10 Best Maybelline Eyeliner Pencils, According To A Makeup Artist – 2024

Create bold strokes or draw fine lines on your lids with these smudge-proof liners.

Medically reviewed by Tommy Tafoya, Makeup Artist Tommy Tafoya Tommy TafoyaMakeup Artist insta_icon
Written by , MA (English & Literature), Certified Style & Image Consultant Srijita De MA (English & Literature), Certified Style & Image Consultant Experience: 2 years
Edited by , MA (Journalism & Mass Communication) Rajeshwari Das MA (Journalism & Mass Communication) Experience: 3 years
Fact-checked by , MA (Journalism & Mass Communication), Certified Style & Image Consultant Srijani Roy Chowdhury MA (Journalism & Mass Communication), Certified Style & Image Consultant Experience: 3 years
 • 
All products recommended on StyleCraze are independently selected by our editorial team. If you make a purchase through any of these links, we may receive a commission. Learn more about our product selection process.

Choosing a Maybelline eyeliner pencil over other brands can be a wise decision. Maybelline New York offers a wide variety of celebrity-favorite products and their range of eyeliners is one of the best on the market. With some fabulous choices of eyeliner pencils with striking features on offer, you can be certain to find just the one you are looking for. You can pick the water-proof and smudge-proof options that can last for long hours, especially if you are always on the go and hardly get the opportunity to touch up. Smeared eyeliner is something that no one wants, so it is absolutely essential to invest in a product you can trust.

That’s why Maybelline is a great choice. Whether you want bold strokes or clean lines that are tug-free, you can rely on the best Maybelline pencil liners to help you make your vision a reality. We want to help too, so we’ve got the top 10 eyeliner pencils by Maybelline in a carefully selected and reviewed list for you!

Top Picks
CHECK PRICE
Best Long-Lasting Finish:Maybelline New York Unstoppable Eyeliner - Pewter
Price on Amazon
Price on Walmart
Best Sebum-Resistant:Maybelline New York Tattoo Studio - Deep Onyx
Price on Amazon
Price on Walmart
Best Waterproof:Maybelline New York Lasting Drama Light Liner - Twinkle Black
Price on Amazon
Price on Walmart
Best For Precision:Maybelline Master Precise Skinny Automatic Gel Pencil - Defining Black
Price on Amazon
Price on Walmart
Best Smudge-Resistant:Maybelline Lasting Drama By Eyestudio Waterproof Gel Pencil - Glazed Toffee
Price on Amazon
Price on Walmart
Best Blendable:Maybelline New York Line Express Sharpenable Pencil Eyeliner - Brownish Black
Price on Amazon
Price on Walmart
Best For Smokey Eye Look:Maybelline New York Define-A-Line Eyeliner - Brownish Black
Price on Amazon
Price on Walmart
Best For Contact Lens Wearers:Maybelline New York Tattoo Studio Smokey Gel Pencil - Smokey Brown
Price on Amazon
Price on Walmart
Best For Sensitive Skin:Maybelline New York Expert Wear Twin Brow And Eye Pencils - Velvet Black
Price on Amazon
Price on Walmart
Best With An Anti-Slip Grip:Maybelline New York Hyper Easy No Slip Pencil Eyeliner MakeupPrice on Amazon

10 Best Maybelline Eyeliner Pencils For A Ravishing Look

1. Best Long-Lasting Finish:Maybelline New York Unstoppable Eyeliner – Pewter

star-ratingstar-ratingstar-ratingstar-ratingstar-rating
4.5
Maybelline New York Unstoppable Eyeliner – Pewter Image: Maybelline New York

Trust the Maybelline New York Unstoppable Eyeliner in the shade Pewter to give you a long-lasting and smudge-proof finish that is sure to make heads turn. This healthy formula is enriched with nourishing ingredients such as beeswax and aloe leaf extracts to give you a signature eye makeup look. What perhaps makes this the best eyeliner pencil is that it allows superior application control with its mechanical head and delivers a natural and bold finish with its sharp-pointed tip. Online reviews claim that this mechanical eyeliner pencil stays on throughout the day, remains blendable, and offers the perfect shade. You don’t have to worry about anything if you have sensitive eyes because this smudge-proof eyeliner is ophthalmologist-tested and suitable for those who wear contact lenses. You can choose from 5 unique dark and defining shades that will not only highlight your eyes but draw attention to them.

