11 Best Cream Eyeshadows For Mature Eyes That Are Crease-proof!

Look beautiful and elegant with these listed cream eyeshadows meant for mature eyes.

By Chaitra Krishnan
All products recommended on StyleCraze are independently selected by our editorial team. If you make a purchase through any of these links, we may receive a commission. Learn more about our product selection process here.

Eyeshadows can make you look elegant when you do it right or break your look and make you dull if you take one wrong step. If you have mature eyes, you need to be very careful and look for eyeshadows that won’t crease. Try out the best cream eyeshadow for mature eyes that is transfer-proof, long-lasting, and effective to make you look effortlessly beautiful. They come with great texture and are easily blendable on the skin. Especially if you have dry skin on your eyelids, a creamy eyeshadow will be a blessing for you. A creamy eyeshadow does not make the fine lines around the eyes more prominent. Furthermore, these eyeshadows are sweat-resistant and are suitable for all skin types.

There are countless brands available in the market that claim that their eyeshadow is best. So, here we have reviewed hundreds of products carefully, and now we bring you a curated list of the 11 best cream eyeshadows for mature eyes. Check them out. Keep scrolling!

Top Picks
CHECK PRICE
Best Fade-Proof: Maybelline New York EyeStudio ColorTattoo 24HR Eyeshadow - Vintage Plum
Price on Amazon
Best Long-Lasting: Maybelline New York Color Tattoo Up To 24Hr Eyeshadow - Urbanite
Price on Amazon
Best Organic Formula: Lauren Brooke Cosmetiques Cream Eyeshadow - Dulce De Leche (Matte)
Price on Amazon
Best Beginner-Friendly: Jillian Dempsey Lid Tint Natural Cream Eyeshadow - Lilac
Price on Amazon
Best Crease-proof: Cargo Cosmetics Swimmables Cream Eyeshadow Stick – Botany Bay
Price on Amazon
Best Nourishing Formula: Au Naturale Creme de la Creme Eye Shadow - Vintage
Price on Amazon
Best Anti-Aging formula: By Terry Ombre Blackstar Cream Eyeshadow Pen – Ombre Mercure
Price on Amazon
Best Sweat-Resistant: Marshique Touch Fit Glitter Cream Shadow - Flamingo
Price on Amazon
Best Travel-Friendly: Burt's Bees Color Nurture Cream Eye Shadow – Caramel Buttercream
Price on Amazon
Best Cruelty-Free: Juice Beauty Phyto-Pigments Cream Shadow Stick - Haze
Price on Amazon

Top 11 Best Cream Eyeshadow For Mature Eyes That Are Must-Try (Buying Guide)

1. Best Fade-Proof: Maybelline New York EyeStudio ColorTattoo 24HR Eyeshadow – Vintage Plum

A lush color, an intense pay-off, this cream-gel eyeshadow created with ink technology will make your eyes pop instantly. Ideal for the women who care to dare, it delivers a desirable matte finish effortlessly. And if you need more drama, all you have to do is reapply to intensify! High-impact and enhancing your eyes with a crease-free look, this 24-hour long-lasting, and sophisticated vintage plum may be the best eyeshadow for the above 50 squad. Here is an informative video that tells you more about the product.

Pros

  • Fade-proof
  • Allergy-tested
  • Super-saturated color
  • Dermatologist-tested
  • Ophthalmologist-tested
  • Suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers

Cons

  • Slightly drying

2. Best Long-Lasting: Maybelline New York Color Tattoo Up To 24Hr Eyeshadow – Urbanite

For your everyday look, this pristine pink will be just right. Ideal to go with all-natural makeup looks, the creamy texture is formulated with high pigment technology to deliver a super-saturated color payoff. Waterproof and with a 24-hour long-wear guarantee, you can set the look and forget about the touch ups for the rest of the day! And what makes this eye makeup for older eyes indulge-worthy is the way it melts and glides on the eyelids in one smooth sweep! Try it.

