5 Best Semi-Permanent Eyeliners Of 2023

Carve those beautiful, bold wings and stunning cat eyes without worries of smudging.

Reviewed by Pilar DeMann Pilar DeMann, Makeup Artist
By Baishali Bhattacharya Baishali Bhattacharya, Certified Image Consultant, Certified In Makeup Artistry • Mar 13, 2023

All products recommended on StyleCraze are independently selected by our editorial team. If you make a purchase through any of these links, we may receive a commission. Learn more about our product selection process here.

The worst fear of eyeliner lovers is halfway wearing off of the product when you have to look your best. That’s when you should put your trust in some of the best semi-permanent eyeliners. You don’t have to worry about it smudging away at the end of the day as it remains strongly intact. It also highlights your eyes beautifully instead of leaving gaps in between. No amount of sweating, rainwater, or crying can make it run down, that’s the guarantee. Here are the 5 best semi-permanent eyeliners for you to choose from.

Top Picks	Check Price
Best Long-Lasting:Stargazer Semi-Permanent Eyeliner Pen	Price on Amazon
Best Waterproof:Maybelline New York Tattoo Studio Liquid Ink Liner	Price on Amazon
Best Smudge-Proof:NYX Professional Makeup Epic Wear Eye & Body Liquid Liner	Price on Amazon
Best For Sensitive Skin:Blinc Brush-On Slide IT Off! Eyeliner	Price on Amazon
Best Fragrance-Free:Magic Stylo Semi Permanent Makeup Pen	Price on Amazon

In This Article

5 Best Semi-Permanent Eyeliners Of 2023

1. Best Long-Lasting:Stargazer Semi-Permanent Eyeliner Pen

3.5

Image: Stargazer

BUY ON AMAZON | $5.25

The Stargazer Semi-Permanent Eyeliner Pen offers you a super precise, dramatic eyeliner look. The ultra-fine tip glides smoothly and delivers rich color in a single stroke. This eyeliner is waterproof and smudge-proof and lasts up to 24 long hours. The felt tip is reversible and helps create accurate lines and shading. This video helps you know more about the product.

Pilar DiMann, a makeup artist with 30 years of experience, says, “I suggest pre-drawing your line with your favorite liner, then applying the waterproof liquid over it as it has strong holding power. That way, your lines are clean and clear.”

Pros

Reversible tip
Long-lasting
Easy to remove
Easy to apply
Value for money
Affordable
Waterproof
Smudge-proof

Cons

None

Pro Tip

If you don’t have micellar water, dab some coconut oil on a cotton pad to gently remove the eyeliner. Follow it up with a mild cleanser.

Price at the time of publication: $5.25

Buy on Amazon | $5.25

2. Best Waterproof:Maybelline New York Tattoo Studio Liquid Ink Liner

4.1

BUY ON AMAZON | $7.98

This long-lasting eyeliner by Maybelline New York is resistant to sebum, tears, sweat, and water. The intense liquid formula offers a tattoo-like definition and lasts up to 36 hours. This eyeliner has a smooth and creamy texture that glides along your eyelids easily. One stroke of this eyeliner delivers rich pigments for a bold look. The liner brush is shaped precisely to provide an expert finish. Check out this video to know more about this product.

Pros

Easy to remove
Sweat-resistant
Smudge resistant
Fade-resistant
Waterproof
Dries quickly
Lasts up to 36 hours
Available in three shades

Cons

May irritate the skin

Pro Tip

Apply an eye cream 5 to 10 minutes before using this eyeliner to prevent skin irritation.

Price at the time of publication: $7.98

Buy on Amazon | $7.98

3. Best Smudge-Proof:NYX Professional Makeup Epic Wear Eye & Body Liquid Liner

4.2

BUY ON AMAZON | $9.95

Indulge in a luxuriously rich and bold look with this liquid gel liner by NYX Professional Makeup. This eyeliner can be used on the eyelids and body. The unique felt tip ensures easy and precise application for any make up look. The long-lasting formula can stay on for up to three days. This product offers a matte finish that looks elegant and chic. Before buying, have a look at this video for more details.

