Maybelline New York Superstay 24 Color 2-Step Lipstick

BY Maybelline
3.7/5     4 Reviews

Product Description

Maybelline New York Superstay 24 Color 2-Step Lipstick is a long-wearing lipstick that stays intact throughout the day. It comes with a lip color and a balm. This lipstick is formulated with Maybelline’s Micro-Flex technology which makes it “real life-proof”, meaning it does not stain, transfer, dry out, or feel uncomfortable. It keeps your lips hydrated and moisturized all day long. Its pigmented color glides on super smoothly, and the balm protects the color and prevents it from wearing off. It can also be reapplied as and when needed. This lipstick is available in 34 super-saturated shades.

Product Reviews

3.1/5

4 Ratings & 4 Reviews

80%

Would recommend this to a friend

PROS

Moisturizes lips

Highly pigmented

Long-lasting

Transfer-proof

No staining and bleeding

No cracking, fading, feathering, smudging, or drying

CONS

May feel a bit sticky

Difficult to remove

Does not last long without the balm

Balm needs to be reapplied every few hours

Requires an oil-based makeup remover

The quantity of the balm lesser than the lipstick

It does what it claims!
4/5

PROS

Affordable

Very long-lasting

Adequate quantity

Lightweight formula

Does not transfer or stain

CONS

Cannot be used without the balm

Requires frequent touch-ups with the balm


I guess all of us are always on the lookout for a product that is just perfect and does everything we want it to do. One such product I always wanted was a lipstick which never wears off, doesn’t transfer, and I don’t have to reapply it every now and then. Well, Maybelline granted my wish, and made this super amazing product- Maybelline New York Superstay 24 Color 2 Step Lipstick. This is what I was looking for.

The lipstick comes in this smart packaging with the lip color’s bottle being transparent and the balm on the other side. The quantity is good for the price it comes at. I got two shades from this range - Firmly Mauve 245 and Constant Cocoa 145. Both the colors are very pretty and versatile. I mostly wear these colors to work, and I love them.

About the texture, it feels super light on the lips, like a balm, making your lips feel moisturized and soft all day. I reapply the balm a few times to keep the lipstick from getting sticky. Without the balm, the lipstick gets very sticky and starts cracking. Although with the balm, there is no problem at all. It does not transfer, smudge, stain, or wear off. These are pretty amazing lipsticks with excellent shade choices.

Not the one for me!
2.5/5

PROS

Affordable

Long-lasting

Nice packaging

CONS

Feels sticky and heavy on the lips

Not completely matte finish

Cannot be used without the balm


I got this lipstick because of the hype it had created everywhere. I was so intrigued, I ordered two shades from the range- Always Heather 120 and All Day Cherry 15. Both the shades are my favorites, especially Always Heather. It’s a beautiful neutral- nudish shade that goes well with my every day wear.

But, these are not the best lipstick formulas. I cannot understand what the hype is all about. Does anyone wear any lip color for 24 hours? Okay anyway, although it does stay on for that long, I do not like how it makes my lips feel while it’s on. The lip color doesn’t stay without the balm, and with the balm, the lips feel so heavy all day. I like lipsticks that turn dry and don’t feel like anything on my lips. But this one is a constant reminder of the balm you’re wearing and have to keep reapplying.

It’s definitely not something for me.

Terrible lipstick!
1/5

PROS

Wide range of shades

CONS

Not very long-lasting

Very sticky

Fades off during a meal


Where are the good reviews coming from? I bought this lipstick, used it once, and instantly knew it’s not working. My lips keep sticking together when I talk. It vanishes from the center of the lips after a meal. It does not last. Even with the balm on, the lipstick does wear off. And with the balm, it’s unbearable. A very bad formula.

Love Maybelline New York Superstay 24 Color 2 Step Lipstick
5/5

PROS

Affordable

Long-lasting

Moisturizes lips

None

Transfer-proof

Pretty shades

CONS

None


I love sticking with the shades I love. The shade I bought from this collection is Absolute Taupe 230 and I absolutely love it. This lipstick is perfect and there is nothing I do not like about it. Good job Maybelline!

Top Questions And Answers

March 24, 2019

What are the ingredients of this product?

