Elliptical Vs. Treadmill: Which One Is Better For Your Health?

To burn calories, which one would you choose – elliptical or treadmill? Both are cardio machines, but when it comes to elliptical vs. treadmill, which one wins and gives you quick and better results?

A good understanding of which parts these two machines target can help you make a better decision. As a result, you will burn fat quickly from the areas you want to, lose weight, improve muscle and core strength, and reduce the risk of injuries.

In this article, you have explained the pros and cons of treadmill and elliptical machines. By the end of it, you will know which machine is best for you to use. Scroll down!

Treadmill Pros

Image: Shutterstock

• Versatile

You can use the treadmill to walk (slow or brisk), run (at 6 mph), or sprint. You can also use the incline option to add resistance to your workout.

• Engages Your Abs

Running requires you to engage your core and activate your ab muscles. This helps your body to be more balanced and prevents you from falling. So, if you run for, say 20 minutes, your core is engaged the whole time. By practicing it regularly, you will build a strong core, which will improve your posture, tone, and exercise stamina (1).

• Burns Calories

Running at 8 mph for 20 minutes may help you burn about 200-300 calories. The number of calories burned also depends on your body weight and degree of incline used. It is best to keep your treadmill at an incline of at least 3 degrees and run intermittently (run at 6 or 7 mph for a minute and then at 13 or 14 mph for 10 seconds).

• Feels More Natural

Walking and running are something that we are so used to doing every day. So, when you hop onto a treadmill, it will just take you a few seconds to get used to the moving platform. This comfort and ease of use will quickly make you like walking or running on the treadmill.

• Great For The Lower Body

Walking or running on the treadmill targets your calves, hamstrings, quadriceps, glutes, abs, and heart muscles. Therefore, it’s a great workout for your lower body (2). If you have excess fat accumulation in your lower body, running intermittently on the treadmill can help you lose such excess fat effectively.

• Strengthens The Bones

Image: Shutterstock

Running requires you to balance on alternate legs. This means that your legs bear the weight of your body alternately. Plus, the incline and speed of running exert double or sometimes triple the weight of your body. Running with correct posture on alternate days strengthens the bones (3), (4).

• Improves Heart Health

Running and walking briskly on the treadmill helps pump up your heart rate and activates the lungs, which can support the strengthening of your heart muscles and improve circulation (5). Over a period, you will be able to run for a long duration without going out of breath. In fact, you will be able to do any other type of cardio (like playing an outdoor sport) without feeling out of breath too soon.

Yes, there are many benefits of running or walking on the treadmill, but there are also a few disadvantages that you should be aware of. Here are the cons of using a treadmill to burn calories.

Treadmill Cons

• Posture May Get Affected

The size of the belt may cause you to change the way you walk or run. And over time, it can cause posture problems that may lead to lower back pain and joint pain.

• Not Easy On The Joints

Running fast on the treadmill or slowly for a long duration can be tough on your knees. That’s because your knees have to bear double or triple your body’s weight. They also absorb shock from the impact of your feet touching the platform.

• Works Only The Lower Body

Walking or running on the treadmill is a great lower body workout, but it neglects the upper body. It might feel like a whole-body workout, but if you think about it, running on the treadmill doesn’t target your upper body muscles to a great extent.

• May Not Be Safe

Not every exercise is meant for everyone. You might be great at running in the field, but you might feel dizzy when it comes to running on the treadmill. Running at high speed and the need to change the speed of the belt can also increase the chances of falling and hurting yourself.

So, does that mean you should steer clear of treadmills? No! Here’s when the treadmill might be useful.

When To Use A Treadmill

You may use the treadmill if:

• You want to walk or run as a warm-up session before heading off to do other exercises.
• You need to lose excess fat from your lower body. Use it once or twice a week for 20-30 minutes to burn fat and include strength training to prevent muscle loss.
• You are in a rehabilitation program, and walking slowly on the treadmill helps strengthen your muscles and bones. You should have supervision by a professional in such cases.
• You want to run, but it is not possible to go out for a run due to inclement weather, for example.

When To Avoid Using A Treadmill

Avoid running or walking rigorously on the treadmill if:

• You have recently injured your knee or have plantar fasciitis or lower back pain.
• You have just had heart surgery.
• Your physician does not allow you to use the treadmill for walking or running.

Tip: Always wear good running shoes while running on the treadmill or outside.

Now, let’s look at the pros and cons of the elliptical.

