13 Best Drugstore Cream Eyeshadows For Well-Defined Eyes On A Budget!

Written by Chaitra Krishnan
All products recommended on StyleCraze are independently selected by our editorial team. If you make a purchase through any of these links, we may receive a commission. Learn more about our product selection process here.

We all love investing in high-end brands for eye products, but sometimes, it can burn a hole in your pocket. To beat that, the best drugstore cream eyeshadows have got your back. Even if it doesn’t work better, it works just well and is great. After all, all good things have great substitutes. The quality of the products on our list will blow your mind. Glitter, sparkle, or just plain matte – all these drugstore cream eyeshadows can be easily used to create a professional makeup look with your beginner skills.

A tinge of color or a simple pop-up of color transforms your entire appearance from drab to fab real quick. Whether it’s a hectic workday at the office or late night party with friends, a little bit of your cream eyeshadow on your eyelids will doll you up instantly. These are easy to apply, smooth and gentle on skin, and ultra-fine to blend effortlessly. Whether you like metallic or shimmery finish or matte hues, we have got you covered with all kinds of cream eyeshadows. Scroll down have a look at the 13 best drugstore cream eyeshadows we have listed below.

TOP 10 PRODUCTS
CHECK PRICE
Best Ophthalmologist-Tested:Revlon ColorStay Crème Eyeshadow – Vanilla
Price on Amazon
Best Crease-Resistant:Maybelline New York Color Tattoo 24HR Metal Cream Gel Makeup- Inked In Pink
Price on Amazon
Best Ultra-Pigmented:e.l.f Cosmetics Bite-Size Eyeshadow Mini Palette - Cream And Sugar
Price on Amazon
Best Transfer-Resistant:WUNDER2 Super-Stay Stick Eyeshadow – Moonstone
Price on Amazon
Best Hypoallergenic:Almay Velvet Foil Cream Shadow - Astro Girl
Price on Amazon
Best Organic:Lauren Brooke Cosmetiques Creme Eyeshadows - Plum Fairy (Matte)
Price on Amazon
Best Cream Formula:L’Oreal Paris Infallible 24HR Eyeshadow - Golden Emerald
Price on Amazon
Best Cruelty-Free:Jillian Dempsey Lid Tint – Peach
Price on Amazon
Best Multipurpose:Glo Skin Beauty Cream Stay Shadow Stick – Echo
Price on Amazon
Best Non-Sticky:Marshique Touch Fit Glitter Cream Shadow - Flamingo
Price on Amazon

13 Best Drugstore Cream Eyeshadows To Enhance Your Eyes In 2021

1. Best Ophthalmologist-Tested:Revlon ColorStay Crème Eyeshadow – Vanilla

Cosmetics and beauty giant Revlon never disappoints with their formulas and unforgettable products. Since they’re on the top of our list, it can only mean one thing — the ColorStay Crème Eyeshadow is one of the best pigmented drugstore eyeshadows. The ultra-smooth, incredibly blendable cream formula offers you a waterproof pigment in both matte and shimmer finishes available. The Vanilla shade is a sparkly one among 18 others that you can use as a base or highlight the inner corner of your eyes with. If you want matte shades for a bold look, or shimmery ones for a little ‘oomph’, this drugstore cream eyeshadow range has got it all. You can check out this YouTuber’s review of the product if you require more convincing.

Pros

  • Ophthalmologist-tested
  • Lasts up to 24 hours
  • Blendable formula
  • High color pay-off
  • Built-in eyeshadow brush for easy application
  • Waterproof
  • Can be used as eyeliner

Cons

  • Not transfer-proof

2. Best Crease-Resistant:Maybelline New York Color Tattoo 24HR Metal Cream Gel Makeup- Inked In Pink

Here it is, the best drugstore single eyeshadow you’ve been waiting for! With a beautiful metallic finish that lasts all day long, this waterproof formula effortlessly blends without creasing or fading. The colors are highly pigmented too and they’re going to stay put once you walk out the door and walk back in after a long, tiring day. It offers up to 24-hour wear, making it the longest lasting drugstore eyeshadow on this list. The 17 bold and vibrant pigments can illuminate your eyes and take your entire look to the next level. Don’t be afraid to shine with Maybelline New York’s pigmented drugstore eyeshadows. If you want to find out more about this product and its usage, make sure to check out this review on YouTube.

