11 Best Healthy Sandwich Makers – A Buyer’s Guide

by Atulya Satishkumar
This post contains affiliate links to products. We may receive a commission for purchases made through these links. Our product selection process.

Everyone loves a good—crispy from the outside and gooey from the inside— sandwich that fills the stomach with sumptuousness and the heart with delight. And the best part is that you can make them at home without much stewing. Some of the best sandwich makers and toasters make it possible to grill deluxe, crusty sandwiches filled with melted cheese or delicious chicken in a flicker. Some can even be used for frying farm-fresh eggs, roasting vegetable nuggets, grilling delicious meat slices or making crispy yet mouth-watering waffles.

So, who wouldn’t want a freshly prepared breakfast stuffed with all the goodness? We would and we know that you would too. That’s why we bring to you a list of a few of the best sandwich makers that will make preparing breakfast as easy as a walk in the park.

Products
Check Price
Hamilton Beach Breakfast Sandwich Maker
Check Price
Proctor Silex Sandwich Toaster
Check Price
Cuisinart Sandwich Grill
Check Price
T-Fal EZ Clean Waffle and Sandwich Maker
Check Price
Gotham Steel Toaster
Check Price
Yoshikawa Atsu-Atsu Hot Sandwich Maker
Check Price
Black+Decker Grill And Sandwich Maker
Check Price
Diablo Stovetop Sandwich Maker
Check Price
Chefman Electric Sandwich Grill
Check Price
Proctor Silex Indoor Grill And Sandwich Maker
Check Price

Best Sandwich Makers – Top 11 Picks Of 2020

1. Hamilton Beach Breakfast Sandwich Maker

Now say no to fast-food joints, as Hamilton’s Sandwich Maker is a quick and easy way of making an egg or a ham sandwich in minutes. Two-layered plating system technology is used to build this sandwich maker that has a medium plate, a bottom plate, and the top lid to cook the entire sandwich all at once. The entire process involves you building the base with one slice and some filling on the bottom plate. This is followed by another filling and the top slice on the middle plate. Then cover it up with the lid and cook for some time. Assemble it later by sliding the middle plate.

Pros:

  • Made of plastic and metal
  • Fast service
  • User-friendly
  • Easily washable
  • Surface covered with non-stick cooking
  • Durable

Cons:

  • Only works with electricity

Buy Now From Amazon

2. Proctor Silex Sandwich Toaster

French toast, omelet, or sandwiches; take your pick with Proctor Silex’s Sandwich Toaster. The sandwich toaster has won the hearts of many by preparing food in mere minutes. It’s compact and space-saving design is best suited for small pantries. The indicator lights, as an added feature with its alert signals, is an advantage for customers. Simply throw in some stuffed bread or egg-washed slices into the toaster and close the appliance. Once it’s done you have a plate full of warm and toasty bread slices with a sumptuous filling.

Pros:

  • 3.08 pounds weight
  • 4.59 x 10.42 x 11 inches dimension
  • Compact design
  • Plates are made of non-stick material.
  • Has indicator lights to guide the customer
  • Easy-to-clean

Cons:

  • The closure isn’t too sturdy

Buy Now From Amazon

3. Cuisinart Sandwich Grill

Cuisinart Sandwich Grill does more than just breakfast. Designed using non-stick plates, the sandwich grill is more useful in making pocket-shaped sandwiches for someone with a light hunger. It’s lock-down lids fix the sandwiches in such a manner that it comes out toasting evenly from both sides. The versatile and easy-to-use and quality of the grill makes it a personal favorite. Make a light filling, press it between two slices of bread, put it inside the grill and you are all set for a few hours.

Pros:

  • Made of stainless steel and plastic
  • Grills 2 sandwiches at once
  • Non-stick baking plates
  • Comes with a lock-down lid
  • Evenly grills from both sides
  • Indicator lights in two different colors for guidance

Cons:

  • The design is too shallow to fit in large-sized sandwiches.

Buy Now From Amazon

4. T-Fal EZ Clean Waffle and Sandwich Maker

From hot sandwiches to crispy waffles, this gives you everything with just the press of a button. T-Fal EZ Clean Waffle and Sandwich Maker comes with two interchangeable plates designed for making Belgian waffles and pocket-sized sandwiches. It has two indicator lights that signal twice—once when the power is on and once when the food is ready. And the design is as customer-friendly as it can get. So now, don’t fret much over the cleaning and can make both savory and sweet dishes with this non-stick sandwich maker.

Pros:

  • Non-stick plates
  • Comes with 2 sets of interchangeable plates
  • Waffle plates also available
  • On/ready indicator lights
  • Dishwasher-safe plates
  • Easy-to-clean
  • Easy-to-use

Cons:

  • Sandwich plate large enough for pocket sandwiches only

Buy Now From Amazon

5. Gotham Steel Toaster

This sandwich toaster is different from the rest, as the press isn’t flat or ridged but has triangular wells to give the sandwiches a pocket-like shape. One of the best sandwich makers, this is best known for preparing sandwiches and toasts, but can also be used to make an omelet or grill fish and chicken. The grilling surface is an ultimate non-stick area coated with ceramic and titanium so that the food comes off easily. What’s more? The cool touch locking handle keeps your hands safe from excessive heat.