Color: PEWTER | Product Dimensions: 0.41 x 1.88 x 5.63 inches | Weight: 0.27 Ounces

Pros

  • Long-lasting finish
  • Smudge-proof
  • Contains nourishing ingredients
  • Ophthalmologist-tested
  • Waterproof formula
  • Available in 5 shades

Cons

  • The eyeliner tip may be slightly hard.

protip_icon Did You Know?
The Egyptians utilized eyeliner to fend off evil spirits and shield their eyes from the sun’s damaging rays. The eyeliner didn’t arrive in the western world until Tutankhamun’s tomb was found in the 1920s. ⁠ ⁠

2. Best Sebum-Resistant:Maybelline New York Tattoo Studio – Deep Onyx

star-ratingstar-ratingstar-ratingstar-ratingstar-rating
4.3
Maybelline New York TattooStudio Waterproof Gel Eyeliner Image: Maybelline

Who doesn’t love a formula that is smudge-resistant, waterproof, and sebum resistant all in one? The Maybelline New York Tattoo Studio in the shade Deep Onyx comes to you in the form of a sharpenable gel pencil that gives you lasting color for up to 36 hours. You don’t have to worry about your eye makeup fading because this sweat-resistant formula will define your eyes with tattoo intensity. Choose from up to 9 stunning shades of Maybelline’s Tattoo Studio eyeliners that have easy to sharpen and use application tips to give you an ultra-intense color. For a smooth stroke of seamless color, get your hands on the pigment-rich hues that are available for every mood. You may check this video for a better understanding of this smudge-proof eyeliner and to gain insights from a reviewer’s experience with it.

Color: Deep onyx | Product Dimensions: 0.4 x 1.88 x 5.63 inches | Weight: 0.32 Ounces.

Pros

  • Precise definition
  • 36-hour lasting finish
  • Available in 9 shades
  • Waterproof and smudge-proof
  • Sebum-resistant

Cons

  • You may find it slightly challenging to sharpen
worth-buy-icon

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

It has received 28,093 reviews on Amazon and is a popular choice among shoppers.

3. Best Waterproof:Maybelline New York Lasting Drama Light Liner – Twinkle Black

star-ratingstar-ratingstar-ratingstar-ratingstar-rating
4.3
Maybelline New York Lasting Drama Light Liner – Twinkle Black Image: Maybelline New York

Brighten your eyes with the Maybelline New York Lasting Drama Light Liner, available in 5 shades like Lustrous White and Twinkle Black that pops on all skin tones. Highlight the inner corners of eyes for the perfect dramatic look, whether you choose to create layered lines, highlights, or smoldering wings to accentuate them. The waterproof formula stays put on your eyelids for up to 16 hours of intense color. The Maybelline Light Liner has an ultra-smooth glide that not only illuminates and defines with shimmery pigments but also does not smudge or wear off as you go about your day. Reviewers have noted that you get the best that Maybelline has to offer when you choose this automatic pencil that brightens your eyes and lines them with a reflective shimmer. Truly, this black eyeliner is one of our more sought-after Maybelline product recommendations!

Color: Twinkle Black,a 0.01 Ounce | Product Dimensions: 0.41 x 1.88 x 5.63 inches | Weight: 0.01 Ounces

Pros

  • Waterproof technology
  • It lasts up to 16 hours
  • Available in 5 brightening shades
  • Smudge-resistant
  • Dermatologist-tested
  • Highly-reflective shimmer
  • Smooth formula with a self-sharpening tip
  • Complements all skin tones

Cons

  • It may have a slightly cakey texture that sticks to your eyelashes.

protip_icon Fun Fact
Tom Lyle Williams, a young chemist from New York, founded the Maybelline Company in 1915. The business was initially known as Maybell Laboratories, after his sister’s name.

Maybelline New York Unstoppable Eyeliner - Pewter
Best Long-Lasting Finish
Maybelline New York Tattoo Studio - Deep Onyx
Best Sebum-Resistant
Maybelline New York Lasting Drama Light Liner - Twinkle Black
Best Waterproof
Color PEWTER Deep onyx Twinkle Black,a 0.01 Ounce
Dimensions 0.41 x 1.88 x 5.63 inches 0.4 x 1.88 x 5.63 inches 0.41 x 1.88 x 5.63 inches
Weight 0.27 Ounces 0.32 Ounces. 0.01 Ounces
Rating
Reviews17,94628,0933,935
Price$6.48$6.3$19.99

4. Best For Precision:Maybelline Master Precise Skinny Automatic Gel Pencil – Defining Black

star-ratingstar-ratingstar-ratingstar-ratingstar-rating
4.4

Take control and precision into your hands with the Maybelline Master Precise Skinny Automatic Gel Pencil. For a skinny and precise liner look, this smooth gel formula offers an ultra-smooth and mistake-proof application to get an intense color that lasts up to 24 hours. Your upper lash line will be left defined and highlighted as this Maybelline eyeliner pencil has a 1.8mm microtip, designed to be sharp always. Who doesn’t love a formula that glides on effortlessly? This eye look-enhancing product has an easy-to-use twist-up feature and is available in 3 defining shades for you to choose from to give you a demure look. This video review details a tester’s experience with this skinny liner. It will help you learn more about the formula.

