11 Best Pizza Pans (2024) – Reviews And Buying Guide

Sometimes the cheesiest, most delicious, and greasiest pizza is all you need to uplift your mood. However, your local pizza place might not always be open when you get pizza cravings. On such days, you need the best pizza pan to make this exquisite Italian dish and an American favorite at home. A pizza pan helps you make a perfectly shaped and yummy-looking dish. There are many types of pizza pans available based on the thickness, surface style, and material of the pan. All the above factors determine the longevity of the utensil. Let us now have a look at some of the best pizza-baking pans along with their reviews. Keep scrolling!

11 Best Pizza Pans – Reviews

1. Best Overall:Cuisinart AMB-14PP Chef’s Classic Nonstick Bakeware 14-Inch Pizza Pan

4.6

Image: Cuisinart

BUY ON AMAZON | $14.99

Cuisinart Chef’s Classic 14-Inch Pizza Pan is the perfect choice for home chefs. This round pizza pan is made of heavy-gauge aluminized steel and contains a non-stick surface to provide even heat distribution and consistent baking results. The extra-thick rolled edges prevent warping. Being a trusted brand, Cuisinart promises a lifetime of great baking time with this pizza pan.

Features

• Dimensions: 15 x 14.4 x 1 inches
• Weight: 1.14 pounds
• Heavy gauge (1.0 mm)
• Holes for even heat flow
• Aluminized steel construction for even heating
• Whit ford Xylan non-stick interior and exterior
• Limited lifetime warranty

Stylecraze Trivia

During the 1970s, Cuisinart rose to fame due to its association with celebrity chefs such as James Beard.

2. Best Durable:Wilton Premium Non-Stick Bakeware 14-Inch Pizza Pan

4.6

Image: Wilton

BUY ON AMAZON | $40.87

The Wilton Premium Non-Stick Pizza Pan is the perfect pan to get nice, crisp results each time you prepare pizzas, thanks to it being a powerful conductor of heat. This also pan cuts down on your cooking time. This 14-inch size flat pan has a smooth and even surface and a very thin lip, which allows your pizzas to slide off very easily once they are ready to be served.

Features

• Dimensions: 14.1 x 0.36 x 14.1 inches
• Weight: 1.15 pounds
• Silicone polyester coating
• Flat, even surface
• Limited 5-year warranty

3. Best Easy To Clean:American Metalcraft TP6 6-Inch Wide Rim Pizza Pan

4.3

Image: American Metalcraft, Inc.

BUY ON AMAZON | $4.9

The pizza industry has trusted American Metalcraft since 1947. Their signature TP6 pizza pan is very reliable and durable because of its heavy-duty 18-gauge aluminum construction. With 70 years of service, American Metalcraft is a leader in the food service industry for trend-focused and unique products.

Features

• Dimensions: 6 x 6 x 0.38 inches
• Weight: 1.6 ounces
• Heavy-duty 18-gauge aluminum
• Hand-wash only
• Range of size options

Fun Fact

The world’s most giant pizza, in the Guinness Book of World Records, had a surface area of 13,580 ft.

	Cuisinart AMB-14PP Chef's Classic Nonstick Bakeware 14-Inch Pizza Pan Best Overall	Wilton Premium Non-Stick Bakeware 14-Inch Pizza Pan Best Durable	American Metalcraft TP6 6-Inch Wide Rim Pizza Pan Best Easy To Clean
	Buy Now	Buy Now	Buy Now
Weight	-	1.19 Pounds	‎1.76 ounces
Dimensions	-	0.36"D x 14.1"W x 14.1"H	‎6"D x 6"W x 0.38"H
Shape	-	Round	Round
Color	-	Silver	Silver
Material	-	Steel.	Aluminum
Rating
Reviews	8,271	9,215	12,099
Price	$14.99	$40.87	$4.9

4. Best Value For Money:G & S Metal ProBake 16″Teflon Pizza Baking Pan

4.5

BUY ON AMAZON | $24.73

Whether you like your pizza frozen, fresh, or reheated from the night before, the ProBake Non-Stick 16” Pizza Pan has got your back. It is tested and trusted by many reviewers for doing an impressive job at baking or reheating thin-crust pizza evenly while giving it the most crunchy crust.