Pros

  • Vivid color
  • Fade-resistant
  • Tattoo intensity
  • Crease-proof
  • Seamless finish

Cons

  • Slightly greasy

3. Best Organic Formula: Lauren Brooke Cosmetiques Cream Eyeshadow – Dulce De Leche (Matte)

Dulce De Leche (Matte) will revitalize your eyes without being over the top. Richly pigmented and easy to blend, it has skin-protecting, moisturizing, and anti-aging benefits. The silky-smooth formula contains rosehip, jojoba oil, vitamin E, and shea butter to nourish your eyes while restoring the natural luster. Infused with a natural and delicious vanilla scent, the multi-purpose eyeshadow also repairs skin and combats free radicals. And the best takeaway— it’s for long-wear, and you can use it as a highlighter too.

Pros

  • 100% organic
  • Cruelty-free
  • Crease-proof
  • Paraben-free
  • Gluten-free
  • Non-GMO
  • Fragrance-free

Cons

  • Slightly expensive

4. Best Beginner-Friendly: Jillian Dempsey Lid Tint Natural Cream Eyeshadow – Lilac

Here’s a beautiful color that’ll make you feel good about applying eyeshadow. Packed with organic and natural ingredients such as coconut oil and shea butter, Jillian Dempsey’s Lid Tint delivers the ultimate sheen to make your eyes glow up. A great eye makeup for women over 60, it’s ideal for sensitive skin and is free from harsh chemicals such as parabens, phthalates, sulfates, GMOs, and synthetic fragrances. For more information about the product, click this video.

Pros

  • Vegan
  • Cruelty-free
  • Mistake-proof
  • Blends easily
  • Beginner-friendly

Cons

  • May require touchups

5. Best Crease-proof: Cargo Cosmetics Swimmables Cream Eyeshadow Stick – Botany Bay

Be it sweat, tears, or a sudden rain shower, this eyeshadow will stay intact until you want it to. Cargo Cosmetics’ Swimmables is for water-loving souls. Take a dip in the pool or hit the waves if you like; this mess-free eyeshadow stick will stay put with its long-lasting and true-to-color finish. Highly pigmented and convenient, it has a 20-second buffer time for you to blend the color seamlessly before it sets. So, if you are looking for the best cream eyeshadow stick for mature eyes, this could be it.

Pros

  • Buildable
  • Blends easily
  • Crease-proof
  • Lightweight
  • Water-resistant
  • Travel-friendly

Cons

  • Slightly sticky

6. Best Nourishing Formula: Au Naturale Creme de la Creme Eye Shadow – Vintage

Sometimes, all your eyes need is a boost of pigment and nourishment to liven up. And this cream eyeshadow does what it promises! It leaves a stunning color payoff on the eyelids, and the formula is infused with skin-loving ingredients to protect and nourish the skin intensely. It contains jojoba seed oil, lavender oil, candelilla wax, meadowfoam seed oil, castor seed oil, and mineral pigments. Plus, you can use this stick 3 in ways— as an eyeshadow, brow filler, and eyeliner. And to top it all, it’s free from harsh chemicals such as gluten, dyes, toxins, parabens, synthetic preservatives, and more.

Pros

  • Vegan
  • 100% natural
  • Cruelty-free
  • Hand-crafted
  • Ultra-creamy formula
  • Suitable for all skin types

Cons

  • Expensive

7. Best Anti-Aging formula: By Terry Ombre Blackstar Cream Eyeshadow Pen – Ombre Mercure

Because it’s never too late to shimmer! Break free from the pastels and mattes, and glam up with this stunning shimmer ideal for get-togethers and parties. Delivering an iridescent finish and a glamorous color payoff, this creamy formula also has anti-aging benefits with calcium and black pearl extracts. Besides this, you can use this mess-free stick as an illuminator and eyeliner. And if you don’t mind stepping out of the beauty “comfort” zone, you can explore a smokey eye or dramatic look too. Check this video to learn more about the product.

