11 Best Eye Primers For Mature Skin To Fight Fine Lines

Written by Chaitra Krishnan
All products recommended on StyleCraze are independently selected by our editorial team. If you make a purchase through any of these links, we may receive a commission. Learn more about our product selection process here.

As we age, the loss of estrogen makes our skin loose and dry, making our eye makeup look creasy, settling into fine lines or fading easily. To prevent this, you need the best eye primer for mature skin. It expands the longevity of your makeup, smoothens the base, and diminishes all signs of aging, preventing the makeup from settling down into fine lines and wrinkles.

You can blindly swear by the eye primers for mature skin if you have aging skin. They perfect your eye makeup and make them last smoothly on your mature skin. Apart from that, they also give your skin a healthy and youthful glow.

The prevention of visible fine lines and wrinkles is enough to rewind your age seamlessly, making you look well-maintained, youthful, with healthy and natural-looking skin. However, with so many brands and eye primer products out there in the market, it might get overwhelming to pick the best one for your mature skin. Finding a skin-friendly one that gives you a flawless finish can get challenging. So, we have listed the 11 best eye primers for mature skin to solve this query for you. Have a look!

Top 10 ProductsCheck Price
Best Overall: Elizabeth Mott Thank Me Later Eyeshadow PrimerPrice on AmazonPrice on Walmart
Best Crease-Proof : Milani Eyeshadow PrimerPrice on AmazonPrice on Walmart
Best For Shine Control: NYX Professional Angel Veil Skin Perfecting PrimerPrice on AmazonPrice on Walmart
Best Waterproof: Too Faced Shadow InsurancePrice on AmazonPrice on Walmart
Best Vegan: Urban Decay Anti-Aging Eyeshadow Primer PotionPrice on Amazon
Best Cruelty-Free: BareMinerals Prime Time Eyelid PrimerPrice on Amazon
Best Hydrating: Smashbox Photo Finish Hydrating Under Eye PrimerPrice on AmazonPrice on Walmart
Best Smudge-Proof: Anastasia Beverly Hills Eye PrimerPrice on AmazonPrice on Walmart
Best Vegan: True + Luscious Angel Eyes Eyeshadow Primer/BasePrice on AmazonPrice on Walmart
Best Oil-Free: Monica Ann Beauty Dual Action Eyeshadow PrimerPrice on AmazonPrice on Walmart

1. Best Overall: Elizabeth Mott Thank Me Later Eyeshadow Primer

The name Thank Me Later may strike you a tad overconfident. But this silky formula brought to you by the NYC-founded and Korean beauty-inspired makeup company, Elizabeth Mott, isn’t all talk. They also deliver. Their paraben-free formula contains a powder to control excess sebum, which fights oily skin, gives a smooth application, and locks in your eyeshadow color all day. Now you can prep your eyelids in the morning and attend that dinner date after work sans the hassle of harried reapplications. Score!

Pros:

  • No animal testing
  • Lightweight formula
  • Combats oily eyelids
  • Refundable

Cons:

  • Not for dry skin type

2. Best Crease-Proof : Milani Eyeshadow Primer

This invisible primer can help boost your favorite eyeshadow’s color, giving your palette a whole new pop of vibrancy. The crease-proof formula applies nude and dries quickly, giving you an even base to work with. A small amount can go a long way and last all day. Milani was founded in the richly diverse East LA and takes pride in designing makeup for all ethnicities, shades, and attitudes.

Pros:

  • Suitable for all skin tones
  • Vegan and cruelty-free
  • Invisible tint and lightweight

Cons:

  • May need additional loose powder

3. Best For Shine Control: NYX Professional Angel Veil Skin Perfecting Primer

This supremely silky, silicon-based primer will sit just like an angel’s kiss, providing a satin smooth, uniform canvas for your entire face. The formula is cruelty-free and on the slightly wetter side (though definitely not runny) to give an easy application on dry skin that is often seen with aging. It’s also been formulated to minimize shine so that you appear flawlessly fresh all day. If you appreciate the design, you can also finish your look with NYX Professional’s range of eyeshadow, mascara, and liquid eyeliner that complement this eye primer.

Pros:

  • Immaculate satin finish
  • No animal testing
  • Great for big pores
  • Can be used on the entire face

Cons:

  • Not suitable for oily skin

4. Best Waterproof: Too Faced Shadow Insurance

Here is your very own eyeshadow insurance! This featherweight formula brought to you by Too Faced is waterproof as well as crease-proof. It contains unique binders that lock down the pigments of your eye shadow and significantly increase its wear whilst simultaneously intensifying the color. The formula also successfully neutralizes any discolorations on your skin, giving you a smooth, blank canvas to work with. Besides the 24 hour-wear guarantee, a little product also goes a long way during application. What’s not to love?