Pros:

  • Cooking time less than 5 minutes
  • Ultra non-stick cooking surface
  • Cooking plates made of ceramic and titanium
  • Indicator lights to announce the completion
  • Cool-touch locking handle
  • Compact and portable

Cons:

  • Not too easy to clean the sides where gooey substance drips off

Buy Now From Amazon

6. Yoshikawa Atsu-Atsu Hot Sandwich Maker

The best quality of this sandwich toaster is that it does not need any electricity to run. A stovetop sandwich toaster can be used in three simple steps; put the sandwich into the toaster, press and lock the lid from both sides, and put it over a stove burner for toasting. The toaster is also lightweight and easily portable, making it a great option for camping and cookouts. Enjoy a hot, freshly-grilled sandwich somewhere in the outskirts with this unbeatable Yoshikawa Atsu-Atsu Sandwich Maker.

Pros:

  • Dimension: 350 x 150 x 32 mm
  • Weighs 350 g
  • Works on both gas and electric stove
  • Easy-to-clean
  • User-friendly

Cons:

  • Smaller in size

Buy Now From Amazon

7. Black+Decker Grill And Sandwich Maker

There is nothing better than a multi-purpose sandwich maker, especially when there is very little time to spare in the kitchen. Plates designed with ridges in the shape of waffles, grills, and pocket sandwiches can be used for all of your breakfast and snack needs. It is also designed in such a way that the plates have channels for excess grease to run-off making the sandwich healthy and fit to be consumed by people of all ages. Made of stainless steel, this one is non-stick for easy scrape-off of food sediments. Black+Decker grill is your go-to sandwich maker when you are looking for a 3-in-1 breakfast appliance.

Pros:

  • 3-in-1 compact design
  • Interchangeable plates
  • Non-stick plates for easy cleanup
  • Accents made of stainless steel
  • Temperature control indicator lights
  • Dishwasher-safe

Cons:

  • Edges of the plates too sharp

Buy Now From Amazon

8. Diablo Stovetop Sandwich Maker

Tiny and portable, just like how you want it—Diablo Stovetop Sandwich Maker is for people who want their sandwiches cooked on a gas stove. This circular sandwich toaster cuts your sandwiches into circles with the brand name embossed on every slice of sandwich making it look #Instaworthy. Looking at the tiny size one can say that this sandwich maker is highly useful for people who take packed lunches.

Pros:

  • Extra-strong aluminum body
  • Scratch-resistant coating
  • Handle that is heat-proof
  • Used both on gas and electric stove
  • Dishwasher-safe

Cons:

  • Not suitable for induction cookers

Buy Now From Amazon

9. Chefman Electric Sandwich Grill

This one is for those who love hot, toasty, and juicy sandwiches without too much fuss. Chefman’s Electric Panini press is your go-to sandwich maker and grill for a firm and moist panini. With a cooking surface of 5.5” x 8.75”, the grill can make sandwiches for up to 2 people. This one also has an adjustable hinge that can fit in sandwiches and hamburgers of any size. Fulfill that sandwich craving by getting yourself a nicely toasted chicken sandwich for lunch or any big meal.

Pros:

  • Compact size
  • Non-stick grill plates
  • Designed for oil-free cooking
  • Adjustable floating hinge
  • Removable drip tray
  • Opens at 180 degrees

Cons:

  • Does not fit more than one large size sandwich

Buy Now From Amazon

10. Proctor Silex Indoor Grill And Sandwich Maker

Not just sandwiches, but this one will fulfill all your barbeque, grilling needs. Compact to store, yet 70 inches big to fit in a delectable hamburger, this one serves meals for up to 4 people. The floating lid is a plus as it helps press, cook, or grill food to any thickness. And how do you clean the sandwich maker at home? The removable plates are dishwasher-safe and their non-stick surface wipes completely, making the washing process effortless.

Pros:

  • Cooking time less than 10 minutes
  • Has a 70 sq inch surface
  • Compact storage
  • Easy-to-clean
  • Tested to meet safety standards

Cons:

  • Doesn’t have a power button
  • Power cord is extremely short

Buy Now From Amazon

11. Ovente Electric Sandwich, Grill, And Waffle Maker

Start the very first meal of the day with Ovente’s Electric Sandwich and Waffle Maker. The sandwich maker is time-saving and comes with 3 options for breakfast— grills, sandwiches, and waffles. The detachable plates are easily washable and the design is such that cooking a variety of dishes is child’s play. Be it a tempting grilled sandwich or a yummy waffle with ice-cream, this high-power sandwich maker is ready to serve you in minutes.

