15 Best Makeup Artist-Approved Natural (Non-Toxic) Eyeliners Of 2024
Style the perfect winged eyes with the goodness of natural ingredients and safe formulas.
Grace has been a professional makeup artist for 5 years. Her tryst with makeup started as a hobby and developed into something more. She experimented with all sorts of makeup looks on herself and posted pictures on social media. She then we... read full bio
Baishali is a beauty and lifestyle writer and holds a master's degree in English from Assam University. She specializes in makeup and fashion and is also a certified Style and Image Consultant. Prior ... read full bio
Srijani is an associate commerce editor with a master's degree in journalism and mass communication from the University of Calcutta, West Bengal. She is certified in makeup techniques and is also a ce... read full bio
Krati is an associate commerce editor, a certified skin care coach, and a beauty enthusiast. She has a master’s degree in advertising and publishing relations from DAVV University and three years of ... read full bio
Image: Shutterstock
If you want to flaunt a cat eye, subtle wing, or a smokey eye, all you need to do is invest in the best natural eyeliner that’s available on the market. Although sometimes these eyeliners are ignored under the presumption that they do not give impactful results and are not pigmented and durable, many brands are offering an extensive array of non-toxic eyeliners that work wonders for everyday wear and on special occasions! Like your regular eyeliners, these natural options offer enhanced features and define the eyes by allowing you to create the look of your choice. To this end, in this article, we have reviewed and listed some really amazing natural eyeliners that you must consider. So, scroll down and find out!
In This Article
15 Best Natural and Safe Eyeliners
1. Best For Contact Lens Wearers:Burt’s Bees Nourishing Eyeliner
This natural eyeliner from Burt’s Bees is the ideal choice for sensitive eyelids and people who wear lenses. The formula consists of rich oils like mango seed oil, jojoba oil, and meadowfoam seed oil, which nourish your skin. It is super buttery, glides across your eyelids, and defines your eyes with an instant pop of color that stays intact for long hours. This smudge-free eyeliner is available in three different shades – Midnight Gray, Soft Black, and Warm Brown. This natural eyeliner is not tested on animals and is a good fur-friendly option. If you want to know more about the results, take a look at this reviewer’s experience in this YouTube video.
Pros
- Long-lasting
- Easy to apply
- Smudge-free
- Safe for contact lens wearers
- Value for money
- Ophthalmologist-tested
- Petroleum-free
- Synthetic fragrance-free
- Paraben-free
- Phthalate-free
- SLS-free
- Cruelty-free
Cons
- Not easy to sharpen
"This eyeliner applies smoothly and stays for a long time. It actually stays throughout a work day without smudging. It makes my eyes look defined and bold. I like that it does not require too many touch-ups might."
Pro Tip 
Why We Think It's Worth Buying
The product has received 2,333 positive Amazon reviews from its users, stating its numerous benefits.
2. Best Water-Resistant:Zuzu Luxe Liquid Eyeliner
Want to nail that winged eyeliner look? Try it with the Zuzu Luxe Liquid Eyeliner. The applicator is designed with a super fine calligraphy tip for precise and fine strokes. The formula of this liquid eyeliner is infused with jojoba oil and aloe vera juice, which allow smooth application and keep your skin hydrated and soothed. The richly pigmented formula dries quickly into a matte finish. This water-resistant liner comes in eight gorgeous shades – Nile, Amethyst, Azure, Raven, Black pearl, Storm, Luxor, and Tuareg. You can check this YouTube video for the tester’s experience with the product.
Pros
- Quick-drying
- Water-resistant
- Easy to apply
- Paraben-free
- Vegan
- Gluten-free
- Cruelty-free
- Non-GMO
Cons
- Smudges easily
StyleCraze Says Why We Think It's Worth Buying
It has gained over 934 positive reviews on Amazon, making it an all-time best-seller.