Pros

Flake-free
Liquid-gel formula
Matte finish
Bleed-proof
Flexible applicator
Waterproof
Smudge-proof
Cruelty-free
Available in multiple shades

Cons

None

Price at the time of publication: $9.95

Buy on Amazon | $9.95

4. Best For Sensitive Skin:Blinc Brush-On Slide IT Off! Eyeliner

4.1

BUY ON AMAZON | $24

The blinc Brush-On Slide IT Off! Eyeliner is a must-have in your vanity. The long-wear formula is water-resistant and does not fade, smudge, or flake. The richly pigmented color helps define your eyes beautifully. This eyeliner is easy to apply and provides precise application in a single stroke.

Pros

Water-resistant
Easy to remove
Fade-proof
Smudge-proof
Run-proof
Smear-proof
Suitable for sensitive skin types

Cons

Takes time to dry

Price at the time of publication: $24

Buy on Amazon | $24

5. Best Fragrance-Free:Magic Stylo Semi Permanent Makeup Pen

4.1

BUY ON AMAZON | $19.95

This unique wink eyeliner acts as a lip liner, eyelash enhancer, eye shadow, and temporary body tattoo. The eyeliner pen is super flexible and enables a smooth and consistent application. This product provides rich, bold color in a single swipe that lasts for up to 24 hours.

Pros

Smudge-proof
Easy to apply
Fragrance-free
Non-sticky
Lasts for 24 hours
Available in various shades

Cons

Comes off easy

Price at the time of publication: $19.95

Buy on Amazon | $19.95

A long-wear eyeliner that requires no touch-ups is a must-have in every makeup enthusiast’s kitty. Read on to find out what you should consider before buying one.

Things To Consider Before Buying A Semi-Permanent Eyeliner

Color

The first and most important thing you need to decide is the color of the semi-permanent eyeliner. You can choose a good old black liner for everyday use. If you want your eyes to stand out during special occasions, go for other vibrant colors such as intense brown, dark green, or royal blue.

Durability

If an eyeliner does not stay for long and smudges, flakes, or transfers easily, it will ruin your look. Always check if your product is resistant to water, tear, sweat. Opt for a smudge-proof, transfer-proof, and flake-proof eyeliner. Also, your semi-permanent eyeliner should last not less than 24 hours.

Applicator

The most common types of applicators are liquid liners or felt tip liners. Different types of eyeliner applicators help achieve different thicknesses. For instance, felt tip liners create a thick and soft line, whereas ultra-thin tip liners give you sharp and thin lines.

Grip

If the brush or pen is heavy and thick, it will be uncomfortable to draw a perfect line. You might also find it difficult to rotate or move the liner to make a precise wink. Thus, choose a semi-permanent eyeliner that you can control easily.

Price

Make sure you select a product that is superior in quality and justifies the price. If you end up going for a cheaper option, you might end up with a non-effective formula.

Eyeliners elevate the overall eye makeup look. It helps to define and highlight your eyes. Unlike regular eyeliners, semi-permanent eyeliners last longer and are smudge-resistant. If you are looking for an eyeliner that requires no reapplication, you should consider semi-permanent eyeliner. These eyeliner pens have a sharp tip and deliver rich color. In addition, the creamy texture of these semi-eyeliners glide smoothly over the eyes. Some eyeliners listed in our article offer 24 hours of protection, while others offer 36 hours of smudge-resistance. However, stay away from the eyeliners that irritate your skin.

Why Trust StyleCraze?

The author of this article, Baishali Bhattacharya, is certified in makeup artistry. She has curated this list of the best semi-permanent eyeliners after carefully browsing online reviews. These products are smudge-proof and easy to remove. Not only are these semi-permanent eyeliners budget-friendly but also they are fade-resistant and available in many shades.