11 Best MAC Eyeliners For Your Eyes – 2024, According To A Makeup Expert
Create perfect wings with smudge-proof and waterproof eyeliners that last through the day.
Jocelyn FrasardLicensed Esthetician
Jocelyn is a licensed esthetician with over five years of experience in skin care and makeup. Since discovering her love for all things beauty in 2014, she has been on a remarkable journey of growth and learning. Jocelyn spent countless hou... more
srijani roy chowdhuryMA (Journalism & Mass Communication), Certified Style & Image Consultant
Experience: 3 yearsSrijani is an associate commerce editor with a master's degree in journalism and mass communication from the University of Calcutta, West Bengal. She is certified in makeup techniques and is also a ce... more
srijita deMA (English & Literature), Certified Style & Image Consultant
Experience: 2 yearsSrijita De is a makeup and fashion enthusiast with a passion for empowering readers through practical tips and tricks to present their best selves with confidence. Armed with a postgraduate degree in ... more
krati darakMBA, Certified Skin Care Coach
Experience: 3 yearsKrati is an associate commerce editor, a certified skin care coach, and a beauty enthusiast. She has a master’s degree in advertising and publishing relations from DAVV University and three years of ... more
Image: Shutterstock
It is incredible how something as simple as eyeliner can enhance your look in no time. And if you have the best MAC eyeliners in place, you are going to steal the show wherever you go. The brand has always been a favorite of every celebrity makeup artist and with these eyeliners, you can create statement-making wings, a sultry and unique smokey eye without much hassle. They will also allow you to tight line without shedding tears in abundance. So, it is time for you to have these expertly crafted, gorgeous eyeliners by MAC in your makeup pouch without a second thought. Don’t worry! We shall help you with this.
We have created a list of the 11 most amazing MAC eyeliners that will add convenience to your daily eye makeup routine. Since the market is already saturated with umpteen options, take this article as your buying guide and pick the one that your heart desires.
In This Article
Top 11 Best MAC Eyeliner Reviews Of 2024
1. Best Waterproof Formula:MAC Pro Longwear Fluidline
This stunning wonder product is one of the best-selling MAC eyeliners that is loved by millions worldwide. If you’ve ever dreamed of an easy-glide eyeliner that applies like butter, hugs your skin like silk, and lasts throughout the day, your prayers have been answered. This dermatologist-tested gel formula is ultra-smooth and easy to apply with an angled brush. Numerous reviewers attest that a single stroke of this gel offers a rich matte finish and buildable coverage. If that winged-eyeliner look has always seemed out of your reach, this smudge-resistant formula can help you master it with the precision of a liquid liner.
Pros
- Lasts up to 16 hours
- Smudge-proof
- Fade-proof
- Waterproof
- Ophthalmologist-tested
- Dermatologist-tested
Cons
- Some may find the formula dull in color and not well-pigmented.
"I look stunning with this eyeliner on. It glides smoothly on my lids and remains smudge-proof. In just one stroke, I can line my upper lash line entirely. The color remains prominent and has a softer finish. I like that it stays all day without budging."
StyleCraze Trivia2. Best Transfer-resistant:MAC Technakohl Liner
Before we talk about this incredibly pigmented product, let’s understand why tightlining is all the rage this season. It’s the easiest way to change the way your eyes look. By tightlining your eyes, you are creating an illusion of darker and thicker lashes. This makes your eyes look bigger and brighter. However, not all eyeliners are safe for the waterlines, especially for contact lens wearers, but this twist-up eyeliner pencil is the ultimate champion for tightlining. Reviews on online forums recommend this as an excellent choice for your waterlines, that can also double up as a precision intense black liner. This transfer-resistant and rich eyeliner offers extraordinary color and dries quickly upon application.
Pros
- Mechanical retractable eyeliner pencil
- Rich and creamy formula
- No-smudge formula
- Transfer-resistant
- Ophthalmologist-tested
- Safe for contact lens wearers
Cons
- It lasts for up to 8 hours.
"I use it for tightlining my lashes, and it looks wonderful. The pigment stays put without transferring. It also never runs into my eyes and stings them. I like that the eyeliner has a retractable feature. It goes on smoothly without breaking my lashes or pinching my skin."
Quick Tip
Why We Think It's Worth Buying
This product has garnered over 439 positive reviews on Amazon, and the number continues to grow.
