10 Best Hypoallergenic Eyeshadows For Sensitive Eyes

Say goodbye to skin irritation because these eyeshadows are here to your rescue.

Reviewed by Elizabeth Hickman, Hair & Makeup Artist Elizabeth Hickman Elizabeth HickmanHair & Makeup Artist insta_icon
Written by , MA (English & Literature), Certified Style & Image Consultant Srijita De MA (English & Literature), Certified Style & Image Consultant linkedin_icon Experience: 2 years
Edited by , MA (Journalism & Mass Communication), Certified Style & Image Consultant Srijani Roy Chowdhury MA (Journalism & Mass Communication), Certified Style & Image Consultant linkedin_icon Experience: 3 years
Fact-checked by , Integrated MA Medha Deb Integrated MA linkedin_icon Experience: 5 years
 • 
All products recommended on StyleCraze are independently selected by our editorial team. If you make a purchase through any of these links, we may receive a commission. Learn more about our product selection process.

While getting our favorite makeup on, we are often worried about skin sensitivity or some skin allergy, especially on our facial skin or eyelids. That’s why you need the best hypoallergenic eyeshadows in your vanity. Skin-loving makeup brands today manufacture hypoallergenic eye makeup products that not just makes you look great and help you achieve exceptional results but also keeps you away from the worry of getting skin irritation. With these gentle eyeshadow formulas, you don’t have to skip your makeup and go for a naked-face look due to the harmful chemicals present in the makeup. Instead, you can choose toxin-free, sensitive-skin-friendly makeup that is hypoallergenic and gentle on all skin types.

The best hypoallergenic eyeshadows help you achieve all looks – shimmer, shine, smokey eye, or a classic nude look – effortlessly as there’s one eyeshadow available for every look.

If you do not know where to begin, we have listed the 10 best hypoallergenic eyeshadow for sensitive eyes for you to create endless amazing looks. These products are carefully selected after going through positive reviews online. So do not fear glamming up anymore, and have a look at these to pick your most favorite one.

Top Picks
CHECK PRICE
Best Hypoallergenic Glitter: Physicians Formula Shimmer Strips - Smoky EyesPrice on Amazon
Best Pigment-Rich Shades: Honest Beauty Eyeshadow Palette - Get It TogetherPrice on Amazon
Best Long-Lasting Formula: Mineral Fusion Eye Shadow Trio – StunningPrice on Amazon
Best Crease-Resistant Formula: ProBeautyCo Matte Eyeshadow – BlackPrice on Amazon
Best Natural Mineral Colors: BaeBlu Eyeshadow - Smokin’ PlumPrice on Amazon
Best Creamy Texture: Focallure 2-In-1 Eyeshadow And Eyeliner Pen - Frost, Champagne, & MarsPrice on Amazon
Best Vegan Formula: P/Y/T Beauty Day-To-Night Eyeshadow Palette – CoolPrice on Amazon
Best Travel-Friendly Eyeshadow: NewBang Brown Metallic Eyeshadow StickPrice on Amazon
Best Non-Irritating: Almay Eyeshadow Palette - Smoldering EmbersPrice on Amazon
Best Waterproof: LUXAZA Cream Eyeshadow StickPrice on Amazon

What Eyeshadows Are Hypoallergenic?

Put simply, hypoallergenic eyeshadows are clinically tested to be safe for sensitive skin and are formulated without icky chemicals. If the skin around your eyes tends to get red, itchy, and puffy after using certain makeup products, the chances are you may be allergic to some ingredients that are irritating the delicate skin around your eyes. This is where you would benefit from picking a hypoallergenic eyeshadow explicitly designed to be calming and soothing to your skin while you create beautiful, vibrant looks. Not sure if a product is hypoallergenic? Just have a quick look at the product description and detailed reviews and make sure it is labeled as being a hypoallergenic product.

