8 Best Oil-Free Mascaras For Eyelash Extensions To Try In 2024

Get your lashes the goodness of water-based mascaras because you want to look perfect.

Reviewed by Terri L Watts, Skin Care Specialist Terri L Watts Terri L WattsSkin Care Specialist facebook_iconinsta_icon
Written by , MA (English & Literature), Certified Style & Image Consultant Srijita De MA (English & Literature), Certified Style & Image Consultant linkedin_icon Experience: 2 years
Edited by , MA (Journalism & Mass Communication) Rajeshwari Das MA (Journalism & Mass Communication) linkedin_icon Experience: 3 years
Fact-checked by , MA (Journalism & Mass Communication), Certified Style & Image Consultant Srijani Roy Chowdhury MA (Journalism & Mass Communication), Certified Style & Image Consultant linkedin_icon Experience: 3 years
Last Updated on

If wide and Bambi eyes are your thing, then you probably often invite the trouble of grabbing eyelash extensions every month. You might want to add more mystery and drama to the luscious and super thick lashes of yours. In this case, you need an oil-free mascara that can help you achieve the alluring and confident look by holding the extensions for longer and preventing them from falling out before time.

These lightweight mascaras are water-based, and they come with a large variety of strengthening and nourishing ingredients. This implies that you can apply makeup and not harm your natural lashes. These oil-free mascaras just do the double work of taking good care of the eye lashes’ health and conditioning them as required. What is more, they add more intensity as well as impact to the falsies. Oh, and you are yet to hear the best part. They are very easy to remove without applying any kind of harsh makeup removers. Therefore, knowing their significance, we have prepared a list of the eight most amazing oil-free mascaras in this article that you must consider right away. What are you waiting for then? Go ahead and give your lashes that necessary boost, let them pop and help you steal the show.

Top Picks
CHECK PRICE
Best Long-Lasting:Essence Bye Bye Panda Eyes Volumizing & Defining Mascara
Price on Amazon
Best Clump-Free:KC Republic Eyelash Extension Mascara
Price on Amazon
Best Water-Based Formula:Infinit Dimension Premium Eyelash Extension Mascara
Price on Amazon
Best Vegan And Cruelty-Free:GladGirl Lashe Enmasse Mascara
Price on Amazon
Best Smudge-Free Finish:BeautyGarde LashGarde Oil-Free Mascara
Price on Amazon
Best For Sensitive Eyes:Alluring Length & Volume Mascara
Price on Amazon
Best Keratin And Botanical Extracts:BL Noir Mascara
Price on Amazon

Best Natural-Looking Lashes:Max2 Special Mascara Gold
Price on Amazon

What Is Oil-Free Mascara?

As the name suggests, oil-free mascaras are made without oil and are generally water-based. They’re the ideal choice for those with eyelash extensions, as oil-based eye makeup can dissolve the glue and bonding that hold your falsies in place and make them clump together or fall out entirely. A good oil-free mascara adds length and volume to your extensions without damaging them, and the gentle formula ensures the mascara comes off easily without too much tugging and pulling. If you love flaunting big, beautiful eyes and organize your calendar around your monthly extension appointment, make sure to invest in a good oil-free mascara and eyeliner to elevate your look further.

Try The 8 Best Oil-Free Mascaras For Eyelash Extensions Today!

1) Best Long-Lasting:Essence Bye Bye Panda Eyes Volumizing & Defining Mascara

star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
3.8
Essence Bye Bye Panda Eyes Volumizing & Defining Mascara Image: Essence Cosmetics

Bid goodbye to smudged panda eyes and say hello to thick, luscious lashes with this gorgeous oil-free mascara which delivers volume and definition without the mess. Water-resistant and long-lasting, this formula goes on smoothly without any flaking, clumping, or fading so that you look your absolute best as you go about your day with more beautiful, thicker lashes. And there’s more! This mascara is easy to remove without harsh makeup removers. All you need is some warm water and some gentle pressure to slide the product off, making this the ideal mascara for lash extensions. This video review will help you understand more about the product with the help of the reviewer’s experience. Moreover, numerous positive Amazon reviews indicate that people experience great results with this product.

Color: #000000.