Pros

  • Waterproof
  • Crease-resistant
  • Doesn’t fade
  • Highly-pigmented shades
  • Smooth texture
  • High blendability

Cons

  • Some may find the consistency slightly sticky

3. Best Ultra-Pigmented:e.l.f Cosmetics Bite-Size Eyeshadow Mini Palette – Cream And Sugar

This classy drugstore copper eyeshadow by e.l.f Cosmetics will have you squealing in delight with their top-notch pigments. This mini-palette contains 4 neutral colors that can be worn as is or can be blended with other colors to achieve multiple looks. There’s both matte and shimmer shades, so make your pick for a statement look that is impossible to forget. Also, there are no parabens, sulfates, phthalates, triclosan, hydroquinone, ethoxylates, and triclocarban so your eyes are healthy while looking gorgeous. So, if you’re looking for a good drugstore cream eyeshadow that delivers color while being safe for you (and the environment), this is the one! If you need further convincing, check this YouTuber’s review out.

Pros

  • Weightless creams
  • Vegan
  • Easy to blend
  • Cruelty-free
  • Travel-friendly size
  • Gluten-free
  • Ultra-pigmented

Cons

  • The eyeshadow may not be long-wearing

4. Best Transfer-Resistant:WUNDER2 Super-Stay Stick Eyeshadow – Moonstone

Don’t you just love the convenience that comes with makeup in the form of a stick? Experience that with WUNDER2’s Super-Stay Stick Eyeshadow, as it is the best drugstore cream eyeshadow stick you can get your hands on. Super-easy to use and convenient to travel with, this waterproof stick combines high pigment with no hassle of fallouts as with traditional eyeshadow palettes. The shade Moonstone is a beautiful shimmery neutral that glides on easily and instantly brightens up your eyes. This is the best drugstore shimmer eyeshadow stick and is available in 7 pretty shades for you to choose from. And what’s even better, is the presence of soothing ingredients like silk powder, hydrogenated castor and safflower seed oils, and aloe vera to keep your eyes moisturized on-the-go.

Pros

  • Travel-friendly
  • Contains aloe vera to soothe eyes
  • Cruelty-free
  • Transfer-resistant
  • Paraben-free
  • Weightless formula

Cons

  • May feel sticky when blending with fingers

5. Best Hypoallergenic:Almay Velvet Foil Cream Shadow – Astro Girl

One of the best drugstore brand eyeshadows out there, Almay’s Velvet Foil Cream Shadow will bring some sparkle into your life. With a velvety finish that shimmers, say hello to the best drugstore glitter makeup you can use for a metallic look. With a staying power of up to 24 hours, this creamy formula infused with vitamin E won’t budge from your eyes and the pigments are rich and luscious. And to top it all off, this is an eyeshadow that doesn’t crease! You can experiment with every eye makeup style you want to as it is available in 12 deeper colors that are easy to blend and make for great color combinations. And that’s not all–you can even use these creams as a base for powder eyeshadows.

Pros

  • Hypoallergenic
  • Ophthalmologist-tested
  • Fragrance-free
  • Made with clean ingredients
  • Cruelty-free
  • Safe for people with sensitive skin and contact lens wearers
  • Waterproof

Cons

  • The cream may be a little thick

6. Best Organic:Lauren Brooke Cosmetiques Creme Eyeshadows – Plum Fairy (Matte)

The shade Plum Fairy is a great drugstore purple eyeshadow from the Creme Eyeshadows line by Lauren Brooke Cosmetiques. Made with a base of botanical ingredients and exuding a subtle vanilla scent, this eyeshadow will give your eyes as much love as the color it delivers. Shea butter moisturizes and revitalizes your eye area and rosehip acts as an antioxidant that reduces inflammation and irritation. Along with vitamin E, a blend of oils protect the skin while jojoba seed, olive and coconut hydrate it, leaving your skin feeling nourished and well cared-for. There’s also raspberry that helps reduce signs of aging so you can be on your way to youthful eyes. This is one of the best matte drugstore eyeshadow ranges and is safe for sensitive eyes as it doesn’t irritate the skin. Available in 12 matte and shimmery shades, these are the best drugstore eyeshadow singles you can have in your makeup vanity.

Pros

  • Made with organic, non-toxic ingredients
  • Buttery-smooth formula
  • Suitable for people with sensitive eyes
  • Cruelty-free
  • Highly pigmented

Cons

  • May not offer long-lasting wear

7. Best Cream Formula:L’Oreal Paris Infallible 24HR Eyeshadow – Golden Emerald

For the perfect eye makeup look, you don’t have to go scouring high-end brands. One of the top drugstore eyeshadows is brought to you by L’Oreal Paris.The intense pigments stay put for up to 24 hours in this powder-cream hybrid that blends and glides seamlessly. This luxurious formula won’t crease on your eyelids and won’t fade away either. It’s going to stay just as fresh as when you dabbed it on with your fingertips for the first time! Enhance your eyes with the best drugstore eye makeup to turn heads wherever you go.

