13 Best Selling Makeup-Artist-Approved Smudge-Proof Mascaras Of 2024

You cannot deny the fact that mascara is a game-changer. But when it smudges, bleeds under the eyes, and transfers to clothes , it leaves you wondering if you need the extra worry. So why not opt for one of the best smudge proof mascaras available. Not only will it define your eyes and give them a boost, but it will also conceal the fact that you spent all night sobbing over a rom-com for the seventh time. So, you don’t need to worry because, in this article, we have curated a must-buy list of the 13 most effective smudge-proof mascaras. Each product in this list is tried-and-tested and is selected after careful research and in-depth review and feedback analysis. They have received many positive customer reviews. These products will enhance your eye makeup and make sure you stand out from the crowd. All you need to do now is, scroll down and pick the one that suits you best! So go on!

What Is A Smudge-Proof Mascara?

Smudge-proof mascaras are designed to lessen the amount of product that transfers from your eyelashes in case of smudging or bleeding. They won’t transfer, budge, or bleed under your eyes to give the appearance of ‘raccoon eyes’. Ideal for hot or humid climates and summers in general, smudge-proof mascaras are resistant to oils and are easy to remove. The brush separates each lash and coats it with adequate pigment for an even application. To avoid smearing and messy residues and experience an intact mascara look all day long, opt for a smudge-proof formula.

13 Best Smudge-Proof Mascaras In 2024 To Give Your Eyes A Wake-Up Call

1. Best Hypoallergenic:Bestidy Twinkle Starlight Long Curl Mascara

4.1

Image: Bestidy

Now 44% Off

BUY ON AMAZON | $9.99

Is there a rule for the best non-smudge mascara to come in the prettiest bottle? Well, not really, but this one does! Bestidy’s smudge-resistant mascara comes with a soft fiber mascara brush and is gentle on your lashes. The expertly crafted black formula is richly pigmented and dramatically thickens and lengthens your eyelashes for a voluminous look. Ideal for both everyday wear and dressy occasions, the Twinkle Starlight Long Curl Mascara is easy to build if you want a bold lash look. Made with gentle ingredients that are kind to your eyes, this water-resistant mascara is safe for sensitive skin and doesn’t smudge. It stays put all day and will carry you through rain, sweat, and even tears, while remaining picture-perfect!

Quick Tip

Apply mascara from the base to the tip of your lashes in a zigzag motion to achieve fuller and thicker lashes.

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

It has received 10,625 reviews on Amazon and is a popular choice among shoppers.

2. Best Cruelty-Free:Elizabeth Mott It’s So BIG Volumizing Mascara

3.8

Image: Elizabeth Mott

BUY ON AMAZON | $13.99

Make all your long-lash dreams come true with Elizabeth Mott’s no-smudge mascara. It’s made with flexible tubing polymers, which ensure that each lash is richly coated and is resistant to water and sweat all day long. Aesthetic benefits aside, It’s So BIG uses a natural carnauba wax instead of paraffin, an emollient that lengthens up your lashes like it’s nobody’s business. Carnauba is non-irritating, lightweight, and holds the lashes in place to give them a glossy finish. This professional-grade smudge-free mascara comes with a peanut-shaped application brush for even application without clumping the lashes together. You can easily load up this anti-smudge mascara on the lashes to get exceptional results, even if you have sensitive and oily skin. Watch this video detailing a tester’s experience with this regular mascara.

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

More than 7,215 rave reviews on Amazon prove why we are so in awe of this product.

3. Best Buildable Formula:Covergirl Professional Remarkable Mascara

4.3

Image: Covergirl

BUY ON AMAZON

Become the talk of the town at the next party with the Covergirl Professional Remarkable Mascara. Its volumizing and transfer-resistant formula is enriched with deep black-brown pigment that provides an intense definition to your lashes from root to tip, lengthening their appearance to deliver statement-making lashes. This lightweight mascara offers buildable volume. It doesn’t clump, smudge, or dry out. It uses natural bristles that evenly coat each lash for a fuller and more dramatic effect.