Bid Farewell To Teary Eyes With The 10 Best Hypoallergenic Eyeshadows

1. Best Hypoallergenic Glitter: Physicians Formula Shimmer Strips – Smoky Eyes

star-ratingstar-ratingstar-ratingstar-ratingstar-rating
4.4
Physicians Formula Shimmer Strips – Smoky Eyes Image: Physicians Formula

If you are looking for a hypoallergenic makeup brand that offers eyeshadows to create smoky eyes, try the Physicians Formula Shimmer Strips – Smoky Eyes. Shimmer and shine with this dynamic set of 6 gorgeous, highly pigmented eyeshadows to create a look that is equal parts mysterious and dramatic. Use this set of hypoallergenic glitter eyeshadows by wetting it for intense color that transforms the shadow into a liner or dry for a softer result. The long-wearing, blendable hypoallergenic, and dermatologist-tested eyeshadow formula is easy to apply and lasts up to 24 hours. This beauty product is free of synthetic fragrance and is ideal for everyday wear. This little drugstore makeup platter of deliciously fun, sophisticated, and multi-reflective shimmer eyeshadows is all you need to create the perfect smokey eye for an ultra-glam and statement-making look that is sure to turn heads. It is a good fur-friendly option as it is free from animal testing.

Pros

  • Long wearing, blendable formula
  • Powder formula
  • Contains no artificial fragrances
  • Contains no alcohol
  • Free of parabens and gluten
  • Hypoallergenic formula
  • Safe for sensitive skin
  • Dermatologist-tested
  • Cruelty-free
  • Suitable for contact lens wearers

Cons

  • Some might find the texture of these eyeshadows a bit dry.

protip_icon Did You Know?
Leading allergist Dr. Frank Crandall created the brand Physicians Formula in 1937 for his wife Edith, who suffered from lupus.

worth-buy-icon

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

The product has more than 3,401 reviews and is a top choice all around the world.

2. Best Pigment-Rich Shades: Honest Beauty Eyeshadow Palette – Get It Together

star-ratingstar-ratingstar-ratingstar-ratingstar-rating
4.4
Honest Beauty Eyeshadow Palette – Get It Together Image: Honest Beauty

Get your hands on this must-have collection of 10 versatile, pigment-rich timeless shades from the hypoallergenic makeup brand Honest Beauty to create gorgeous and stunning eye looks that switch seamlessly between day and night, from subtle and classy, to elegant and couture. This color palette with everyday neutrals and night-wear shades is ideal for those looking for a single palette with a variety of finishes. These hypoallergenic cream eyeshadows have a velvety texture and effortless blendability, making them a popular favorite among reviewers online for everyday use. Dermatologist tested for safety, this palette has a great mix of shimmer, satin, and matte colors, making it the ideal palette of hypoallergenic eyeshadows for all skin tones and occasions. You can either use a single shade in the palette on its own or mix and match light and darker shades to create a look to match your mood. The cream shadow shades will help you create stunning makeup looks for all eye colors. Go through this video to check out the detailed review and demo of the Honest Beauty Eyeshadow Palette – Get It Together along with the reviewer’s experience of using it.

Also Recommended By: Weheartthis has also listed Honest Beauty Eyeshadow Palette – Get It Together in their top 10.[1]11 Best Eyeshadows for Sensitive Eyes, Weheartthis. https://weheartthis.com/best-eyeshadow-for-sensitive-eyes/

Pros

  • 10 versatile, pigment-rich palette
  • Powder formula
  • Versatile shades
  • Dermatologist-tested and hypoallergenic
  • Toxicologist-verified
  • Ideal for everyday wear
  • Free of parabens, talcs, silicones, alcohol
  • Cruelty-free

Cons

  • Some might find the texture of these eyeshadows a bit grainy.

protip_icon Pro Tip
Blend the lightest shade you plan to use on the inner half of your lids and add the darker shades towards the outer corners.

worth-buy-icon

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

The overwhelming 1,809 positive reviews on Amazon show how popular this product is with happy users.

3. Best Long-Lasting Formula: Mineral Fusion Eye Shadow Trio – Stunning

star-ratingstar-ratingstar-ratingstar-ratingstar-rating
4.4
Mineral Fusion Eye Shadow Trio – Stunning Image: Mineral Fusion

If you are looking for mineral makeup for your eyes, the Eye Shadow Trio from the hypoallergenic makeup brand Mineral Fusion is ideal for you. This beautiful eyeshadow palette helps transform your look while providing gentle nourishment to the delicate skin around your eyes. Formulated with a soothing mix of key ingredients like chamomile, vitamin E, and meadowfoam, this palette is the ideal choice for anyone looking for a highly pigmented hypoallergenic eyeshadow for sensitive skin. Further, the brand never conducts animal testing. This dynamic trio is free of synthetic fragrance and has the perfect combination of vibrant shades that can be used as a base, highlighter, and contour for your eyes. So what are you waiting for? Bring home this product with versatile shades to create ultra-wearable and sophisticated eye looks in the blink of an eye! Check out this YouTube Video to learn best about the Mineral Fusion Eye Shadow Trio through a tester’s experience of using it.

