10 Best Makeup Artist-Recommended Wet N Wild Eyeshadows In 2024

Get wildly creative with buttery soft shimmers, gentlest nudes, and intense mattes!

Reviewed by Tina Tempest, Makeup Artist & Hairstylist
Written by Srijani Roy Chowdhury, MA (Journalism & Mass Communication), Certified Style & Image Consultant
Edited by Srijita De, MA (English & Literature), Certified Style & Image Consultant
Fact-checked by Krati Darak, MBA, Certified Skin Care Coach  • 
All products recommended on StyleCraze are independently selected by our editorial team. If you make a purchase through any of these links, we may receive a commission. Learn more about our product selection process here.

If you are someone who has seen the hype around drugstore makeup brands that have been making the lives of many makeup enthusiasts easier than ever, then the celebrity-endorsed brand Wet N Wild should ring a bell. This brand caters to a wide range of makeup-related requirements, and beauty enthusiasts just love the products. So, if you are looking for the perfect eye shadow, you must get your hands on the best Wet N Wild eyeshadow available in the market right now. The color payoff and the variety of colors this brand offers have attracted the attention of many makeup influencers. Not only are the products affordable, but they are of high quality too. So give your eyes that classic bold smokey look or blend some complementary colors for a look with more dimension with Wet N Wild eyeshadow.

Since the market is already brimming with endless options, finding the right fit might be difficult. Take inspiration from this article, consider it your buying guide, and allow it to help you pick the one that your heart desires and suits you without any hassle. All you have to do is go ahead, give this piece a read.

Top PicksCheck Price
Best Versatile:Wet N Wild Color Icon Eyeshadow 10 Pan Palette - Nude AwakeningPrice on Amazon
Best Blendable:Wet N Wild Rebel Rose Color Icon Eyeshadow Quad - Bed Of RosesPrice on Amazon
Best Bold Shades:Wet N Wild The Ultimate Rainbow PalettePrice on Amazon
Best For Beginners:Wet N Wild Color Icon 5-Pan Palette- Walking On EggshellsPrice on Amazon
Best Long Lasting:Wet N Wild MegaLast Liquid Catsuit Shimmer Liquid EyeshadowPrice on Amazon
Best For Smooth Formula:Wet N Wild Color Icon 10-Pan Palette - Heart And SolPrice on Amazon
Best Creamy Texture:Wet N Wild Fantasy Makers Paint Palette - NeutralsPrice on Amazon
Best Hypoallergenic:Wet N Wild Color Icon Eyeshadow Single- BruleePrice on Amazon
Best Affordable:Wet N Wild Color Icon Eyeshadow Trio - Sweet As CandyPrice on Amazon
Best Satin Finish:Wet N Wild Idol Eyes Crème Shadow Pencil- EnvyPrice on Amazon

The 10 Best Wet N Wild Eyeshadows To Make Your Eyes Stand Out In 2024

1. Best Versatile:Wet N Wild Color Icon Eyeshadow 10 Pan Palette – Nude Awakening

4.3
Wet N Wild Color Icon Eyeshadow 10 Pan Palette – Nude Awakening Image: Wet N Wild

The Wet N Wild Color Icon Eyeshadow 10 Pan Palette is a must-have if you simply can’t resist dolling up your eyes. With 10 richly pigmented eyeshadow shades, you have the creative freedom to turn your eyelids into color galore. The highly impeccable blending formula of these shimmer shades can be used wet with a drop of water or liquid primer to transform these gorgeous powders for a wet eyeshadow look. The Nude Awakening palette contains sophisticated neutral eyeshadow shades which range from light nudes to medium beiges and dark browns. And that’s not all– if you want to go all Picasso and use more than one shade, Wet N Wild Color Icon Eyeshadow also has 2 matte transitional shades to make your blending seamless! Packed with a subtle shimmery finish, you can opt for a smokey eye or an almost invisible nude neutral eye makeup depending on your #OOTD. Here’s a video featuring a detailed review of the product and a reviewer’s experience with this excellent palette.

