8 Best Olay Eye Creams To Help Banish Dark Circles And Puffiness

Get rid of stubborn dark circles and tired eyes with these fantastic eye creams.

Reviewed by Nyssa Green, Makeup Artist
Written by Kirtana Divakar
Edited by Krati Darak, Certified Skin Care Coach
Fact-checked by Madhumati Chowdhury  • 
All products recommended on StyleCraze are independently selected by our editorial team. If you make a purchase through any of these links, we may receive a commission. Learn more about our product selection process here.

If your eyes are tired of looking at the laptop screen all day or binge-watching Netflix all night, do it some favor and pamper it with the best Olay eye cream you can get your hands on. A stressful digital lifestyle, irregular sleep cycles, improper diet and nutrition, lack of exposure to natural sunlight, or too much exposure to the sun, can all lead to tired, exhausted eyes. All of these factors on their own or altogether can play havoc on your eye health and the delicate skin surrounding it. Dark circles, puffy eye bags, dry eyes, or dehydrated skin around your eyes, can all mean that your eyes need that extra care and effort to rest and rejuvenate. Thankfully, brands like Olay make eye creams that make for a one-point solution to address all your eye concerns.

Blemishes, wrinkles, fine lines, dark circles, or puffy eyes, the nourishing ingredients in the Olay eye cream can help your eyes regain their natural strength and refreshed look over time. To help you choose the right one for yourself, we have shortlisted the 8 best Olay eye creams for you to try out.

Top PicksCheck Price
Best Hydrating Formula:Olay Ultimate Eye CreamPrice on Amazon
Best For Morning Use:Olay Total Effects 7-In-1 Eye Transforming CreamPrice on Amazon
Best For Fine Lines:Olay Eyes Deep Hydrating GelPrice on Amazon
Best For Skin Discoloration:Olay Age Defying Classic Eye GelPrice on Amazon
Best For Moisturizing:Olay Regenerist Retinol 24 Night Eye CreamPrice on Amazon
Best In Budget:Olay Eyes Illuminating Eye CreamPrice on Amazon
Best For Sensitive Skin:Olay Effects Eye Brightening CC CreamPrice on Amazon
Best For Exfoliation:Olay Regenerist Micro-Sculpting Eye SwirlPrice on Amazon

8 Best Olay Eye Creams To Glam Up Your Eyes In 2023

1. Best Hydrating Formula:Olay Ultimate Eye Cream

Olay Eyes Ultimate Eye Cream Image: Olay

If this is your first time shopping for an eye cream, Olay’s Ultimate Eye Cream is the best Olay eye product to start your daily eye care regime with. If you need a basic eye cream that helps you reduce those dark circles under your eyes, this eye cream for tired eyes one’s worth a try. And apart from dark circles, this 3-in-1 product also treats dark circles, puffiness, and wrinkles. Loaded with vitamin B3, peptides, and pigments, this Olay eye cream leaves your skin deeply moisturized, hydrated, and smooth. There’s also color-correcting technology in the mix so that you can use this as a mild concealer, too! Apply this lightweight cream morning and night for 2 weeks, and you’ll see a marked improvement in the skin around your eyes!

| Product Dimensions: 2.44 x 2 x 5.13 inches | Weight: 0.4 Ounces


  • Fragrance-free
  • 24-hour hydration
  • Reduces puffiness
  • Effective dark circle coverage
  • Visible results within weeks


  • May take longer than expected to show visible results

protip_icon Trivia
Olay was launched in 1952 by South African chemist Graham Wulff, inspired by his wife and other women who want deep skin hydration without the thick heavy creams.

Why It’s Worth Buying: With over 9,993 Amazon acclaimed reviews, this product is sure to find a place in everyone’s shopping bag.
Price at the time of publication: $27.47

2. Best For Morning Use:Olay Total Effects 7-In-1 Eye Transforming Cream


If you’re looking for something that tackles all skincare challenges but aren’t keen on piling up tubes and bottles of creams on your counter, we’ve got great news for you! The Olay Total Effects 7-In-1 Eye Transforming Cream provides 7 skincare benefits and transforms your under-eye skin into a youthful, healthy, and smooth texture! This antioxidant-rich formula visibly improves dark spots and blemishes thanks to the antioxidants in the ingredients, making the skin look firmer while reducing wrinkles and fine lines. This hydrating eye cream also treat uneven skin tone, shrinks pores, and leaves your skin luminous, supple, and smooth. What’s more, the VitaNiacin complex and vitamins B and E help exfoliate and renew damaged skin cells. You’d think that such a loaded Olay eye cream would be thick and greasy. But, no, quite the contrary! It’s an oil-free eye cream that pampers your skin, leaving it youthful and radiant. Need more information? Watch this video to make an informed decision about the product.