Features

• Dimensions: 16 x 16 x 1 inches
• Weight: 3.34 pounds
• Teflon Xtra non-stick finish
• 10-year limited warranty

5. Best Easy Release Surface:Chicago Metallic Deep Dish Pizza Pan

4.7

Now 17% Off

BUY ON AMAZON | $18.32

The Chicago Metallic Deep Dish Pizza Pan is great for cooking Chicago-style deep dish pizzas. It is also a great pan for preparing a cookie pie, stuffed pizzas, or any other kind of pies at home. It is durable and strong due to its heavy-duty carbon steel surface. Though it is dishwasher-safe, it is recommended to wash this pan by hand to extend its life. The product has garnered rave reviews for being easy to use and even heat distribution ability.

Features

• Dimensions: 14 x 14 x 1.5 inches
• Weight: 1.85 pounds
• Silicone-based non-stick surface
• Smooth, flat surface
• Made from heavy-duty carbon steel
• Dishwasher-friendly

6. Best For Faster Baking:New Star Foodservice 50721 Restaurant-Grade Aluminum Pizza Pan

4.3

BUY ON AMAZON | $17.97

Pizza pans are very helpful in preparing restaurant-grade pizzas at home. The New Star Restaurant-Grade Pizza Pan is an economical choice, offering you the convenience of baking and serving pizzas in the same pan. Thus, you can cut down on a number of steps and save time. This pan offers even heat distribution and allows you to bake both mini and large pizzas faster so you can serve your guests fresh pizzas in no time.

Features

• Dimensions: 8 x 8 x 1 inches
• Weight: 0.8 ounces
• Made of commercial-grade aluminum
• Gently sloped edge

7. Best Warp-Resistant:LloydPans Kitchenware Detroit Style Pizza Pan

4.7

Image: Lloydpans Kitchenware

BUY ON AMAZON | $33.93

LloydPans Kitchenware Detroit Style Pizza Pan provides easy release from the pan after baking. It is metal utensil-safe and easy to clean with its non-stick coating. This Detroit-style pizza pan does not require any pre-seasoning before use. It has the exclusive Dura-Kote finish that is permanent, non-toxic, and stick-resistant. It eliminates the hassle of maintaining seasoned pans.

This expert-recommended, commercial-quality pan is the same as used in Detroit-style pizza restaurants. It is made of heavy-duty anodized aluminum and manufactured in the USA. Tested and trusted by many reviewers, it does not rust and lasts for years. It is made at a nesting 76° angle that allows nesting when empty, thus saving storage space

Features

• Dimensions: 8 x 10 x 2.25 inches
• Weight: 1.42 pound
• Non-stick coating
• Ready to use
• Heat-safe up to 700° F

8. Best Non-Stick Surface:USA Pan Bakeware Aluminized Steel Pizza Pan

4.6

Image: Usa Pan

BUY ON AMAZON | $20.84

The USA Pan 12-inch Pizza Pan provides an easy baking time experience. It is coated with AMERICOAT Plus, a patented non-stick silicone that allows you to release the pizza easily from the pan and gives you an easy clean-up experience. This non-stick coating is PTFE-, PFOA-, and BPA-free.

Every USA Pan is made with aluminized steel and heavy-gauge steel construction that provides even heat distribution and maximum service life. This product’s unique fluted surface design facilitates air circulation and maximizes pan strength, which aids the resistance to warping. This professionally tested and trusted product offers even heat distribution, enabling faster cooking.

Features

• Dimensions: 12.5 x 12.5 x 0.2 inches
• Weight: 1.55 pounds
• AMERICOAT Plus non-stick coating
• Unique fluted design
• Aluminized steel construction
• Limited lifetime warranty

9. Best Dishwasher-Safe:Calphalon 1893302 16-Inch Non-Stick Pizza Pan

4.6

BUY ON AMAZON | $24.99

Get delectable results with the Calphalon Non-Stick Pizza Pan. Its toffee-colored surface with a non-stick coating releases baked goods easily for flawless results. Its heavyweight construction facilitates even heating and long life. This 16-inch pizza pan has perforations all over its surface that circulate air to give your homemade or store-bought frozen pizzas a perfectly baked base. This product is dishwasher-safe, which makes it easy to clean. It is oven-safe up to 450° F. Moreover, this high quality pizza pan has received positive reviews from numerous users for its mess-free functioning and non-stick design.