Pros

  • Buildable
  • Easy-to-blend
  • Travel-friendly
  • Highly pigmented
  • Anti-aging formula
  • Glides on smoothly

Cons

  • May not be crease-proof

8. Best Sweat-Resistant: Marshique Touch Fit Glitter Cream Shadow – Flamingo

Don’t settle for matte when you can shimmer at 60 with this gorgeous flamingo. The kind of shimmer that’ll make your eyes stand out without being over the top, this pretty color pairs beautifully with mature eyes. And the best part is, it adds luster to the eyelids instantly, and its creamy texture has a color base infused with medium-sized sparkles. Besides this, you can use this non-sticky glitter cream on cheeks and lips too. Glitter lovers, indulge!

Pros

  • Fall-proof
  • Clump-free
  • Crease-free
  • Sheer finish
  • Sweat-resistant
  • Water-resistant
  • Long-lasting

Cons

  • May not blend easily

9. Best Travel-Friendly: Burt’s Bees Color Nurture Cream Eye Shadow – Caramel Buttercream

Not a fan of vivid glitter eyeshadows? No problem, this shimmery nude by Burt’s Bees can be subtle and party-worthy at the same time. In fact, it is so sheer that you can also use it as a highlighter or add it to your daily look. With a lightweight texture and luxuriously creamy formula, it goes on like butter and is easy to blend. The formula contains shea butter and berry fruit wax to nourish your skin intensely and has light-reflecting sparkles for the shine effect.

Pros

  • Buildable
  • SLS-free
  • Natural formula
  • Travel-friendly
  • Petroleum-free
  • Phthalate-free
  • Paraben-free

Cons

  • It may crease after a few hours.

10. Best Cruelty-Free: Juice Beauty Phyto-Pigments Cream Shadow Stick – Haze

How about adding some drama to your eyes with this vivid shimmer? Boosting the glam factor instantly, the texture is easy to blend and buildable, which means the more you apply, the more dramatic it gets! And besides highlighting your eyes, this creamy formula pampers with an age-defying serum technology. It contains antioxidants such as vitamin E and C and Juice Beauty’s exclusive moisture blend of betaine, glycerin, and phospholipids. Want more? It’s free of parabens, gluten, silicones, synthetic fragrances, sulfates, GMOs, and other harsh chemicals.

Pros

  • Vegan
  • Cruelty-free
  • Luminous finish
  • Sheer to smokey effects
  • Suitable for all skin types
  • Reduces wrinkles and fine lines
  • Contains plant-derived phyto-pigments

Cons

  • May require touch ups

11. Best Vegan: Charlotte Tilbury Eyes To Mesmerise Cream Eye Shadow – Marie Antoinette

So mesmerizing, you’ll fall in love with your eyes! This shimmer eyeshadow has a luxe creamy texture that will not drag on your lids but glide smoothly like butter. And if you are wondering what makes this eyeshadow unique, it’s the water-infused formula that leaves an ultra-cooling effect on tired and mature eyes. Plus, it also contains vitamin E to nourish and protect the skin and is free from harsh chemicals such as parabens, sulfate, and gluten.

Pros

  • Vegan
  • Cruelty-free
  • Minimum effort
  • Maximum impact
  • Antioxidant protection

It’s time to make those beautiful eyes pop this season! There you go, those were the 11 best cream eyeshadows to explore this 2021. However, if you still need some tips on buying the right cream eyeshadow or wondering how to apply one, you must check our buying guide below.

How To Select The Cream Eyeshadow For Mature Eyes?

Look out for the following features before buying the product for the best experience:

Color pay-off
The color payoff is the impact of the eyeshadow on the eyelid after application. A saturated pigment will leave an intense color payoff compared to a sheer one. Similarly, glitter eyeshadows have a high color payoff compared to shimmer and matte eye shadows. Also, choose a buildable texture so you can enjoy both sheer and dramatic looks with the same eyeshadow.

Color:
A wrong color can be unflattering, or worse, make you a topic of telltales! Here are some flattering colors that pair well with mature eyes and will make you look younger. Experts suggest choosing darker shades such as browns, tans, and pastel colors for a younger-looking finish. And when nothing works, you can settle for the universal color pink as it works for all skin tones and ages.

