11 Best Expert-Approved Conditioning Mascaras For Healthier Lashes – 2024

Keep your eyelashes thick and healthy with these nourishing conditioning mascaras.

Reviewed by Lorrie Pearson, Professional Makeup Artist
Written by Srijani Roy Chowdhury, MA (Journalism & Mass Communication), Certified Style & Image Consultant
Edited by Krati Darak, MBA, Certified Skin Care Coach
Fact-checked by Shatabdi Bhattacharya, BSc  • 
All products recommended on StyleCraze are independently selected by our editorial team. If you make a purchase through any of these links, we may receive a commission. Learn more about our product selection process here.

If you are looking for a mascara that gives your lashes extra volume, lift, and length and keeps them nourished and healthy, then consider using the best conditioning mascara. A conditioning mascara has lash-strengthening abilities that provide you with luscious and long eyelashes. It is loaded with lash-friendly ingredients like peptides, keratin, proteins, and other natural agents and is formulated to strengthen and protect your eyelashes.

Apart from giving your eyelashes dramatic curls and length, conditioning mascaras also help build an environment that can promote natural lash growth. If you are ready to switch your regular mascaras with a lash-friendly option, scroll down and check out our list of the 11 most amazing lash-conditioning mascaras.

Lorrie Pearson, a professional makeup artist, says, “Using conditioning mascara is like pampering your lashes.

Top Picks
Check Price
Best For Length:Maybelline New York Lash Stiletto Ultimate Length Mascara
Price on Amazon
Best Multipurpose:it Cosmetics Hello Lashes™ 5-in-1 Mascara
Price on Amazon
Best Hypoallergenic:Marcelle Xtension Plus + Pro Lash Growth Complex Mascara
Price on Amazon
Best Cruelty-Free:Almay Volume & Conditioning Mascara
Price on Amazon
Best For Natural Look:Sorme Cosmetics Ultra Lash Natural Mascara
Price on Amazon
Best Water-Resistant Formula:Grande Cosmetics Mascara Conditioning Peptide MascaraPrice on Amazon
Best Flake-Free:jane iredale PureLash Lengthening Mascara – Jet Black
Price on Amazon
Best Clump-Free:Revlon Ultra Volume Mascara – Blackest Black
Price on Amazon
Best Smudge-Proof:Neutrogena Healthy Volume® Mascara – Black/Brown
Price on Amazon
Best Vegan:Rimmel KIND & FREE Clean Mascara
Price on Amazon

11 Best Conditioning Mascaras For Longer Lashes To Make Your Eyelashes Grow

1. Best For Length:Maybelline New York Lash Stiletto Ultimate Length Mascara – Very Black

4.4
Maybelline New York Makeup Lash Stiletto Ultimate Length Washable Mascara Image: Maybelline New York

This Lash Stiletto Ultimate Length Mascara is considered to be one of the best drugstore mascaras for fragile short lashes and for a good reason. True to its name, this popular mascara does to lashes what stilettos do for your feet – it helps give your lashes alluring length and amp up your eye makeup look. Plus, with the addition of pro-vitamin B-5, this washable mascara conditions and softens your lashes. All while the Grip + Extend brush grabs every individual lash and coats them upwards from root to tip to separate and instantly lengthen them while lending an intense black Patent Shine finish. This video detailing a tester’s experience will give you a better insight into the qualities of the product.

Color: WASHABLE VERY BLACK | Product Dimensions: 0.67 x 2.71 x 5.62 inches | Weight: 0.94 Ounces

Pros

  • Contains pro-vitamin B5
  • Lends glossy shine
  • Ophthalmologist-tested
  • Suitable for contact lens wearers
  • It is a washable mascara, so it is easy to remove.

Cons

  • Tends to flake

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

With 8,031 positive reviews on Amazon, this product has become a bestseller.