Pros

  • Highly pigmented
  • Waterproof
  • Smooth texture
  • Longwear cream eyeshadow
  • Crease-resistant

Cons

  • Glitter flakes can get messy

8. Best Cruelty-Free:Jillian Dempsey Lid Tint – Peach

The neutral shade Peach in Jillian Dempsey’s Lid Tint range is a warm and bright drugstore orange eyeshadow with a soft matte finish. Highly-saturated pigments, which give an instant pop of color and blend like a dream are the key features of this drugstore eye makeup.Rest assured that your eyes are in good hands with skin-nourishing ingredients that provide natural antioxidants such as cocoa and shea butter with oils like coconut, castor and rosehip seed, sunflower seed oils. These elements help repair, revitalize, and moisture the skin, so that your delicate eye-area remains healthy. And to supplement your skin with more benefits, this drugstore matte cream eyeshadow is formulated without parabens, sulfates, petrochemicals, phthalates, GMOs, synthetic fragrances or dyes.

Pros

  • Cruelty-free
  • Contains nourishing ingredients
  • Easy to blend
  • Doesn’t smudge
  • Vegan
  • Made with organic ingredients
  • Perfect for on-the-go

Cons

  • Slightly expensive

9. Best Multipurpose:Glo Skin Beauty Cream Stay Shadow Stick – Echo

A high-quality cream shadow, Glo Skin Beauty’s Cream Stay Shadow Stick is best for longwear and will find a permanent place in your makeup routine. Ultra-pigmented, the stick also doubles as an eyeliner for a highly-defined look. Enriched with jojoba oil, this Cream Stay Shadow Stick intensely moisturizes and hydrates the area around your eyes for healthy skin. The 13 available shades are buildable and you can go your entire day forgetting that it’s even there! You can also use this cream eyeshadow stick as an eyeshadow base and the stick comes with a built-in sharpener that makes it a convenient travel partner. Count on this drugstore cream eyeshadow stick to make you look fab even when you are pressed for time.

Pros

  • Works as an eyeliner and eyeshadow base
  • Comes with an in-built sharpener
  • Travel-friendly
  • Buildable formula
  • Can be used as a primer or an eyebrow pencil

Cons

  • May not be smudge-proof

10. Best Non-Sticky:Marshique Touch Fit Glitter Cream Shadow – Flamingo

If you love dressing up your eyes in different styles, this drugstore glitter cream eyeshadow needs to be in your vanity right now! The brightness in Marshique’s Touch Fit Glitter Cream Shadow can power a whole town. Resistant to both sweat and water due to a silicone film, this drugstore glitter formula blends incredibly well and stays put for long hours. No clumping or creasing with this one, folks. It can be used as a primer or a highlighter to illuminate the corners of your eyes and you can also dab a little on your lips and cheeks for a soft, flushed look. Who doesn’t love a product that multitasks? The drugstore glitter pigment in Flamingo is a soft coral color with hints of pink and the range has 4 equally stunning colors to choose from. Is this one of the best drugstore eye glitters? We think so!

Pros

  • Creamy formula
  • Sweat and water-resistant
  • Can be used as primer, blush, lip tint
  • Doesn’t clump together
  • Crease-resistant
  • Non-sticky formula

Cons

  • May not be smudge-proof

11. Best Shimmery Finish:Burt’s Bees Color Nurture Cream Eye Shadow – Rose Cream

Light up your entire world with the Burt’s Bees’ Color Nurture Cream Eye Shadow, which is a weightless formula that blends seamlessly without creasing. With vitamin E as the main ingredient that offers antioxidant benefits, this drugstore shimmer eyeshadow nourishes the delicate eye-area. This eyeshadow is kind to your skin with the presence of soybean, castor, and sunflower seed oils. The kaolin helps draw out impurities and pore-clogging oils to render your skin a clean feeling.The Rose Cream shade is a soft pink with a light gold glimmer. You can build on these shades that are also free from parabens, sulfates, petrolatum or SLS. One of the best drugstore rose gold eyeshadows out there, this shade is ideal for transitioning from a day to a night look.