Color: Nude Awakening | Product Dimensions: 2.5 x 0.5 x 4.31 inches | Weight: 0.8 Ounces

Pros

  • Can be used wet or dry
  • 2 transitional shades for flawless blending
  • Glides on easily
  • Pigmented formula
  • Shimmery finish

Cons

  • May not offer long-lasting wear

protip_icon Pro Tip
Always apply eyeshadow to the crease of your eyelids and work down toward the lash line. This will help you avoid messy crease lines.

2. Best Blendable:Wet N Wild Rebel Rose Color Icon Eyeshadow Quad – Bed Of Roses

4.3

We all know that roses symbolize love, and what better way to express that on various special occasions from anniversaries to dates than wearing rose colors on your eyes? This Wet N Wild Eyeshadow Palette is inspired by roses and features 4 ultra-pigmented shades that blend as smooth as butter. Allow your eyes to tell stories with the bold matte and soft shimmer eyeshadow shades that stay resistant to creasing. You can use the neutral shades for an understated everyday look, or the intense ones for bold eyeshadow looks when you want to add a little drama to your favorite outfit. With cakes shaped like roses and shadows that give you satiny shimmer shades, these might just be the prettiest Wet N Wild Eyeshadows out there! This video details a tester’s experience with the product. Watch it for better understand of the formula.

Color: House Of Thorns | Product Dimensions: 3 x 0.56 x 3.15 inches | Weight: 0.17 Ounces.

Pros

  • Allow for seamless blending
  • Crease-resistant
  • Features both shimmery and matte shades
  • Travel-sized

Cons

  • May not be suitable for oily skin types

My Personal Experience

"I love the rose-shaped eyeshadows in this quad. The blend is flawless! The top two shimmer shades are particularly lovely—buttery and easy to blend. This nice palette helped me create a graceful smokey eye. They performed surprisingly well throughout a hot day on my oily eyelids—even without a primer. I'm delighted with my purchase."


3. Best Bold Shades:Wet N Wild The Ultimate Rainbow Palette

With a whopping 40 beautiful colors from every shade of the rainbow comes this new Wet N Wild Eyeshadow Palette which is a must-have for all beauty connoisseurs! If having endless options in shades without having to break the bank is your dream, it can be turned into a reality with this collection of matte, pearl, and shimmer shades. Offering seamless blendability, this top-notch palette features bolder shades that glide on oh-so-smoothly and can be applied both wet or dry. It’s time to unleash your creative potential and go all out with this modern renaissance palette. And to ensure that your eyes are well hydrated when rocking these eyeshadows, the formulation contains jojoba oil. Talk about a two-timing product!

Product Dimensions: 7.44 x 11.54 x 0.51 inches | Weight: 1.03 Pounds.

Pros

  • Easy to blend
  • Shades are richly pigmented
  • Can be applied wet or dry
  • Contains jojoba oil
  • Matte, shimmer, and pearl finishes
  • Offers long-lasting wear

Cons

  • There may be fallouts

My Personal Experience

"The variety in color is satisfying, even though some shades are a tad sheer. It's a good pick for beginners trying out eyeshadows. I enjoyed experimenting with the multitude of colors. The shadows blend beautifully, adding a fun touch to my makeup routine."


protip_icon Pro Tip
Create the illusion of bigger eyes by blending eyeshadow on the lower lash line. This also makes for a softer look compared to a sharp liner.