Pros
  • Long-lasting smudge-proof formula
  • Fragrance-free and oil-free
  • Contains no parabens, acetone, or alcohol
  • Vegan and cruelty-free

Cons
  • Some might find the texture of this mascara a bit thick.
worth-buy-icon

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

It has gained over 4,959 positive reviews on Amazon, making it an all-time best-seller.

2) Best Clump-Free:KC Republic Eyelash Extension Mascara

star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
3.5

Add drama and intensity to your look with this oil-free mascara for eyelash extensions, and get ready to sport eyes that are well-defined and bursting with oomph. The anti-static volumizing brush head ensures the mascara goes on smoothly without clumps for fuller lashes that look great day and night. Suitable for sensitive eyes, this mascara is easy to apply and requires only water and diluted soap to remove effortlessly. Terri L Watts, skin care specialist, says, “Waterproofing an oil-free mascara is no easy feat, believe me, I know as I have a team of 9 cosmetic scientists/formulators. That plus value, size, and allergy-testing, this is one of my top picks for the best oil-free mascara.” A bonus – this product is free of artificial fragrances, making it ideal for those sensitive to scents and prone to allergies.

Package Dimensions ‏ : ‎ 4.76 x 1.06 x 1.02 inches; 1.12 Ounces

Pros
  • Waterproof mascara
  • Long-lasting formula
  • Clump-free and smudge-resistant
  • Ophthalmologist-tested and fragrance-free
  • Allergy-tested

Cons
  • Some might find the texture of this mascara a bit sticky.

3) Best Water-Based Formula:Infinit Dimension Premium Eyelash Extension Mascara

Designed to accentuate both your natural lashes and classic lash extensions, this water-based mascara for eyelash extensions helps give your eyes the pop they deserve. Infused with beeswax, chamomile, and witch hazel, this clump-resistant mascara adds intense volume and unbelievable length with a beautifully soft finish to your lashes. Easy to apply, this long-lasting, oil-free mascara is a hot favorite with professional lash artists and is widely recommended by lash studios everywhere. Elevate your makeup artistry with this mascara and get statement-making lashes.

Skin Type: Sensitive

Pros
  • Lengthening mascara
  • Water-based, oil-free mascara
  • Glossy, full finish
  • Suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers
  • Tested and approved by lash artists

Cons
  • Some might find this mascara a bit difficult to remove.

protip_icon Pro Tip
Use a clean lash comb through your lashes to remove any clumps. You can also use a clean toothbrush to comb through your lashes for better application of mascara.

4) Best Vegan And Cruelty-Free:GladGirl Lashe Enmasse Mascara

star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
4.3
Glad Girl Lash EnMasse Mascara Image: Gladgirl

Get ready to bat those thick, bountiful eyelashes with this vegan oil-free mascara which promises to add a ton of intensity and drama to your eyelash extensions. This mascara features a dual brush wand which consists of a thick brush to create a lush and full look and a brush comb to separate and define each lash. This gorgeous mascara can either be used to add intensity to any eyelash extensions, be it strip, single, or cluster, or to beautify your bare eyelashes on the go. Moreover, no animal testing was done in the making of this product. So what are you waiting for? Add this must-have beauty product to your makeup bag, and get ready to see the difference.

Color: Black | Product Dimensions: 5 x 1 x 1 inches | Weight: 1.09 Ounces

Pros
  • Smooth, smudge-free finish
  • Long-lasting formula
  • Safe for sensitive eyes
  • Vegan and cruelty-free
  • Hypoallergenic, oil-free mascara

Cons
  • Some might find the scent of this mascara a bit strong.

5) Best Smudge-Free Finish:BeautyGarde LashGarde Oil-Free Mascara

Clean beauty never looked this good! Here’s an oil-free mascara that adds intense volume and length to your eyelashes for a look that is mesmerizing and stunning. This non-toxic formula lasts all day without flaking and provides a smudge-free finish that is sure to turn heads. Hypoallergenic and safe for sensitive eyes, this mascara has a moisturizing formula that helps strengthen and condition lashes. Perfect to pack into your handbag for quick touch-ups on the go, this mascara will see you through your early morning meeting to evening cocktails with your girlfriends. So, experience enhanced beauty with its flawless application anywhere, anytime!

