Top 8 Mascaras For Eyelash Extensions In 2022

Written by Baishali Bhattacharya, Certified Image Consultant, Certified In Makeup Artistry
All products recommended on StyleCraze are independently selected by our editorial team. If you make a purchase through any of these links, we may receive a commission. Learn more about our product selection process here.

If you invest in eyelash extensions, you’d want them to look perfect. That is why you need to invest in the best mascaras for lash extensions. When it comes to eyelashes, the beauty industry has seen it all. From magnifying mascaras to growth serums and heated curlers, there are so many versatile products to enhance the beauty of your eyelashes. But did you know that you can wear mascara with eyelash extensions? Yes, to make your lash extensions look perfectly enhanced, you need mascara. A good mascara offers a crowning touch to your makeup routine.

This article has narrowed down and reviewed the 8 best mascaras for eyelash extensions. Let’s take a peek at the list!

Top 8 Products
Check Price
Best Overall: Thrive Causemetics Liquid Lash Extensions Mascara
Price on Amazon
Best Waterproof: DDK 4D Mascara
Price on Amazon
Best Smudge-Proof: Jo Mousselli Xtreme Lashes
Price on AmazonPrice on Walmart
Best Fragrance-Free: KC Republic Eyelash Extension Mascara
Price on Amazon
Best For Sensitive Eyes: Alluring Length & Volume Mascara
Price on Amazon
Best For Volume: BL Noir Mascara
Price on Amazon
Best Pigmented: Lash Affair HD Mascara
Price on Amazon
Best Natural: Alluring Max 2 Special Mascara
Price on Amazon

Why Wear Mascara With Eyelash Extensions?

Here’s why you should apply mascara on your false lashes.

  •  Your lash extensions look thicker and you look bolder and brighter.
  •  A contrast-colored mascara can change the color of your lashes.•
  •  It can increase and enhance the length of your fake lash extensions.•
  •  If your lash extensions are sparse and you need a refill, one or two coats of mascara can help you boost the volume of your fake lashes.
  •  Certain mascaras are infused with natural ingredients like peptides, stem cell complexes, vitamin E, biotin, and keratin. They can help in growing your natural lashes besides keeping them healthy.

So now, which mascaras can you use on lash extensions? Let’s take a look at the top 8 mascaras for lash extensions.

The 8 Best Mascaras For Eyelash Extensions That You Must Try In 2022

1. Best Overall: Thrive Causemetics Liquid Lash Extensions Mascara

Now you can instantly create the look of lash extensions with this award-winning, best-selling mascara that won’t clump, flake, or smudge. This mascara is available in three gorgeous shades. The revolutionary high-performance formula is powered by Flake-Free Tubing Technology to offer you voluminous, show-stopping lashes. In addition, the Orchid Stem Cell Complex encourages + supports longer, healthier-looking lashes powered by plant stem cell technology. The best part about this mascara is that it is easy to apply and remove.

Pros

  •  Available in 3 shades
  •  Vegan
  •  Cruelty-free
  •  Paraben-free
  •  Phthalate-free
  •  Sulfate-free
  •  No synthetic fragrances

Cons

None

2. Best Waterproof: DDK 4D Mascara

The DDK 4D Mascara will offer you infinitely lengthening eyelashes if used correctly. Different brush methods will help you achieve different effects: Daily(normal style), super-long, crazy-long. It can be easily removed with the help of lotion or warm water. It is enriched with vitamin E that helps to strengthen your lashes. The mascara is safe for pregnant women. It can be diluted if dry; just spraying water on the brush.

Pros

  •  4D mascara
  •  Easy to remove
  •  Waterproof mascara
  •  Suitable for everyday wear

Cons

None

3. Best Smudge-Proof: Jo Mousselli Xtreme Lashes

The Jo Mousselli Xtreme Lashes are formulated specifically with semi-permanent lash extensions. This mascara gives you dramatic definition and color that lasts without any clumps, flakes, or smudges. You can easily remove it with the Xtreme Lashes Eye Makeup Remover & Facial Cleanser. It has a water-based formula that is enriched with vitamin B5. The mascara is formulated with Xtreme Lashes Semi-Permanent Eyelash Extensions and natural eyelashes. It is also safe for contact lens wearers and those with sensitive eyes.

Pros

  •  Long-lasting
  •  Smudge-proof
  •  No flakes
  •  Safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers

Cons

None

4. Best Fragrance-Free: KC Republic Eyelash Extension Mascara

This Eyelash Extension Mascara by the KC Republic is an oil-free mascara, safe for lash extensions. It can be used with all types of eyelash extensions, and it is water-resistant and reusable. The mascara gives a much fuller and more dramatic look to your lashes. It is suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.