Aishwarya KamalMarch 25, 2019

Aishwarya KamalMarch 25, 2019

These are the ingredients of the lipstick (Step 1):

  • G2417 Isododecane
  • Trimethylsiloxysilicate
  • Nylon-611/Dimethicone Copolymer
  • DisteardimoniumHectorite
  • Lauroyl Lysine
  • C30-45 AlkyldimethylsilylPolypropylsilsesquioxane
  • Alumina
  • Propylene Carbonate
  • Synthetic Fluorphlogopite
  • Silica
  • Calcium Sodium Borosilicate
  • Calcium Aluminum Borosilicate
  • Polyethylene Terephthalate
  • Parfum/Fragrance
  • Aluminum Hydroxide
  • Acrylates Copolymer
  • Benzyl Alcohol
  • Dimethicone
  • Paraffin
  • Tin Oxide
  • [+/- May Contain/PeutContenir Mica, CI 77891/Titanium Dioxide
  • CI 77491
  • CI 77492
  • CI 77499/Iron Oxides
  • CI 15850/RED 7
  • CI 15985/Yellow 6 Lake
  • CI 45410/Red 28 Lake
  • CI 45380/Red 22 Lake
  • CI 19140/Yellow 5 Lake
  • CI 42090/Blue 1 Lake
  • CI 75470/Carmine]
  • F.I.L. D41008/5.

These are the ingredients of the lip balm (Step 2):

  • G2296 TrimethylPentaphenylTrisiloxane
  • Is-Diglyceryl Polyacyladipate-2
  • Ozokerite
  • Cera Alba/Beeswax/CireDabeille
  • Calcium Sodium Borosilicate
  • Calcium Aluminum Borosilicate
  • Tocopheryl Acetate
  • Parfum/Fragrance
  • [+/- May Contain/PeutContenir Mica
  • CI 77891/Titanium Dioxide
  • CI 77491/Iron Oxides]
  • F.I.L. D8974/11.

March 23, 2019

What are the shades available in this range?

Shagun SinghMarch 24, 2019

Shagun SinghMarch 24, 2019

There are 34 shades available in this range:

  • Wear On Wildberry 45
  • Absolute Taupe 230
  • All Day Cherry 15
  • All Night Apricot 240
  • Always Heather 120
  • Blush On 105
  • Boundless-Berry 260
  • Committed Coral41
  • Constant Cocoa145
  • Constant Toast136
  • Continuous Coral20
  • Endless Espresso275
  • Everlasting Wine5
  • Extreme Aubergine270
  • Firmly Mauve245
  • Forever Chestnut115
  • Infinite Petal80
  • Keep It Red35
  • Keep Up The Flame25
  • Lasting Lilac85
  • Loaded Latte235
  • Merlot Armour265
  • More & More Mocha141
  • Never Ending Pearl95
  • On And On Orchid70
  • Perpetual Plum55
  • Relentless Ruby255
  • Reliable Raspberry10
  • So Pearly Pink110
  • Stay Scarlet250
  • Timeless Rose90
  • Timeless Toffee150
  • Unlimited Raisin50
  • Very Cranberry100

March 22, 2019

How to apply Maybelline New York Superstay 24 Color 2 Step Lipstick?

Prerna SharmaMarch 23, 2019

Prerna SharmaMarch 23, 2019

This lipstick comes with two lipstick coats which need to be applied one after the other.

  • On bare lips, apply one coat of the lipstick and let it air dry for about two minutes.
  • After the lip color is dry, apply the ultra-conditioning balm to lock in moisture and let the lipstick set.
  • Reapply balm as and when needed.

March 21, 2019

How to remove this long-lasting lipstick?

Sonali Dubey

To remove Maybelline New York Superstay 24 Color 2 Step Lipstick, you will need an oil based makeup remover. Water-based makeup removers will not be effective in removing the lip color. To remove the lipstick, take the remover on a cotton pad and rub it on the lips gently to help loosen the color.

March 20, 2019

Does the lipstick really stay on for 24 hours? Are touch-ups required?

Arti SethiaMarch 21, 2019

Arti SethiaMarch 21, 2019

The lipstick does stay on for the claimed amount of time. It is transfer-proof and smudge-proof. Reapply the balm once it wears off to maintain the longevity of the lipstick and keep your lips soft and moisturized.

March 19, 2019

What is the finish of this lipstick?

Mahira AliMarch 20, 2019

Mahira AliMarch 20, 2019

The Maybelline New York Superstay 24 Color 2-Step Lipstick has a matte finish on the lips. The balm keeps the lips moisturized and soft after application.