Features

• Dimensions: 16 x 16 x 0.5 inches
• Weight: 1.45 pounds
• Perforated surface
• Non-stick coating
• Dishwasher-safe
• 10-year limited warranty

10. Best Rust-Free: CROWN Cookware Solid Pizza Pan

4.4

Image: Crown Cookware

BUY ON AMAZON | $18.95

The CROWN Cookware Solid Pizza Pan is designed with a smooth finish with high-quality virgin aluminum. The set includes two 16-inches pizza pans with a high quality baking surface that you can use for home and professional baking. You can conveniently bake thin or thick-crust pizza and enjoy it with your friends and family. These quality-tested and high quality pans provide even heat distribution, don’t crack or chip, and are easy to clean.

Features

• Dimensions: 16 x 16 x 0.4 inches
• Weight: 1.34 pounds
• Designed for multiple uses
• Made of food-grade virgin aluminium
• Good heat conductivity for even baking

11. Best Portable:Deedro 12-Inch Stainless Steel Pizza Pan

4.5

BUY ON AMAZON | $19.99

Deedro 12-Inch Pizza Pan is made of pure stainless steel and does not have any toxic substances or chemical coating, thus bringing you a healthier baking experience. Its high quality baking surface and heavy-gauge steel makes it stable, rust-resistant, and durable. Its gently sloped edge allows you to completely cover your pizza’s crust with toppings and prevents them from falling out. Trusted by many reviewers for its multifunctionality, you can use this pizza pan to prepare, bake, slice, and serve the pizza. All in one go!

Features

• Dimensions: 12 x 12 x 0.7 inches
• Weight: 13.4 ounces
• Mirror finish for less sticking
• Made of pure stainless steel
• Gently sloped edges

Now that you know all about the pizza pans available right now, let’s check out all the things you need to consider before buying one in the buying guide below.

Pizza Pans – Buying Guide

Pizza-making is an art that needs to be perfected in order to enjoy this scrumptious delicacy. So when you are looking for a pizza pan, always look for one that best suits your taste and preferences. Here are a few factors that you need to answer to make a well-informed decision.

• Different Types Of Pizza Pans

You must consider what type of pizzas you want to make before zeroing in on a pizza pan. Some main types of pizza pans include:

• Deep Dish Pizza Pan: They have high side walls and are used to make Chicago-style pizzas. They may come in a round or a square shape.
• Pizza Screen/Disk: These pans have a mesh bottom for easy heat transfer. They are great for making crispy thin-crust pizzas.
• Pizza Stone: It is made of ceramic or cordierite and has a porous surface that absorbs excess moisture from the crust to make it crispy.
• Wide Rim Pizza Pan: It makes handling, slicing, and serving a pizza super easy.
• Cast Iron Pizza Pan: It can be used on any cooking surface – grill, oven, broiler, stovetop.
• Cutter/CAR Pizza Pan: It has a curved edge that is suitable for baking rolled pizza dough.
• Regular (Coupe) Pizza Pan: It is very durable and easy for baking and serving pizza.

• Surface Of The Pan
  • Perforated Surface: This kind of pizza pan has several holes all over the surface. These holes are supposed to help cook the crust evenly by letting heat directly come in contact with the crust through the holes.
  • Solid Surface: A pizza pan that has a smooth, even surface is called a non-perforated or solid surface pan. The metal with which such pans are constructed plays an important role in creatinga crispy, crunchy, and evenly cooked crusts. These pizza pans should be constructed with heavy-gauge metals that are powerful conductors of heat. Such pans are usually constructed with steel, aluminum, or cast iron.
  • Fluted Surface: A pizza pan that has a fluted or ridged surface helps in the even distribution of heat. It also makes it easy to release the pizza from the pan once it is baked to perfection. One downside of such pans could be that they can be hard to clean if any small pieces of food get stuck in between the grooves of the pan.