4. Best For Beginners:Wet N Wild Color Icon 5-Pan Palette- Walking On Eggshells

4.2
Wet n Wild Color Icon 5-Pan Palette Image: Wet N Wild
Now 24% Off

This Wet N Wild Eyeshadow Pan is proof that a makeup vanity is incomplete without some high-quality nude shades. This is the best eyeshadow for beginners as it is an affordable eyeshadow palette and you can use it for an effortless everyday look, or to accentuate bolder ones, as neutral shades never disappoint. What makes this a stand-out Wet N Wild Color Icon Eyeshadow Palette among others is that there are 5 shades that offer transitions and sparkly glitters, so you can dress up warm, cool, and neutral undertones without any hassle. To add on, the warm-toned shades go on buttery-smooth, blend like a dream, and come in matte, shimmer, satin, metallic, and glitter eyeshadow finishes. We think Walking On Eggshells is one of the best neutral Wet N Wild eyeshadow palettes as it’ll make you a pro at ‘no makeup-makeup’ eyes. Could a girl ask for anything more than some Color Icon hues to get her through the day? In this video, check out a detailed review of the product based on a tester’s experience with it.

Color: Walking On Eggshells | Product Dimensions: 4.33 x 0.79 x 1.5 inches | Weight: 0.21 Ounces

Pros

  • Versatile
  • Allow for easy blending
  • Comes in satin, shimmery, glittery, metallic, and matte finish
  • Contains jojoba seed oil for hydration

Cons

  • May not offer long-lasting wear

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

It has gained over 752 positive reviews on Amazon, making it an all-time best-seller.

5. Best Long Lasting:Wet N Wild MegaLast Liquid Catsuit Shimmer Liquid Eyeshadow

4.1
Wet N Wild MegaLast Liquid Catsuit Shimmer Liquid Eyeshadow Image: Wet N Wild

Wearing this glistening Wet N Wild Eyeshadow Stick shade can make you look like you just popped out of a fairytale. Reviewers have noticed that this versatile eyeshadow in light shimmer shade has a silky formula that glides on super-smoothly, this creamy eyeshadow gives you a high color payoff that lasts all day. The pearl pigments in this Wet N Wild Liquid Eyeshadow leave your eyelids sparkling and we think they could power a whole town! Just swipe some of this Wet N Wild glitter eyeshadow onto your eyelids before a night out with the girls, and you’re all everyone’s going to be talking about.

Color: Fairytale Ending

Pros

  • Cruelty-free
  • Gluten-free
  • Paraben-free
  • Fragrance-free
  • Easy to apply

Cons

  • Might be difficult to blend with other eyeshadows

My Personal Experience

"This Wet n Wild liquid eyeshadow glided on with effortless sparkly finesse, drying up pretty quickly. A trendy light pink, it was surprisingly versatile. The standout was its long-lasting shimmer – whether solo or topped with another shade, it beautifully accentuated my eyes all day."


6. Best For Smooth Formula:Wet N Wild Color Icon 10-Pan Palette – Heart And Sol

4.3
wet n wild Eyeshadow Color Icon 10-Pan Eye Makeup Palette Image: Wet N Wild

‘Pretty in pink’ has never been truer for the Heart And Sol palette which will allow you to create a rosy pink look for summer picnic days, or a dark pink brooding eye look for those weekend clubbing nights. Many reviews suggest wearing the summery eyeshadow shades as is, or blend them for a little bit of experimentation. With an ultra-smooth formula that glides beautifully onto the eyelids, you can choose from soft shimmers to flashy glitters from these colorful shades. As a plus, the Wet N Wild Color Icon Eyeshadow Palette’s sultry shades transition well from day to night to create amazing eye makeup looks. So you can go about your business worry-free!

Color: Heart & Sol | Product Dimensions: 0.47 x 4.33 x 2.64 inches | Weight: 0.42 Ounces

Pros

  • Suitable for day and evening looks
  • Easy to blend
  • Shimmery and glittery finishes
  • Long-lasting color
  • Highly pigmented

Cons

  • There might be fallouts

7. Best Creamy Texture:Wet N Wild Fantasy Makers Paint Palette – Neutrals

4
Wet N Wild Fantasy Makers Paint Palette – Neutrals Image: Wet N Wild

Live out your best eye makeup fantasies with the 6 ultra-pigmented complementary shades in this Wet N Wild matte eyeshadows palette. The subtler neutrals make for a simple and subtle look but if the situation calls for more drama, there are some vivid and bolder tones you can pick from. With a creamy texture that glides on like a dream, this Paint Palette from Wet N Wild is perfect for performance, special occasions, and Halloween makeup. So, whenever you’re in the mood to experiment, make sure to pick this Wet N Wild matte eyeshadow palette. You can do a smoky eye look or a subtle earthy look with these eye-catching shades. The rich pigments in this nude eyeshadow palette deliver a high color payoff that allow you to wear your heart on your eyes!