Product Dimensions: 0.83 x 0.83 x 4.92 inches | Weight: 1.59 Ounces

Pros
  • Creamy, moisturizing mascara
  • Hypoallergenic, oil-free formula
  • Safe for lash extensions and faux lashes
  • Non-toxic and cruelty-free

Cons
  • Some might find the texture of this mascara a bit clumpy.

protip_icon Pro Tip
Always apply mascara after eye shadow and liner. This helps to keep the eye clean and free from any mascara spot.

6) Best For Sensitive Eyes:Alluring Length & Volume Mascara

If you’re looking to accentuate the beauty of your eyes and add that extra oomph factor to your look, you’re in the right place. Recommended and approved by lash artists, this oil-free mascara adds extra drama and definition to your lashes for a finish that is unbelievably thick and luscious. This mascara makes the perfect gift for the makeup lover in your life as it is not only easy to apply and remove, it comes in a cute, compact package that makes it the perfect addition to a fashionista’s makeup bag.

Package Dimensions ‏ : ‎ 4.5 x 0.8 x 0.8 inches; 0.81 Ounces

Pros
  • Specially formulated for eyelash extensions
  • Easy to apply and remove
  • Designed for daily use
  • Suitable for sensitive eyes

Cons
  • Some might find the application brush of this mascara a bit thick.

protip_icon Quick Tip
Apply a mascara primer before applying mascara. This provides a barrier between mascara and your lashes so the application is effortless and the eyes look beautiful.

7) Best Keratin And Botanical Extracts:BL Noir Mascara

star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
star-rating
4
BL Noir Mascara Image: Bl Bl

Add instant Hollywood glamour to your look and get ready to turn heads with this eyelash extension safe mascara which helps build dramatic volume and define each lash for a bolder and fuller finish. This water-based formula is enriched with keratin and botanical extracts to strengthen and restore natural lashes while preventing breakage and damage. Easy to apply and a breeze to remove, this buildable mascara goes on smoothly without leaving clumps or residue along the lash line, making it the ideal product for everyday use. So, enhance your look with this mascara and create a celebrity-inspired glam look.

Color: Black

Pros

• Safe to use on lash extensions
• Strengthens natural lashes
• Infused with keratin and botanical extracts
• Easy to remove with warm water

Cons

• Some might find that this mascara is prone to a bit of smudging.

8) Best Natural-Looking Lashes:Max2 Special Mascara Gold

Whether you’re looking for subtle, natural-looking lashes, or an over-the-top smokey eye, this versatile mascara will deliver exceptional results. Enriched with royal jelly and herbal extracts, this nourishing formula helps strengthen and condition lashes while providing unbelievable length and volume. This mascara goes on smoothly for a gorgeous finish and is easy to remove with just a bit of warm water. Terri L Watts, skin care specialist, says, “This is also one of my choices because I can use it on both my natural lashes as well as lash extensions. Moreover, it has more natural ingredients which is super important for the eye area.” So pair this amazing mascara with a peachy pink lip gloss, and get ready to step out with confidence and style.

Color: black

Pros
  • Nourishing oil-free formula
  • Water-soluble and environmentally-friendly
  • Enriched with natural ingredients
  • Easy removal
  • Suitable for both eyelash extensions and natural lashes

Cons
  • Some might find the texture of this mascara a bit sticky.

How To Choose An Oil-Free Mascara

  • Finish

Whether you’re looking to add volume to your lashes for a thick, full finish, or you desire length and definition, there is an oil-free mascara designed especially for your needs. A lengthening oil-free mascara is ideal for a daytime, professional look when you want a neutral, subdued finish. In contrast, volumizing mascara is better suited to match your cocktail dress when you’re looking for a finish that is dramatic and over-the-top.

  • Texture

Not all oil-free mascaras are created equal when it comes to their texture. Pick a mascara that goes on smoothly without clumps for a finish that lasts all day long without fading or smudging. If you’re wearing your mascara out for a long day out in the sun, pick a water-resistant one to avoid your mascara from running with sweat.

  • Ingredient list

While most oil-free mascaras are generally water-based, it is vital to quickly look at the rest of the ingredients to make sure your mascara nourishes your lashes without damaging them. If you’re looking for a mascara that doubles up as a lash conditioner, pick one which is enriched with moisturizing ingredients like coconut oil, keratin, and botanical extracts. As always, steer clear of potentially harmful ingredients like parabens, phthalates, and sulfates, which might cause your lashes to get brittle and more prone to breakage. Go for dermatologist-tested ingredients and do a patch test to check for allergies.