2. Best Multipurpose:it Cosmetics Hello Lashes™ 5-in-1 Mascara

it Cosmetics Hello Lashes™ 5-in-1 Mascara

Thanks to the perfect combination of biotin, proteins, collagen, jojoba, amino acids, and other nourishing lash care ingredients, this mascara by it Cosmetics volumizes and conditions your lashes while boosting growth. Aside from that, this formula provides intense stay-true color and shine and some much-needed curl, helping you achieve healthy lashes. This multi-benefit mascara has a unique ball detailer-tip wand that grabs every single lash, even the tiniest lashes in the inner and outer corners of eyes, to lengthen and separate them beautifully. Conditioner mascara was developed by plastic surgeons, this award-winning formula is clinically proven to increase lash volume by 430%. No doubt, your lashes are going to look dramatically voluminous without the use of false eyelashes or lash extensions! Several reviewers recommend this mascara for a lash-extension like finish. Click here to check out a detailed personal review of a tester’s experience of using this product.

Color: Black | Product Dimensions: 5.51 x 1.18 x 5.51 inches | Weight: 0.32 Ounces

Pros

  • 5-in-1 formula
  • Long-wearing
  • Lash-nourishing mascara
  • Lends long and luscious lashes
  • The ball-tip applicator allows you to GO VERTICAL.

Cons

  • May have a thick consistency

My Personal Experience

"The applicator of the mascara has a unique design. Its bristle ball tip works well to lengthen and define even the smallest lashes without weighing them down. It isn't waterproof, but the formula stays put all day without flaking and enhances volume commendably."


protip_icon Pro Tip
If the mascara feels too thick, add a few drops of almond oil. Not only will it thin out the mascara but also nourish your eyelashes.

3. Best Hypoallergenic:Marcelle Xtension Plus + Pro Lash Growth Complex Mascara – Black

Marcelle Xtension Plus + Pro Lash Growth Complex Mascara - Black

From the makers of some of the best skincare and makeup products comes this mascara formula made without irritants or harsh chemicals. Rest assured it’s hypoallergenic and suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. This is a dermatologist-tested, innovative mascara formula that promises to give you longer-looking lashes in only 2 weeks. Yes, that’s right! Rich in peptides and vitamins, this mascara penetrates your lashes with every coat to make your lashes grow faster and healthier. It features a dual-sided wand that offers precise application– the longer bristles add length and the shorter one lends volume, helping you achieve any look you want. The no-clump formula has made the product a favorite among several reviewers.

Color: Black | Product Dimensions: 2.5 x 2 x 13.8 inches | Weight: 0.64 Ounces

Pros

  • Gives thicker and healthier lashes
  • Highly-pigmented formula
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Does not clump or flake
  • Fragrance and paraben-free

Cons

  • Tends to dry quickly, so you need to work fast while applying more coats.

My Personal Experience

"This mascara offers immediate volumizing effect. Regular use will not only lend a plumping look but can also improve the appearance of lash fullness over time. Its staying power is quite impressive. It's a good choice for sensitive eyes, as it hasn't caused irritation, and the ease of removal is a bonus."


Maybelline New York Lash Stiletto Ultimate Length Mascara - Very Black
Best For Length
it Cosmetics Hello Lashes™ 5-in-1 Mascara
Best Multipurpose
Marcelle Xtension Plus + Pro Lash Growth Complex Mascara - Black
Best Hypoallergenic
Color WASHABLE VERY BLACK Black Black
Dimensions 0.67 x 2.71 x 5.62 inches 5.51 x 1.18 x 5.51 inches 2.5 x 2 x 13.8 inches
Weight 0.94 Ounces 0.32 Ounces 0.64 Ounces
Rating
Reviews8,0311,788617
Price$7.59$25.0$17.0