Pros:

  • Prevents smudging, melting, and creasing
  • Contains vitamin E
  • Waterproof formula
  • Moisturizing eye primer

Cons:

  • Not suitable for oily skin

5. Best Vegan: Urban Decay Anti-Aging Eyeshadow Primer Potion

Urban Decay has a reputation for making extraordinary eye primers, and their anti-aging potion doesn’t disappoint either. This nude shade primer contains dermaxyl to help even out textures, and is perfect for those with mature skin complaints like fine lines. The formula contains kalpariane for firmer, plumper and better hydration for dehydrated skin, which improves its elasticity and suppleness. Additionally, its optical-blurring pigments aid in reducing the appearance of red, puffy lids so you can say good-bye to hooded, tired eyes.

Pros:

  • Vegan and cruelty-free
  • Polymer technology
  • Lightweight and anti-aging formula
  • Color boosting

Cons:

  • Not suitable for oily skin

6. Best Cruelty-Free: BareMinerals Prime Time Eyelid Primer

If you’re a gal who works hard but plays harder, you need an eyelid primer that can ensure immaculate 24 hour coverage. And the 100% cruelty-free bareMinerals is just the one for you! Their silky smooth formula is lightweight and designed to last all day and all night – perfect for those who suffer from fading eye color after a long day. This crease-free solution is quick to dry and fights excess sebum accumulation so that your eyelids never look greasy.

Pros:

  • Paraben and gluten-free
  • Cruelty-free
  • Synthetic fragrance-free
  • Long-lasting plus boosts color

Cons:

  • Slightly sticky

7. Best Hydrating: Smashbox Photo Finish Hydrating Under Eye Primer

An uber hydrating eye primer from the LA-based makeup empire, SmashBox, this ingenious formula will truly have mature gals selfie-ready at any time of the day. Infused with the soothing properties of peptides and caffeine, the Photo Finish primer helps fight undereye bags and inflammation whilst smoothening the texture. It’s also designed to lock in your eye concealer, preventing it from feathering into delicate fine lines, thereby keeping you looking fresh all day.

Pros:

  • Hydrating formula
  • Oil-free
  • Combats puffy eyes
  • Crease-proof

Cons:

  • Relatively more expensive

8. Best Smudge-Proof: Anastasia Beverly Hills Eye Primer

This creamy formula, by the beloved Anastasia Beverly Hills, glides smoothly to create a perfect, uniform base for eyeshadow application. The satiny texture ensures easy blending and smudge-proof application of metallic, matte, and shimmery eye colors. Additionally, the nude shade of the primer helps enhance the vibrancy of eyeshadow colors whilst locking in the color for all-day wear.

Pros:

  • Water-resistant
  • Vegan and cruelty-free
  • Free of parabens, phthalates, oil, gluten, and alcohol
  • Dermatologist tested and noncomedogenic

Cons:

  • Not suitable for oily skin

9. Best Vegan: True + Luscious Angel Eyes Eyeshadow Primer/Base

Made with a smooth formulation for a spotless matte finish, the Angel Eyes Eyeshadow Primer is available in 3 different shades to flatter a wider range of skin tones and offers 12 hours of smudge-free resistance. The lightweight texture applies evenly to prevent creases and lines, whilst the high-grade emollient base blends with ease and gives your eyeshadow a uniform foundation. Bonus? The indie beauty brand True + Luscious uses all skin-loving, non-toxic ingredients and incorporates natural botanical ingredients to give your makeup routine its own glamorous glow up!

Pros:

  • Non-drying and alcohol-free
  • Good for sensitive skin
  • Vegan and cruelty-free
  • Accommodates darker skin tones
  • Fruit and flower extracts

Cons:

  • May not be effective on oily skin

10. Best Oil-Free: Monica Ann Beauty Dual Action Eyeshadow Primer

Searching for a YouTube tutorial-worthy luminous finish? Then the Dual Action Eyeshadow Primer by Monica Ann Beauty may be just up your alley! Unlike most of the other eye primers that saturate the market, this unique formula contains skin-nourishing ingredients to enrich the delicate skin of your eyes, all whilst providing an immaculate primer base for your eyeshadow. With skin elixirs like hyaluronic acid and vitamin C, you can fight pigmentation and plump skin to reduce the appearance of fine lines right under your makeup on the go! Talk about killing two birds with one stone.