Blending ability
The creamier the texture, the lesser efforts you’ll have to put in the blending. Although cream eyeshadows blend effortlessly compared to powder eyeshadows, some textures like powder-cream fusions or matte cream eyeshadows may require some effortful blending to get the desired look.

Crease-proof
Experts suggest that cream eyeshadows are ideal for mature eyes because they conceal the aging lines to deliver a seamless and smooth finish. However, not all cream eyeshadows may be crease-proof which is why you need to check this feature before buying. However, if your cream eyeshadow does end up creasing, you can use a powder eyeshadow for setting to prevent the cracking or creasing lines.

Ingredients
If you are dealing with dryness or dullness, choose an eyeshadow with nourishing formulas. Ingredients such as vitamin E and shea butter have hydrating and moisturizing benefits that’ll repair and protect your skin. Plus, there are eyeshadows with age-defying formulas such as Juice Beauty Phyto-Pigments Cream Shadow Stick and Lauren Brooke Cosmetiques Cream Eyeshadow. But on a different note, you must avoid parabens, sulfates, talc, phthalates, alcohol, and other harsh chemicals that may be harmful to your eyes.

Steps To Apply Cream Eyeshadow For Mature Eyes:

Beginners, here are some easy steps for you:

  • Make sure the brush is dry and clean
  • Apply and start from the lash line
  • Continue patting the color while blending upwards
  • Lastly, use your fingertip to spread the cream in all directions until you get the desired look

Be it a date night, a formal party, or a casual hangout with your best friends, you can ace any event in style with the right eyeshadow. It is time to ditch your normal eyeshadows for safe, cruelty-free cream eyeshadows that are easily blendable and protect your skin while reducing fine lines, wrinkles, and patches. Cream eyeshadows with age-defying formulas give the best results when it comes to looking ageless. Furthermore, ingredients including vitamin E and shea butter are fruitful in moisturizing, hydrating, and rejuvenating the skin above the eyes. These waterproof, sweat-resistant, and travel-friendly eyeshadows have a big fanbase but make sure you avoid parabens, sulfates, alcohol, phthalates, and other chemicals.

Why Trust StyleCraze?

The author, Chaitra Krishnan, is a makeup and skincare enthusiast who loves trying products that take your makeup and beauty routine a notch higher. After multiple product comparisons and customer feedback reviews, she has brought you this specially curated list of the top cream eyeshadows that are crease-proof. These products are easily blendable, long-lasting, and do not accentuate your fine lines, making your eyes speak flawlessly for themselves.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is cream eyeshadow good for mature eyes?

Absolutely! Cream eyeshadows glide on smoothly, blend easily, and are crease-proof to deliver a smooth and stunning look on the eyes. Besides this, they conceal aging lines too.

Does eyeshadow make you look older?

Applying too much eyeshadow may make your eyelids look cakey, dull, and older, which is why you must not overdo it and keep as light as possible for a fresh look.

What color eyeshadow makes you look younger?

Pastels, browns, tans, or pink eyeshadows are great choices for mature eyes. Ideally, you must settle for satin or matte finish because they tend to stay crease-proof longer than shimmers and glitters that might fill in the creases.

What kind of brush do you use for mature eyes cream eyeshadow?

A small, dense but fluffy eyeshadow brush is ideal for applying cream eyeshadows onto your mature eyelids. These brushes spread the color evenly on the wrinkled lids and do not form any unnecessary lines.

What is the most affordable cream eyeshadow for mature eyes?

Maybelline New York EyeStudio ColorTattoo 24HR Eyeshadow is an affordable cream eyeshadow that has great color pay-off and is long-lasting.

Recommended Articles

Was this article helpful?
thumbsupthumbsdown
The following two tabs change content below.
Chaitra has a triple main bachelor’s degree in journalism, communicative English, and economics from St. Aloysius College, Mangalore, and a... more

LATEST ARTICLES