Pros

  • Long-lasting eye makeup
  • Crease-resistant color
  • Powder formula
  • Everyday neutrals
  • Gluten-free and vegetarian
  • Hypoallergenic and fragrance-free
  • Free of parabens, phthalates, and harsh ingredients
  • Cruelty-free
  • Available in other color options

Cons

  • Some might find these eyeshadows a bit difficult to blend.

protip_icon Quick Tip
Dust a translucent layer of pressed powder over your lids to keep your eyeshadow matte.

Physicians Formula Shimmer Strips - Smoky Eyes
Best Hypoallergenic Glitter
Honest Beauty Eyeshadow Palette - Get It Together
Best Pigment-Rich Shades
Mineral Fusion Eye Shadow Trio - Stunning
Best Long-Lasting Formula
Color Smoky Eyes Get It Together Stunning.
Dimensions- 0.7 x 5.1 x 4 inches -
Weight- 0.8 Ounces.-
Rating
Reviews3,4011,809898
Price$12.96$26.99$21.47

4. Best Crease-Resistant Formula: ProBeautyCo Matte Eyeshadow – Black

If you’re looking for a matte, hypoallergenic eyeshadow that provides high-impact color without drying out the delicate skin around your eyes, your search ends with the hypoallergenic makeup brand, ProBeautyCo. Infused with key ingredients like vitamins C and E, this conditioning formula provides full, buildable coverage for an unmatchable dramatic effect. The luxurious, suede-like texture glides over lids smoothly and evenly for a look that can range from soft and teasing to intense and eye-catching. What’s more, the natural ingredients ensure that this long-wearing matte shade eyeshadow is safe for even the most sensitive skin types and contact lens wearers.

Pros

  • Crease-resistant, matte finish
  • Delivers long-lasting eye makeup
  • Powder formula
  • Infused with moisturizing vitamins
  • Hypoallergenic and safe for sensitive skin
  • Free of parabens and mineral oil

Cons

  • This eyeshadow might not be suitable for darker skin tones.

5. Best Natural Mineral Colors: BaeBlu Eyeshadow – Smokin’ Plum

star-ratingstar-ratingstar-ratingstar-ratingstar-rating
4.1

Say hello to rich, dense, and decadent color with this natural hypoallergenic eyeshadow that delivers unmatched performance and long-lasting wear. Made with skin-loving, nourishing, organic, and gentle, non-irritating ingredients, these blendable and highly-pigmented shades from the hypoallergenic and animal-test free makeup brand BaeBlu can be used to create a wide variety of looks, from bold and bright to subtle and classy. Easy to apply, a little goes a long way when it comes to these natural mineral colors. And that’s not all! The non-irritating formula of this hypoallergenic product makes this eyeshadow an instant favorite amongst those with sensitive skin. This mineral-based makeup product has a powder formula and is ideal for everyday wear.

Pros

  • Smooth, flawless application
  • Delivers long-lasting eye makeup
  • Made with natural and organic ingredients
  • Sweat and humidity-resistant
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Vegan and cruelty-free
  • Available in other color options

Cons

  • Some might find the texture of this eyeshadow a bit powdery.

6. Best Creamy Texture: Focallure 2-In-1 Eyeshadow And Eyeliner Pen – Frost, Champagne, & Mars

star-ratingstar-ratingstar-ratingstar-ratingstar-rating
3.7
Focallure 2-In-1 Eyeshadow And Eyeliner Pen – Frost, Champagne, & Mars Image: Focallure

Enhance your eyes with this creamy eyeshadow from the hypoallergenic makeup brand Focallure that glides smoothly to deliver a beautiful, luminous finish. The convenient stick-style design of this hypoallergenic product helps you quickly achieve your desired look without worrying about brushes and sponges, making this the ideal beauty accessory for your handbag. With a creamy formula, huge color payoff, and incredible staying power, this long-lasting hypoallergenic eyeshadow is the perfect choice for a professional finish without compromising the quality of ingredients.

Pros

  • Lightweight, creamy texture
  • Crease-proof color
  • Water-resistant formula
  • Long-lasting color
  • Hypoallergenic and safe for all skin types
  • Available in other color options

Cons

  • Some might find the scent of this eyeshadow a bit unpleasant.