| Product Dimensions: 1.89 x 1.89 x 3.07 inches | Weight: 0.49 Ounces


  • Non-greasy
  • Contains vitamins B & E
  • Ideal for morning routine
  • Easy to blend with makeup


  • Contains mica that may not suit all skin types

protip_icon Quick Tip
Apply the cream in little dots around your eyes and lightly blend it with your ring finger to prevent straining or irritating the delicate eye area.

Why It’s Worth Buying: There are more than 5,412 Amazon reviews attesting to the quality of the product and endorsing its value.
Price at the time of publication: $13.37

3. Best For Fine Lines:Olay Eyes Deep Hydrating Gel

Olay Deep Hydrating Eye Gel with Hyaluronic Acid for Tired Eyes, 0.5 fl oz Image: Olay

There’s nothing worse than having to look your best and after a restless night. The Olay Eyes Deep Hydrating Gel is a heaven-sent gift to soothe your tired under-eye skin. This Olay eye cream visibility rejuvenates the skin, giving it a plump and fresher look. Hyaluronic acid aids in moisture binding and keeps the skin hydrated, which reduces fine lines and wrinkles. The formula also contains Vitamin B3 that treats hyperpigmentation, skin redness, or blotchiness, promoting skin elasticity. If this was not all, the witch hazel in the mix relieves inflammation and treats pores, and cucumber extract offers a cooling sensation and relaxing effect on your skin. This hyaluronic acid-enriched eye cream is lightweight and non-greasy, which works great if you need a quick fix while you’re getting ready in the morning! “This is my favorite Olay eye cream to use under makeup,” says Nyssa Green, an Emmy award winning makeup artist.

| Product Dimensions: 2 x 2.44 x 5.13 inches | Weight: 0.5 Ounces


  • Contains hyaluronic acid, pro-vitamin B5, and peptides
  • Clinically-tested
  • Non-sticky
  • Ideal for fine line coverage


  • Formula may have an overpowering scent
Why It’s Worth Buying: This product has made it to our top favorite list with more than 3,394 rave reviews on Amazon.
Price at the time of publication: $18.95

4. Best For Skin Discoloration:Olay Age Defying Classic Eye Gel


You won’t need to scale an entire rainbow to get to this little pot of gold. Of all the Olay eye creams, this leaves skin looking radiant, young, fresh, and glowing! Since the skin around your eyes is the first to showcase signs of aging, the Olay Age Defying Classic Eye Gel meets this challenge head-on. With a soothing combination of cucumber extract, witch hazel, and pro-vitamin B5, this Olay eye treatment will remarkably reduce fine lines, wrinkles and even out your skin tone considerably. Another surprise element of this Olay anti-aging eye cream is rosemary leaf oil. This firming eye cream is a great natural anti-bacterial solution to acne and eczema-prone skin. It also controls excess oil production while deeply hydrating your skin. Ease this Olay eye product into your daily skincare regime, and you certainly won’t regret it!

| Product Dimensions: 1.93 x 1.93 x 3.74 inches | Weight: 0.3 Ounces


  • A little goes a long way
  • Soothing feel
  • Can be used as a primer
  • Fragrance-free
  • Fast-absorbing formula


  • May cause a little dryness

protip_icon Pro Tip
Apply this eye cream after washing your face with the Olay Age Defying Classic Cleanser for the best results.

Why It’s Worth Buying: With over 2,613 reviews, this product has become a fan favorite among users.
Price at the time of publication: $12.99

5. Best For Moisturizing:Olay Regenerist Retinol 24 Night Eye Cream


After a long day of hustling and being exposed to the skin-damaging triggers, it is crucial to pamper your skin. The Olay Regenerist Retinol 24 Night Eye Cream deeply penetrates your skin and provides 24-hour hydration. Leave this overnight, and you’ll find your skin tighter, firmer, visibly brighter, and less puffy. It’ll even tackle those stubborn dark circles and wrinkles you thought you’d have to tolerate for the rest of your life. Olay’s restorative combination of vitamin B3 and retinol is the dream team of skin regeneration. Try this retinol eye cream for a month, and you’ll be astounded by the transformation!

Product Dimensions: 3.31 x 3.31 x 5.56 inches | Weight: 5.76 Ounces.


