13 Best Makeup Artist-Approved Non-Clumping Mascaras Of 2024

If you are on the hunt for the best non-clumping mascaras that give your lashes a clean finish, then you are at the right place! Mascaras can either make or break your whole look. You do not want a product on your lashes that leaves a goopy mess and makes the lashes sticky so that they end up resembling spider legs! Understanding this situation, we have created a list of the 13 most effective mascaras that do not clump and distribute evenly.

Just like your regular mascaras, these too give your lashes the required volume, curl, and length. But the difference is that they provide you with a clump-free finish too. It does not matter if your lashes are short or long; these expertly crafted products will give you the best results ever. So, scroll down and check out the list to take your pick.

What Does A Non-Clumping Mascara Do?

A non-clumping mascara is a formula that will give you the desired results, be it length, volume, or both without making your lashes brittle or clumping them together. However, for a clump-free result, it’s not just the formula that matters. The wand and the application technique also have a role to play. For instance, skinny or comb-like brushes work well to keep your lashes separate, which helps to minimize clumps. Likewise, when you apply mascara, always start with a small amount of product. Plus, as you layer, don’t let the mascara dry out in between. Keep layering (work as fast as you can) until you have achieved the look you want.

Ahead, you will find some of our favorite clump-free mascaras.

13 Best Non-Clumping Mascaras Of All Time – 2024’s Top Picks

1. Best Long-Lasting Option: Vivienne Sabó Cabaret Première Artistic Volume Mascara – Black

4.1

Image: Vivienne Sabó Paris

BUY ON AMAZON | $13.95

Buy on Walmart

There are very few non-clumpy mascaras that can magnify your lashes and also separate them beautifully. This mascara not only does that but also keeps your lashes clump-free. One coat is all it takes to create voluminous and defined lashes that have a natural look. This flake-free mascara is ultra-lightweight, which means you could also go for the full, fanned-out volume look by applying multiple coats and not worrying about clumping. Reviewers love this clump-free mascara’s petite wand that ensures to coat each and every lash, even the hard-to-reach ones. This product stays put for long without smudging and is a bestseller on Amazon with more than 22,000 reviews. Moreover, it is not tested on animals, which makes it ideal for people seeking cruelty-free options. So, go ahead and enliven the makeup artist in you and draw out fine lashes and say au revoir to spidery lashes.

Quick Tip

Blinking your lashes on the mascara wand can help define and volumize the lashes quickly.

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

Almost 6,489 happy users have mentioned the value and quality of this product.

2. Best Vegan Formula: COVERGIRL Clump Crusher Extensions Mascara By LashBlast – Very Black

4.2

Image: Covergirl

BUY ON AMAZON | $7.99

Buy on Walmart

Build attractive, clump-free lashes with every single swipe with the help of this Clump Crusher Extensions Mascara. With more than 4,000 reviews, this is an Amazon favorite for good reasons. This no-clump, voluminous mascara delivers immensely rich color and takes your existing lashes to great heights without weighing them down. This product with an intensely pigmented formula includes a unique curved brush that features 2 sides. The straight bristle edge coats lashes from root to tip for massive volume, while the fine-tooth comb evenly coats and separates your lashes for a no-clump result. Ethically conscious consumers love this clean formula as it does not undergo animal testing to determine its efficacy. Check out a tester’s experience with the COVERGIRL Clump Crusher Extensions Mascara By LashBlast in this video.

Quick Tip

Never layer your mascara with more than three coats if you want to avoid flakes.

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

This product is so liked by shoppers that it has gained over 4,053 great reviews on Amazon.

3. Best Hypoallergenic Formula: Maybelline New York Full ‘N Soft Washable Mascara – Washable Very Black

4.4

Image: Maybelline

BUY ON AMAZON | $6.98

Buy on Walmart

Get thicker and healthier lashes of your dreams with this Full ‘N Soft Washable Mascara by the celebrity-endorsed brand Maybelline New York. As the name suggests, this non-clumping mascara gives you fuller-looking lashes in an instant. Infused with vitamin E, this formula nourishes your lashes with every coat. The lash-thickening applicator brush grabs every individual lash and evenly coats them to help you achieve separated and well-coated lashes. Thanks to its Quick Dissolve System, this non-clumping mascara is easy to remove, which, in turn, minimizes lash loss while offering soft, feathery lashes. With over 11,000 rave Amazon reviews, this is a crowd-favorite that you must give a try.

Pro Tip

Use a liner brush or a small fan brush to apply mascara on your bottom lashes for a feathery and mess-free look.

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

A whopping 9,056 reviews on Amazon make it obvious that users genuinely love this product.

