11 Best Eye Pencils (Eyeliners) For Your Waterline In 2020

by Sneha Manandhar
This post contains affiliate links to products. We may receive a commission for purchases made through these links. Our product selection process.

Before we jump straight into discovering the best eye pencils for waterline, we must ask you this – have you heard of the term ‘Invisible Liner’? If you haven’t, we are pretty sure you’ve seen it on runways, on fashion magazines, on celebrities, and you might have even tried it yourself too. It’s now popularly known as ‘tightlining’. For those of you who are new to the concept of tightlining, it is the process of applying eyeliner on the upper and lower waterline. For many professional and amateur make-up artists, tightlining is a favored trick. Why, though, one might ask?

Products
Check Price
Vasanti Cosmetics Waterline Kajal
Check Price
Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Pencil Eyeliner
Check Price
Artisan L’uxe Velvet Eyeliner Pencil
Check Price
Jillian Dempsey Kohl Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil
Check Price
Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner
Check Price
Immovable By Mia Adora Eyeliner Pencil And Sharpener
Check Price
Milani Stay Put Waterproof Eyeliner
Check Price
NARS Larger Than Life Long-Wear Eyeliner
Check Price
Vasanti Cosmetics Hazel Brown Kajal Waterline Eyeliner Pencil
Check Price
MAC Technakohl Liner
Check Price

Tightlining helps in creating an illusion of darker lashes and roots. It makes the eyes look bigger, and if you can master the art of it, it makes your eyes look like you’ve got some complicated eye-makeup done. However, because our eyes are sensitive and our water lines even more so, we shouldn’t just go ahead and apply any eyeliner on them. You can take a look at this list of the 11 best eye pencils and eyeliners for your water lines. To make the hunt for the best eyeliners for your water lines one step easier, we’ve included a helpful buying guide. Now, you can tightline your way to gorgeousness, anytime, any day!

11 Best Eye Pencils (Eyeliners) For Your Waterline That Won’t Make You Tear Up

1. Vasanti Cosmetics Waterline Kajal

Your search for the best waterline eyeliner could very well end here with this miracle product! Add drama and definition to your eyes with this eyeliner pencil specially designed for tightlining. Safe to apply on both your upper and lower waterline, it can give your eyes an instant lift by making it look bigger. It can also make your lashes look dense and fuller. It offers a smooth finish that lasts all day and comes with a creamy formula that glides like a dream. Even if you have the most sensitive eyes, you need not think twice before using this eyeliner pencil as it is both dermatologist and ophthalmologist-tested. To add to that, it’s also vegan, cruelty-free, and does not contain any parabens.

Pros

  • Safe for sensitive eyes
  • Safe for contact lens wearers
  • Long-lasting wear
  • Cruelty-free
  • Gluten-free
  • No parabens

Cons

  • Does not come in any other color

Buy Now From Amazon

2. Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Pencil Eyeliner

When it comes to offering makeup products that go the extra mile, Urban Decay doesn’t disappoint. This eyeliner pencil with a rich formula for waterline glides on smoothly and stays put for the entire day. Its velvety and creamy texture makes it easy to apply and stays soft for at least 30 seconds if you wish to give it a little blending. Not only is it free of parabens, sulfates, and phthalates, it is also formulated with a host of moisturizing ingredients and coated with a waterproof formula. This dramatic eyeliner pencil offers a multi-colored, iridescent finish. So, whether it’s a subdued day look or a sultry night-time look you want to achieve, this best eyeliner pencil for waterline won’t let you down.