3. Best Smudge-Proof Formula:MAC Fluidline Eyeliner Gel
If you wish to take a break from your regular black eyeliner pencil, give this brown colored beauty a shot. Suitable for all eye colors to perfectly line the upper lids, this rich and creamy gel formula settles like a smooth dream. This dermatologist-tested, fade-resistant product is also an excellent eyeliner to line your lower lash line for a well-defined look. When you’re running out of eyeshadow or wish to experiment with brown shades, grab a thick brush, dip it into this gel and give your eyelids a generous swipe of this gel liner. The best part is that this MAC brown eyeliner gel is non-acnegenic and waterproof too.
Pros
- Smudge-proof
- Lasts up to 16 hours
- Ophthalmologist-tested
- Dermatologist-tested
- Suitable for all eye colors
Cons
- If you have oily skin, it may not last a long time.
4. Best Long-Lasting Effect:MAC Liquid Eyeliner
What would we do without liquid eyeliners? It’s almost impossible to think of a world without them, isn’t it? This MAC liquid eyeliner comes with a fine tip that offers unparalleled precision. The application stick rests on a tall cap for a comfortable grip and helps even the clumsiest of hands to create a perfect line. Whether you’re in the mood for a subtle look to define your eyes or want to try out something bold to make your eye the center of attention, this intensely black formula is one of the best liquid eyeliners to create an infinite number of looks. It is one of the best MAC liquid eyeliners and will undoubtedly have you covered for all special occasions!
Pros
- Long-lasting
- Doesn’t smudge
- Ophthalmologist-tested
- Tested by a dermatologist
- Safe for contact lens wearers
- Easy to remove
Cons
- It is not waterproof.
"This eyeliner looks prominent on my lids. The deep black pigment makes my eyes appear bigger and bolder. The formula is waterproof, so it stays put even when I sweat. It creates seamless fine lines on my upper lash lines, which is ideal for the soft, everyday looks I love."
Pro Tip5. Best For Contact Lens Wearers:MAC Pro Longwear Eyeliner
Once you try this luxurious formula, we assure you that there is no going back. It is the perfect eyeliner to keep in your handbag for a quick fix me up or when you’re running errands. If you love an ultra-pigmented eyeliner, this one will be your new favorite go-to product. Give your eyes all the rest it needs from pulling and tugging. Although it’s one of the denser MAC liners, it glides like butter. This water-resistant liner offers an 8-hour wear and is safe for use on your waterline. Tested by both a dermatologist and ophthalmologist, this eyeliner is suitable for people wearing contact lenses. This video detailing a tester’s experience will provide you with added insights about the product.
Pros
- Transfer-resistant
- Smudge-free
- Ideal for use on the waterline
- Thick texture
Cons
- It is not easy to wipe off.
"I love how smoothly this eyeliner goes on my eyelids. The pigment looks bold on my eyes and I can use it for both everyday and party makeup looks. The color is easy to remove as well. It does not irritate my eyes or cause redness. The best part is that once it dries on my lids, it will not smear."
6. Best Metallic Matte Finish:MAC Powerpoint Eye Pencil
Do you want to be that person who commands attention and respect as soon as they walk into a room? Are you ready to show the world just how much of a “Boss Lady” you are? If you’re nodding your head, we recommend that you get your hands on this eyeliner that means business and is here to stay. A long-lasting eyeliner in a metallic matte finish, this one is smooth to apply and will give your eyes intense definition. If you want someone to look you in the eye while talking to you, you should have an eyeliner that can hold a stare, don’t you think. Pick this one. It won’t transfer. It won’t smudge. It won’t budge. The eyeliner is perfect for everyday wear, you can also take a a look at this video to know more about the reviewer’s experience with the product.
Pros
- Enriched with cottonseed and jojoba oil
- Smooth yet pigmented formula
- Transfer-proof
- Long-wearing
- Waterproof
- Smudge-resistant
- Ophthalmologist-tested
Cons
- One has to be careful while sharpening it as the whole tip may break off.
"This eye pencil glides seamlessly on my eyelids. The pencil tip feels soft against my skin. I like that the color does not flake or budge. It also does not make my lids dry. I also often use the pigment as my eyeshadow as it is blendable. The formula lasts long on my eyelids."