	Vivienne Sabó Cabaret Première Artistic Volume Mascara - Black Best Long-Lasting Option	COVERGIRL Clump Crusher Extensions Mascara By LashBlast - Very Black Best Vegan Formula	Maybelline New York Full 'N Soft Washable Mascara - Washable Very Black Best Hypoallergenic Formula
	Buy Now	Buy Now	Buy Now
Color	Black	Very Black	Washable very black
Dimensions	0.5 x 0.5 x 0.7 inches	2.88 x 0.95 x 5.63 inches	0.69 x 2.75 x 5.69 inches
Weight	0.8 Ounces	0.8 Ounces	0.32 Ounces
Rating
Reviews	6,489	4,053	9,056
Price	$13.95	$7.99	$6.98

4. Best Lightweight Formula: L’Oreal Paris Bambi Eye Mascara – Washable Black Noir

4.3

Image: L'oreal Paris

BUY ON AMAZON | $9.59

Buy on Walmart

The Bambi Eye Mascara by the celebrity-endorsed L’Oreal Paris has over 8,000 reviews on Amazon and is considered one of the best non-clumping drugstore mascaras for small eyes. True to its name, this lash magnifying mascara has the ability to make your eyes look bigger and more awake by giving your lashes colossal volume and a slight curl. Aside from that, this flake-free mascara is intensely pigmented and contains pearls to give your lashes a bold, glossy appearance. The included wide-eyed brush of this stretch volumizing mascara featuring long and short bristles offers an even application while separating lashes. Rest assured, it glides on smoothly without clumping. Go through this video that details a makeup reviewer’s experience with this amazing separating mascara.

Quick Tip

If you are using fake lashes, apply a thin coat of mascara to your natural lashes before attaching the falsies for a seamless blend between the two.

5. Best For Contact Lens Wearers: Mary Kay Lash Love Waterproof Mascara – I Love Black

4.3

Image: Mary Kay

BUY ON AMAZON | $19.4

If you want exceptional volume and definition, look no further than the Mary Kay Lash Love Waterproof Mascara. This formula comes with a flexible, sculpted brush that captures every individual lash, even the tiny ones, to separate and evenly coat them. All the while the Mary Kay Panthenol-Pro Complex® and vitamin E elements in this conditioning mascara moisturize and strengthen your lashes while preventing breakage. So, after every application, all you will be left with are soft, well-defined, and non-clumpy lashes.

6. Best Smudge-Resistant Mascara: Benefit They’re Real! Lengthening Mascara – Black

4.4

Image: Benefitcosmetics.

BUY ON AMAZON | $14.75

Achieve dramatically lengthened and volumized lashes no matter where you go with the travel-sized version of this drugstore lengthening and non-smudging mascara by Benefit! This non-clumping formula also curls, lifts, and separates your lashes, thanks to its custom-designed applicator brush. Use this brush horizontally for the staggered bristles to coat your lashes evenly from base to tip. Meanwhile, when used vertically, the domed tip can grab even the tiniest of lashes and the hard-to-reach ones in the inner and outer corners of your eyes. This is a long-wearing mascara that doesn’t clump into flakes or smudge to give you raccoon-like eyes. Many reviews subtly indicate that this is one of the best mascaras with a lash comb applicator in the market.

7. Best Waterproof Formula: Clinique High Impact Waterproof Mascara–Black

4.4

Image: Clinique

BUY ON AMAZON | $20.98

The Clinique High Impact Waterproof Mascara is designed to deliver instant length and volume to your lashes. It helps you achieve lusher and bolder eyelashes that look like you are wearing falsies. The mascara features a twisted wire brush that combs the lashes as it deposits even pigment on them. The voluminous mascara is resistant to heat and humidity and is long-wearing. Several reviews have noted that it comes off easily with a makeup remover without tugging and pulling the lashes.

8. Best For Volume: Buxom Lash Volumizing Mascara – Black

4.4

Image: Buxomcosmetics

BUY ON AMAZON | $23

Buy on Walmart

The statement-making Buxom Lash Volumizing Mascara defines your eyes and lengthens your eyelashes to impart a fanned-out look. Get thrice the volume and no clumps with one simple stroke. The highly dense lash brush that is shaped like an hourglass that makes your eyes open up and look beautiful with just a single coat of mascara. Formulated with rose water and enriched with vitamin E and antioxidants, the lashes get naturally conditioned and lifted. Nourish your lashes and get a glossy and leathery black look every single day.