3. Best Chemical-Free:Pacifica Natural Eye Pencil
The Pacifica Natural Eye Pencil is enriched with rich mineral pigments. The smooth formula glides across your eyelids for a seamless finish. It is infused with shea butter, vitamin C, and jojoba oil, which moisturize and rejuvenate the skin around your eyes. This natural eyeliner comes in three different shades – Black, Brown, and Gray. The brand does not conduct animal testing and is leaping bunny-certified.
Pros
- Waterproof
- Smudge-proof
- Glides on smoothly
- Gluten-free
- Phthalate-free
- Paraben-free
- Sulfate-free
- Mineral oil-free
- Cruelty-free
- Vegan
Cons
- Not long-lasting
"I like this eyeliner because it does not sting. It glides smoothly and offers a striking jet-black color. Sometimes, it requires occasional touch-ups, depending on the weather. However, on most days, it does not smudge or fade away."
| Burt’s Bees Nourishing Eyeliner Best For Contact Lens Wearers | Zuzu Luxe Liquid Eyeliner Best Water-Resistant | Pacifica Natural Eye Pencil Best Chemical-Free | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dimensions | 2 x 0.39 x 8.31 inches | 4.1 x 0.7 x 0.7 inches | 0.5 x 0.5 x 6.31 inches |
| Weight | 0.43 Ounces | 0.16 Ounces | 0.32 Ounces |
| Color | - | Raven | Black |
| Rating | |||
| Reviews | 2,333 | 934 | 716 |
| Price | $9.59 | $15.6 | $19.99 |
4. Best Hypoallergenic:Fifth & Skin Better In Your Eyes Natural Eyeliner Pencil
Do your eyes constantly tear up while applying eyeliner? This natural eyeliner pencil by Fifth & Skin can help prevent that. The non-irritating formula is made with quality botanical ingredients that are perfect for sensitive eyes. It has a super soft texture and glides on smoothly without pulling or tugging at your fragile eyelids.
This natural eyeliner is infused with castor oil and jojoba oil that moisturize your eyelids and helps your eyelashes grow. The highly pigmented formula is super long-lasting and does not smudge or fade. This liner comes along with a handy sharpener. It is not tested on animals and is a good choice for animal lovers.
Pros
- Smooth application
- Hypoallergenic
- Water-resistant
- Long-lasting
- Easy to remove
- Petroleum-free
- Lead-free
- Synthetic fragrance-free
- Gluten-free
- Cruelty-free
- Paraben-free
- Value for money
Cons
- May cause irritation
5. Best Dermatologist-Tested:Lavera Soft Eyeliner
Create a bold, dramatic, and well-defined look with this Lavera Soft Eyeliner pencil. The formula glides seamlessly on your eyelids and dries into a beautiful matte finish. It is gentle and does not cause any irritation to your eyes. The eyeliner contains organic ingredients like shea butter, jojoba oil, sunflower oil, vitamin E, and vitamin C that moisturize, tone, and nourish your skin. It is available in four shades – Black, Brown, Golden Brown, and Blue. The brand does not test this product on animals, which makes this a good choice for ethically conscious consumers.
Pros
- Non-irritating
- Non-greasy
- Dermatologically tested
- Ophthalmologist-tested
- Easy application
- Cruelty-free
- Vegan
Cons
- Smudges easily
"This eyeliner applies smoothly. I like its intense black finish! It doesn't irritate even when I wear it on the waterline. However, I would ask you to handle it carefully during sharpening."
6. Best Smudge-Proof:Shimarz Absolute Black Eyeliner
This natural eyeliner pencil from Shimarz accentuates your eyes and nourishes the delicate under-eye skin. The ultra-smooth formula glides seamlessly like butter on your eyelids. This hypoallergenic formula has no synthetic dyes, does not irritate the skin, and the smudge-free eyeliner lasts for several hours. The brand also offers a 30-day money-back guarantee in case you are not satisfied with the product.