• Material
  • Stainless Steel Pans: Stainless steel pizza pans usually do not have any kind of non-stick coating on them. They have a mirror finish that makes it easy to clean and easily release the pizza from the pan when it is greased properly with oil, shortening, butter, or flour.
  • Aluminum Pans: Aluminum pans may or may not have a non-stick coating on them. Since aluminum is a weak metal, it is known to get scratched and stained easily. Apart from that, it is also not safe for the dishwasher. If you are looking for a cheap alternate for a pizza pan, go for an aluminum pan.
  • Cast Iron Pans: Cast iron pans are supposed to be the most durable of the lot. They are heavy-duty pans that need to be seasoned from time to time. Linseed oil is very commonly used to season cast iron surfaces. Though these pans do not have any non-stick coating on them, their grooved surface makes it easy to lift off the pizza without any sticking.

• Shape Of The Pan
  • Flat Edge Pan: A pizza pan that has a completely flat edge with little to no lip can be used as a pizza pan itself or even a pizza peel to slid off your pizza from a hot surface. Flat edge pans effortlessly release your pizza when you first get it out of the oven. Though this can be convenient for some people, others may find this dangerous as the pizza can slide off and onto the floor if you are not careful.
  • Sloped Edge Pizza Pans: A pizza pan that has a sloped edge is perfect for people who like their pizza base to be entirely covered with cheese and other toppings. The sloped edge keeps the toppings in place and does not let them fall out.
  • Deep Dish Pizza Pans: Deep dish pizza pans are perfect for anyone who enjoys a hearty amount of toppings and cheese on their pizzas. It is important to check that such deep dish pizza pans are made of great-quality metals that are good conductors of heat in order to cook the crust completely throughout, while not burning the edges. What is great about these pans is that they can also be used to make a variety of savory as well as sweet dishes, such as lasagna and pies.

• Non-Stick Coating
  • Teflon Coating: This kind of non-stick coating is made from a chemical called PTFE, which is also known as Teflon. It makes cooking and washing up fast and easy. However, Teflon has become quite infamous in recent times for releasing harmful gases when exposed to very high temperatures. Needless to say, the Teflon cookware being manufactured today is completely safe for normal home cooking as long as the temperature does not exceed 570° F (300° C).
  • PTFE-Free Non-Stick Coating: There are many different kinds of non-stick coatings, such as silicone-based coating, Dura-Kote finish, etc. Many people prefer these coatings as they are PTFE-free. Thus, they are safer and easier to maintain. These permanently coated pans also do not require any seasoning of linseed or any other oil.
  • Mirror Finish: This kind of finish is usually done on stainless steel pans. It offers ease of cleaning and helps release the pizza easily once it is baked. It should be kept in mind, however, that these pans should always be greased with some kind of oil, butter, shortening, or a dusting of flour before setting the pizza base on it to prevent it from sticking to the pan.
  • Size: You should check the measurements of your oven before buying a pizza pan to make sure that the pan will fit in it. There is a wide range of sizes options to choose from, so make sure you do not order a pan that is too big for your oven. If you prefer smaller pizzas, you can also check if you can fit two pans side by side in your oven.

Here are a couple of questions that you also need to answer before you buy a pizza pan.

Why Do You Need The Best Pizza Pan In Your Kitchen?

The answer to this question is simple – when you invest in a superior-quality pizza pan, you not only get evenly cooked pizza crusts every single time, but the pan itself lasts for years, thus adding value to the money you spent on it.

How Do You Clean A Pizza Pan?

The best way to clean a pizza pan is to understand what it is made of and to follow its cleaning instructions.

• Pizza pans that have a non-stick coating should never be washed in a dishwasher as it may corrode the coating and ruin your pan. They should also not be scrubbed harshly. Use a sponge and some soapy water to clean these pans as they are supposed to be “easy to clean.”
• Stainless steel pizza pans can usually be washed in the dishwasher. However, it is best to read the instructions of the product beforehand to be on the safer side.
• Cast iron and pre-seasoned pans should never be washed with lots of water. They should only be cleaned lightly with a damp washcloth. This is the only way to protect its seasoning and prevent it from staining.