9. Best For Lash Growth: Urban Decay Perversion Volumizing Mascara – Black

4.5

Image: Urban Decay

BUY ON AMAZON | $26

Do you believe that black and bold eyelashes are only possible when you wear false lashes? Skip the time and effort you otherwise spend on falsies as there is nothing that gets blacker and bolder than this mascara. Formulated with a creamy texture and hyper-pigmented with an intense black color, this clean mascara does not clump yet builds on thicker. You can get the ultimate feathery lashes for that fanned look — thanks to the tapered criss-cross brush that lengthens and lifts even the smallest lash. The mascara is enriched with honey to offer exceptional results while deeply conditioning your lashes. It is also formulated with amino acids and sea-hydrolyzed elastin to promote lash growth.

10. Best For Sensitive Eyes: La Roche-Posay Toleriane Extension Lengthening Mascara – Black

4.1

Image: Laroche-posay

BUY ON AMAZON | $25

Buy on Walmart

Craving for dramatic eyes but eyes and skin too sensitive? Define your lashes and give it a smooth and long effect with this amazing non-flaking mascara. The mascara is free from parabens and allergens and also fragrance-free and ophthalmologist-tested. You can achieve intense lash volume by applying several layers and using the 2-sided brush and there will not be any extra clumps of mascara left on the lashes. Reviewers love this non-irritating voluminous mascara as it separates the lashes while coating them to make your eyes look better.

11. Best Buildable Formula: Revlon Volumazing Mascara–Blackest Black (901)

4.3

Image: Revlon

BUY ON AMAZON | $5

If you want to achieve beautifully fluffy, fanned-out lashes, try out the Revlon Volumizing Mascara. Its turn-it-up brush features wavy bristles that offer a curling effect to your lashes. The rich, inky-colored mascara adds a rich color to your lashes and makes them appear longer and thicker. This ultra-creamy mascara contains olive oil and carnauba wax that nourishes your lashes. The volumizing effect of the product is long-lasting and remains unaffected by humidity and perspiration.

12. Best Ophthalmologist-Tested: Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara–Black

4.4

Image: Too Faced

BUY ON AMAZON | $19.65

Buy on Walmart

The statement-making Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara contains film-forming polymers that help keep your lashes in place. The formula is infused with Acai Senegal tree extracts that volumize your lashes and peptides that infuse your lashes with plumping benefits. This non-toxic and non-irritating clean mascara comes with an hourglass-shaped brush, featuring extra stiff bristles that help create an effortless fake lash effect.

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

This product has made it to our top favorite list with more than 10,595 rave reviews on Amazon.

13. Best Sweat-Resistant Formula: D-UP Volume Extension Mascara – Black

3.9

Image: D-up

BUY ON AMAZON | $22

Buy on Walmart

Unlike a few other volumizing mascaras that tend to flake, this D-UP Volume Extension Mascara creates voluminous eyelashes sans clumping. This is a clump-free waterproof mascara that separates and shapes lashes and doesn’t smudge, come sweat, rain, or tears. Plus, it is formulated to last for 24 hours straight. That said, this clump-free waterproof mascara is also easy to remove with warm water. This all-day wear mascara features a 3-D structure brush that provides a smooth and uniform application. What we love the most about this smooth formula is that it contains 10 types of beauty serums that promote healthier and stronger lashes.

Now that you have taken a look at some of the best non-clumpy mascaras that can be added to your enhanced beauty routine, here are a few tips that will help you buy the right one without any hassle. You can also take a look at the application tips to use mascara without creating clumps.

How To Choose A Non-Clumping Mascara

If you want that celebrity-inspired dramatic and dazzling eye look, picking the right lash-effect mascara matters a lot. Here are a few things that you need to look into while choosing one.

1. Texture

There is a wide range of mascaras, from glossy and creamy textured ones to matte-finished ones. Feathery eyelashes are achieved when you use an excellent creamy mascara that does not clump and comes with a good lashes-coating brush. Mascaras formulated with natural ingredients and vitamins are a good choice to enhance the natural lashes and their texture.

2. Composition

Naturally composed products are the safest. Avoid picking up a mascara that has chemicals infused in it. There are a lot of mascaras formulated with vitamin E, amino acids, rose water, and other such products. The products are gentle on the eyes and are considered to be hypoallergenic. Amino acids and vitamin E boost the growth of your lashes and keep them healthy. Get one such natural anti-clump mascara to keep your eyes safe from chemical reactions and allergies.

3. How long it lasts

How would it be if you beautifully adorned your eyes with a good non-clumping mascara in the day and ended up looking like a raccoon at night? Yes, if the mascara is not a long-lasting one, it will smudge and make your eyes look extremely bad. Get a long-lasting mascara that won’t flake to keep your eyes looking beautiful all day long. On the flip side, ensure to use a micellar water for effective removal.