Color: NeutralsItem Weight: 2.39 ounces

Pros

  • Blends easily
  • Versatile
  • Smooth texture
  • Highly pigmented
  • Cruelty-free

Cons

  • The shades may fade after a couple hours

My Personal Experience

"These shades blend beautifully to offer good color payoff. They also last all day with a bit of setting primer and do not irritate sensitive skin. It is a good palette for beginners and for regular use."


8. Best Hypoallergenic:Wet N Wild Color Icon Eyeshadow Single- Brulee

3.8
Wet N Wild Color Icon Matte Eyeshadow Single Image: Wet N Wild

One quick swipe with these Wet N Wild Eyeshadow Singles is enough to make your eyes pop. This crease-proof eyeshadow offers high quality-pigments combined with pearlescents and deliver a satiny smooth finish that stays for a long time. Brulee is a shade from the Wet N Wild Single Eyeshadow range that is a subtle nude that you can rock for a classic office look, or you can even use it as a base for a striking, bolder color. Or, just use it as a transition shade, and no one will know. Also, no more worries about creasing or fading– we don’t do that here! We think this can be the classic addition to your Wet N Wild Color Icon Eyeshadow collection and become your favorite shade!

Color: Brulee | Product Dimensions: 1.42 x 1.42 x 0.43 inches | Weight: 0.32 Ounces

Pros

  • Travel-friendly
  • Satin finish
  • Crease-resistant
  • High blendability
  • Can be worn with other shades
  • Can be used as eyeshadow base

Cons

  • Some may find the color too subtle.

9. Best Affordable:Wet N Wild Color Icon Eyeshadow Trio – Sweet As Candy

The Wet N Wild Sweet As Candy Eyeshadow is ideal for beginners and professionals alike! 3 pans with shimmery colors labeled ‘brow bone’, ‘crease’, and ‘eyelid’ help guide an eye makeup rookie to know which part of the eye is which. And following these instructions help you define your eyes with precision which can be the perfect glam for occasions like your bestie’s bachelorette party. The pearly white from this Wet N Wild Eyeshadow Trio goes on the brow bone to accentuate it and also makes for a great highlighter for the inner corner of the eye. A chocolate brown shade with bronze undertones is used for the crease and can also be used for a light contour shade and a shimmery soft pink graces the eyelids with a light pop of color. What earns this Wet N Wild Eyeshadows Trio some brownie points is that it fits perfectly in the purse and in the vanity!

Product Dimensions: 3.15 x 1.89 x 0.43 inches | Weight: 0.12 Ounces

Pros

  • Richly pigmented shades
  • Ideal for beginners
  • Easy blendability
  • Creamy, satiny texture
  • Shimmery finish
  • Long-lasting

Cons

  • Contains parabens

My Personal Experience

"This product ticked my boxes with its stellar packaging. The trio of shades offer great flexibility for any look. Although lighter than expected, it presents as a charming summer color and comes across as an affordable alternative to some high brands. Fell in love with the quality, enough to make me keep exploring more from Wet n Wild."


10. Best Satin Finish:Wet N Wild Idol Eyes Crème Shadow Pencil- Envy

When you mix a pencil and a gorgeous eyeshadow cream, you get convenience that is also glamorous! The silky smooth formula of this eyeshadow is high-impact with a light-infused color that won’t disappoint. Inspired by the saying ‘green with envy’, Envy is a bright green shade with a shimmery finish which will add some character to your makeup. And what’s great about this Wet N Wild Idol Eyes Crème Shadow Pencil is that it doubles as an eyeliner, too! Just draw a line over your eyelid to give any outfit an overall edgy look. This Wet N Wild cream eyeshadow is not tested on animals. It is the right pick if you aim for everyone in the room to be green with envy!