  • Moisturizes the skin
  • Leaves skin with a soft texture
  • Easy to spread
  • Imparts a tightening and lifting effect
  • Ideal for dark circle reduction


  • May not be suitable for sensitive or allergy-prone skin
Price at the time of publication: $33.95

6. Best In Budget:Olay Eyes Illuminating Eye Cream


Sometimes you just need a pick-me-up to get through your week, and this Olay eye product is designed to do just that! What’s great about the Olay Eyes Illuminating Eye Cream is its lightweight, non-greasy, and fast-absorbing formula. You can apply a pea-sized amount on your under-eye region, gently massage it into the skin, and feel instantly revitalized. In addition, it has a dual-swirl formula that simultaneously reduces the appearance of dark circles and deeply hydrates the skin. For people with sensitive skin, who are also worried about eye irritation, don’t worry! This Olay eye product is ophthalmologically tested and vouched for. Try this gel-based Olay eye treatment regime if you’re on the go and need to glow!

| Product Dimensions: 2.44 x 2 x 5.13 inches | Weight: 0.53 Ounces


  • Opthamologist tested
  • Reasonably priced
  • Ideal for dark circles
  • Suitable for all age groups


  • Contains added fragrances
Price at the time of publication: $55

7. Best For Sensitive Skin:Olay Effects Eye Brightening CC Cream

It doesn’t matter if you smile ear to ear or wear the brightest outfits or have the chirpiest. If you’re tired and unrested, your eyes will give you away every single time. Try the Olay Eyes Brightening Eye Cream For Dark Circles and ensure you look youthful, fresh, and ready-to-go at all times! What we love about this pot of creamy goodness is that it contains caffeine that reduces puffiness, encourages blood circulation, and regenerates your delicate under-eye region to eliminate under-eye bags! In addition, the Olay eye treatment bouquet of vitamins C, B3, cucumber extract, and light-reflecting complex keep the skin smooth, hydrated, and well-protected against environmental contaminants. You want to keep this in your beauty box if you’re someone who has many late nights, connecting flights, and a busy schedule.

Skin Type: Sensitive | | Product Dimensions: 1.89 x 1.89 x 3.9 inches | Weight: 0.63 Ounces


  • Dermatologically tested
  • Suitable for sensitive skin
  • Visible improvements in 24 hours
  • A little goes a long way


  • Moisturizing effects may not last very long
Price at the time of publication: $19.99

8. Best For Exfoliation:Olay Regenerist Micro-Sculpting Eye Swirl


Sometimes it isn’t just about rejuvenating and revitalizing with an Olay eye cream. Sometimes you need to take things to the next level. Sculpt your skin into a beautifully natural, young, firm, and smooth texture, and feel like a brand new person! This advanced Olay anti-aging cream is one for the books, with its revolutionary cocktail of ingredients that work to rebuild your skin around the eyes. While hyaluronic acid brings deep hydration to those tired, dry, and weathered skin cells, amino acids deal with skin damage. Vitamin B3 not only helps with skin cell regeneration but also exfoliates the dead skin cells, leaving a shiny new surface. This lightweight eye cream makes your skin feel supple, young, wrinkle-free, plump, and elastic.

| Product Dimensions: 2.13 x 1.5 x 3.47 inches | Weight: 0.53 Ounces


  • Fragrance-free
  • Lightweight
  • Revitalizing formula
  • Value for money
  • Highly recommended
  • Suitable for sensitive skin


  • May not be the best choice for oily skin
Price at the time of publication: $17.5

If this is your first time using an eye cream, have a look at our buying guide for some useful tips on how to maximize your Olay eye cream ritual!

How To Choose An Olay Eye Cream

  • Ingredients

When buying any Olay eye cream, always check the ingredient list on the packaging before making any decisions. Olay eye products always provide a comprehensive ingredient list. Vitamin C is an important antioxidant, which helps protect your skin cells. Retinol helps provide an anti-aging effect, while peptides help your skin create more collagen without being too invasive. Hyaluronic acid helps plump and hydrate the skin, getting rid of fine lines. Depending on your needs, you can make your pick.

  • Texture

If you have oily skin, it is best to use gel-based formulas that are lightweight and non-greasy. The Olay Age Defying Classic Eye Gel is a suitable choice. For those with dry skin, use moisturizing with a creamy formula to hydrate your skin. Try the Olay Regenerist Micro-Sculpting Eye Swirl, as this one contains hyaluronic acid that leaves skin plump and nourished. We suggest you use Olay Effects Eye Brightening CC Cream for sensitive skin as it is dermatologically tested and is suitable for sensitive skin.