Pros

  •  Water-resistant
  •  Suitable for all types of lash extensions
  •  Clump-resistant
  •  Reusable
  •  Safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers•
  •  Ophthalmologist-tested
  •  Fragrance-free
  •  Allergy-tested

Cons

None

5. Best For Sensitive Eyes: Alluring Length & Volume Mascara

The Alluring Length & Volume Mascara for eyelash extensions is one of the most suitable mascaras specially made for eyelash extensions on the market. It also works great on natural lashes as well. The deep black formula makes your lashes feel softer and look shinier, in addition to longer and fuller. It is easy to remove and is also ideal for long-lasting wear. In addition, it comes in a cute, compact package that makes it the perfect addition to a fashionista’s makeup bag.

Pros

  •  Long-lasting
  •  Easy to remove
  •  Intense formula
  •  Can be used on natural lashes
  •  Safe for sensitive eyes

Cons

None

6. Best For Volume: BL Noir Mascara

The Noir Mascara helps to elongate and add maximum volume to your lashes. It is the perfect mascara that you can use on lash extensions. It also helps to strengthen your natural lashes. It has a water-based formula enriched with keratin and botanical extracts to strengthen and restore natural lashes while preventing breakage and damage. The mascara is easy to apply and a breeze to remove without leaving clumps or residue along the lash line, making it perfect for everyday use.

Pros

  •  Long-lasting
  •  Smudge-proof
  •  Can be used on natural lashes

Cons

None

7. Best Pigmented: Lash Affair HD Mascara

This HD mascara by Lash Affair has an ultra-creamy formula best suited for your eyelash extensions. This lash extension safe mascara gives your bottom lashes the perfect added length and drama. In addition, the applicator of this mascara is specially designed to help you with precise application so that each lash is coated separately.

Pros

  •  Highly pigmented
  •  Ultra-creamy formula
  •  Long-lasting
  •  Won’t flake off
  •  Precise applicator
  •  Cruelty-free

Cons

None

8. Best Natural: Alluring Max 2 Special Mascara

Whether you want subtle, natural-looking lashes, or an over-the-top smokey eye, this versatile mascara will be the right one for you. The formula of this mascara is enriched with royal jelly and herbal extracts that strengthen and condition lashes while providing unbelievable length and volume. It goes on smoothly for a gorgeous finish and is easy to remove with just a bit of warm water. Pair this amazing mascara with a peachy pink lip gloss, and get ready to step out with confidence and style.

Pros

  •  Nourishing oil-free formula
  •  Water-soluble
  •  Environmentally-friendly
  •  Enriched with natural ingredients
  •  Suitable for both eyelash extensions and natural lashes

Cons

  •  Some might find the texture of this mascara a bit sticky

Eyelash extensions help add Hollywood glamor to your look, and a good oil-free mascara can elevate your lashes and add that extra oomph factor that makes you stand out. In the following section, let’s look at the types of mascaras that you can use on lash extensions.

Types Of Mascaras You Can Use On Lash Extensions

A plant-based mascara or an organic one might not be the best option to use on lash extensions. You need to remember that not all premium products are safe for eyelash extensions. Instead, look for a water-based mascara made exclusively for those with false lashes.

While most mascaras for natural lashes are infused with oils, additives, and artificial waxes. But to maintain the longevity of your fake lashes and to preserve the health of your natural ones, you need a pH-balanced formula. These mascaras are also safe for sensitive skin around the eyes. They dry quickly and can be removed very easily with warm water.

Not all mascaras are good for lash extensions, regardless of whether yours are made from synthetic or natural fibers. Here are the types of mascara you need to avoid on lash extensions.

What Type Of Mascara To Avoid On Lash Extensions

  •  Waterproof Mascara

Waterproof mascara is not good for false lashes. The key components of a waterproof mascara are Teflon (the non-stick coating on your cookware) and Dimethicone copolyol (a type of silicone). This is why waterproof mascaras often end up damaging the bond created by the lash adhesive and subsequently leading to the early falling-off of lash extensions. Due to its water-repellant nature, it often makes your natural lashes brittle and dries them out too. For daily wear purposes, waterproof mascara is not the right one. Waterproof mascara is very difficult to remove. There are just a handful of ways to remove it without intense rubbing, pulling, or snagging. That’s also why it can cause lash extensions to fall out early.

  •  Oil-Based Mascara

If you are using mascara for lash extensions, it is very important to avoid oil-based products. Oil can damage the eyelash glue and break the bond between eyelash extensions and natural lashes. Therefore, try and avoid mascaras with ingredients like lanolin, castor oil, beeswax, carnauba wax, paraffin, mineral oil, turpentine oil, linseed oil, eucalyptus oil, and sesame oil.