Product Dimensions: 0.53 x 0.53 x 3.57 inches | Weight: 0.3 Ounces

Pros

  • Soft tip
  • Glides on effortlessly
  • Rich pigmentation
  • Doubles as eyeliner
  • Smooth texture

Cons

  • May not be crease-resistant

My Personal Experience

"I've found my perfect shade in the form of this light green color, 'envy'. I use it as an eyeliner opposed to an eyeshadow and absolutely love it!"


*The prices provided in this article are based on the latest available information. However, they may vary due to changes in pricing by the seller and/or promotional offers.

Now that we’ve gone over some of the best Wet N Wild makeup palettes on the market, we’ll tell you how to choose the right one below!

How To Choose The Right Wet N Wild Eyeshadow

  • Eye color

The statement-making brand Wet N Wild offers a plethora of eyeshadow palettes that range from neutrals to bright colors to the darkest shades of blacks and browns. But it’s necessary to know if a certain shade will suit your eye color, as the right shade can bring out the depth in your eyes while complementing the color of your eyes. If you’ve got blue eyes, opt for a sparkly grey or a rich brown for a daily look. To add a flair or drama, the ever-so-classic smokey eye will definitely make your eyes stand out.

Since brown eyes look great with any color, you can try blues, greens, bronzes, and adding some gold or silver glitter will only take brown eyes to the next level. Neutral shades like pinks, taupes, coppers complement green or hazel eyes beautifully. If you’re looking to make more of a statement, darker shades like purples and reds can create an amazing contrast. And to make black eyes pop, you can opt for bold colors like golds, silvers, and bronzes as they create some variety. Neutral colors like nudes and pinks are perfect for an everyday look for black eyes.

  • Finish

There is no end to the kinds of textures you can find in Wet N Wild eyeshadow ranges. You’ve got your metallics, shimmers, glitters, satins, and mattes. Each texture helps accentuate the eye in its own special way, and it’s good to learn how. Matte-textured eyeshadows work wonders to create the illusion of reshaping and redefining the eyes. Satin textures are a mix of matte and shimmer for all of you out there that don’t want to overdo the shine. The combination of the 2 textures makes them easier to blend and suited for all skin types.

If you love sparkle and shine, shimmery eyeshadows will help you achieve eyes that light up the whole room. Also ideal for mature skin, they offer a subtle sparkle and you can also layer them with darker hues for a dramatic look.

  • Form

For an impressive staying power, cream textured eyeshadows are the real deal as they are a dream to blend. However, they’re not recommended for those with oily skin types. But if you want to try, you can get them to work with a little primer before and some translucent powder after the eyeshadow. Wet N Wild also offers eyeshadows in palettes that come in 3 or more colors, and the benefit is that you can either use 1 color for a simple understated look, or blend 2 or more for a look with more definition. Some single colors come in small tubs, and these are easy for on-the-go application, and if you have a signature color you simply can’t live without. Also, always pick expert-recommended products that better suit your skin type.

After you’ve picked out your favorite Wet N Wild eyeshadow, let’s learn how you can apply it to define your eyes.

