Most women want straight or smooth hair. It looks good and glossy and is easy to maintain. While curly and wavy hair look beautiful too, they need constant maintenance. Although a solid hair care routine does help to some extent, not everyone finds enough time to pamper their hair with oil massages and hair masks. That is why there are treatments like hair smoothing and hair straightening that help transform the structure of your hair, making it more manageable. While both these treatments result in sleeker hair, there is a slight difference between the two.
Hair straightening came before hair smoothing. The first hair straightening procedure was done on African hair. This procedure was invented to manage coarse hair but quickly became a popular trend. Hair smoothing was invented in Brazil around 2003 and, hence, is also called Brazilian keratin treatment or Brazilian blowout. There are many more differences between these two procedures. Read on to know more.
What Is Hair Straightening?
There are two types of hair straightening treatments: permanent and temporary. Temporary straightening is done with heat styling tools like hot irons or hot combs. Here, functioning cohesive and adhesive forces work in a highly viscous system to keep the fibers parallel. The straight hair you get as a result of these procedures is temporary. Your hair goes back to its natural texture when you wash it.
Permanent hair straightening is a process by which the structure of your hair is altered to give you pin-straight hair. The chemical relaxers used in this process permanently break the bonds in your hair shaft. Heat is applied to restructure your hair, and more chemicals are used to seal the newly formed bonds. The alkaline agent in the chemical relaxer breaks the keratin bonds in curly/wavy hair to stretch and smoothen them (1).
How Does It Work?
Alkaline straighteners contain 1–10% sodium hydroxide (lye-relaxer), lithium hydroxide, calcium hydroxide, or a combination of these ingredients. The high pH of these chemicals helps open the cuticle scales and penetrate into the hair fibers. When these chemicals come in contact with the cortex, they react with keratin to break and rearrange the disulfide bridges to stretch them out, thus giving you straight hair (1).
While this process causes more damage than hair smoothing, it can straighten even the curliest of hair and is permanent. Thus, the treated hair remains straight until your natural hair grows out (1). Permanent hair straightening is also known as ‘Japanese straightening.’
When Can You Choose This Method?
Hair straighteners work on all hair types, from wavy to kinky curly hair. Depending on the hair texture, the procedure will need to be repeated every 8-12 weeks. One important thing to remember is that permanent straightening uses hydroxides or thioglycolate that are incompatible with bleached hair.
Side Effects Of Hair Straightening
- Chemical relaxers should not be applied on the scalp as they can burn your skin. This is why it is recommended to apply some petrolatum along the hairline and on the ears before the application of the relaxer to prevent alkaline burns (1).
- Wrong technique may cause scalp burns and hair breakage (1).
- The swelling of hair fibers and opening of cuticle scales can make the hair susceptible to friction, thus lowering its resistance and strength (1).
- The most commonly reported side effects of permanent hair straightening are: frizzy hair, dandruff, hair loss, thinning and weakening of hair, graying of hair, and split ends (1).
What Is Hair Smoothing?
Hair smoothing is a temporary treatment that is considered to be a procedure under hair straightening by some people. The process involves saturating your hair with a formaldehyde solution followed by drying it out and using a flat iron to lock your hair in a straight position (1). However, the chemicals used for hair smoothing are not as strong as the ones used in hair straightening treatments. This makes this treatment less damaging. But it is not ideal for all hair types.
Brazilian keratin treatment has become popular because the procedure is compatible with bleached hair and gives the hair a naturally smooth, shiny look, which is impossible to acquire with chemical relaxers.
How Does It Work?
First, a formaldehyde solution is applied to the hair. The water in the solution breaks the hydrogen bonds of the keratin molecule. It is then blow-dried straight (a flat iron can also be used). The newly redesigned keratin remains straight because the formaldehyde crosslinks the keratin filaments in perfect alignment. This makes the hair comparatively straighter and shiny (1).
When Can You Choose This Method?
The effects of hair smoothing last between 2 to 5 months. It is primarily recommended for hair that is wavy or frizzy. This is because it does not so much alter the structure of your hair so much as it aligns it. The treatment is not likely to be very effective on hair that is extremely thick or curly.
Side Effects Of Hair Smoothing
- Earlier, when formaldehyde was used in the Brazilian keratin treatment (BKT), consumers complained of burning eyes, strong smell, and burning mouth and nose. However, the ingredients are not formaldehyde- or glutaraldehyde-based. Formaldehyde-releasers, such as methylene glycol or glyoxylic acid, are used now (1).