Pros
- Hypoallergenic
- Smudge-proof
- Non-irritating
- Easy to use
- Sulfate-free
- Paraben-free
- Artificial dye-free
- Phthalate-free
- Petrochemical-free
- Value for money
Cons
- Fades easily
7. Best Fragrance-Free:Baeblu Natural Eyeliner Pencil
Flaunt your gorgeous eyes all day long with this all-day wear eyeliner pencil by Baeblu. It is formulated with certified organic ingredients like castor oil and jojoba oil, which moisturize your skin. It also stimulates lash growth and reduces wrinkle formation on your lids. The richly pigmented color is great for creating different looks, such as smokey eyes, smudged look, or the classic fine lines. The natural oils in this eye pencil repel any sweat and water with ease. This eyeliner is available in three shades – Black, Brown, and Smoke. Multiple reviewers have vouched for this product and stated how safe it is for the delicate skin around sensitive eyes.
Pros
- Hypoallergenic
- Easy to use
- Smudge-proof
- Sweat-resistant
- Water-resistant
- Easy to remove
- Non-irritating
- Waterproof
- Fragrance-free
- Gluten-free
- Paraben-free
- Petroleum-free
- Cruelty-free
- Vegan
Cons
- Waxy texture
"This eyeliner glides on without any irritation and offers a deep and rich color. I apply it carefully and touch it up around mid-day to make sure it stays all day long. It does not make my eyelids rough or weigh them down."
8. Best Handcrafted Formula:Nefertari 100% Natural Egyptian Eyeliner
The Nefertari 100% Natural Eqyptian Eyeliner comes in powder form. It is formulated with frankincense gum and olive oil which moisturize your lids. It is a 100% lead-free formula that looks amazing on your eyes. You can also wear it to sleep without worrying about harming your eyes. It comes in a sterile wooden bottle made of olive tree wood. Reviewers mention that this product is easy to apply once you get the hang of its traditional application process.
Pros
- No additives
- Highly pigmented
- Long-lasting
- Vegan
- Cruelty-free
- Lead-free
Cons
- Smudges-easily
"This eyeliner is best for all-day wear. It is gentle on my eyes and does not smudge. I like the wand's design which helps me achieve raised eyebrows."
9. Best Vegan Formula:Mineral Fusion Eye Pencil
The Mineral Fusion Eye Pencil is a hypoallergenic formula that glides seamlessly on your lids to give you dramatic eye looks. It is infused with meadowfoam, chamomile, and vitamin E that moisturize your lids and soothe irritation. It is formulated with rich mineral colors that look vibrant on your eyes. The eye pencil has a precision tip that helps you draw precise lines. The product is not tested on animals, which makes it a good fur-friendly option.
Pros
- Hypoallergenic
- Precise tip
- Gluten-free
- Paraben-free
- Talc-free
- Artificial colors-free
- Synthetic fragrances-free
- SLS-free
- Phthalate-free
Cons
- Not waterproof
"This eyeliner is gentle and gives me a natural finish. It is great for both subtle and dramatic eye makeup looks. I like that it does not weigh my eyes down or make them feel itchy."
Pro Tip10. Best Flake-Proof:Petra Organics Eyeliner
If you are an amateur when it comes to drawing precise lines, this liquid eyeliner by Petra Organics is simply perfect for you. The sharp felt tip works well for smooth application and helps you draw thin, precise yet bold lines with ease. The quick-drying formula glides on smoothly without pulling at your skin. The smudge-free eyeliner contains castor oil that stimulates eyelash growth and hydrates your skin, and plant-based ginseng extract that strengthens and nurtures your hair follicles. Several reviews mention that the eyeliner formula dries quickly once applied and lasts long.
Pros
- Long-lasting
- Smudge-proof
- Waterproof
- Dries quickly
- Easy to use
- Flake-proof
- Smooth application
- Non-irritating
Cons
- Applicator brush frays quickly.
11. Best Pigmented:Au Naturale Organic Eye Liner Pencil
This organic eyeliner pencil by Au Naturale is a must-have for your vanity! The buttery formula and rich pigmentation aid in precise application and help you create bold strokes in a single swipe. The castor seed oil in this eyeliner acts as a natural preservative and hydrates your skin, while the candelilla wax gives a smooth texture to the formula and helps retain moisture. The smudge-free eyeliner is easy to apply and is available in 10 shades.
