10 Best Mascaras That Don’t Flake For Fuller Lashes In 2023
Say 'goodbye' to unnatural and clumpy lashes with these mascaras that don’t flake.
Tina TempestMakeup Artist & Hairstylist
Expertise: Makeup & Hairstyling
Experience: 26 years
Tina Tempest is a highly qualified makeup artist and hairstylist. She is extremely passionate about helping women feel confident and beautiful through the power of makeup. Tina teaches makeup artists and women from all backgrounds through h... more
Expertise: Makeup & Fashion
Experience: 2 years
Srijita De is a makeup and fashion enthusiast with a passion for empowering readers through practical tips and tricks to present their best selves with confidence. Armed with a postgraduate degree in ... more
Image: Shutterstock
No one likes a mascara that clumps and flakes off the eyes and also dries up the lashes. And this is exactly why you need to get your hands on the best volumizing mascara that doesn’t flake. Given that mascara is not less than an asset for your eyes because it just helps you flaunt your eyelashes effortlessly, using a product that makes your lashes look unnatural will only ruin your whole makeup. But the products listed in this article will work wonders. Just like your regular mascara that is available in different colors and take your eye makeup to another level the moment you apply it, these curated ones will have the same functionalities, with the added benefit of making your lashes look super, super natural. So, it is finally time for you to add length, thickness, or definition to your natural lashes without dealing with the issues that come along with regular mascaras. With these mascaras in place, you can attend a Zoom call and go out on a casual day brunch without your mascara flaking. Now, scroll down to pick your right fit.
In This Article
10 Best Mascaras That Don’t Flake For Stunning Eyes in 2023
1. Best Overall: Vivienne Sabó Paris Cabaret Premiere Artistic Volume Mascara – Black
Image: Vivienne
Is your current mascara starting to flake and clump when you apply it? Well, it’s time to make a change with this elegant flake-free mascara by Vivienne Sabó Paris! Designed for everyday use, this mascara is made with a formula that guarantees you flake-free and transfer-proof while feeling light to give you a soft, natural look. You can get defined and voluminous lashes with just a single coat that you can layer for a more bold fanned lash. You can also bid farewell to smudges as the long-lasting formula is smudge-proof and clump-free. The makeup wand is petite in size yet covers every lash delicately, making it easy to apply and safe for your natural lashes.
Pros
- No flaking
- Transfer and smudge-proof
- Clump-free mascara
- Offers volume in 1 coat
- Cruelty-free
- Petite makeup wand
- Lightweight formula
- Easy to apply and remove
Cons
- Formula may be heavy for straight eyelashes
- Targets thickness rather than length
Pro Tip2. Best Water-Resistant: Blinc Original Tubing Mascara – Black
Get ready to discover the joys of tubing mascara with Blinc! Unlike a traditional mascara, Blinc mascara forms tiny water-resistant tubes that bind to your lashes and are smudge-proof. So, if you’re looking for a no-flake mascara that can hold all day through sweat, steam, rain, and humidity, this one’s for you! The formula is oil-free and doesn’t run, smear, or clump, and is perfect for sensitive eyes and those who wear lenses. So, when looking for a mascara that doesn’t flake, grab this Blinc mascara to get you through long days without eye irritation.
Pros
- Water-resistant
- Smudge and flake-proof mascara
- Doesn’t clump
- Oil-free
- Suitable for sensitive eyes
- Doesn’t need makeup remover
- Gentle formula
- Eco-friendly packaging
- Vegan
- Targets volume and length
Cons
- May take some time to dry
- Slightly expensive
Pro Tip3. Best For Sensitive Eyes: Neutrogena Healthy Lengths Mascara – Black
Image: Neutrogena
We sometimes tend to worry about the health of our lashes when we apply mascara often. Will they fall out, will they weaken with the excess application, or will they wither with time? Wipe these worries away with the Neutrogena Healthy Lengths Mascara that gives you a mascara that doesn’t flake while also keeping your lashes healthy and strong day after day. Enriched with vitamin E, rice protein, and olive oil to keep your lashes strengthened and nourished, the formula lengthens your lashes while also keeping them clump, smudge, and flake-free. The flake-free mascara wand coats the formula across your lashes to give them an intensified look as well as being safe and gentle for sensitive eyes and lens wearers. You can check this video out if you need to know more about the product.
Pros
- Maintains lash health
- Lengthens lashes
- Enriched with vitamin E, rice protein, and olive oil
- Smudge and flake-proof
- Doesn’t clump
- Suitable for sensitive eyes
- Affordable
Cons
- Targets length rather than volume
- May dry out sooner than expected
4. Best Volumizing: Urban Decay Perversion Volumizing Mascara
Image: Urban Decay
You may think it’s hard to get a false-lash look using a mascara that doesn’t flake, but this can be a reality with Urban Decay’s ultra-pigmented perversion mascara. It gives your lashes volume and length with a creamy formula that doesn’t flake or brittle. Infused with hairdensyl, a blend of proteins and amino acids that stimulate hair growth, the formula nourishes and lengthens your lashes while also being enriched with honey extract and elastane. If you’re looking for a paraben-free mascra and cruelty-free voluminious mascara that doesn’t clump and comes with a fluffy brush with criss-cross bristles to make application easier, this is a great flake-free mascara to go for! To find out more about this product, check this video review out.