Pros

  • Can be used as highlighter
  • Blends easily
  • Shimmery finish
  • Contains vitamin E to nourish skin
  • Recyclable packaging
  • Delivers even color
  • Cruelty-free

Cons

  • It has a scent, which might be off-putting for people sensitive to fragrance.

12. Best Smudge-Proof:Laura Geller Make It A Double Eyeshadow Stick And Powder – Absinthe

Is 2 always better than 1? In this case, yes! Primarily because it means double the glam. Laura Geller’s dual-function eyeshadow stick and powder glide with a silky texture to give you an eye makeup look you’ll never forget. The creamy texture feels luxurious and won’t crease or smudge. When you lock the cream in with powder, the shade stays put without budging, so you can go about your day worry-free. It also doubles as an eyeliner, and helps create statement looks while the powder makes for a glowy look. In our books, this is a good drugstore glitter eyeshadow for a minimalistic or dramatic look. As a plus, this product doesn’t use any parabens, talc, phthalates, oil or gluten.

Pros

  • Gluten-free
  • Works as eyeliner
  • Smooth texture
  • Great for on-the-go
  • Vegan
  • Cruelty-free

Cons

  • Not waterproof

13. Best Blendable:Barry M Cosmetics Euphoric Metallic Eyeshadow Cream – Aurora

A good drugstore cream eyeshadow can make you feel euphoric the entire day and this Barry M Eyeshadow Cream is testament to that. A highly-pigmented formula that glides on smoothly and blends without a hassle is everyone’s dream and this drugstore metallic eyeshadow is here to make your dreams come true. Blending the shade with your ring finger or a brush applicator ensures even coverage that’s perfect for night or day. The shades sit well without getting into creases and are available in 6 bold colors you can choose from.

Pros

  • Easy to blend
  • Texture is smooth
  • Applies evenly
  • Crease-resistant
  • Rich pigments

Cons

  • Not resistant to water or sweat

Now that we’ve looked at some of the best drugstore cream eyeshadows out there, here are some tips to help you apply this product better.

Tips To Apply Cream Eyeshadow

  • If you have oily or mature skin, it always helps to use primer before using cream eyeshadow as it can get greasy or crease otherwise.
  • For a look with more dimension, you can layer the cream eyeshadow with some powder.
  • Always be gentle when blending, because if you’re aggressive, you may end up tugging at the delicate skin around the eyes. This gives an uneven look.
  • Dab some cream eyeshadow in the middle of the eyelid and gently move inwards to the corner of your eye and outwards from the middle to ensure even color distribution.
  • Don’t wait too long to blend, as cream eyeshadows can dry quite quickly, and make the product difficult to work with. Quick but gentle is the key.

Powder eyeshadows can often become messy during the application, and that is why the good idea is to invest in the best cream eyeshadows. These eyeshadows are easy to apply. Thankfully, you don’t have to worry about drilling a hole in your pocket with so many drugstore options. Whether you are looking for glitter, sparkle, or simply matte finish, you will find your pick in this list based on your preference. Both beginners and professionals can use them. Cream eyeshadows come in handy when you are looking for a quick touch-up. They are easy to apply, gentle on your skin, and blend effortlessly. The reviewed options mentioned above in the curated list are long-lasting, highly pigmented, waterproof, and crease-resistant. You don’t have to be a professional makeup artist to know how to use these shadows. We recommend you not wait for too long to blend these creamy shadows as they dry up very quickly. These drugstore cream eyeshadows will allow you to enjoy your makeup experience on a different level.

Why Trust Stylecraze?

Our in-house makeup enthusiast, Chaitra Krishnan, wrote this eloquent article where she lists the best cream eyeshadows you can get at any drugstore. Yes, it is quite possible to achieve a flawless eye look at an affordable price. She scoured the internet, investigating many products and reviews, to bring you this reliable list. These cream eyeshadows come with benefits such as high color payoff, smooth texture, color variety, skin care benefits, and more.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are cream eyeshadows better than powder?

Cream eyeshadows fare better on dry skin types due to the moisture content in them. However, they give mostly a shimmery or glittery finish, so if you’re someone who’s fond of matte, powder would be a better option. Additionally, cream eyeshadows are harder to mix with another color but powder eyeshadows blend easily for a dual-tone look.

Do you need primer for cream eyeshadow?

Since a cream eyeshadow is generally resistant to creasing and smudging, a primer is not necessary as in the case of powdered eyeshadows.

Recommended Articles

The following two tabs change content below.

LATEST ARTICLES