7. Best Vegan Formula: P/Y/T Beauty Day-To-Night Eyeshadow Palette – Cool

star-ratingstar-ratingstar-ratingstar-ratingstar-rating
4.3
P/Y/T Beauty Day-To-Night Eyeshadow Palette - Cool Image: Pyt Beauty

Clean beauty never looked so good! Here’s a high-performance eyeshadow palette by P/Y/T Beauty, a hypoallergenic makeup brand, made of safe, good-for-you ingredients. Lightweight and conveniently sized, this palette features a gorgeous collection of 4 matte shades and 4 shimmer shades of hypoallergenic eyeshadow for cool undertones that blend easily. Enriched with key ingredients like vitamin E for long-lasting staying power, these vibrant colors layer beautifully for more intensity and glide on effortlessly for a charming look that transitions easily from day to night. The color palette contains everyday neutrals and shimmery shades that deliver long-lasting eye makeup. Take a look at this video for visuals of the reviewer’s experience on using the P/Y/T Beauty Day-To-Night Eyeshadow Palette.

Pros

  • Enriched with nourishing vitamin E
  • Free of parabens, phthalates, and talc
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Vegan and cruelty-free
  • Available in other color options

Cons

  • Some might find the consistency of the eyeshadows a bit powdery.

8. Best Travel-Friendly Eyeshadow: NewBang Brown Metallic Eyeshadow Stick

Here’s the perfect hypoallergenic eye makeup for sensitive eyes to try out the next time you’re heading to a happening party! The convenient crayon-style eyeshadows do not irritate the eyes and can be used without a brush. These hypoallergenic products feature a creamy texture that glides on effortlessly without skipping, smudging, or fading to help you achieve exceptional results. Waterproof and hypoallergenic, this set has 7 vibrant cream shadow colors which can be used to create any number of gorgeous looks, be it for your prom night, dance party, the wedding of the season, or just a special date night.

Pros

  • Metallic finish
  • Portable and easy to apply
  • Soft and creamy texture
  • Smudge-proof and waterproof formula
  • Set of 7 vibrant colors

Cons

  • Some might find the texture of these eyeshadows a bit oily.

9. Best Non-Irritating:Almay Eyeshadow Palette – Smoldering Embers

star-ratingstar-ratingstar-ratingstar-ratingstar-rating
4.3

If you’re looking for an eye makeup product of the highest caliber that is also gentle on sensitive skin, the Almay Smoky Eye Trio Eyeshadow Palette is a fantastic option. You can use its three warm-toned shades to achieve a variety of looks. The long-lasting palette of hypoallergenic eyeshadow for warm undertones applies and blends easily with brushes and fingers. It is a gentle formula made with clean ingredients that make it safe for use on all skin types. It has been tested by an ophthalmologist as well. This drugstore makeup palette is lightweight, compact, and travel-friendly, allowing you to refresh your look anytime, anywhere. The versatile shades in the palette are ideal for all eye colors.

Pros

  • Smooth texture
  • Crease-resistant
  • Smudge-free
  • Blends seamlessly
  • Fade-resistant
  • Ophthalmologist tested
  • Suitable for contact lens wearers

Cons

  • None

10. Best Waterproof:LUXAZA Cream Eyeshadow Stick

Say goodbye to caked-up eyeshadows and prepare to dazzle your eyes with the LUXAZA Cream Eyeshadow Stick. This product from the popular hypoallergenic makeup brand is an easy-to-use stick and has a one-swipe, quick application. The best part is that it blends easily and is long-lasting. Once applied, it won’t fade or smudge and will stay put all day long. Whether you’re getting ready for a night out or simply want to add a pop of shimmer to your everyday look, this hypoallergenic eyeshadow stick has you covered!

Pros

  • Highly pigmented
  • Creamy formula
  • Long-lasting
  • Suitable for sensitive skin
  • Cruelty-free
  • Vegan
  • Glides on smoothly
  • Available in other color options

Cons

  • None
*The prices provided in this article are based on the latest available information. However, they may vary due to changes in pricing by the seller and/or promotional offers.

Now that we’ve had a look at our pick of the 10 best hypoallergenic eyeshadows in 2024, let us look at some things to consider when buying the best product to create your desired look.

How To Choose A Hypoallergenic Eyeshadow

  • Color

Depending on your skin tone and the kind of look you’re trying to create, pick a suitable color palette that helps you achieve your desired finish. If you’re going for an understated, professional look, pick nudes and neutral colors with a smooth, matte finish. Going out for evening cocktails and want to replicate your favorite runway look for your statement-making outing? Pick an eyeshadow palette from a hypoallergenic makeup brand with shimmery, luminous shades and create a look that is equal parts mysterious and dramatic. With the right eyeshadow colors in your makeup bag, you can have a lot of fun making a different look for matching every outfit.