Pros

  • Creamy texture that can be blended easily
  • No parabens, sulfates, and phthalates
  • Rainbow finish
  • Waterproof formula
  • Long-lasting

Cons

  • Slightly expensive
  • Does not self-sharpen

Buy Now From Amazon

3. Artisan L’uxe Velvet Eyeliner Pencil

Designed to make your lashes look thicker and to intensify your eye makeup, this eyeliner pencil kills two birds with one stone. It glides smoothly on the waterline and can also be used on the eyelids to help you create a smoldering smokey-eye in a matter of minutes! It is not only long-lasting, but it is water-resistant as well. Have you come across an eyeliner that provides ultimate hydration and delays the signs of aging? If you haven’t, you should get your hands on this one as it is formulated with essential oils such as sunflower seed oil, which also works towards cell stimulation. It is also suitable for contact lens wearers and people with sensitive eyes.

Pros

  • Made with essential oils and organic ingredients
  • Waterproof
  • Delays the signs of aging
  • Safe for sensitive eyes
  • Provides hydration
  • Can be used to create a smokey-eye

Cons

  • Should be sharpened with the Artisan Lúxe Eye Pencil Sharpener as other sharpening tools might easily break it

Buy Now From Amazon

4. Jillian Dempsey Kohl Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil

Created by celebrity makeup artist Jillian Dempsey, this kohl pencil is arguably one of the best waterline eyeliners. Infused with the natural goodness of ingredients like organic jojoba oil, organic shea butter, sunflower seed oil, and avocado oil, this eyeliner pencil makes tightlining look like a walk in the park. Not only does it deliver a clean yet edgy finish, but the built-in smudger helps you blend out your eyeliner to create a smokey-eye as well. Made without parabens, sulfates, petrochemicals, and synthetic fragrances or dyes, this waterline eye pencil is cruelty-free too.

Pros

  • Made with oils like jojoba, sunflower seed, and avocado oils
  • Easy application
  • Can be used for smokey-eye
  • Comes with a built-in smudger
  • Phthalate and GMO-free
  • Cruelty-free

Cons

  • Not long-lasting

Buy Now From Amazon

5. Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner

Do you struggle to apply eyeliner to your waterline? Are you tired of going through the same section over and over again, rubbing it out and applying it again to get the eyeliner to stay just right? If yes, this top-selling eyeliner pencil might just become your new best friend. It’s dense, rich, and extremely easy to use (you’ll just have to use it once to believe us). Not only can it be used on the waterline, but it can also be applied on the eyelids, and you won’t have to ever worry about it tugging or pulling. If you want a faded-out soft look, you can simply use your finger to smudge out the eyeliner. If black is not your cup of tea, you can also explore other exciting colors like Lionfish in the color of graphite and Espresso in deep burgundy.

Pros

  • Contains vitamin E
  • Waterproof
  • Available in other colors
  • Long-lasting
  • Easy to apply

Cons

  • May not be suitable for extremely sensitive eyes

Buy Now From Amazon

6. Immovable By Mia Adora Eyeliner Pencil And Sharpener

Do you need to cry your heart out but also have a meeting to attend right after it and are worried that your eyeliner won’t hold? With this waterline eyeliner, you can cry whenever and wherever you want to without restraint, and yet it will still stay on like a pro. It helps in accentuating your waterline, making your eyes look bigger and brighter. Another way to make your eyes shine is by using this eyeliner to create a smokey-eye. Apart from these styles, you can also trust this pencil to give you the perfect cat-eye, one that won’t smudge for anything in the world. This best eyeliner for waterline comes with a special eyeliner pencil sharpener, so you never have to worry about dull lines ever again.

Pros

  • Affordable
  • Smudge-proof
  • Waterproof
  • Paraben and fragrance-free
  • Cruelty-free
  • Sharpener included

Cons

  • Some may find the intensity of the black color not up to mark

Buy Now From Amazon

7. Milani Stay Put Waterproof Eyeliner

Considered to be one of the best eyeliners for tightlining, this highly-pigmented eyeliner pencil can make your eyes look bigger and intensified in a jiffy. It comes with a waterproof gel formula and can be used not only for tightlining but also for creating the perfect winged look or a flattering smokey-eye as well. Its creamy texture makes it a delight for blending and offers a smudge-free finish. Available in 5 attractive shades, this eyeliner is transfer-resistant and lasts all day long. In case you were wondering, yes, it is cruelty-free as well.