How To Apply Wet N Wild Eyeshadow

  • Step 1: Use a primer suited to your skin type as a base before going in with your celebrity-inspired eyeshadow look. This can help make the eyeshadow budge-proof, and also prevent your eyelids from getting oily. A primer can be applied with a primer brush, a Q-tip or just your fingers.
  • Step 2: Start with a nude or neutral shade as you can use this to build your whole eye makeup. A base nude also adds more depth to your eyes. If you’re going for a simple look, you can leave it at this, and if you want to add some flair, nude shades with a shimmery finish will do great.
  • Step 3: To add more dimension, highlight your crease from the inner corner by sweeping the brush over it. A darker shade like brown usually helps achieve the best results for this. As you blend outwards, make the line thicker by adding some pressure, and then gently blend it so as to not make it too apparent.
  • Step 4: Between your crease and brow bone, choose a lighter color with a hint of shimmer like a soft pink and make sure to blend it seamlessly.
  • Step 5: Add a tiny bit of shimmer to the inner corner of your eye as this instantly brightens your entire look. This step is optional.
  • Step 6: You can gently color your lower lash line with the same color used above, to complete the look. Even though this step is optional, it can help bring the whole look together.

The Bottom Line

Expertly crafted eyeshadows up your makeup game by adding drama and intensity to your eyes. From vibrant to subtle, you can create all kinds of looks according to your mood and occasion. The best Wet N Wild eyeshadows stand apart from the endless options available in the market as they are pocket-friendly yet effective. This brand offers a plethora of shades, from nude to bright dark colors. They are richly pigmented and blend easily. Some also offer crease resistance and a smooth texture to prevent cakey application. In addition, some eyeshadows are available in matte, shimmer, metallic, and satin finishes to match your mood. The super-smooth silky formula of these eyeshadows glides well on your eyes and leaves a long-lasting hue. There are plenty of products to explore including the Wet N Wild Color Icon Eyeshadow 10 Pan Palette, which offers dual matte transitional shades for a subtle shimmery finish, the Wet N Wild Color Icon 5-Pan Palette which lends a smooth blend via the versatile shades provided, and the Wet N Wild MegaLast Liquid Catsuit Shimmer Liquid Eyeshadow features pearl pigments that deliver an intense color payoff. You can add these eyeshadows to your enhanced beauty routine for daily or party wear to create a minimalist or elegant professional look. It would be best to consider long-lasting eyeshadows that glide smoothly on the skin. And stay away from the eyeshadows that contain parabens as it is not safe for your skin.

Why Trust Stylecraze?

Our author, Srijani Roy Chowdhury, is a makeup enthusiast and loves Wet N Wild eyeshadows. She has curated this list of eyeshadows after thorough research. She has checked reviews online, and browsed through multiple user feedback on online forums to shortlist the top-rated products. These Wet N Wild eyeshadows blend well, can be used wet or dry, and give a shimmery finish.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Wet N Wild eyeshadow oil-free?

Wet N Wild eyeshadows don’t contain any harmful or harsh oils, but some of their eyeshadow ranges are formulated with jojoba oil to offer moisturization benefits to the delicate eye area.

Does Wet N Wild eyeshadow have parabens?

Wet N Wild has some eyeshadows that contain parabens, and some that do not. It is advisable to check the label prior to making a purchase.

Are the Wet N Wild eyeshadows vegan?

Yes, according to Wet N Wild Beauty, their makeup, which includes the eyeshadow range, is completely vegan. The brand also claims to be PETA-certified and cruelty-free.

Is the Wet N Wild eyeshadow good for hooded eyes?

Yes, Wet N Wild eyeshadows are good for hooded eyes. The slightly darker colors in the palettes help add definition to hooded eyes.

Is the Wet N Wild eyeshadow good for sensitive eyes?

Most Wet N Wild eyeshadows do not contain harsh oils or toxic ingredients, making them great for sensitive eyes. Check the ingredients list before committing to an eyeshadow palette from this brand.

Is the Wet N Wild Eyeshadow good for acne-prone skin?

Yes, most Wet N Wild eyeshadows are good for oily and acne-prone skin. The formulas do not separate, flake off, or melt when applied on excessively oily skin. Since the brand is paraben-free and non-comedogenic, the eyeshadows also do not clog your pores or trigger acne.

How long do the Wet N Wild eyeshadows last?

Wet N Wild eyeshadows last for three to four years.

Recommended Articles


Was this article helpful?
thumbsupthumbsdown
The following two tabs change content below.

Latest Articles