4. Best Cruelty-Free:Almay Volume & Conditioning Mascara

4
Almay Volume & Conditioning Mascara Image: Almay

The lightweight and nourishing Almay Volume & Conditioning Mascara gives the illusion of thicker, fuller, and firmer eyelashes instantly. It is a hypoallergenic mascara that nourishes and moisturizes lashes for a healthy appearance. The buildable, gentle formula is comfortable to wear and lasts up to 24 hours without clumping, smearing, or giving you stumpy lashes. The efficient peanut-shaped brush, which promises to cover every lash, even those hard to reach areas for a stretched-out finish, comprises 100% organic bristles Additionally, the cap and vial are both constructed of 96% and 5%, respectively, of PCR material. The mascara is also not tested on animals, making it ideal for ethically conscious consumers.

Color: 20 Black | Product Dimensions: 2.75 x 0.71 x 5.75 inches | Weight: 0.64 Ounces.

Pros

  • Cruelty-free
  • Fragrance-free mascara
  • Dermatologist tested
  • Ophthalmologist tested
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Long-lasting
  • Affordable

Cons

  • None

My Personal Experience

"The Almay mascara is a clear standout for anyone with sensitivity issues. It's a good choice for daily use. It is comfortable to wear all day long as is irritation-free as well."


5. Best For Natural Look:Sorme Cosmetics Ultra Lash Natural Mascara

3.7

With the Sorme Cosmetics Ultra Lash Natural Mascara, you can achieve the best, lushest-looking, thick eyelashes. Each lash is immediately lengthened, thickened, and defined for a full, flirty flicker without clumping. Shea butter, vitamin E, and rejuvenating jojoba oil strengthen, condition, and protect weak lashes, preventing dehydration and damage. In addition, this oil-free chamomile blend is gentle and comforting for those who wear contact lenses, lash extensions, or sensitive eyes.

Color: Dark Brown | Product Dimensions: 1.8 x 0.3 x 0.7 inches | Weight: 0.32 Ounces.

Pros

  • Ultra-conditioning
  • No clumping
  • Water-resistant
  • Hydrating
  • High pigmentation
  • Travel-friendly

Cons

  • None
My Personal Experience

"This mascara is a good fit for those aiming for a subtle enhancement of their lashes. Its gentle texture post-application helps you achieve that perfect everyday, natural look. The best part is you only require just a few coats to achieve a desirable effect."

6. Best Water-Resistant Formula:Grande Cosmetics Mascara Lash Boosting Formula

Achieve both volume and moisturization for your eyelashes with this mascara from Grande Cosmetics. It is infused with natural waxes, peptides, and panthenols that help condition your adorable and delicate lashes. This cruelty-free mascara also promotes a healthier looking and voluminous look. In addition, it helps prevent lash breakage and keeps them strong. The applicator brush made of hard and soft fibers enables smooth and easy application and gives a dramatic lash lift. Its buildable and water-resistant formula has received numerous positive customer reviews online.

Color: Black | Product Dimensions: 12 x 6 x 12 inches | Weight: 0.32 Ounces

Pros

  • Water-resistant formula
  • Buildable
  • Does not clump
  • East to remove
  • Suitable for contact lens and lash extensions
  • Cruelty-free
  • Ophthalmologist tested

Cons

  • Might smudge

protip_icon Pro Tip
Use primer on your eyelids to prevent oil from your skin from seeping into your lashes and smudging your mascara.

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

Almost 2,692 happy users have mentioned the value and quality of this product.

7. Best Flake-Free:jane iredale PureLash Lengthening Mascara – Jet Black

jane iredale PureLash Lengthening Mascara - Jet Black

Get longer and fuller-looking lashes you have always dreamed of with this PureLash Lengthening Mascara by jane iredale. Formulated with D-panthenol and wheat protein, this lengthening mascara provides nutrients to your outer lashes as you coat them. This lash-protecting mascara will further strengthen and smoothen your lashes and minimize splitting, breakage,and brittle lash. Meanwhile, the easy-to-use dual-edged brush captures every lash and evenly coats them to help you achieve a thick and feathery lash appearance. If your lashes could speak, they will surely thank you for this.