Elliptical Pros

Image: Shutterstock

• Low Impact And Easy On Joints

Cardio on an elliptical machine puts less pressure on the bones, especially the knee joints (6). This machine emulates the movement of climbing the stairs or cross-country skiing. Therefore, you do not have to stomp your feet on the belt or floor, and that will save you from injuring your knees in the long run (literally!).

• Full Body Workout

The elliptical targets the leg muscles and the biceps, triceps, lats, and the core (7). So, basically, you will get a full-body workout that will help you tone up your body, strengthen your core, and improve balance.

• You Can Go Reverse Too

You can pedal reverse on an elliptical. That way, you will target other muscles and engage in a mixed workout that will get you great results.

• Good Calorie Burner

The elliptical helps burn about 200-300 calories in 30 minutes – which is the same as running on a treadmill. However, with the elliptical, you will get a full body workout.

Elliptical Cons

• Does Not Strengthen The Bones

The elliptical does not impact your bones and joints. And that’s good news and bad news. Running on the treadmill will help you improve the strength of your bones. But working out on the elliptical has less impact and does not help in making your bones strong.

• Not So Dynamic

On a treadmill, there are options to increase the incline degree to add resistance to your workout. But, on the elliptical, because the pedals are high up, you do not even fully bear the weight of your body. In turn, there’s minimum resistance to your movement.

So, when is it best to use elliptical? Let’s find out in the next section.

When To Use Elliptical

Image: Shutterstock

You may use the elliptical when:

• You are recovering from an injury.
• You are over fatigued and need to do low-impact exercises.
• You need a mix of lower and upper body exercise.

When is it best to avoid using the elliptical machine? Find out next.

When To Avoid Using Elliptical

Avoid using the elliptical if your doctor says so.

Tip: Make sure you are standing upright and not bending forward while using the machine.

If you want to lose weight, you need to burn calories. And both the elliptical and the treadmill burn about the same number of calories. So, which one’s better for weight loss? Let me explain.

Calorie Burn – Elliptical Vs. Treadmill For Weight Loss

Image: Shutterstock

Using a treadmill can help you burn almost the same number of calories as you would if you use an elliptical. But depending on your goal, you should decide if you need a full body workout or just a lower body workout. And that will determine if you should use the treadmill or the elliptical.

Yes, you can support weight loss efforts by using a treadmill or elliptical exercise machine regularly. But also make sure you do strength training each week to preserve your muscles and improve the tone of your body structure.

So, what’s best to buy for your home? Let’s find out.

Treadmill Vs. Elliptical: Which Is Best To Buy For Your Home?

The best cardio machine to buy depends on your fitness goals. If you want to prepare for an upcoming marathon, it is best that you buy a treadmill and use it effectively. But if you are recovering from an injury or have a weak knee, it is best that you opt for an elliptical machine.

Infographic: Who Should Avoid Using Treadmill And Elliptical

Treadmills and ellipticals are widely used to perform cardio exercises. However, they are not recommended for everyone. People with certain health conditions should stay away from them. Check the infographic to learn more.

Save

Illustration: StyleCraze Design Team

Save the high-quality PDF version on your device now.

Download Infographic

Frequently Asked Questions

Will the elliptical get rid of love handles?

No, there is currently no evidence that indicates that elliptical can get rid of love handles. A combination of proper diet and exercise will help you lose weight and body fat. Consult your doctor for further information.

Do elliptical tone buttocks?

No, the elliptical does not tone the buttocks. It is an ideal workout for your glutes, chest, triceps biceps, and hamstrings

Sources

Was this article helpful?

The following two tabs change content below.

• Reviewer
• Author

Staci GulbinMS, MEd, RD, LDN

   

Staci Gulbin is a registered dietitian, freelance writer, health editor, and founder of LighttrackNutrition.com. She has been a registered dietitian with the Commission on Dietetic Registration since 2010 and has over a decade of experience in the nutrition and dietetics industry. Staci has also been applying her health and wellness knowledge to writing and editing for websites, such as CDiabetes,...more

Charushila BiswasHealth & Wellness Writer

 

Charushila is an ISSA certified Fitness Nutritionist and a Physical Exercise Therapist. Over a span of 6 years, she has authored more than 400 articles on diet, lifestyle, exercises, healthy food, and fitness equipment. She strives to inform, educate, and motivate her readers via authentic, straightforward, and fact-checked information. After completing her master's in biotechnology from Vellore Institute of Technology,...more