Pros
- Ultra-pigmented
- Creamy texture
- Flake and clump-free
- Grows and nourishes lashes
- Paraben-free and cruelty-free
- Volumizing wand
- Provides volume and length
Cons
- Maybe slightly difficult to remove
Pro Tip5. Best Hypoallergenic: Secret Xpress 4D Fiber Lash Mascara – Black
The Secret Xpress Control 4D Silk Fiber Eyelash Mascara is made of non-irritating ingredients, making it suitable for all skin types. It coats each lash separately, adding volume and making the lashes look fuller and gorgeous. The waterproof and smudge-proof formula lasts long and stays fresh all day. In addition, it is hypoallergenic and doesn’t irritate or hurt sensitive eyes. This easy-to-use mascara is also easy to clean.
Pros
- Hypoallergenic
- Suitable for all skin types
- Waterproof
- Smudge-proof
- Easy to clean
Cons
- Might not add length to the lashes
6. Best Natural: Ilia Natural Limitless Lash Mascara – After Midnight Black
Image: Ilia Natural
With the world moving on the clean beauty wagon for safer skin and environment, it’s time you got on it too! With Ilia’s natural mascara, you can get a vegan, gluten-free, and flake-free mascara, 99% derived from natural ingredients. This weightless formula is buildable and adds length and volume to your lashes, enriched with organic bee and carnauba waxes. Organic shea butter and keratin are also infused into the formula to nourish, fortify, and enhance your eyelashes. Its fragrance-free and synthetic dye-free formula make it suitable for sensitive eyes while lifting and defining your lashes. If you are an absolute beginner, this video review might be useful.
Pros
- Weightless and buildable formula
- Flake-free
- Infused with shea butter and keratin
- Enriched with organic bee and carnauba waxes
- Nourishes, lengthens, and adds volume
- Suitable for sensitive eyes
- Comes with a dual-sided brush
- Vegan mascara
Cons
- Slightly expensive
- May need warm water to take off entirely
Pro Tip7. Best Quick-Building Formula: Revlon Volumazing Mascara
The Revlon Volumazing Mascara is an ultra-creamy formula that delivers thick, fluffy, and fanned-out lashes. It is infused with carnauba wax and olive oil that intensely nourishes your lashes. The quick-building formula provides an instant color impact that lasts throughout the day without smudging. This highly-pigmented black mascara comes with a unique turn-it-up brush containing wavy filaments that tightly hug your lash curve while coating the lashes.
Pros
- Creamy formula
- Highly pigmented
- Long-lasting
- Clump-free
- Turn-it-up brush
Cons
- Might irritate sensitive eyes
8. Best Affordable: Essence Lash Princess Volume Mascara – Black
Image: Essence
Get ready for voluminous deep black lashes that make your eyes pop with this mascara that doesn’t flake or fade, giving you a dramatic and intense look perfect for any setting. This cruelty-free mascara comes with a specially shaped cobra brush that is curved in such a way that each lash is covered and lifted, giving your eyes a voluminous appearance while staying flake-free! Apply one coat for a casual soft volume look or 2-3 coats for an intense, dramatic, and glam look for a night out! Let out your inner princess with this volumizing mascara that doesn’t flake, and stay away from flaking and fading.
Pros
- Volumizing mascara
- Specially shaped cobra brush
- Flake-free
- Clump-free
- Doesn’t fade
- Cruelty-free
- Affordable
Cons
- May not be pigmented enough for some
9. Best Non-Clumping: L’Oréal Paris Lash Paradise Mascara – Black
Image: L’Oréal
Perfect your lash look and check one of the best non-clumping mascaras to give you dramatic volume and length while keeping your lashes feathery soft. Infused with cornflower extract, rose oil, and castor oil, the formula smoothly glides onto your lashes and gives you a thick, voluminous look that is free from flaking, smudging, and clumping. The soft, wavy bristle brush makes for easy application, and the formula is suitable for sensitive eyes.
Pros
- Flake-free
- Clump-free
- Doesn’t smudge
- Gives volume and length
- Infused with cornflower extract, rose oil, and castor oil
- Smooth, easy application
- Affordable
Cons
- May dry fast after application
10. Best Drugstore: Honeybee Gardens Truly Natural Mascara
Image: Honeybee
If you’re looking for a drugstore mascara that doesn’t flake and is great for everyday wear while giving your lashes a long, healthy, and natural look, the Honeybee Gardens has just the mascara for you! The weightless, non-flaking mascara defines your lashes and has 0 clumping thanks to the clay-free formula. The smudge-proof formula is enriched with botanical ingredients such as coconut-oil-based glycerin and fruit oil, which help condition the lashes and keep them healthy and natural. Its water-resistant feature makes it great to wear for your workout sessions while keeping your lashes feeling light and flake-free.