	Bestidy Twinkle Starlight Long Curl Mascara Best Hypoallergenic	Elizabeth Mott It’s So BIG Volumizing Mascara Best Cruelty-Free	Covergirl Professional Remarkable Mascara Best Buildable Formula
	Buy Now	Buy Now	Buy Now
Color	Black	Black	BLACK BROWN
Dimensions	-	4.8 x 0.7 x 0.7 inches	1.9 x 0.75 x 5.65 inches
Weight	-	0.64 Ounces	0.32 Ounces
Rating
Reviews	10,625	7,215	-
Price	$9.99	$13.99	-

4. Best For Sensitive Eyes:Neutrogena Healthy Lengths Mascara

4.2

Image: Neutrogena

Now 42% Off

BUY ON AMAZON | $7.47

For eyes that stand out, pick Neutrogena’s Healthy Lengths Mascara, as it is made with a unique lengthening formula. A blend of antioxidant vitamin E and nourishing olive oil deeply condition your eyelashes and strengthen them, so they can withstand harsh makeup products and pollutants. This dermatologist-tested mascara also contains rice protein, which helps naturally moisturize and lengthen your lashes for a fuller look. Neutrogena’s non-clumping mascara comes with a bristle brush that gently combs your lashes with an antioxidant-rich pigment. Hide the after-effects of the terrible hangover from last night with this no-smudge mascara. No more raccoon eyes or clumping with this one, folks! Check out this video for a detailed review of this drugstore mascara.

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

With over 740 reviews, this product has become a fan favorite among users.

5. Best Waterproof Formula:Eyeko Beach Waterproof Mascara

4.3

Image: Eyeko

BUY ON AMAZON | $24

Whether you love swimming or like spending time on the beach, the Eyeko Beach waterproof Mascara will keep your makeup on point all day. It is infused with coconut oil and 12 fruit extracts to moisturize and nourish your lashes while adding length, dramatic volume, and definition to them instantly for enhanced beauty of your eyes. The waterproof volumizing mascara even protects your lashes from stressors like the damaging rays of the sun. The innovative brush design of this water-resistant mascara helps evenly coat the lashes, add lift, and give them a natural curl.

Also Recommended By: The experts at byrdie also think highly of Eyeko Beach.^{[1]The 9 Best Waterproof Mascaras of 2024 – byrdie https://www.byrdie.com/best-waterproof-mascaras-4780404}

Quick Tip

Gently comb your lashes with a lash comb to separate the lashes before using this mascara to achieve voluminous lashes.

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

This product has received 380 reviews from customers on Amazon, indicating its popularity and reliability.

6. Best Talc-Free Formula:Beauty For Real Hi-Def Mascara

4.6

Image: Beauty For Real

BUY ON AMAZON | $22

The revolutionary Beauty For Real Hi-Def Mascara is a great way to get long, well-defined, and beautifully curled-up lashes in a jiffy. This waterproof formula provides a long-lasting finish without any smears or smudges. Its micro brush uses only a little product to deliver full coverage and volumize even the smallest of lashes. You can wear this mascara even on hot and humid days and even out in the sun and still it will stay intact throughout the day. If you want to hide the after-effects of a terrible hangover from last night, look no further than this smudge-proof mascara.

Pro Tip

If you have applied excess mascara on your lashes, swipe them with a dry q-tip to remove the extra product.

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

This product is so liked by shoppers that it has gained over 4,959 great reviews on Amazon.

7. Best For Volumizing:Benefit Cosmetics BADgal Bang! Volumizing Mascara

4.5

Image: Benefit

BUY ON AMAZON | $23.4

A mascara that graces your eyes for a whopping 36 hours doesn’t sound real, right? Well, Benefit Cosmetics does long-wear like a pro, with their BADgal Bang! mascara that gives your lashes volume without weighing them down. The intense, pitch-black pigment can be layered easily for those statement-making lashes that you’ve always wanted! With aero particles derived from space technology, this celebrity-endorsed mascara glides easily over your eyelashes for root-to-tip, intense volume. And for a natural strength and thickness boost, it contains vitamin B5. Become the talk of the town at the next party with the Covergirl Professional Remarkable Mascara. Its volumizing and transfer-resistant formula is enriched with deep black-brown pigment that provides an intense definition to your lashes from root to tip, lengthening their appearance. This lightweight mascara is easily buildable. It doesn’t clump, smudge, or dry out. It uses natural bristles that evenly coat each lash for a fuller and more dramatic effect.

8. Best Flake-Free Formula:Revlon So Fierce! Mascara

4.1

Image: Revlon

BUY ON AMAZON | $8.12

If you think a full-glam eye is incomplete without falsies, you ought to think again. Revlon’s So Fierce! Mascara goes above and beyond to give you lashes for days! It’s the perfect choice if you can’t be bothered with false lashes. It is infused with lash-lifting polymers, rice bran waxes, and paraffin that volumize your lashes for that instant boost of confidence. With a tapered wand with 252 multi-layered bristles, no eyelash will go untouched. On days when you’re feeling empowered and carefree, apply a coat of So Fierce! for glossy lashes that slay as hard as you do. Wow everyone and go from a simple to a full-on glam look with this mascara!