Color: Defining Black | Product Dimensions: 0.34 x 1.88 x 5.63 inches | Weight: 0.35 Ounces

Pros

  • For laser-sharp precision
  • Smooth gel intensity
  • Available in 3 shades

Cons

  • The eyeliner tip may easily crumble when used with pressure.

5. Best Smudge-Resistant:Maybelline Lasting Drama By Eyestudio Waterproof Gel Pencil – Glazed Toffee

star-ratingstar-ratingstar-ratingstar-ratingstar-rating
4.3

Get an all-day color that glides on smoothly with the Maybelline Lasting Drama Waterproof Gel Pencil. This statement-making eyeliner has a staying power of up to 16 hours supported by high-intensity pigments. This allergy-tested formula is also ophthalmologist and dermatologist-approved, making it suitable for contact lens wearers and those with sensitive eye areas. The translucent gel base gives you a super easy glide as you sport the waterproof and smudge-resistant formula. For those who want the only drama in their lives to be on their eyes, this Maybelline eyeliner pencil in the shade Glazed Toffee is just the right one to give you a winged eyeliner look. It is a must-have among Maybelline cosmetics!

Color: GLAZED TOFFEE | Product Dimensions: 0.41 x 1.88 x 5.63 inches | Weight: 0.27 Ounces

Pros

  • All-day wear up to 16 hours
  • Ophthalmologist-tested
  • Dermatologist-tested
  • Waterproof and smudge-resistant
  • Intense pigments to create dramatic eye looks

Cons

  • This eyeliner pencil may not stay sharp

6. Best Blendable:Maybelline New York Line Express Sharpenable Pencil Eyeliner – Brownish Black

star-ratingstar-ratingstar-ratingstar-ratingstar-rating
4.3

Creamy, smooth, intense, and blendable are just some of the ways you can describe this magical eyeliner pencil from Maybelline. If you are looking for a color impact that you can use to create any liner effect ranging from subtle to intense, this pencil liner is a must-have. The sharpenable wood pencil eyeliner is available in 3 perfect shades, including brownish-black, ebony black, and soft black, so you can pick one that best defines your eyes and gives you celebrity makeup looks. Reviewers have recommended this sharpenable eyeliner for those who love the mesmerizing classic smudged eyeliner look. This affordable eyeliner is one of the best Maybelline eyeliner pencils as it comes with an in-built contour smudge tool as well.

Color: Brownish Black | Product Dimensions: 0.5 x 1.9 x 5.75 inches | Weight: 0.2 Ounces.

Pros

  • Intense and smooth finish
  • Easy to blend
  • Available in 3 unique shades
  • Ophthalmologist-tested
  • Suitable for those who wear contact lens

Cons

  • This eyeliner pencil may require more frequent reapplication for lasting color.

7. Best For Smokey Eye Look:Maybelline New York Define-A-Line Eyeliner – Brownish Black

star-ratingstar-ratingstar-ratingstar-ratingstar-rating
4.5

Get yourself a starry eyeliner that glides on smoothly and precisely in just one stroke with the expertly crafted Maybelline New York Define-A-Line Eyeliner. Infused with nourishing ingredients like castor seed oil and jojoba seed oil, this super-enriching formula is safe to use around your eyes. The mechanical pencil liner helps create defined eye looks that leave your eyes feeling highlighted and beautiful. It is also ideal for that perfect winged eyeliner look. This bold eyeliner pencil comes with a contoured smudger that makes blending easy so you can get a pro-smokey eye look at your fingertips. You can jump onto the bandwagon of subtle and sexy or dramatic and demure eyeliners by switching it up with this Maybelline eyeliner pencil. If you’re someone with sensitive eyes, then you need a precision eyeliner that is ophthalmologist-tested for safety. This is where this product comes in your aid, even if you are a contact lens wearer.

Color: Brownish Black | Product Dimensions: 0.41 x 1.88 x 5.63 inches | Weight: 0.34 Ounces

Pros

  • Easy to remove
  • Smooth and precise strokes
  • Contains natural ingredients
  • It comes with a contoured smudger
  • Ophthalmologist-tested

Cons

  • This eyeliner pencil isn’t waterproof and may fade quickly.