  • Skin condition

The best thing about hypoallergenic eyeshadows is that they are designed for sensitive and allergy-prone skin and are generally free of harmful and chemical ingredients like parabens, phthalates, and sulfates. Most of them are also ideal for contact lens wearers. If your skin tends to get dry and flaky, pick an eyeshadow enriched with nourishing, moisturizing ingredients like vitamin E. Those with oily skin and acne-prone skin would benefit from an eyeshadow made of non-comedogenic ingredients, preventing your pores from clogging up. Lastly, if you are sensitive to strong scents, go through the key ingredient list of the products to pick a fragrance-free eyeshadow. Also, pick an eyeshadow that is free of alcohol, heavy metals, talc, and other toxins and irritants. However, remember to patch test the product before using it to avoid potential reactions.

  • Texture and finish

From soft and powdery to velvety and creamy, there is a wide range of textures available when it comes to eyeshadows, and it largely comes down to a matter of personal preference. While soft and powdery eyeshadows offer better blendability, creamy eyeshadows are more long-lasting and have better-staying power. Another factor to consider is the finish you are looking to achieve. You can find eyeshadows with a variety of finishes. While a matte finish is better suited to a professional setting, a more sparkly and shimmery finish will add an oomph factor to your party look. A metallic finish is perfect adding a bold touch to your overall look.

Along with this, you also need to pay attention to the formulation and the list of ingredients of the eyeshadows. Opt for mineral makeup if you have acne-prone skin and a creamy formulation if you have dry or mature skin. Keep your skin in mind while looking at the ingredient list. For instance, Cetearyl alcohol is generally considered safe for the skin. However, some skin types may develop an allergic reaction to it. Elizabeth Hickman, hair & makeup artist, says, “If you have sensitive eyes and skin stay away from anything made with perfumes, harsh chemicals, or irritating ingredients as they can sensitize your skin.”

Infographic: Eyeshadow For Sensitive Eyes: How To Choose And How To Apply

Eyeshadows are an integral part of the eye makeup routine. They highlight your eye shape and color and make it the center of attraction on your face. However, the eyes are an extremely sensitive part of our body, and using products around this area needs some serious consideration. Go through the infographic below to know how you can choose and apply eyeshadow on sensitive eyes without causing irritation.

Eyeshadow For Sensitive Eyes: How To Choose & How To Apply (infographic)

Illustration: StyleCraze Design Team

The Bottom Line

Adding a pop of color to your lids can be a fun way to express yourself. But, if you have got sensitive eyes, you need to be picky about the eyeshadow palette that you choose to buy. Having sensitive eyes does not mean you have to give up on having the colorful cut crease or the perfect smokey eye altogether. The good news is nowadays, skin-loving brands have come up with hypoallergenic formulations of eyeshadows that are safe for sensitive eyes. The Physicians Formula Shimmer Strips – Smoky Eyes is perfect for creating a glamorous multi-reflective finish for cool skin tones. The Honest Beauty Eyeshadow Palette – Get It Together offers a satin, matte, and shimmer finish for all skin tones, while the Almay Eyeshadow Palette – Smoldering Embers is ideal for achieving a velvet finish for warm skin tones. These are skin-friendly, toxin-free, and gentle on your skin. They have a pigmented, long-wearing, and blendable formulation that is easy to apply. Consider the texture and finish types before purchasing the best hypoallergenic eyeshadows for sensitive eyes.

Why Trust StyleCraze?

The author, Srijita De, is a makeup aficionado. She is very passionate about eye makeup products, especially eyeshadows suitable for sensitive eyes. She has carefully researched brand websites and checked online reviews and user feedback to compile the list of the best hypoallergenic eyeshadows. These products are toxin-free, designed with non-irritating formulas, and are gentle on all skin types.


Recommended Articles

Elizabeth Hickman

Elizabeth HickmanHair & Makeup Artist

Elizabeth Hickman is a hair and makeup artist in Southern California with over 15 years experience in styling people for weddings and special events. She believes in the ‘less is more’ concept and focuses on enhancing the natural beauty of her clients to help them look and feel their best on their special day.

Read full bio of Elizabeth Hickman