- BKT (hair smoothing) uses formaldehyde releasers. Formaldehyde has been associated with reactions, such as eye problems, nervous system problems (for example, headaches and dizziness), respiratory tract problems, nausea, chest pain, vomiting, and rashes (2).
- A study showed that formaldehyde could increase the risk of developing asthma (3).
- The excessive use of heat (flat iron) in hair smoothing can damage your hair (1).
Note: African people’s hair has less volume and density compared to Caucasian people’s hair. Their hair is also more prone to breakage and dryness as their scalp produces lesser sebum. Thus, when they straighten their hair, it can look like they are experiencing hair loss (1).
Why Hair Smoothing Over Hair Straightening?
This decision is simply based on the client’s hair type and desired result. Most people want a natural finish without their hair looking pin straight. Hair smoothing, although temporary, serves this purpose with less damage.
The highlight of hair smoothing is that it can be done on bleached, permanently dyed, and relaxed hair. It is also great for improving shine and softness (1).
With hair straightening, the hair bonds need to be broken and then rebuilt. This causes a certain amount of hair damage. While your hair can be repaired, it will need intensive care and regular touch-ups and trims when the natural hair starts to grow back (1).
Why Hair Straightening Over Hair Smoothing?
While frizz can be tamed with hair smoothing, it does not do much for straightening really curly hair. Hair straightening is preferred when dealing with difficult hair types like thick and kinky hair when the client desires straight hair.
While smoothing your hair can transform your curls into frizz-less waves, the chances of it going straight are poor. You are more likely to get the results you desire when you choose to straighten your hair permanently.
Note: Check if you have any chemical allergies, hair loss issues, or any other serious conditions before getting any of these hair treatments. Get a hair test done at a salon. If you experience any discomfort or hair breakage, consult a doctor before you proceed any further.
So, what should you go for?
Hair Smoothing Vs. Hair Straightening – The Final Verdict
Both these procedures have their advantages and setbacks. Both of them have to be done at a salon by trained hairdressers. Remember, both procedures require regular upkeep to maintain the obtained hair texture and structure.
Before making your decision, here are some questions you need to ask yourself:
- Do you want a treatment that is permanent or temporary?
- Do you want pin-straight hair or something that looks more natural?
- Are you just trying to battle frizz or is straight hair the end goal?
These are some of the questions you can ask yourself to decide which treatment is likely the best option for you.
Repeated chemical treatments can damage hair. How can you protect your hair after these procedures? Here’s how!
Hair Maintenance For Smoothened Or Straightened Hair
- Use silicone-based hair care products to rejuvenate your hair. They are known to protect the hair shaft from abrasive actions and increase its thickness (1).
- Massage your hair and scalp with oil (coconut, sunflower, mineral oils). A study has shown that coconut oil can reduce protein loss in damaged hair (4).
- Use a leave-in conditioner and hair masks to hydrate and strengthen your hair.
- Limit the use of heat styling tools on your hair for the first few weeks until your hair regains its moisture and strength.
Whether you decide to straighten or smoothen your hair, remember that both use chemicals that can damage your hair when done repeatedly. If you do get them done, nourish and take care of your hair to prevent further damage and hair fall.
- Hair Cosmetics: An Overview, International Journal Of Trichology, US National Library Of Medicine, National Institutes of Health.
- Hair smoothing treatments: Perceptions and wrong practices among females in Saudi Arabia, Journal Of Dermatology And Dermatologic Surgery.
- Asthma From Hair Straightening Treatment Containing Formaldehyde: Two Cases And A Review Of The Literature, Toxicology And Industrial Health, US National Library Of Medicine, National Institutes of Health.
- Effect of mineral oil, sunflower oil, and coconut oil on prevention of hair damage, Journal of Cosmetic Science, US National Library Of Medicine, National Institutes of Health.
Latest posts by Anjali Sayee (see all)
- 40 Crazy Katy Perry Hairstyles You Need To Check Out! - October 29, 2019
- 32 Incredible Jennifer Aniston Hairstyles - October 28, 2019
- 27 Beautiful DIY Side-Swept Hairstyles To Check Out In 2019 - October 7, 2019
- Top 62 Short Bob Hairstyles That Are Trending In 2019 - September 18, 2019
- 30 Stunning Long Dark Brown Hairstyles - August 8, 2019