Pros
- Smooth application
- Highly pigmented
- Smudge-proof
- Easy to apply and remove
- Paraben-free
- Synthetic preservative-free
- Nanoparticle-free
- Gluten-free
- Vegan
- Cruelty-free
Cons
- Sticky
"This eyeliner glides gently and gives me a natural look. It does not irritate my eyes or make them appear messy. I like that it helps me create different eye looks without any issues."
12. Best For Sensitive Skin:Benecos Natural Kajal
Add depth and definition to your eyes with the Benecos Natural Kajal. The smooth formula glides smoothly onto your eyelids and dries into a matte finish. It contains vitamin E and jojoba oil to nourish the delicate and sensitive skin around the eye area. The product is talc-free, long-lasting, and gives a glamorous definition to the eyes. The easy-to-apply formula has safe ingredients for sensitive eyes.
Pros
- Non-irritating
- Safe for sensitive skin
- Easy to apply and remove
- Easy to sharpen
- Durable
- Gluten-free
- Cruelty-free
- Vegan
Cons
- Smudges easily
"This vegan kohl eyeliner applies smoothly. It stays for a long time and makes my eyes appear bold. It requires little touch-ups here and there but nothing major."
13. Best Gentle Formula:W3LL People Natural Hypnotist Eyeliner
Be it a seductive smokey eye or classic bold strokes, this W3LL People Natural Hypnotist Eyeliner is your go-to for all kinds of eyeliner looks. The formula goes on smoothly and dries to a semi-matte finish. The rich botanical oils in the eyeliner moisturize your eyelids and prevent wrinkle formation. The gentle formula has no harmful chemicals and is safe for sensitive eye skin.
Pros
- Smooth application
- Gentle formula
- Safe for sensitive skin
- No artificial chemicals
- Petrochemical-free
- Cruelty-free
- Gluten-free
- Vegan
Cons
- Smudges easily
- Fades quickly
14. Best Double-Ended Design:Radiant Professional Makeup Softline Eye Pencil
The Radiant Professional Makeup Softline Eye Pencil has a regular sharpenable tip at one end and a smudger at the other end. This versatile liner is fade-resistant, waterproof, and lasts all day. It glides smoothly onto your eyelids and delivers a richly pigmented color. This eye pencil is available in a wide variety of shades – from classic dark browns and blacks to bold blues and purples.
Pros
- Long-lasting
- Waterproof
- Fade-proof
- Easy to use
- Double-ended design
- Ophthalmologist-tested
Cons
- Not smudge-proof
"This eyeliner works well on my eyes. It stays put and holds up well for hours. It glides smoothly and does not smudge at all. It is great for making my eyes pop."
15. Best Non-Irritating:BaeBlu Organic Gel Eyeliner Pot
The BaeBlue Organic Gel Eyeliner Pot has a super creamy formula and delivers maximum color with ease. The natural oils in the formula repel sweat and water effectively. This blendable and smudge-free eyeliner with a creamy texture is non-irritating and applies as an intense color to the eyes. It is richly pigmented and helps you nail various eye makeup looks with ease.
Pros
- Non-irritating
- Waterproof
- Sweat-resistant
- Smudge-free
- Hypoallergenic
- Synthetic fragrance-free
- Gluten-free
- Preservative-free
- Vegan
- Cruelty-free
Cons
- Too thick
"This gel eyeliner has a solid black pigment! It glides on without tugging, especially when I am applying to the waterline. It lasts all day on the lid and does not need too many touch-ups."
These eyeliners can help you achieve perfectly defined eyes. But before you get one, read the section below to find out what to look for.
Things To Consider Before Buying A Natural Or Organic Eyeliner
- Shade
The first and most important thing that you want to decide is the shade of your eyeliner. You can choose a good old black liner for everyday use and timeless beauty. If you want your eyes to really stand out on special occasions, you can go for statement-making shades like green, gray, blue, etc.