  •  Fiber Mascara

Fiber mascaras are enriched with dry fibers like silk, rayon, or nylon to make your lashes look thicker and denser. However, unlike tube mascara, it is very hard to remove, and that’s why it’s not recommended for lash extensions.

  •  Tube Mascara

Tube mascara is a product that coats lashes by forming tubes around each lash. While this mascara is easy to remove from natural lashes, it sticks like tar on eyelash extensions. Hence, prolonged use of tube mascara ends up damaging lash extensions.

Applying mascara to false lashes is not the same as doing it to your natural ones. Here are a few tips on applying mascara to lash extensions correctly.

How To Apply Mascara To Lash Extensions

  •  Wash, dry, and comb your lashes before applying.
  •  Gently apply a coat of your favorite mascara on your natural lashes and then extensions.
  •  Always start applying from the middle and go towards the tips.
  •  Do not apply mascara to the roots.
  •  Avoid adding more than a coat or two of mascara to false eyelash extensions.

If your lash extensions are not too thick or heavy, wearing mascara will safely enhance your look. Let’s look at a few things you need to consider when using mascara on lash extensions.

Things To Consider When Using Mascara On Lash Extensions

  •  Application

When wearing mascara on eyelash extensions, it is important not to follow the same method for your natural lashes. Instead, pick a wand that doesn’t grip tightly on the lash extensions to make the application process easy. A convenient way to apply mascara on the lash extensions is by starting at the middle of the eyelash and moving forward to tips. Apply on the tips without touching the base because it can damage the bond created by lash adhesives, making them fall out early.

  •  Removal

While removing mascara that’s applied on lash extensions, you need to be extremely careful to avoid them from falling out ahead of time. Firstly, avoid using makeup removers with oils. Once you have picked the right cleanser, clean the mascara gently. Don’t be too harsh, and remove the mascara without any rubbing or pulling. Use cotton pads or towels to minimize snagging too.

  •  Sleeping Etiquette

Lastly, never wear your mascara to bed. Letting mascara stay overnight is unsafe and might lead to eye pain, bacterial infections, and corneal erosions. Always wash and comb your lash extensions after removing the mascara.

If you are trying to remove eyelash extensions and they start falling off piece by piece, you can’t go to the salon for a touch. We have mentioned a few tips on removing eyelash extensions at home in the next section.

How To Remove Lash Extensions – A Step By Step Guide

Applying Glue Remover

  •  Buy a professional-grade eyelash extension glue remover. This is because the glue used to apply eyelash extensions is very strong. Regular eyelash glue remover may not work on your lashes.
  •  Remove your eye makeup at first with the help of a cotton swab or pad to see where the extensions start.
  •  Place under-eye pads to protect the skin underneath your eyes.
  •  Use disposable brush applicators or spoolies and apply the eyelash glue remover so you can easily apply the glue remover to your lashes.
  •  Remember to close your eyes while working on it, so you don’t get the glue remover in it.
  •  Pull the applicator or spoolie through your lashes just like you’re applying mascara.
  •  Let the glue remover sit for 2-3 minutes to break down the glue.
  •  Pull the second applicator or spoolie through your lashes and gently remove the extensions.
  •  Soak a cotton swab or pad with a gentle eye makeup remover and remove the excess glue remover.

Using Steam Oil

  •  Thoroughly remove your eye makeup so you can tell where your natural lashes end.
  •  Take a bowl and fill it with steaming hot water.
  •  Put a towel over your head, and then lean over the steam for 15 minutes.
  •  Take a cotton swab and soak it in olive or coconut oil.
  •  Start from the inner corner of your eye and pull the cotton swab gently across your lashes so that all the extensions come off.
  •  Use a gentle cleanser to wash away the excess oil as a final step.

Now you can easily get thick, gorgeous eyelashes that have everyone around wondering if you’ve just stepped out of a TV commercial. These high-performance mascaras will help you move out of the stumpy lash territory. These mascaras will help lengthen, volumize, and separate your false lash extensions. We recommend applying your mascara in a zig-zag motion from as close to the roots as possible. The ones reviewed in the curated list come with precise applicators, and they are long-lasting and smudge-proof.

Why Trust StyleCraze

The author of this article, Baishali Bhattacharya, is certified in makeup artistry and image consultation. She loves to use mascara to volumize and enhance the look of her eyelash extensions. She has gone through multiple products and hundreds of online reviews to pick the best products for this list so that her readers experience only the best.

The following two tabs change content below.

LATEST ARTICLES