Pros:

  • Waterproof formula
  • Contains vitamin C and hyaluronic acid
  • Crease-proof and oil-free
  • Quick-drying and 24-hour wear

Cons:

  • Can be sticky

11. Golden Rose Eyeshadow Primer

Tired of looking for an eye primer that matches your skin tone? Then perhaps try the Eyeshadow Primer by Golden Rose. Designed to give a lightweight sheer application, this tiny wonder blends flawlessly to complement just about all skin tones and all types of eye makeup! Crease-proof and clump-free, it offers an extra boost to your eyeshadow color and promises to hold its vibrancy all day. Win-win, we say.

Pros:

  • Dermatologically tested
  • Paraben-free and cruelty-free
  • Increases the life of vibrant colors
  • Sheer and weightless

Cons:

  • No applicator tip

No more hiding behind sunglasses and wacky hats. With our pick of the best eye primers for mature eyes, you can reclaim your makeup magic and get Insta-ready within minutes. But before you go grab your credit card, take a quick peek at our buying guide for helpful tips for choosing the right primer for you. Read on!

Buying Guide To The Best Eye Primer For Mature Skin!

How To Choose The Best Eye Primer For Mature Eyelid Skin

If you’re an older woman who hasn’t had much experience with eye primers or if, whilst scrolling down, you’ve gotten progressively nervous with the overwhelming amount of choice in this article, fear not! We’re about to break down the basics of what makes the best eyelid primer for mature skin. Take a look:

  • A Lightweight Formula:

Thick, clunky eye primer formulas are a big no-no. Not only do they not look natural, but they also settle rather stiffly and exacerbate the appearance of creases and puffiness in mature skin. Besides, no one likes to feel any extra weight upon their lids. Ergo, a light formulation is a crucial feature to assess when purchasing an eye primer for mature eyes. These also, characteristically, make the best under eye primer to prevent creasing. And since they typically require less product for more coverage as they apply rather evenly and provide a smooth canvas, they’re friendlier to your wallet too!

  • 24 Hour Wear:

Another essential primer feature to search for is an all-day wear guarantee. The older you get, the more responsibilities you stack up. Be it due to juggling work, home or kids, most of your hours now belong to social commitments that demand you to look fresh and crisp at all times. Meanwhile, those luxurious windows for self-care and makeup magic get squeezed to mere minutes. Solution? Don’t work overtime; get an eye primer that works overtime for you! Get 24-hour wear resistance and save yourself more worry lines.

How To Use An Eye Primer For Mature Skin

Introducing a primer into your makeup routine is easier than you would think. You apply a pea-sized portion on your eyelids right after you finish moisturizing. Once you’ve patted it into your creases and achieved a smooth base, go ahead and apply your eye makeup— Voilá! You’re good to go!

Good eye primers can really help you get rid of fine lines, dark spots, and wrinkles that come with age. It is better to invest in a primer that can suit your skin type, and also aid your makeup to offer a youthful radiance. However, while choosing the right eye primer for yourself, you should check if the primer is formulated with moisturizing ingredients that can help bring back the glow that fades away with age. You should go for primers that can act as a smooth base for your cosmetics while also offering to keep your skin hydrated all day long! Needless to mention, the eye primers that make your skin feel cakey, or fail to minimize pores must be avoided at all costs.

Why Trust StyleCraze?

Chaitra Krishnan, the author of this post, is a makeup wizard fond of trying products that make makeup look flawless. Here, she has compiled a list of the best eye primers for mature skin that prevents the makeup from settling into fine lines and creases. Chaitra has invested an immense amount of time studying and analyzing these products to provide their pros and cons that help the reader navigate their options better. She has also included a buying guide to assist readers in picking the best.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do eye primers help with wrinkles?

Not all. But, yes, some primers are specifically formulated for aging skin to help prevent the appearance of creasing.

Is there a difference between face primer and eye primer?

The core difference between an eye primer and a face primer lies in the formula. Silicon is a key ingredient in most face primers as it fills out potential pores and smoothens imperfections. But if applied to the surface of the eyelids, it creates an excessively slippery surface that accentuates creases and makes the even blending of eyeshadow difficult.

Can I use eyeshadow primer under my eyes?

Yes, you can. An under eye makeup primer prevents your foundation from creasing and helps boost its longevity.

Recommended Articles

The following two tabs change content below.

LATEST ARTICLES