The Bottom Line

An oil-free mascara will be an ideal choice if you desire to add texture to your eyelash extensions while giving them a good definition. While oil-based mascaras can dissolve the glue and make lash extensions fall apart, these mascaras are water-based and can help hold the lashes longer. So, you should carefully pick your mascara and go for options that are long-lasting, smudge-resistant, oil-free, hypoallergenic, formulated with natural ingredients, and paraben-free. The Essence Bye Bye Panda Eyes Volumizing & Defining Mascara is extremely easy to remove despite being smudge-free. The GladGirl Lashe Enmasse Mascara offers intense dramatic eyes, while the BL Noir Mascara helps nourish and strengthen natural lashes along with enhancing volume. With oil-free mascaras, getting thicker eyelashes that add glamor to your look is not a distant dream anymore.

Why Trust StyleCraze?

Srijita De is a makeup and beauty aficionado who is also an experienced product reviewer. She has compiled this list of the best oil-free mascaras that give you thicker and voluminous eyelashes without the hassle of eyelash extensions. After reviewing thousands of user feedback, she has listed these top-rated products to help her readers make the best purchase.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can you use an oil-free mascara on eyelash extensions?

Absolutely! Oil-free mascaras are the perfect choice for eyelash extensions as they help add intensity and impact without damaging your lashes. The gentle, water-based formula is ideal to ensure that your lashes don’t clump together or fall out, allowing you to sport your falsies for longer.

Is Too Faced mascara oil-free?

Too Faced Better Than Sex Volumizing mascara is a water-based, oil-free product designed specially for eyelash extensions. Make sure to check the labelling before buying any mascara to ensure it is oil-free and safe for eyelash extensions.

Does mascara damage your eyelashes?

Mascara can only damage eyelashes if you don’t use proper care in applying and removing your eye makeup. Ensure you use a good eye makeup remover to clean your eyelashes before going to bed, and use a good non-irritating lash conditioner to keep your lashes strong and healthy.

Does mascara have an effect on eyelash growth?

Certain mascaras are enriched with lash-conditioning and strengthening ingredients like keratin and serums to help lengthen your lashes. Mascaras certainly don’t inhibit growth, so you can rest easy knowing that mascaras won’t restrict eyelash growth.

Can I wear mascara on my lower lashes while using eyelash extensions?

Absolutely! We say the more the better! Just make sure to use an oil-free mascara so that the formula doesn’t interfere with the glue or binding of your eyelash extensions.

How many times a week should I wear oil-free mascara?

You can wear oil-free mascara daily, but avoid heavy coats. Also, make sure to remove your eye makeup before going to bed. Try to take a five to seven-day break from your mascara every two weeks. This will provide time for your natural lashes to grow and stay healthy.

Does wearing oil mascara every day prevent lash growth?

Yes, wearing oil mascara every day can prevent lash growth as the product dries out the lashes and affects your delicate eyes. However, you can keep the eyelashes hydrated and healthy by moisturizing them with jojoba oil, vaseline, or coconut oil. Also, try to be careful and gentle during mascara application and removal to reduce lash breakage. Remember, wearing mascara daily is not bad and will not damage your lashes if you remove the product properly.

How do I know if my mascara is oil-free?

Oil-free mascaras are made without oil and are generally water-based. They come with natural hydrogen PG levels, which are suitable for people with sensitive or oily skin. The chemical-free formula is easy to remove and dries up faster than its oil- or silicone-based counterparts. Oil-free mascara also contains vitamin B5, hyaluronic acid, or aloe vera, which keeps your lashes hydrated and healthy in the long run. Therefore, check the ingredients thoroughly before purchasing an oil-free mascara or water-based makeup product.

Recommended Articles

Terri L Watts
Terri L WattsSkin Care Specialist
Terri Watts is a highly qualified skin care specialist with over 24 years of experience in the beauty industry. In 2005, driven by a commitment to empower others, Terri launched her own clean beauty skin care line. This line is more than just about achieving radiant skin; it's a testament to her deep passion for making a difference.

Read full bio of Terri L Watts