- Thickness
You also need to consider the thickness of your eyeliner. If you want a bolder look, choose an eyeliner with a thick tip. For a thinner application or winged looks, go for liners with sharper tips.
- Type Of Liner
If you use eyeliner regularly, drawing a precise and straight line is probably something you have managed to master by now. But if you are a beginner, the best way to start with is using a pencil liner or a felt tip liner, as they give more precision application and stability. If you have a steady hand or better experience, a liquid liner can work wonders.
- Staying Power
The duration for which your eyeliner lasts depends on the formula. Make sure it is waterproof, smudge-proof, and flake-free.
- Ingredients
Choose a formula with expert-recommended ingredients like jojoba oil, coconut oil, or vitamin E to moisturize and fortify your skin along the process. Also, look out for ingredients that you are allergic to.
Infographic: Common Ingredients Found In Natural (Non-Toxic) Eyeliners
Non-toxic eyeliners typically contain naturally sourced ingredients. These elements improve the consistency of the formulas, darken their pigmentation, and smooth out their texture. They also benefit the skin. Check out the infographic below for a list of the commonly used ingredients in non-toxic natural eyeliners and learn about their benefits.
Illustration: StyleCraze Design Team
The Bottom Line
Natural eyeliners are widely popular because they are non-toxic, durable, and long-lasting. The Burt’s Bees Nourishing Eyeliner offers smooth application and is suitable for sensitive eyes, while the Zuzu Luxe Liquid Eyeliner hydrates the eyelids and offers unparalleled precision for your sleek looks. The Pacifica Natural Eye Pencil is smudge-free and long-lasting, making it ideal for everyday use. Some of these eyeliners are ophthalmologist-tested and devoid of sulfates, parabens, phthalates, or other harmful products. They offer smooth application while hydrating the skin around your eyes. Choose natural eyeliners that do not smudge or create a mess even when using them in a hurry. If you are going for affordable pencil eyeliners, steer clear of those that cannot be easily sharpened.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it bad to sleep with one’s eyeliner on?
Yes, it is! No matter what kind of makeup you are wearing, it is important to wash it off before you go to sleep. Sleeping with your eyeliner can cause allergies and irritation, and there are high chances that the eyeliner particles may accidentally enter your eyes.
Is it okay to apply eyeliner every day?
Yes, it is okay to apply high-quality eyeliner every day. However, wash it off with a makeup remover at the end of the day.
Is an eyeliner pencil or liquid better?
Both of them are great on their unique terms. Eye pencils are easy to use and great for regular usage. On the other hand, liquid eyeliners glide easily and offer great precision.
How long does natural eyeliner last?
A natural eyeliner can last eight to ten hours. They may last longer, depending on your lifestyle.
What is natural eyeliner made of?
The key ingredients in a natural eyeliner include lanolin, castor oil, and mineral pigments. Some eyeliners also include waxes and activated charcoal or cocoa powder.
What ingredients to avoid in natural eyeliner?
Avoid parabens, aluminum powder, retinyl acetate, and titanium dioxide in natural eyeliners. Also, try to avoid products with formaldehyde since it irritates the skin.
How to apply natural eyeliner ?
Create a line closer to your upper lashes and build on it for a fuller look. You may gently make a wing if you prefer. Use short strokes to cover the areas with your eyeliner that you may have missed on the first go.
How to remove natural eyeliner?
Remove nail eyeliner with a cotton swab and coconut or olive oils. Dissolve the liner and wipe it while rubbing the oil on your delicate skin. Keep repeating the process until the entire liner is removed.
Why Trust StyleCraze?
The author Baishali Bhattacharya is a skin care enthusiast certified in makeup artistry. She keeps an updated check on many makeup products and always hand-picks the best for the readers. The curated list of best natural eyeliners was compiled after extensive research and reading through many consumer reviews on trusted platforms. These natural eyeliners complete your look, and the best part is that they are non-toxic!