  • Scented creams

If some of you are overpowered by strong scents from eye creams, it is best to buy one that is unscented or fragrance-free. Olay’s Ultimate Eye Cream and Olay Age Defying Classic Eye Gel are both without an overpowering scent and make the ideal option if you don’t want a cream that has a fragrance.

How To Apply Olay Eye Cream

Here are some helpful tips to guide you through your best Olay Eye Cream ritual:

Step 1 – Take a tiny (pea-sized) amount of your Olay eye cream and place it on your skin in spots.

Step 2 – Use your ring finger gently in your under eye area.

Step 3 – You can dab or lightly massage the cream into your delicate eye areas.

Step 4 – Start at the inner corner of your area, and work your way out around the orbital bone.

Benefits Of  Olay Eye Cream

Using an Olay under eye cream is very beneficial for women of all age groups.

  • Not only do Olay eye creams help reduce common signs of aging, they keep the skin deeply moisturized and hydrated.
  • The application of an Olay eye cream reduces fine lines, puffiness, blemishes, wrinkles and dark circles.
  • Your skin tone is evened out, protected, brighter and fresher.
  • Using an eye cream preps it for makeup usage too, leaving it delicate and smooth even after you take the makeup off!

Infographic: Olay Skin Care: Facts And Trivia

Olay skin care brand has been in the market for more than 60 years. It offers a wide range of skin care products that cater to different skin types and concerns. However, the brand is most popularly known for its anti-aging skin care products that target wrinkles and fine lines. Check out the below infographic to know more interesting facts about the brand.

Olay Skincare Facts & Trivia (infographic)

Illustration: StyleCraze Design Team

Save the high-quality PDF version on your device now.

Download Infographic in PDF version Download Infographic
Download Infographic in PDF version

The Bottom Line

Dark circles, puffy eyes, and wrinkles are inevitable when you are constantly under stress or some medical treatments or spend long hours in front of a laptop or TV. Sometimes improper diet and irregular sleep cycles might also be the reason for under-eye skin concerns. And such skin needs special attention to minimize the visibility of issues. The best Olay eye creams can effectively minimize the appearance of dark circles, reduce puffiness, and eliminate wrinkles. The Olay Ultimate Eye Cream treats puffiness, dark circles and wrinkles, the Olay Eyes Deep Hydrating Gel provides intense hydration to the delicate eye area with a lightweight and non-greasy formula, and the Olay Regenerist Retinol 24 Night Eye Cream targets signs of aging. These eye creams are loaded with Vitamin B3, peptides, and other effective ingredients, which help address the concerns. In addition, some eye creams listed above hydrate and soothe your skin, some blend well with your makeup, and some provide you with a fresh look rejuvenating the skin. So consider investing in the Olay eye creams to address your under-eye concerns.

Why Trust Stylecraze?

The author of this article, Kirtana Divakar, is a skin care enthusiast who loves trying out different beauty products. She has carefully read online reviews of the best Olay eye creams before curating this list. The author has picked only the top-rated products that are beneficial for the skin, reduce dark circles, and puffiness.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best Olay eye treatment for puffiness, dark circles, wrinkles, sagging?

The best Olay eye creams for dark circles are Olay Ultimate Eye Cream, Olay Eyes Illuminating Eye Cream, and Olay Eyes Retinol 24 Night Eye Cream. An Olay eye cream for puffiness is Olay Total Effects 7-in-1 Eye Transforming Cream.

Which Olay Eye Cream should I buy for dark circles?

Olay Ultimate Eye Cream, Olay Eyes Illuminating Eye Cream, and Olay Eyes Retinol 24 Night Eye Cream are all good choices to banish dark circles.

Does Olay Eye Cream have retinol?

The Olay Regenerist Retinol 24 Night Eye Cream contains retinol.

Is Olay Eye Cream hypoallergenic?

Most of Olay’s eye creams are considered hypoallergenic, ophthalmologist-tested and fragrance-free.

How often should I use Olay Ultimate Eye Cream?

Apply Olay Ultimate Eye Cream daily to improve the appearance of dark circles, reduce puffiness, and eliminate eye bags.

How long does it take for Olay Ultimate Eye Cream to work?

Olay Ultimate Eye Cream takes 7 to 10 days to improve the skin around your eyes and reduce wrinkles.

Recommended Articles:

Was this article helpful?
The following two tabs change content below.

Latest Articles