4. Type of wand/brush

Not all mascaras and wands are built alike and you need to first figure out which specific purpose you want the wand for. The classic perfect mascara wand is a great choice to make your lashes look thick and voluminous but may not reach the smaller lashes as well as you would want it to. A curved comb wand has thinner bristles than a classic wand and is a stellar choice if you want to curl your lashes upwards but may not offer intense lash volume. On the other hand, a tapered wand is best used to reach the smaller lashes in the corner of your eyes while a ball-tipped wand is useful in coating the lower lashes.

How To Apply Mascara Without Clumping

• Always apply a small amount of product when you are starting off. After you take out the wand from the tube, wipe off the excess product at the edge of the tube.
•  Start with a single coat of your favorite mascara that doesn’t flake and will surely not make your lashes clumpy.
•  Place the wand at the base of your upper lashes and wiggle it back and forth till you reach the tip. Don’t use too much pressure while applying. Do this on the lower lashes too.
•  If you prefer to apply multiple coats, wait for the mascara to set (not dry out) between each layer.
•  Use the mascara brush vertically to coat your tiny lashes at the inner and outer corners of your eyes.
• Most non-clumping and non-flaking mascaras feature bristles that ensure to separate your lashes and remove any buildup. Alternatively, you could use an eyelash comb or brush to comb your lashes. An eyelash curler can also assist in completing the entire eye makeup look!

Although clumpy mascara seems to be the trend, not everyone likes to have spider-leg lashes. You know what you need and what suits you. Choose a good non-clumping mascara for your eyes based on the texture, composition, and application, and never stop looking beautiful. Additionally, you can seek guidance from a renowned makeup artist to gain better insights about the product and application techniques!

Infographic: 6 Mascara Mistakes To Avoid

A little swipe of mascara can transform your eye makeup game. Unfortunately, many of us end up committing a few mistakes that make our lashes look dull. Worry not! Check out the infographic below to find out about the common mistakes and make sure to avoid them.

Illustration: StyleCraze Design Team

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I stop my mascara from clumping?

• Use a mascara that keeps lashes soft.
• Use a wand that coats your lashes evenly and separates them.
• Don’t apply too much product initially.
• Wiggle the brush back and forth during application.

Why does my mascara clump on my lashes?

There are various reasons why your mascara could clump on your lashes. Some of the most common mistakes are overdoing it, using an expired product, not following the right technique, or not separating your lashes with a comb.

What is the best natural-looking mascara?

The Vivienne Sabó Cabaret Première Artistic Volume Mascara is an ideal choice for its clump-free finish and lightweight formula..

How do you remove non-clumping mascaras?

Dab makeup remover on a cotton pad to gently wipe away your non-clumping mascara. If your mascara is waterproof, you have to use an oil-based cleanser.

Do non-clumping mascaras expire?

Yes, the shelf life of any mascara is around three months after opening the bottle.

Why Trust StyleCraze?

The author of this article, Srijita De, is a makeup enthusiast. She knows what it’s like to have mascara clumped up, leaving your eyes sticky and messy. She has conducted thorough research by reading through product formulations on websites to give you the finest non-clumping mascaras to buy. What sets these mascaras apart from your regular ones is that they magnify your lashes and give you a gorgeous and lump-free look.

Recommended Articles

• Best Lengthening Mascaras For Long, Fluttery Lashes
• Best Natural-Looking Mascara For Lashes
• Best Mascaras That Don’t Flake For Fuller Lashes
• Best Mascaras For Contact Lens Wearers’ Eye Comfort

The following two tabs change content below.

• Reviewer
• Author
• Editor
• Fact-checker

Elizabeth HickmanHair & Makeup Artist

 

Elizabeth Hickman is a hair and makeup artist in Southern California with over 15 years experience in styling people for weddings and special events. She believes in the ‘less is more’ concept and focuses on enhancing the natural beauty of her clients to help them look and feel their best on their special day. She also takes classes to keep...more

Srijita DeCommerce Writer

 

Srijita De is a makeup and fashion enthusiast with a passion for empowering readers through practical tips and tricks to present their best selves with confidence. Armed with a postgraduate degree in English and Literature from the University of Calcutta, she has honed her writing skills and developed an in-depth understanding of the beauty and fashion world. Prior to her...more

Srijani Roy Chowdhury Associate Commerce Editor

Srijani is an associate commerce editor with a master's degree in journalism and mass communication from the University of Calcutta, West Bengal. She is certified in makeup techniques and is also a certified style and image consultant. She began her career as a freelance content writer, has worked as a journalist in several media houses, and has over three years...more

Asmita DeAssociate Editor

Asmita De is an associate editor with over three years of experience. She graduated in English Literature from the University of Calcutta. She has collaborated with several digital companies and reputed publishing houses as an editor. Her adeptness in refining content, ensuring clarity, and preserving the essence of the written word has consistently contributed to enhance the quality of published...more