8. Best For Contact Lens Wearers:Maybelline New York Tattoo Studio Smokey Gel Pencil – Smokey Brown

star-ratingstar-ratingstar-ratingstar-ratingstar-rating
4.4

Are you heading out to a party with your friends or a fancy dinner date and want to impress? A smokey eye is a great way to draw the focus to your eyes. With the Maybelline New York Tattoo Studio Smokey Gel Pencil, you can create a lasting impression. The blendable mechanical gel liner is available in 3 shades, including a classic Smokey Brown, suitable for all skin tones. This Maybelline brown eyeliner pencil is smudge-proof, waterproof, and lasts long for a smoldering eye makeup look. In addition, you get to be the judge of how smokey and blurred you want your eyes to appear with the matte eyeliner. You can even control your gel liner with the easy-to-use and controllable application tip for precision with the outer corner of your eye. All in all, this smudge-proof eyeliner is a must-have in your beauty routine!

Color: Smokey Brown | Product Dimensions: 0.4 x 1.88 x 5.68 inches | Weight: 0.32 Ounces.

Pros

  • Ophthalmologist-tested
  • Suitable for contact lens wearers
  • Smudgeproof and waterproof
  • Blendable formula
  • Glides on smoothly
  • Available in 3 shades

Cons

  • It may feel slightly waxy on your skin.

9. Best For Sensitive Skin:Maybelline New York Expert Wear Twin Brow And Eye Pencils – Velvet Black

star-ratingstar-ratingstar-ratingstar-ratingstar-rating
4.6

Shape your brows or define your eyes with the Maybelline New York Expert Wear Twin Brow And Eye Pencils in this combo pack. The blendable color is perfect for filling in your eyebrows or lining your lids with smooth precision. Either way, your eyes will do the talking because this Maybelline eyeliner pencil is waterproof and meant for long wear. This Maybelline eyeliner pencil has additional beneficial skin-loving properties with a nourishing formula containing Japanese fruit wax, palm oil, cottonseed oil, and soybean oil. This allergy-tested formula is suitable for those who wear contact lenses and have sensitive eyes. You can choose from a range of up to 5 shades, including Velvet Black and Dark Brown, to compliment your eyebrow makeup and get a sultry look.

Color: 101 Velvet Black

Pros

  • Dual-purpose wooden eye pencils
  • Combo pack
  • Water-resistant formula
  • Suitable for sensitive skin
  • Allergy-tested
  • Available in 5 shades

Cons

  • You may have to sharpen this eyeliner pen frequently.

10. Best With An Anti-Slip Grip:Maybelline New York Hyper Easy No Slip Pencil Eyeliner Makeup

star-ratingstar-ratingstar-ratingstar-ratingstar-rating
3.5
Maybelline New York Hyper Easy No Slip Pencil Eyeliner Makeup Image: Maybelline New York

The Maybelline New York Hyper Easy No Slip Pencil Eyeliner Makeup guarantees flawless application every time. From subtle to dramatic wings, you can create versatile looks with this Maybelline waterproof eyeliner. Its gel-like formula infused with the goodness of argan oil delivers exceptional results. The formula glides over your eyes and defines them without irritating your skin. It is perfect for long wear and humid climates. This waterproof eyeliner pencil is tested by ophthalmologists and is perfectly suitable for application on sensitive skin and while wearing contact lenses.

Color: 003 MEDIUM BROWN | Product Dimensions: 0.32 x 1.88 x 5.63 inches | Weight: 0.33 Ounces.

Pros

  • Waterproof
  • Suitable for sensitive skin
  • Suitable for contact lenses
  • Easy to apply
  • Infused with argan oil
  • Ophthalmologists-tested

Cons

  • None
*The prices provided in this article are based on the latest available information. However, they may vary due to changes in pricing by the seller and/or promotional offers.

So there you have it! Choose from the list of 10 best Maybelline eyeliner pencils, and be assured that your eye makeup will remain bold and enticing! If you’re wondering what to consider when choosing the right eyeliner pencil for you, we’ve wound up some factors to help you.

Things To Consider Before Buying A Maybelline Eyeliner Pencil

  • Application

When choosing an eyeliner pen from this celebrity-endorsed brand, the most important thing to consider is the kind of softness that the product delivers. You will want to pick an eyeliner pencil that will give you a smooth finish without pulling or dragging your skin. The best Maybelline eyeliner pencils give you the benefits of a smooth application process, and what’s more, they can even be amped up to create a more bold and smokey look if that’s something you are looking for. Most of these eyeliner pencils are relatively easy to use and can either be sharpened or come with a twist-up cap to secure them.