Pros
- Weightless
- Flake-free
- Clump-free due to no clay
- Doesn’t smudge
- Enriched with botanical ingredients
- Water-resistant
- Paraben-free
- Cruelty-free and vegan
Cons
- Scent may irritate eyes
So, there you have our curated list of the 10 best mascaras that don’t flake. If you still need a bit of help choosing the right mascara that doesn’t flake, here are a couple of things to keep in mind while picking out one to make your lashes look striking while staying flake-free.
How To Choose The Best Mascara That Doesn’t Flake
Target area
Are you looking for a mascara that adds volume to your lashes? Or are you looking for one to make your lashes longer? There are also many mascaras available that can fulfill both of those desires. Still, some mascaras only target specific areas, so keep in mind what kind of area you want your non-flaking mascara to work on. You can pick one depending on what kind of results it delivers, or even buy different types for different occasions. Tina Tempest, a renowned makeup artist, and hair stylist, adds, “Flaking happens because you are not waiting long enough between coats. Too much too soon.”
Waterproof
If you’re prone to sweating, crying, or want to apply mascara on humid, hot days, then you may want to consider buying a waterproof or water-resistant mascara that won’t rub off or melt away quickly. They also usually hold longer and are helpful if you have naturally watery eyes. However, they may dry your eyes out quicker, and if you don’t remove them properly and carefully, you could end up pulling your lashes out during removal. If you prefer removing your mascara more efficiently, you can opt for a washable mascara.
Ingredients
Clean makeup is trending for all the right reasons nowadays, and taking care of the environment is just as important as taking care of ourselves, and you can do both with clean makeup! Newer brands are formulating their mascaras with organic, natural ingredients free from parabens and other harmful chemicals. Our beloved traditional brands are also striving to make the switch towards cleaner beauty. So you may want to consider what goes into your mascara when making a purchase, especially if you have sensitive eyes or skin. Other bonus ingredients you can consider include elements that stimulate lash growth and keep your lashes shiny and conditioned to maintain lash health.
How To Apply Mascara That Doesn’t Flake
Step 1 – Place the wand at the base of your upper lashes
Step 2 – Move it up and down, coating the base of your lashes
Step 3 – Pull the wand upward towards the tip of your eyelashes
Step 4 – Repeat the steps and apply a second coat
Flaunt your eyelashes with just a few correct strokes of good-quality mascara. It also helps the lashes appear voluminous, thick, and long. But mascaras that clump or flake your lashes make your makeup look clumsy. So, it would be best if you have a mascara that does not flake and clump but help to flaunt your lashes. Invest in smudge-resistant, flake-proof mascaras that spread evenly and are gentle on lashes. Mascaras enriched with olive oil, vitamin E, or other powerful ingredients will strengthen the lashes and keep them hydrated while looking glamorous. But restrain from using mascaras that irritate your eyes.
Why Trust StyleCraze?
Chaitra Krishnan, the author, is a beauty and makeup enthusiast, who loves experimenting with new looks and trends. She knows how to let your eyes do all the talking with different makeup items. She brings you this specially curated list of the best mascaras that don’t flake for your full lashes doll-eyed look. After carefully going through several makeup and beauty forums and websites, she has chosen nothing short of the best for you. These mascaras add the required length, volume, and thickness to make your eyelashes look naturally full and voluminous.
Infographic: Mascara Rules You Can’t Afford To Forget
Check out the infographic below to learn about the do’s and don’ts of applying a mascara. This infographic talks in detail about the things you need to consider while applying a mascara. Following these tips will help you achieve perfectly elongated and voluminous lashes. Illustration: StyleCraze Design Team
Save the high-quality PDF version on your device now.
Download Infographic 
Frequently Asked Questions
How do you keep mascara from flaking under your eyes?
If you prefer coating your lashes with multiple formula layers, be sure to make sure each coat is dry before applying the next layer. This is one way to keep mascara from flaking.
If you have oily skin, there is a tendency for the mascara to flake, so make sure you’ve properly washed your face before applying your makeup and you can use either an oil-free or waterproof mascara, or use blotting paper to remove the oil before application. These methods can help keep mascara from flaking under your eyes.
What causes mascara to flake?
When the air gets inside your mascara bottle, it dries out the formula and causes your mascara to flake. This also happens when the mascara is old or has lost its moisture.
Is there any mascara that doesn’t flake and cause under-eye circles?
You can avoid under-eye circles by using a smudge-proof and non-flaking mascara. There are plenty available and most of them are available in our list!
Does Benefit mascara flake?
Benefit has an extreme lengthening mascara that doesn’t smudge or flake.
Recommended Articles
Best Mascaras For Short Lashes
Best Smudge-Proof Mascaras
Best Mascaras For Bottom Lashes
Best Conditioning Mascaras That Make Your Eyelashes Grow