Color: Jet Black | Product Dimensions: 1.25 x 0.75 x 5 inches | Weight: 0.06 Ounces.

Pros

  • Protects and nourishes lashes
  • Gives you long and thick natural-looking lashes
  • Can be used on brows
  • Does not smudge or flake
  • It does not contain lacquers, shellac, or petroleum-based ingredients.

Cons

  • May not be long-wearing

My Personal Experience

"This mascara boasts a natural look and durability. It does not clump at all, and is a significant advantage for those seeking a cleaner makeup option. Although it's not waterproof, using it with a lash primer can mitigate smudging during sweats."


8. Best Clump-Free:Revlon Ultra Volume Mascara – Blackest Black

Revlon Ultra Volume Mascara - Blackest Black

Mascara is one of those makeup products that elevate your look to a whole new level without much effort. All you have to do is coat your lashes a couple of times, and you’re good to go. As the name suggests, this Ultra Volume Mascara plumps your lashes to provide exceptional volume like no other. All while conditioning your lashes with every sweep. What we love the most about this product is its applicator wand, referred to as the LASH PLUMPING brush. It is designed with triple grooves that have long and short fluffy bristles to comb your lashes evenly while providing the right amount of product for a voluminous lash look. The user-friendly brush handle for smooth application has made the product a must-buy for many reviewers.

Color: Blackest Black | Product Dimensions: 2.38 x 0.75 x 5.75 inches | Weight: 0.28 Ounces

Pros

  • Waterproof formula
  • Clump-free application
  • Has conditioning benefits
  • Makes your lashes appear longer and fuller

Cons

  • May be difficult to remove

My Personal Experience

"This mascara provides fuller-looking lashes without excessive lengthening. It is long-lasting and can stay put through sweaty runs. It is easy to remove with the help of a normal makeup remover. The brush design is unique and enhances application, separating lashes rather than clumping them."


protip_icon Pro Tip
Rub some natural oil such as almond, olive, or coconut oils gently on your closed eye, and use a cotton pad to remove waterproof mascara.

9. Best Smudge-Proof:Neutrogena Healthy Volume® Mascara – Black/Brown

Neutrogena Healthy Volume® Mascara - Black/Brown

Not all mascaras are created equally, and not all mascaras are suitable for everyone. Some products irritate the delicate area around your eyes. Neutrogena Healthy Volume® Mascara is an ophthalmologist and dermatologist-tested mascara, which means it is safe to use for women with sensitive skin or eyes and also suitable for contact lens wearers. This waterproof, lash-growing mascara includes a Visible Volume Brush that coats your lashes, even the tiniest ones to build ultimate volume without clumping or flaking. Infused with olive and sweet almond oil, this everyday wear formula penetrates your lashes to nourish them while delivering a rich color pay-off that lasts long. This pack contains 2 tubes of this volumizing and conditioning lash mascara that are ophthalmologically and dermatologically-tested.

Color: 08 / Black/Brown | Product Dimensions: 1.18 x 1.18 x 1.18 inches | Weight: 0.11 Ounces.

Pros

  • Waterproof and smudge-proof
  • Comes with a super-sized brush
  • Dermatologist-tested
  • Ophthalmologically-tested
  • Includes lash-conditioning properties
  • Lends rich color and bold volume

Cons

  • May dry quickly

protip_icon Pro Tip
Do not over-pump your mascara wand into the tube. This will pump air into the tube and make your mascara dry.

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

More than 407 Amazon users have vouched for this amazing product.