7. Best Pearly Matte Finish:MAC Eye Kohl
Anyone who’s ever been on the hunt for the perfect shade of brown eyeliner will know the struggle of how hard it is to find one. If you’re struggling, you need not worry anymore. One of the best MAC kohl eyeliners, the Teddy eyeliner is the brown pencil that you’ve been waiting for your entire life. The eyeliner effortlessly contours your natural eye shape, giving a subtle yet bold look. A soft MAC eye pencilthat’s loved by amateur and professional makeup artists alike, this one helps you shade your upper and lower lash lines to reveal a pearly matte finish.
Pros
- Easy to apply
- Contains castor seed oil
- Unique brown shade
- Ophthalmologist-tested
Cons
- It is not waterproof.
- May not be not long-lasting
8. Best Color Payoff:MAC Brushstroke 24-Hour Liner
The name of this MAC liquid liner is a dead giveaway, isn’t it? Perhaps it’s all you need to know because if a 24-hour liner doesn’t impress you, you’re a tough cookie to crack. If that’s not enough to convince you, maybe these qualities will do the trick. This matte liquid liner is equipped with a tapered-tip pin that helps you create a flawless line, each time. For a thicker line, you can use the flat side of the brush. Its rich black color is visible from a mile away and stays put, no matter how hot, sweaty, or humid the day is. In case you were wondering, yes, it’s completely budge-proof too. As it is tested by an ophthalmologist, it’s safe to say that it is suitable for contact lens wearers. You may check more about a tester’s experience with this product in this video.
Pros
- Precision tip
- Doesn’t smudge
- Easy to remove with warm water
- 24-hour wear
- Water-resistant
- Transfer-resistant
- Ophthalmologist-tested
Cons
- When it dries, it may not reveal a matte finish but rather a shiny one.
9. Best Quick-Drying Formula:MAC Liquidlast Liner
Another 24-hour wear marvel from MAC, this one adds glamor and pizzazz to your eyes. A velvety liquid eyeliner that flows gently and settles quickly, it offers a pearly satin finish. It comes with a pointy tip that helps in creating neat and perfect lines effortlessly or twirly shapes if that’s what you’re in the mood for. This quick-drying and long-lasting MAC waterproof eyeliner has garnered positive customer reviews for its no-budging quality and is exceptionally transfer-resistant. Don’t forget to give this one a shot for your next girl’s night out. Trust us; you won’t regret it.
Pros
- 24-hour wear
- Precision tip brush
- Waterproof
- Transfer-resistant
- Budge-proof
- Ophthalmologist-tested
Cons
- It is not easy to remove.
"The MAC Liquidlast eyeliner is ideal for all-day looks. The applicator applies the pigment to my eyelids in just a few strokes. I can also create cat wings with its precise applicator. The pigment is waterproof, so it never smudges. I can also remove it easily with my micellar water."
10. Best Humidity-Resistant Formula:MAC Dual Dare All-Day Waterproof Liner
Which one do you prefer more — a liquid eyeliner or a kajal eyeliner pencil? If you can’t decide which one makes you happier and have the same amount of love for both of them, you need not decide as long as you grab this 2-in-1 double-ended eyeliner. Yes, this MAC eye-candy features a matte black liquid eyeliner with a felt tipon one end and a kajal pencil on the other. What more could a girl ask for? You can trace the shape of a killer winged look with the liquid liner and fill it in with the creamy kajal pencil, or you can also blur out the edges for a smokey eye. The MAC kajal eyeliner pencil is also suitable for tightlining. There’s not much left to ask for, is there?
Pros
- 2-in-1 liquid liner and kajal pencil
- Long-lasting
- Mechanical kajal pencil
- Smudge-resistant
- Waterproof
- Sweat-resistant
- Humidity-resistant
Cons
- The kajal pencil tends to run out faster than expected.
- It is slightly expensive.
11. Best Shimmery Finish:MAC A Novel Romance Eyeliner
From the ‘A Novel Romance’ collection, MAC offers a deep blue shade of eyeliner pencil with a soft pearl finish. It offers an opaque and buildable coverage along with a rich and creamy texture. A mechanical pencil that is easy to use and apply, it lasts up to 8 hours. Although the formula is dense and matte, this MAC eyeliner pencil reveals a metallic sheen and is easy to remove. If you are looking to add some colors to your summer makeup routine, this eyeliner pencil will be the perfect fit.
Pros
- Water-resistant
- Smudge-proof
- Budge-proof
- Metallic and shimmery finish
Cons
- Not long-lasting.
