamin b5 for a thickening effect. Besides this, the unique brush will separate, define, and coat every lash optimally for a voluminous look. The formula contains vitamins and plant waxes to pamper your eyes inside out. It also contains aloe leaf juice, sea fennel extract, and eyebright extract for nourishing and soothing benefits. Want more? The mascara is suitable for sensitive skin, sensitive eyes, and contact lens wearers.

Pros:

  • Cruelty-free
  • Gluten-free
  • Non-GMO
  • Paraben-free
  • Smudge-proof
  • Ultra-conditioning

Cons:

  • It may clump.

Buy Now From Amazon

10. Harvest Natural Beauty Lengthening Organic Mascara

With a non-toxic formula and maximum volume effect, trust this lash-extending mascara to make your eyes the talk of the town! Sensitive eyes or not, this ultra-conditioning blend will lengthen and volumize your lashes with the infused organic ingredients. Are you worried about smudging or irritation? Don’t be! The formula is water-resistant and free from harsh chemicals such as preservatives, parabens, phthalates, SLS, artificial fragrances, and colors. Vegan and 100% natural, this blend contains sunflower seed oil, coffee powder, corn starch, lemon peel, rice powder, and extracts of oregano, thyme, rosemary, chamomile, cinnamon, and more for nourishing benefits.

Pros:

  • Vegan
  • Gluten-free
  • Cruelty-free
  • Non-GMO
  • Lightweight
  • Easy to remove

Cons:

  • Slightly drying

Buy Now From Amazon

11. CPCP Peacock Mascara – Black

One word— scandalous! Just the mascara you need to glam up your eyes without worrying about redness or irritation the next day, this non-toxic formula contains natural and gentle ingredients. Also, its creamy texture will coat and condition every lash in just one sweep! Intensely pigmented and non-clumping, watch your lashes look longer, thicker, and stunning instantly with this long-lasting blend. A must-try for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers, this formula will not smudge or dry out. And that’s not all; its wide-angle bristles provide optimal coverage from roots to ends. Give it a try!

Pros:

  • Waterproof
  • Easy to apply
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Dramatic long lashes
  • Easy to remove with warm water
  • Suitable for all skin types and tones

Cons:

  • May take longer to dry

Buy Now From Amazon

Safe for your eyes and stunning for your lashes, there’s no reason to give these non-toxic gems a miss! With 11 non-toxic mascaras to choose from, we bet you might feel spoilt for choices. And, if you are still wondering how to pick the best non-toxic mascara or its benefits, you must check out our buying guide below.

How To Choose The Best Non-Toxic Mascara?

Look out for the following features in the mascara for maximum benefits:

  • Bristles:

Not all brushes are the same. Some may have long, short, both, or twisted bristles to deliver different effects. Long bristles will define, separate, and add length to your lashes instantly. Short ones are ideal if you are looking for maximum volume. The twisted bristles will elongate and curl your lashes at the same time. So, inspect and choose according to the look you desire.

  • Ingredients to have:

The skin around the lash line is sensitive, so before applying mascara, even the non-toxic ones, check the ingredients in the formula. Vitamin E formulas are ideal for fighting free radical damage, whereas plant-based and oil-based mascaras will soothe and nourish the lash line intensely.

  • Ingredients to avoid:

Although labeled non-toxic, check to what extent the mascara is gentle and safe for your eyes. Is it dermatologist-tested? Is it ophthalmologist-tested? If not, it should be free from toxic chemicals such as parabens, coal tar, Teflon, phthalates, petrolatum, artificial fragrances, artificial colors, preservatives, SLS, and more.

  • Waterproof:

Unless you enjoy raccoon eyes, you should choose a waterproof non-toxic mascara, especially if the climate is humid around you. The waterproof formula will not smudge or smear, be it sweat, tears, or rain, and most of them are long-lasting too.

  • Easy to remove:

One of the main reasons why eyes turn red or irritated is due to the mascara removal process. The harsh scrubbing and tugging can be harmful not only for sensitive eyes but normal eyes too. So, pick a formula that cleans off quickly and effortlessly with water or makeup remover.

What Are The Benefits Of Using A Non-Toxic Mascara?

Non-toxic mascaras are a boon for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers, but anyone can benefit from them. Here are some of its pros:

  • Stimulates lash growth
  • Prevents redness or irritation
  • Reduces chances of allergic reactions
  • Nourishes eyes and lash line intensely
  • Ensures healthy, fuller, and longer lashes
  • Free from chemicals that can irritate your lash line
  • Strengthens and protects lashes from radical damage

There you go; you don’t have to skip the mascara anymore but sweep on a non-toxic one instead. Gentle and nourishing, these formulas will give your eyelashes a fuller and healthier look even when you don’t have mascara on. And it’s no mystery that a good mascara can break or make the look. However, a non-toxic mascara can keep them healthy and nourished for a long, long time. So, what are you waiting for? Give these all-natural and ultra-conditioning mascaras of 2021 a try and get ready to flutter with confidence this season. Hurry, pick the best non-toxic mascara from our list today!

Expert’s Answers for Readers Questions

Which ingredient in mascara causes an allergic reaction?

Several ingredients can irritate the eyes, such as parabens, phthalates, iron oxides, coal tar, synthetic fragrances, yellow carnauba wax, nickel, and more can cause a severe allergic reaction. So, if your eyes are sensitive, then it is best to use mascara free from the above-stated ingredients.

Which mascara can make your eyelashes grow?

There are umpteen non-toxic mascaras with all-natural ingredients that can help stimulate lash growth. If you have weak or scanty lashes, Endlessly Beautiful Natural Organic Mascara and 100% Pure Fruit Pigmented Ultra Lengthening Mascara would be great options to promote lash growth.

Is using mascara daily bad for your eyes or lashes?

Yes, but it depends. Regardless of the type of mascara (chemical-based or non-toxic), it’s essential to remove it with a good makeup remover and wash your eyes with lukewarm water to ensure no residue is left behind. Also, avoid applying it daily as it may cause inflammation, irritation, or loss of lashes in worse cases.

Is mascara bad for your eyes?

No! It is not bad for the eyes but using the right mascara is essential to avoid redness and irritation. Non-toxic mascaras are great substitutes as they are free from harsh chemicals, have all-natural ingredients, promote lash growth, and are safe for the eyes too.

The following two tabs change content below.
Chaitra is an extremely passionate writer and storyteller. She has a triple main Bachelor’s degree in Journalism, Communicative English, and Economics and a Master’s degree in Journalism and Mass Communication. She has more than three years of experience in content writing and editing and specializes in beauty, fashion, and lifestyle genres. Her background in journalism helps her guide her team in churning out fine content for the readers. When she’s not editing or juggling tasks at work, she likes to daydream and stalk doggos on Instagram.
scorecardresearch