10. Best Vegan:Rimmel KIND & FREE Clean Mascara

4.2
Rimmel KIND & FREE Clean Mascara Image: Rimmel

This Rimmel KIND & FREE Clean Mascara is designed to intensify your look. It volumizes your lashes while conditioning them with its special formula, infused with biotin, a well-known hair conditioning stimulant. The slim yet spaced bristles of this brush easily reach even the smallest of lashes and help separate them for a fuller effect. The waterproof, volumizing mascara ensures that you look gorgeous even after a full 36-hour wear. Plus, it’s free of perfumes, making it an excellent option for sensitive eyes. Reviewers attest that this product offers luscious, defined lashes all day with just one swipe.

Color: 02 Black Brown | Product Dimensions: 5.51 x 4.76 x 0.83 inches | Weight: 1.13 Ounces.

Pros

  • 100% bio-based fibers
  • Vegan and cruelty-free
  • Long-lasting
  • Adds volume, length, and curl

Cons

  • None

11. Best Cruelty-Free:BaeBlu Organic Mascara – Black

BaeBlu Organic Mascara - Black

Created with sensitive eyes and skin in mind, this BaeBlu Organic Mascara is a great choice if you want to enhance your lashes without irritating your eyes. It lengthens your lashes and delivers fanned-out volume. It is formulated with organic ingredients such as chamomile and cinnamon bark that have anti-inflammatory and antibacterial benefits, and grape seed oil that hydrates your lashes from root to tip. This is a healthy, vegan mascara that has not been tested on animals. The mascara is easy to use and offers a smooth application. Plus, it is intensely pigmented, which means a little goes a long way. So, only fewer coats are needed to give your lashes a defined look.

Product Dimensions: 0.75 x 0.75 x 3.5 inches | Weight: 0.64 Ounces.

Pros

  • Cruelty-free
  • Protects and conditions lashes
  • Prevents lash loss and damage
  • Does not cake, clump, or flake
  • Vegan, and gluten-free
  • Non-irritating and chemical-free formula
  • Made with organic and natural ingredients

Cons

  • May not be long-wearing

My Personal Experience

"This mascara is a clean formula. It not only provides a noticeable lengthening effect but it also nurtures the lashes. It sets quickly and stays on for a long time, but may require extra work to avoid clumping."


*The prices provided in this article are based on the latest available information. However, they may vary due to changes in pricing by the seller and/or promotional offers.

Before buying a conditioning mascara, go through the points given below that might help you pick the right mascara that is good for your lashes.

What Is A Conditioning Mascara

A conditioning mascara is a product that is formulated to protect and nourish lashes. Keratin, vitamin E, panthenol, jojoba oil, and silk protein are some of the ingredients that can be found in a conditioning mascara. It could contain one or more of these lash-conditioning ingredients. A mascara that conditions lashes also contains rich pigments that give your lashes a longer and thicker appearance.

How To Choose The Best Conditioning Mascara For Your Eyelashes

  • Choosing a conditioning mascara is not rocket science. It’s similar to choosing your regular mascara, with the only exception being the former is enriched with nourishing ingredients. So if you want a formula that strengthens your lashes and encourages lash growth for enhanced features, you need to look for a formula that contains one or more of the lash-loving ingredients. Opt for a fiber mascara, if you want to plump up your lashes.
  • Besides conditioning properties, you need to look for a mascara that also suits your eyelashes best. For instance, if you have thin, straight lashes, a mascara that gives a volumizing effect is an excellent option for you.
  • Nobody likes a mascara that smudges or bleeds or gives you raccoon-like eyes by mid-day. So opt for an affordable, lightweight formula or a high-end mascara that’s waterproof or water-resistant with good staying power is what you should opt for.
  • An applicator wand has an important role to play in terms of how your lashes appear. Thick, fluffy brushes give you fuller-looking, thicker, and statement-making lashes, while skinny wands are used to separate and evenly coat lashes.

How To Use A Conditioning Mascara

Step 1: Curl your lashes using an eyelash curler to lift and lengthen them.

Step 2: Use a lash primer to thicken and separate your lashes. This provides a smooth surface for the mascara to adhere to. Apply one or two coats on your lashes and wait for 30 seconds before applying mascara.