Before you settle on an eyeliner that’s right for you, here are a few pointers that may help you make the decision easier.
What To Look For When Buying An Eyeliner
What Are The Best-Selling Mac Eyeliners In 2024?
MAC eyeliners are hard-to-fault, and choosing just one can be a tricky feat. However, the following eyeliners are the best-selling ones:
- MAC Brushstroke 24-Hour Liner
- MAC Technakohl Liner
- MAC Liquidlast Liner
- MAC Pro Longwear Fluidline
- MAC Eye Kohl
How To Choose The Best MAC Eyeliners
As mentioned before, choosing just one MAC eyeliner isn’t an easy thing to do because the eyeliners are exceptional in their make and loved by all. However, choosing the best eyeliner depends on your preference. Take a look at these pointers; it may help you decide which one you like best from the list given above:
- Most MAC Cosmetics eyeliners are known all over the world for its long staying power. Some offer 8 hours of wear, while others offer up to 16 hours. Depending on what your day looks like, pick one that’s right for you. If you are someone who likes their eyes to look defined and alluring for the longest time, choose one that offers 24-hour wear.
- Though MAC eyeliners are not marketed as a hypoallergenic formula, all of them are ophthalmologist-tested and safe for contact lens wearers. If you have extremely sensitive eyes, try a little bit of product first and see how your eyes react.
- If you have oily skin, always stick to an eyeliner that is smudge and budge-free.
- If you are constantly under the sun or in warm climates, specifically look for one that is sweat, humidity, and water-resistant.
Infographic: Top 3 Hacks For Beginners To Apply Eyeliner Perfectly
In the realm of makeup, eyeliner is one of those products that can make or break your entire look. When it comes to choosing the best eyeliners, M.A.C. has a lot of options. However, the biggest challenge is applying these perfectly, especially as a beginner. Check out the infographic below for some easy hacks. Illustration: StyleCraze Design Team
The Bottom Line
MAC Cosmetics need no introduction, do they? They are a household name and have consistently proven themselves to be the leading powerhouse in all things makeup. There’s much to be said about their brilliant line of eyeliners that offer an enhanced beauty, and perhaps, that’s a discussion for another day. MAC eyeliners offer exceptional results and are cult-favorite. If you are looking to switch up your look in a major way, then definitely check out these amazing waterproof liners mentioned above. If you want more definition, you can opt for MAC Pro Longwear Fluidline that gives you a silkier, darker finish. The MAC Technakohl Liner is great for those looking for a transfer-resistant formula. But if you are looking for a non-acnegenic formula, consider the MAC Fluidline Eyeliner Gel. Now we hope you’ve found one that’s tailor-made for you in this list of the 11 best MAC eyeliners of 2024.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a MAC eyeliner smudge proof?
Yes, MAC eyeliners are smudge-proof. They offer a well-defined look to your eyes with a pigmented finish.
Is a MAC gel liner waterproof?
Yes, most MAC gel liners are waterproof. They offer 24 hours stay on lids and 12 hours stay on water lines.
How do you apply MAC eyeliner?
Apply a MAC eyeliner the same way that you apply regular eyeliners. Begin from the inner corner of your eyes and move outward as you keep drawing a line. Make sure the line is closer to your lashes. If not, fill in the gaps between your lash line and the eyeliner line.
Does MAC have waterproof eyeliner?
Yes. Some MAC eyeliners like the MAC Pro Longwear Fluidline and the MAC Powerpoint Eye Pencil are great waterproof liners.
Are MAC eyeliners safe during pregnancy?
Yes, MAC eyeliners are safe during pregnancy. The eyeliners from this brand contain wax that does not get absorbed into the skin. The other ingredients used in the formulas are also not harmful to pregnant people. However, it is always wise to consult your doctor before committing to any product.
Are MAC cosmetics vegan or cruelty-free?
No, MAC is not a vegan or cruelty-free company, as their products in China are tested on animals as part of the country’s safety assessment of the cosmetic brand. Otherwise, MAC does not own any animal testing facilities.
Why Trust StyleCraze?
The author, Chaitra Krishnan, is a makeup enthusiast. In this article, she shares her recommendations for the best MAC eyeliner to add to your cosmetic collection. She compiled this list of the top products after conducting extensive research and reviewing numerous user reviews available on trusted e-commerce sites. From a delicate wing to a bold smudge-free edge, make your eye makeup stand out with these recommended eyeliners.