Infographic: How To Clean An Aluminum Pizza Pan

Everyone loves pizza but not many like scrubbing out the stubborn grease left on the pizza pan. But don’t worry! The infographic below has a step-by-step guide to make your metal pizza pan shine like a new one. Check it out!

Illustration: StyleCraze Design Team

The Bottom Line

Although selecting a pizza pan may seem like a difficult task, it mostly boils down to one question – What kind of pizza do you enjoy? Once you know the answer to this question, it is fairly easy to choose between a perforated pan that makes crispy crusts or a deep dish pizza pan to make Chicago-style pizzas. All you have to do then is select the one that best suits your needs. The Cuisinart AMB-14PP Chef’s Classic Nonstick Bakeware 14-Inch Pizza Pan has a perforated base, making it perfect for a crispy crust. For easy release without pre-seasoning, go for the LloydPans Kitchenware Detroit Style Pizza Pan, while the Wilton Premium Non-Stick Bakeware 14-Inch Pizza Pan is durable, dishwasher safe, and offers even heat distribution. Grab a pan from the ones listed above to get cooking right away!

Frequently Asked Questions

Are aluminum pizza pans safe?

Aluminum cookware poses no health risks. However, it can be fragile and using metal cutting tools on it may possibly wear off minuscule pieces of aluminum that might get onto your food. Therefore, proper precautions should be taken to not scratch the surface of aluminum bakeware.

Can pizza pans be stored easily?

Most pizza pans can easily be tucked away into your kitchen cabinet. However, the kind of non-stick coating of your pizza pan should be kept in mind. Be sure that your pizza pan does not come in direct contact with any sharp objects or anything that can scratch its non-stick surface.
Another important point to keep in mind before storing your pizza pan is that it should be completely dry. Any moisture on the pan can damage its surface and make it rust or stain.

Is a cast iron pizza pan as good as a stone?

Yes. A cast iron pizza pan is pre-seasoned with vegetable oil. So, it is easier to clean than stone ones as sticky elements and oil do not seep in. They can be scrubbed with steel chain cleaners or salt and brush.

What do you put on pizza pans to keep them from sticking?

Sprinkle flour or cornmeal on the pan to keep your dough from sticking.

Is there a pizza pan designed for the maximum crust?

Yes. The Wilton Premium Non-Stick Bakeware 14-Inch Pizza Pan is an excellent choice for the maximum crust.

Why Trust StyleCraze?

The author, Pratyasha Ray, is enthusiastic about all things related to home and the kitchen. She loves to explore various products and appliances. After thorough research and reading many customer feedbacks on various trusted platforms online, she has compiled the list of best pizza pans. These pans are non-stick, easy to clean, and durable.

Recommended Articles:

• Best Heat Resistant Gloves for Grilling
• Best Heated Gloves That’ll Keep Your Hands Warm!
• Best Energy-Efficient Convection Microwaves

The following two tabs change content below.

• Author
• Editor
• Fact-checker

Pratyasha RayCommerce Writer

 

Pratyasha has a master's degree in English from the University Of Calcutta, West Bengal, and is an avid lover of art and literature. She has over two years of experience in writing articles across beauty and lifestyle, and she curates and reviews products and appliances that make the readers’ household chores easy and keep their homes running smoothly. She started...more

Medha DebCommerce Editor

Medha Deb is a commerce editor with a master's degree in applied linguistics from the University of Hyderabad, which has allowed her to develop a deep understanding of language and its application in various contexts. She specializes in the areas of beauty, health, and wellness and is committed to ensuring that the content on the website is of the highest...more

Aditi NaskarAssociate Commerce Editor

Aditi Naskar has a postgraduate degree in English literature from Presidency University, Kolkata, a bachelor’s degree in education from WBUTTEPA, Kolkata, and a diploma in health and wellness. She is an associate commerce editor with 5 years of experience and specializes in reviewing fitness and health products. She has previously worked as a scriptwriter for an educational technology company and...more