9. Best For Contact Lens Wearers:Estee Lauder Double Wear Zero-Smudge Lengthening Mascara

4.4

Image: Estee Lauder

BUY ON AMAZON | $25.88

Estee Lauder’s anti-smudge mascara will have all your friends asking if you got eyelash extensions! With up to 15 hours of wear, the Smudge Shield formula locks in the pigment with innovative polymers. Come rain or shine, you’re good to go, as the micro-fibre bristles separate each lash and coat them for a much-needed lift. How your eyelashes look in the morning before you step out, is exactly how they’ll look when you’re back, too. No matter what your skin type, comb through your lashes with Estee Lauder’s smudge-proof mascara for instantly bright and lively eyes. A perfect mascara for a super busy person, always on the go!

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

The overwhelming 210 positive reviews on Amazon show how popular this product is with happy users.

10. Best Soft Gel Formula:CLIO Kill Lash Superproof Mascara

4.3

Image: Peripera

Now 17% Off

BUY ON AMAZON | $14.9

Killer lashes are super easy to achieve with CLIO’s top-rated smudge-proof mascara. At the base, a soft gel formula and wax ingredients combine for an instantly lifted and volumized appearance. You simply can’t go wrong with the Kill Lash Superproof Mascara as it is water- and oil-resistant, and its Strong Curve System technology holds your lashes in place for a curl like never before! The slim, curved wand is designed to fit your eyelash line precisely and glides easily for an even, smooth application. Apply a light coat for work meetings and when you’re ready to let loose at night, you can easily build on it!

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

With 539 positive reviews on Amazon, this product has become a bestseller.

11. Best Weightless Formula:Peripera Long Lash Curling Ink Black Cara

4.2

Image: Peripera

BUY ON AMAZON | $9.9

If you’re lamenting about how your mascaras can never grab onto those hard-to-reach lashes, it’s time to toss them out and bring home a new one. We’re talking about Peripera’s best no-smudge, no-flake mascara that mimics the effects of your eyelash curler. With a dense, evenly curled brush, your lashes are going to get an instant 3D lift, and yes, it hugs those tiny little lashes too! On days when you have an unannounced Zoom meeting, and you want to look natural, swipe some of this lightweight formula onto your lashes for a quick energy boost for the eyes. This smudge-proof mascara is also ideal for you if touching up your makeup frequently is not your game. As this tubular formula is also buildable, it’s now up to you whether you want to go minimalistic or dramatic!

12. Best For Lengthening Lashes:Lancome Grandiose Smudge-Proof Mascara

4.4

BUY ON AMAZON | $42.99

If you’re a sucker for elegantly packaged makeup, you won’t be able to ignore this Lancome mascara. However, its packaging isn’t the only thing worth raving out! The Grandiose Smudge-Proof Mascara has a swan-neck wand, which goes in deep to coat all your lashes from root-to-tip and corner-to-corner. This intense black mascara has a waterproof formula that adds visible length to your lashes with a glossy finish. This mascara contains rose-cell extract which ensures your lashes stay soft and supple. It is a weightless formula that is ideal for 24-hour wear. You won’t find any harsh waxes in this luxury mascara.

13. Best Long-Lasting:Clinique Lash Power Mascara Long-Wearing Formula

4.5

Image: Clinique

BUY ON AMAZON | $18.46

With Clinique’s 12 hour-long staying formula, you can go swimming on that first date without any worries as it lasts through rainy and humid conditions without any problem. Formulated for all skin types, the Lash Power Mascara has a unique brush that follows the contours of your eyes and goes to the roots to lift up each lash with precision. It naturally lengthens them too, without any smearing, streaking, or clumping. As it lasts long, you don’t need to worry about retouching your eyelashes while at work! No more ‘spider legs’ eyelashes for us, thank you!

Now that we’ve gone over some of the best smudge-proof mascaras on the market, let’s look at how you can pick the right one for yourself.

How To Choose The Best Smudge-Proof Mascara

After your favorite smudge-proof mascara is staring back at you from your dresser table, it’s time to learn how to use it for those statement eyes!

• Water-resistant

Not all smudge-proof mascaras are waterproof, but if you’re going to be spending time swimming or in the rain, choosing a water-resistant formula is a no-brainer. If you happen to have oily skin, too, waterproof formulas will prevent your mascara from getting messy during the day.

• Wear time

Smudge-proof mascaras offer varying hours of wear and the one you choose depends on the type of occasion you’re attending. A 12 or 24-hour long wearing mascara is ideal for fancy or even office occasions where you can’t afford to retouch your makeup. However, if you’re going to be able to retouch your eyelashes here and there at work, a mascara with a short-staying power will also do.