Pros

  • Pigmented gel-formula
  • Available in 5 shades
  • Affordable
  • Waterproof
  • Easy to blend

Cons

  • As the eyeliner is soft, it may break off easily when not sharpened with Milani sharpeners

Buy Now From Amazon

8. NARS Larger Than Life Long-Wear Eyeliner

A brand that needs no introduction, NARS has been a go-to favorite for many make-up enthusiasts, both professionals, and amateurs. This eyeliner pencil by NARS will give the waterline of your eyes a whole new makeover. Made with a highly-pigmented and intense color, this eyeliner pencil stays on throughout the day. With its precision tip, not only can you tightline your waterline with ease, but you can also perfect the art of pulling off a cat-eye or a winged eyeliner. Available in 9 shades ranging from Black to Bright Violet to Light Almond, this eyeliner comes with a budge-proof, long-lasting formula.

Pros

  • Pigment rich
  • Available in 9 colors
  • Precision tip
  • Smudge-proof
  • Long-lasting

Cons

  • Expensive

Buy Now From Amazon

9. Vasanti Cosmetics Hazel Brown Kajal Waterline Eyeliner Pencil

For those who are looking for a way to subtly define the shape of their eyes without a black eyeliner making it look too intensified, this little gem can come in super handy. The hazel-brown shade of this eyeliner pencil will help you tightline with ease while giving your eyes a naturally radiant look. Its smooth and creamy formula glides across in a single stroke and offers you a non-messy application. As it is made with no harsh chemicals such as parabens, it is suitable for sensitive eyes and contact wearers as well. It is also dermatologist and ophthalmologist-tested. This cruelty-free product is considered to be the best eyeliner for lower lash line.

Pros

  • Long-lasting formula
  • Available in 4 colors
  • Suitable for sensitive eyes
  • No parabens
  • Cruelty-free
  • Gluten-free

Cons

  • As it is a non-retractable eyeliner pencil, it should not be over-twisted

Buy Now From Amazon

10. MAC Technakohl Liner 

One of the best waterproof eyeliners for the waterline; this one by MAC, doesn’t fall short when it comes to impressing beauty gurus all over the world. Sleek and chic, this eyeliner pencil comes with a precision tip to help you achieve any look and also to tightline your waterline like a pro. It not only offers a smudge-free finish, it also blends easily and dries quickly as well. As it is a mechanical pencil, one can achieve best results when holding the pencil at a 90° angle for a precise line.

Pros 

  • Precision tip
  • Smudge-free
  • Easy to blend
  • Dries quickly
  • Transfer-resistant

Cons

  • Lasts upto 8 hours only

Buy Now From Amazon

11. Sleek Makeup Intense Waterliner

What do you look for when you are buying a waterline eyeliner? The top few qualities must include its intensity, its sharp tip, how pigmented it is, how smudge-proof it is, and how versatile it is. This eyeliner pencil is super versatile, meets all the criteria, and will leave your eyes looking fierce by adding definition to them. Safe to be applied directly on the upper and lower waterline, it can also help you create precision-looks along with smokey-eyes as well. As it is a highly-pigmented eyeliner, you can apply it over your eyelids and simply blend it out to create a soft smokey-eye look for the evening. This eyeliner is cruelty-free as well.

Pros

  • Cruelty-free
  • Rich pigmentation
  • Precision tip
  • East to blend
  • Affordable

Cons

  • Lasts upto 8 hours only

Buy Now From Amazon

How To Choose The Best Waterline Eyeliner – A Buying Guide

What Is Waterlining?

Waterlining or tightlining is using an eyeliner pencil to line the upper and lower waterline. You can use an eyeliner of any color to tightline, but black is the most preferred color. Apply the eyeliner directly on the waterline, right above and below the lashes. This will make your lashes look thicker from the roots and also give the illusion of bigger eyes.