Pros:

  • 3-in-1 switchable plates
  • Powered by 120V and 750W
  • Cooks fast
  • LED indicator lights for signal
  • Non-stick detachable plates
  • Hassle-free cleaning

Cons:

  • Not free of Polytetrafluoroethylene and Perfluorooctanoic acid

Buy Now From Amazon

While it’s very important to know about all the features a sandwich maker boasts of while buying, one must also be aware of what features suit their preferences. Let’s explore a bit more about the important features of a sandwich maker.

Important Features To Consider

1) Size:

Everyone loves their sandwiches to have enough stuffing to fill them for an entire meal. Therefore, a sandwich maker must be big enough to fit in sandwiches and burgers of even large sizes. Some sandwich makers can take up to 4 sandwiches depending on the size of your family. So go for a sandwich that is big enough to cook hassle-free meals for everyone in one go.

2) Ease of cleaning:

Sandwich makers that have detachable plates are dishwasher-safe and easiest to clean are the ones you must look for. The material used to coat the cooking surface also plays a big factor in the cleaning process. Just take a warm, damp cloth soaked in soap water and wipe off oil or any other food sediments from the cooking surface every time you use it.

3) Storability:

An appliance like a sandwich maker might take up a lot of space in any kitchen. Storing a hugely built toaster or sandwich maker might lead to a space crunch. Therefore, look for an appliance that is compact to store in kitchens of all sizes.

4) Even pressing:

Every sandwich lover wants their sandwich to be evenly crisp from the outside and well-cooked from the inside. If the press of the sandwich maker isn’t well manufactured, then the sandwich might come out burnt from one side and half-cooked from the other. Always check the press before a purchase.

5) Versatility:

Check if the sandwich maker is multi-functional or not. It must have the ability to grill more than just sandwiches. A sandwich maker is only considered useful when you can use it for grilling slices of bread as well as other food items like meat, fish, or patties.

The above factors make us want to discuss more on how a sandwich maker works

How Does A Sandwich Maker Work And How To Use It?

Different kinds of sandwich makers work differently. Some run with electricity, while some are used on stovetops. The basic method is very easy where you have to stuff the press with bread slices and some filling. Then you toast the sandwiches according to the sandwich maker’s functioning. Plug-in the electric one to switch on the sandwich maker and use the stovetop one with the help of the gas burner.

This brings us to the discussion about the various types of sandwich makers that are available either online or in the market.

Different Type Of Sandwich Makers

There are mainly two types of sandwich makers. The first one runs with electricity while the other one is more like a pan that is used on a stovetop. Both the sandwich makers have their advantages and disadvantages. An electric sandwich maker uses high voltage and cooks the sandwich faster whereas a stovetop sandwich maker takes more time to cook a sandwich but cooks the filling from deep within. The major disadvantage is that an electric sandwich maker does not run without electricity while a stovetop sandwich toaster only needs a gas burner. Both sandwich makers must be used according to your preferences.

A Sandwich maker has come as a blessing in the world of sandwich lovers. It has made the life of a sandwich lover easier as they no longer have to run to the nearest sandwich store to enjoy the taste of crispy bread stuffed with fillings. All sandwich craving can now be met by getting one of the best sandwich makers from the market. So hurry up and get yourself some best grill sandwich makers to satisfy all those sandwich cravings.

Expert’s Answers For Readers’ Questions

Is a sandwich maker a healthy way of making sandwiches?

A sandwich maker usually has a non-stick ceramic coating that cooks or grills sandwiches with little to no oil. The sandwiches can be made as healthy as possible by stuffing it with a good choice of vegetables. Use a sandwich maker for a fat-free and healthy breakfast or tea-time snack.

What is the difference between a toaster and a sandwich press?

The basic difference between a toaster and a sandwich press is the function that they perform. A toaster is used to heat single slices of bread from both sides turning it into a crisp toast while a sandwich maker uses lever action to press together and heat two slices of bread with some filling.

Can you cook eggs in a sandwich press?

A press with a flat base can be used for grilling more than just sandwiches. You can use it to make poached eggs, grilled vegetables, grilled bacon, steak, and fishes.

Can we use oil in a sandwich maker?

With some sandwich makers, little oil is greased over the plates that help the sandwich to come off easily. There are a few high-quality sandwich makers with non-stick plates also available in the market that do not require a single drop of oil to grill sandwiches evenly.

Can we grill chicken in a sandwich maker?

One can easily grill chicken, fish, or any other kind of meat in a sandwich maker. Though it will take more time for any meat to cook as compared to a sandwich, the results are absolutely marvelous.

Can we cook pancakes on a sandwich press?

Just like meat, a sandwich maker can also be used for cooking pancakes and waffles provided appropriate plates are available.

The following two tabs change content below.

Atulya Satishkumar

‘Techie by day, writer by night’ is how she described herself before embarking on the journey of writing. Her strong belief in the magic of the written word, coupled with a very keen eye for detail, helps her guide her team to create quality content. When she is not editing beauty, fashion, and lifestyle-related content, she writes prose and poetry, plays her ukulele (and/or guitar), and pets floofs.
scorecardresearch