• Other benefits

Smudge-proof mascaras can offer only smudge-proof benefits or they also have added features such as lengthening, curling, and thickening the lashes. Usually, the added benefits are mentioned on the packaging, and if you happen to have short, sparse lashes, these lifting mascaras can make them appear fuller and thicker.

Now, it’s time to learn the professional techniques of using them for those statement-making eyes looks!

How To Use A Smudge-Proof Mascara

• Step 1: Ensure that your lashes are clean and dry
• Step 2: Curl your eyelashes with an eyelash curler for a natural lift
• Step 3: Using the wand, place the brush at the base of your eyelashes and slowly wiggle it to reach the tips
• Step 4: Wiggle the brush another time gently
• Step 5: If you want a fuller look, you can repeat the steps mentioned above until you get the desired volume and length
• Step 6: Apply a coat of mascara on your bottom lashes
• Step 7: Make sure you’ve tightly sealed your mascara tube after use!

Infographic: Tips To Prevent Your Mascara From Smudging

The following infographic is designed to help you master the art of applying mascara and prevent smudging to experience pretty, fluttering lashes. The infographic talks about the steps involved in attaining perfectly applied smudge-proof mascara. It includes cleansing your lashes, applying a primer, blotting, and then applying mascara to the front of your lashes.

Illustration: StyleCraze Design Team

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between waterproof and smudge-proof mascara?

A waterproof formula is resistant to water, sweat, and rain, but not oils. Smudge-proof mascaras, on the other hand, are resistant to oil, but not necessarily water.

How to remove smudge-proof mascara?

You can use a water-based cleanser, micellar water, or simply warm water with an eye makeup remover to remove smudge-proof mascara.

Is it okay to use smudge-proof mascara daily?

Yes, it is alright to use smudge-proof mascara regularly. In fact, it is recommended to use it daily (if you are someone who does makeup every day) to keep your eye makeup intact even during sweaty days.

Is smudge-proof mascara safe for contact lenses?

Yes, a smudge-proof mascara with a gentle formula is safe for contact lenses. Choose the ones that do not create goop, clumps, or flakes since those particles can fall and get into your eyes and ruin your lens.

Does a setting spray stop mascara from smudging?

Yes, a setting spray can stop your mascara from smudging. Just like every other makeup item, a setting spray also keeps your eye makeup, especially your mascara, intact if you apply a generous amount of it.

Why Trust StyleCraze?

The author of this article, Srijita De, is a makeup lover whose passion lies in reviewing beauty products. Through careful research of hundreds of user reviews and feedback, she has curated this list of the best smudge-proof mascaras that help define your eyes and add depth and intensity to them. These mascaras are high-quality, bleed-proof, and do not irritate the eyes.

Recommended Articles

• Best Tubing Mascaras Guide With Reviews
• Best Waterproof Mascaras For Swimming
• Best Drugstore Tubing Mascaras For Long Eyelashes
• Best Non-Toxic Mascaras To Glam Up Sensitive Eyes!

The following two tabs change content below.

• Reviewer
• Author
• Editor
• Fact-checker

Stephanie G-MMakeup Artist

     

Stephanie G-M is a green makeup artist. She has worked at Fashion Weeks in London and New York and boasts of a clientele including Alexa Chung, Benedict Cumberbatch, Cara Delevingne, Elle Macpherson, Labrinth, Little Dragon, Morcheeba, and Suki Waterhouse. She helps her clients achieve fantastic skin and enhanced beauty by creating the perfect balance between creative and beautiful makeup, courtesy...more

Srijita DeCommerce Writer

 

Srijita De is a makeup and fashion enthusiast with a passion for empowering readers through practical tips and tricks to present their best selves with confidence. Armed with a postgraduate degree in English and Literature from the University of Calcutta, she has honed her writing skills and developed an in-depth understanding of the beauty and fashion world. Prior to her...more

Srijani Roy Chowdhury Associate Commerce Editor

Srijani is an associate commerce editor with a master's degree in journalism and mass communication from the University of Calcutta, West Bengal. She is certified in makeup techniques and is also a certified style and image consultant. She began her career as a freelance content writer, has worked as a journalist in several media houses, and has over three years...more

Madhumati ChowdhuryAssociate Editor

Madhumati is an associate editor with seven years of professional experience. She has previously worked as an editor, proofreader, and a writer with various organizations, helping her navigate through the various facets of content creation and refinement with ease. She graduated in English Literature from Jadavpur University, West Bengal. Her educational background lends a critical perspective and depth to her...more