How To Choose An Eyeliner For Waterline

Before you buy an eyeliner for your waterline, ensure that it is of a creamy texture. It should be blendable and smudge-proof as well. Look for something that does not contain any parabens, sulfate, or phthalates and is suitable for sensitive eyes as well.

How Do You Use A Waterline Eye Pencil?

Step 1: Start with a clean slate. Make sure that your eyes are clean and remove any makeup residues from the night before.

Step 2: Apply the eyeliner directly on the upper lash line, right underneath the lashes.

Step 3: In the same manner, apply the eyeliner on the lower waterline, right above the lashes.

Step 4: Wait for it to dry.

Step 5: Wipe off the excess (if any) from the corners of the eye.

How Do You Get Eyeliner To Stay On Your Waterline?

After you have finished tightlining, take a wide flat makeup brush. Dip it into some black eyeshadow and gently press it over the waterline eyeliner. Don’t apply too much eyeshadow on the first go. Build it up slowly and steadily, without making it look like you have too much on. Wipe away any excess build-up from the eyes and cheeks with a thicker brush.

How Do I Keep My Eyeliner From Smudging On My Waterline?

It may sound complicated, but it is easy as pie. The first step to ensuring that your eyeliner stays in place is to find the correct eyeliner; one that is specifically designed for the waterlines. If you have any eyeliner or eye-makeup left over from the night before, wipe it off properly. After you are done applying eyeliner to your waterline, apply concealer on the corner of the eyes, and underneath the eyes as well.

Tightlighting or applying eyeliner on the waterline sounds like risky business, but only if you let it be so. There is only one golden rule to follow when it comes to makeup –  practice makes perfect. Yes, during the first few tries, you may poke yourself, some tears may run, but remember that each mistake will lead to success. Also, keep in mind that not all eyeliners are meant for the purpose of tightlining. Our eyes are sensitive and precious, so we need to take good care of it. Only use an eyeliner that is safe enough to be used on the waterline. The list of 11 best eyeliners mentioned above is a good place to get a head start. Reach out to us in the comments and tell us how you tightline your eyes and how much of a difference it makes in your everyday look. We are all ears!

Expert’s Answers for Readers Questions

What should I use on my waterline?

Look specifically for an eyeliner that is creamy, easy to blend, and is safe to be used for the waterline. Look for products that are free of parabens, sulfate, fragrance, phthalates, and other harmful chemicals.

Does eyeliner on the waterline make your eyes look smaller?

When applied correctly, eyeliner on the waterline can make your eyes look bigger.

Can I use liquid liner on the waterline?

As a liquid eyeliner may not stay on the waterline and also irritate your eyes, it is not recommended.

Can I use black color on the waterline?

Yes, it is the most commonly used eyeliner shade for tightlining. However, if you don’t like black, you can also try brown or a shade of blue in the inner and outer corners for a more dramatic effect.

Can I line my waterline if I have watery eyes?

There are waterline eyeliners available for sensitive eyes. However, tightlining watery eyes may lead to more irritations, and it is best to avoid it.

Is it bad to put eyeliner in your waterline?

Using an eyeliner that is not designed to be used in the waterline may cause an infection. Hence, if you are going to tightline, make sure the eyeliner is waterproof and safe for its intended purpose.

Recommended Articles

Was this article helpful?
The following two tabs change content below.

Sneha Manandhar

Sneha Manandhar holds a Master’s degree in English from the University of Pune. She has previously worked with media and publication houses in varied capacities as a lifestyle writer, an editor, a copywriter, and a translator. She reviews beauty, skin care, and wellness products from specialized curated lists. She believes that SEO-driven content is the present and the future and keeps herself busy by dabbling in SEO-related tools and honing her editing skills.
scorecardresearch