Step 3: Pick your favorite mascara. Take the wand out of the tube and wipe off any excess at the edge of the tube.

Step 4: Now place the brush at the base of your upper lashes and move it towards the tip of your lashes.

Step 5: Coat your lower lashes by using the tip of the wand by moving the bristles back and forth.

Step 6: Use the brush vertically or diagonally to coat the tiny and hard-to-reach lashes at the corners of your eyes. This application technique will help you achieve an uniform look.

Infographic: Tips To Choose A Conditioning Mascara For Your Eyelashes

Conditioning mascaras are great if you want voluminous, long lashes. Alongside enhancing your eyes, these formulas boost the growth of your lashes. So, add them to your makeup bag today and create expressive eye looks instantly. Check out our infographic to understand the factors you must consider while buying conditioning mascaras. Scroll down.

Tips To Choose A Conditioning Mascara For Your Eyelashes (infographic)

Illustration: StyleCraze Design Team

Save the high-quality PDF version on your device now.

Download Infographic in PDF version Download Infographic
Download Infographic in PDF version

The Bottom Line

Mascaras add volume to your lashes and brighten your eyes and make your eyelashes look fluffier and longer. Traditional mascaras do not contain moisturizing ingredients, making the lashes dry and brittle and eventually causing them to fall off. Try using conditioning mascara products formulated with natural ingredients that enhance your lashes, hydrate and moisturize them, and promote lash growth. The Maybelline New York Lash Stiletto Ultimate Length Mascara glides on smoothly to offer a well-defined look while the it Cosmetics Hello Lashes™ 5-in-1 Mascara works wonders in optimal lash separation with intense color payoff. The jane iredale PureLash Lengthening Mascara provides a flake-free look with a thick lash appearance. These conditioning mascaras offer exceptional results and are often hypoallergenic, cruelty-free, and smudge-proof. Read the reviews and the buying guide well to find the best conditioning mascaras for yourself. Also, remember to conduct a patch test before application to check for allergic reactions.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can you wear conditioning mascara overnight?

Although conditioning mascara is a fortifying formula that can hydrate your lashes, leaving it overnight can damage your lashes. It could dry out and cause clumpy lashes to fall out.

Does mascara damage your eyelashes?

Yes, mascara can damage your eyelashes if it is not removed correctly or left on your lashes for longer than recommended.

How do you make conditioning mascara look natural?

Keep a few steps in mind while applying a conditioning mascara to make it look natural.
• Always apply mascara as the last step of the eye makeup. If you apply the eyeshadow after the mascara, lashes can clump and look messy. Do not add it before you use eyeliner as well.
• Look down and curl your lashes with a curler.
• Swirl the brush inside the tube of the conditioning mascara and pull out the product. • Repetitive pumping in and out can dry the product.
• Wipe out the excess mascara on the rim of the bottle.
• Look down and apply a few coats.
• Wiggle the brush back and forth a number of times on the lashes.
• Look up, hold the brush vertically and gently apply it to the inner small lashes.

What is the healthiest conditioning mascara for eyelashes?

Mascaras that are filled with ingredients like vitamins and peptides are immensely healthy. If you have hypersensitive skin, opting for a hypoallergenic mascara is the best bet. The Covergirl Flourish By Lash Blast Mascara is a great option.

Why Trust StyleCraze?

Srijani Roy Chowdhury is a product writer who loves keeping up with the latest fashion and beauty trends. Her extensive knowledge of beauty trends and products enabled her to write a well-researched article for her readers on the best conditioning mascara after extensive study and evaluation across various websites. She also included advice on using conditioning mascara and important aspects to consider before purchasing. These products come with a brief description, pros and cons, and answers to some frequently asked questions to assist you in buying.


Recommended Articles


Was this article helpful?
thumbsupthumbsdown
The following two tabs change content below.

Latest Articles