  • Smudge-proof formula

A dash of eyeliner can easily brighten up your entire face, and finding the best eyeliner is essential for you. A smudge-proof formula that comes in a pencil eyeliner like those that Maybelline has to offer will give you a simple and naturally bold look. Opt for a recipe that stays put round the clock, so you don’t have to worry about it smudging and ruining your entire eye makeup. An opaque eyeliner pencil will give you a fuller color and remains dark and luscious throughout the day. Rain or snow, the best Maybelline eyeliner pencils are made for extended wear and are a must-have in your daily makeup kit.

  • Waterproof and sweatproof

Apart from being smudge-proof, your eyeliner pencil will go a long way if they are waterproof and sweatproof as well. These good-quality liners do not fade away quickly when your skin comes in contact with water or sweat. So don’t worry about leaving behind tear stains or washed away eyeliner with one of the Maybelline eyeliner pencils. Instead, stand your ground against bad weather or pollution when you opt for a pencil eyeliner that does not require you to touch up frequently. Maybelline offers water-resistant and long-lasting eyeliners that are skin-friendly as well as super easy to apply.

Tight eyeliner on the waterlines of the eye has been trending,” says makeup artist, Tommy Tafoya. “Just remember, waterproof formulas won’t adhere to your water line, and choose accordingly!

  • Skin-friendly ingredients

If you’re going to invest in a makeup product, one of the foremost factors that you will need to consider is the ingredients that go into making the product. Starting from what benefits the components will have for you and your skin, you can opt for ones that contain natural ingredients that do not pose a threat to your skin. You can get an eyeliner hypoallergenic and safe to use around your eyes if you are someone with sensitive skin. Those eyeliners that are dermatologist-approved also work well to give you the color and highlight that your eyes need. Add these liners to your enhanced beauty routine if you want products that do not strip your skin of any moisture or cause any harm.

The Bottom Line

Maybelline has become one of the most trusted cosmetic brands, and when it comes to eyeliner pencils, makeup enthusiasts swear by the ones from Maybelline. They offer a bold color payoff in just a single stroke. In addition, the smudge-proof and waterproof eyeliners last for long hours. The Maybelline New York Unstoppable Eyeliner-Pewter has a long-lasting formula and gives a natural and bold finish while the Maybelline Lasting Drama By Eyestudio Waterproof Gel Pencil-Glazed Toffee has a unique color that adds depth to your makeup and is suitable for those who wear contact lens. The Maybelline New York Hyper Easy No Slip Pencil Eyeliner Makeup has a non-irritating formula and is easy to apply. These eyeliner pencils come with convenient tips to make them more user-friendly and offer you a smooth and flawless stroke. You can also choose from a wide range of colorful, intensely pigmented, shimmery, and pointed self-sharpening tips. While buying a Maybelline eyeliner pencil, make sure you consider the ease of application and key ingredients of the product.

Frequently Asked Questions

How can you sharpen Maybelline eyeliner pencils without breaking them?

It is important to choose a cosmetic sharpener instead of an ordinary pencil sharpener to avoid breaking or other damages.

Are Maybelline eyeliner pencils good?

Yes, Maybelline eyeliner pencils are super long-lasting and offer you a precise and sharp look.

How to use Maybelline eyeliner pencil?

Glide the Maybelline eyeliner pencil along your waterline from one end to the other. You can repeat the process multiple times to get a darker line.

Are Maybelline eyeliners hypoallergenic?

Yes, most Maybelline eyeliners are hypoallergenic and safe for sensitive eyes.

How do you sharpen Maybelline eyeliner pencils?

You can use a eyeliner pencil sharpener with a stainless steel blade to sharpen Maybelline eyeliner pencils.

Are Maybelline products tested on animals?

No. For most products, Maybelline does not carry out animal testing. However, Maybelline also has a market in countries that mandate animal testing as per their law.

Do Maybelliners eyeliners have oil?

No. Maybelline eyeliners are oil-free to make them smudge-proof and long-lasting.

Why Trust StyleCraze?

The author of this article, Srijita De, is a makeup enthusiast. She loves to explore various makeup products and keeps up with the latest trends. The list of Maybelline eyeliner pencils is curated after thorough research and consideration of many online reviews on trusted platforms. These eyeliner pencils are easy to use and save a lot of time.


Recommended Articles

Tommy Tafoya

Tommy TafoyaMakeup Artist

Tommy is a New York-based makeup artist with over a decade of experience. He originally hails from Los Angeles and Tokyo and is largely inspired by color, organic life, and spirituality. Tommy has been featured in prestigious publications like Vogue Runway, Vogue Italia, Vanguard, Playbill, and Worldwide, among others. He has worked at several New York Fashion weeks and feels...read full bio

Latest Articles